Parallax

10 November, 1775

Congress votes for two battalions of marines

The resolution that the United States Marine Corps counts as its birth was passed for an invasion of Nova Scotia that never sailed, and the Corps itself did not adopt the date until 1921.

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

On 10 November 1775 the Second Continental Congress, sitting in the Pennsylvania State House in Philadelphia, resolved that two battalions of marines be raised, with one colonel, two lieutenant colonels, two majors and the usual junior officers. The men were to be good seamen, or so acquainted with maritime affairs as to be able to serve to advantage by sea, and the units were to be called the first and second battalions of American Marines. The war with Britain was seven months old. There was as yet no declaration of independence and scarcely a navy.

The purpose was specific. Congress was considering an expedition against Halifax in Nova Scotia, the main British naval base on the coast, and the marines were to be its landing force. They were to be drawn from the army George Washington commanded outside Boston. Washington did not like it. He wrote to Congress that picking out men who knew the sea would break up regiments he was struggling to hold together through the winter, and Congress backed down. The Halifax scheme was dropped, and the two battalions were never formed as written.

What survived was the idea of marines. On 28 November Congress commissioned Samuel Nicholas, a Philadelphian from a family of tavern keepers and a keen fox-hunter, as captain of marines, the first officer of the service. Recruiting went on through the winter in the city’s waterfront taverns, to the sound of a drum, among sailors, tradesmen and recent immigrants. Marine tradition fixes it at the Tun Tavern on Water Street, whose proprietor, Robert Mullan, became a marine captain himself.

In February 1776 Nicholas and some 230 marines sailed from the Delaware with the small squadron of Commodore Esek Hopkins. Hopkins had orders for the Chesapeake but went instead to the Bahamas, where the British were known to keep gunpowder. On 3 March the marines and fifty sailors landed from boats on New Providence, east of Nassau. It was the first amphibious landing in the service’s history. They took Fort Montagu without loss and Nassau the next morning.

They were too slow. The governor, Montfort Browne, had used the night to load most of the powder on to a ship and send it to Florida. The Americans stayed two weeks, loaded the forts’ cannon and mortars and the governor himself, and sailed home. Marines later crossed the Delaware with Washington and fought at Princeton. When the war ended there was no money for a navy; the last ship was sold in 1785 and the Continental Marines had ceased to exist.

How it came to this

Marines were not an American invention. Spain had kept naval infantry since the sixteenth century, and Britain since 1664; colonial Americans had served in British marine regiments, notably the force raised for the disastrous attack on Cartagena in 1741. Their work on board was to fight from the tops and the deck with muskets in action, to form landing parties, and to stand guard between the officers and a crew that might be pressed, underpaid and mutinous.

In the autumn of 1775 Congress was building a navy out of converted merchantmen. A naval committee, in which John Adams of Massachusetts was the driving member, met in the evenings in a Philadelphia tavern to write regulations and buy ships. The first vessels were authorised in October, the marines in November, and rules for the navy at the end of that month. Most of the colonies also raised marines for their own state navies, and privateers carried them as well. The Continental Marines were always few, probably never more than about two thousand men over the whole war.

How each side saw it

The Marine Corps tradition

For Marines the tenth of November is a birthday, kept wherever they are stationed with a cake cut by sword, the first piece to the oldest Marine present and the second to the youngest, and the reading of a message written by Commandant John A. Lejeune in 1921. The tradition holds that the service has existed since the Tun Tavern and that every Marine since belongs to one unbroken line. The Corps has always known that the line was broken in fact between 1783 and 1798, and treats the continuity as one of spirit and name, in the way regiments elsewhere inherit the honours of disbanded predecessors.

George Washington and the army

The commander-in-chief’s objection is on record in his letters to Congress of November 1775. His enlistments were expiring, the men were going home, and he was being asked to sort through the regiments for those who could handle a boat. He thought the Nova Scotia plan itself unwise at that season. From the army’s side the marines began as a raid on its manpower, and the tension between a small sea-going corps and the army recurred through American history, including serious proposals after 1945 to fold the Marines into the army altogether.

Nassau: the governor and the islanders

Governor Browne’s dispatches describe a defenceless colony. The garrison had been withdrawn to Boston, the militia would not turn out in numbers, and many inhabitants traded with the mainland and had no wish to fight Americans. Hopkins issued a manifesto promising that private property would be safe if the forts were given up, and the town accepted. Browne was carried off a prisoner and later exchanged. Much of New Providence’s population was enslaved; no account from them survives, and the raid is known only through the papers of the governor and of the officers who captured him.

What is disputed

The book places the Tun Tavern in Trenton, New Jersey; it stood in Philadelphia. Whether it was really the first recruiting station is itself doubted, since some historians favour the Conestoga Waggon, a tavern owned by the Nicholas family. The larger question is the birthday. The present Corps was created by an Act of Congress signed by President John Adams on 11 July 1798, and until 1921 Marines celebrated that date. The change to 10 November was made by Lejeune’s order on the suggestion of the Corps historian, Major Edwin McClellan. The resolution of 1775 was never carried out in the form it was passed.

What followed

The re-founded Corps fought on the shore of Tripoli in 1805 and in Mexico City in 1847, the two places named in its hymn. In the early twentieth century it was the instrument of long American occupations of Haiti, the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua, a history remembered very differently in those countries than in the United States. It then worked out the doctrine of amphibious assault used across the Pacific after 1942. Today it numbers about 170,000, larger than most national armies.

Read further

  • Charles R. Smith, Marines in the Revolution: A History of the Continental Marines in the American Revolution, 1775-1783 (1975)
  • Allan R. Millett, Semper Fidelis: The History of the United States Marine Corps (1980)
  • Robert Debs Heinl, Soldiers of the Sