Parallax

13 November, 1834

Talleyrand resigns for the last time

At eighty, the man who had sworn loyalty to six French regimes and outlived five of them wrote from his chateau to give up the London embassy, and with it public life.

Valençay, France

The letter was dated from the chateau of Valençay on 13 November 1834 and addressed to the minister of foreign affairs in Paris. In it Charles-Maurice de Talleyrand-Périgord, Prince of Talleyrand, ambassador of the King of the French to the court of St James’s, asked to be relieved of his post. He was eighty, he wrote, and his infirmities advised him to retire. The work he had gone to London to do was done: the monarchy born of the revolution of July 1830 had been accepted into the company of the European powers, and peace had been kept.

He had been in London four years. He arrived in September 1830, a few weeks after the Paris barricades had driven out Charles X, with a tricolour cockade in his hat and the guns of Dover saluting him. He had last lived in England as a refugee from the Terror, and had been expelled in 1794. Now he was received as a monument. He was lame, powdered, wrapped in cravats to the chin, and carried about London by servants; hostesses competed for him, and caricaturists drew him as an ancient fox.

The business was Belgium. In August 1830 the Belgians had risen against the Dutch king to whom the Congress of Vienna had assigned them, and a French or a Prussian intervention could have started a general war. Talleyrand and the British ministers steered a conference of the five great powers in London towards a solution nobody had wanted beforehand: an independent Belgium, declared permanently neutral, under a German prince with an English connection, Leopold of Saxe-Coburg. In April 1834 he added a Quadruple Alliance of Britain, France, Spain and Portugal, which he presented as the liberal West’s answer to the absolutist courts of the East.

By then he was ready to go. He disliked Lord Palmerston, the foreign secretary, who kept him waiting in anterooms and did not hide his opinion that the old man took too much credit. The death of friends, the fog and his legs did the rest. He left London in August 1834 on what was called leave, and did not go back. The person who helped him compose the letter was Dorothea, Duchess of Dino, his nephew’s wife and for twenty years the mistress of his household. She was forty-one, and she wanted his last chapter to be dignified.

It was. He spent his remaining years between Valençay and his house in Paris, putting his memoirs in order and negotiating, slowly, the terms of his return to the Church he had left. On the morning of 17 May 1838 he signed a retraction of his errors. The king came to his bedside that day, and he died in the afternoon.

How it came to this

Talleyrand was born in 1754 into one of the oldest noble families in France. A damaged foot barred him from the army, and he was sent into the Church without vocation, becoming Bishop of Autun in 1788. In the National Assembly a year later he proposed that the nation take over the Church’s property. He celebrated mass at the great revolutionary festival of July 1790, consecrated the first bishops of the new state church, and was excommunicated. He spent the Terror in England and then the United States.

He came home in 1796 and was foreign minister under the Directory, helped Bonaparte to power in 1799, and served him until 1807, becoming very rich. From 1808 he worked against the emperor in secret, advising the Tsar of Russia and taking Austrian money. In 1814 he arranged the return of the Bourbons, and at the Congress of Vienna he obtained for defeated France a place among the powers that decided the map of Europe. Pushed aside after 1815, he waited fifteen years and in 1830 backed Louis-Philippe of Orléans.

How each side saw it

His French enemies, on every side

Each party had its own reason to despise him. To royalists and the devout he was the apostate bishop who had robbed the Church. To Bonapartists he was the man who sold the emperor; Napoleon had told him to his face in 1809 that he was filth in a silk stocking. To republicans he was the aristocrat who rode every regime and believed in none. Chateaubriand, watching him enter the king’s study in 1815 leaning on the regicide police minister Fouché, wrote that he had seen vice supported on the arm of crime. That sentence in the ‘Mémoires d’outre-tombe’ has shaped Talleyrand’s reputation in France ever since.

Talleyrand’s own defence

His answer, given in his memoirs and in the declaration he left with his will, was that he had served France and not governments. Regimes, he argued, had abandoned themselves before he abandoned them; he had left each when it began to harm the country, and his constant aims had been peace, a balance among the powers, and an understanding with England. He pointed to Vienna and to Belgium as the proof. Admirers from Duff Cooper to Emmanuel de Waresquiel have largely accepted this, seeing a consistent liberal conservative behind the changes of coat. It is a defence written by its beneficiary, and it passes lightly over the money.

The Dutch king and the Belgians

William I of the Netherlands regarded the London conference as the dismemberment of his kingdom by the powers that had created it. He invaded Belgium in August 1831, was stopped by a French army, and refused to sign the settlement until 1839. The Belgians, for their part, had little cause to thank the French ambassador. Talleyrand had floated schemes to partition their country among its neighbours, with a share for France, before settling for independence, and he was accused at the time of taking Dutch money. Belgian neutrality, his chief legacy there, was the guarantee Germany violated in August 1914.

Palmerston and the British

British opinion was divided between fascination and distrust. The Duke of Wellington defended Talleyrand’s honour in the House of Lords, and the diarist Charles Greville records that the old man was moved to tears by it. Palmerston found him a tiresome intriguer who went behind the Foreign Office to friends in the cabinet, and after his departure took care to show that the Anglo-French understanding had been British policy, not a Frenchman’s gift. The entente did not long survive Talleyrand’s retirement: within six years the two countries were close to war over Egypt.

What is disputed

How much he took in bribes is unknowable but large: the demand for a payment from American envoys in 1797 is documented, as are Austrian subsidies after 1808. Whether his dealings with the Tsar at Erfurt were treason or foresight depends on whether loyalty was owed to Napoleon or to France. His memoirs were edited after his death by Adolphe de Bacourt and published only in 1891, and scholars have argued over how far the text was altered. Many of his best-known sayings, and the jokes told about his death, are later inventions. The resignation itself was made public some weeks after the date on the letter.

What followed

The deathbed reconciliation, managed by the young Abbé Dupanloup, was itself treated as a final negotiation; when the priest came to anoint his hands Talleyrand is reported to have turned them over, reminding him that he was a bishop. He was buried at Valençay. Belgium’s borders and neutrality were fixed by treaty in 1839. His name remains a byword, used as praise by diplomats and as abuse by nearly everyone else, for the art of surviving a change of government.

Read further

  • Duff Cooper, Talleyrand (1932)
  • Emmanuel de Waresquiel, Talleyrand: le prince immobile (2003)
  • Philip G. Dwyer, Talleyrand (2002)
  • Mémoires du prince de Talleyrand, edited by the duc de Broglie (1891-92)
  • François-René de Chateaubriand, Mémoires d’outre-tombe (1849-50)

Same day, other years

1002

The St Brice’s Day massacre

EnglandEurope

On the feast of St Brice, 13 November 1002, King Æthelred of England ordered the killing of ‘all the Danish men who were in England’, in the words of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, having been told they meant to murder him and seize the kingdom. England had been paying Viking fleets to go away for a decade. A royal charter of 1004 describes what happened in Oxford: Danes living in the town broke into St Frideswide’s church for sanctuary, and the townspeople, unable to get them out, burned it over their heads. A mass grave of some thirty-five young men found in Oxford in 2008 may belong to that day.

Seen from elsewhere. The order cannot have been carried out in the north and east, where much of the population was of Danish descent; historians think the victims were recent settlers and mercenaries in southern towns. Æthelred’s charter calls it a most just extermination. A later story says the Danish king’s sister was among the dead; he invaded the following year.

1914

The Zaian defeat a French column at El Herri

Near Khénifra, MoroccoAfrica

France had declared a protectorate over Morocco in 1912 and was pushing into the Middle Atlas, where the Zaian confederation of Amazigh tribes under Mouha ou Hammou refused to submit. At dawn on 13 November 1914 Lieutenant-Colonel René Laverdure, against the standing orders of the Resident-General, Hubert Lyautey, led most of the Khénifra garrison out to raid Mouha’s camp at El Herri. The raid succeeded; the camp was looted and captives taken. On the march back the column was surrounded by horsemen arriving from every direction. More than 600 of its men were killed, Laverdure among them. It was the worst French defeat of the Moroccan conquest.

Seen from elsewhere. French accounts blame one officer’s disobedience. Many of the dead were Algerian and West African soldiers of the colonial army, whose side of it went unrecorded. Among the Zaian the battle was kept alive in oral poetry as proof the French could be beaten. Their resistance lasted until 1921.

1956

The Supreme Court ends segregation on Montgomery’s buses

Washington and Montgomery, Alabama, United StatesThe Americas

Black residents of Montgomery, Alabama, had refused to ride the city’s buses for almost a year, since the arrest of Rosa Parks in December 1955. The boycott did not itself change the law. That was done by a federal lawsuit, Browder v. Gayle, brought by the lawyer Fred Gray on behalf of four women who had been mistreated on the buses before Parks: Aurelia Browder, Claudette Colvin, Susie McDonald and Mary Louise Smith. On 13 November 1956 the Supreme Court affirmed without argument a lower court’s ruling that bus segregation was unconstitutional. Martin Luther King heard the news in a courtroom where the city was seeking to ban the boycotters’ car pool.

Seen from elsewhere. City officials and the White Citizens’ Council held that the ruling trampled the rights of states and local custom. After integrated buses ran in December, snipers fired on them and four Black churches were bombed. Colvin, fifteen when arrested, was passed over as the movement’s public face and received little recognition for decades.

1985

A volcano’s mudflow buries Armero

Armero, Tolima, ColombiaThe Americas

Nevado del Ruiz, an ice-capped volcano in the Colombian Andes, erupted on the evening of 13 November 1985. The eruption was moderate, but it melted part of the summit glacier, and torrents of mud and rock ran down the river valleys at the speed of a car. About two hours later, near eleven at night, they reached Armero, a farming town of 29,000 people some fifty kilometres away. Around 20,000 of its inhabitants died, and some 3,000 more elsewhere. The world’s attention fixed on Omayra Sánchez, a thirteen-year-old trapped to her neck in water and debris, who talked to rescuers and reporters for three days before she died.

Seen from elsewhere. Scientists had published a hazard map a month earlier showing Armero in the path of a mudflow. Officials answered that the forecasts were uncertain and that a needless evacuation would be costly; that evening residents were told to stay calm indoors. Survivors and volcanologists have called it a disaster of decision, not of nature.

Also on 13 November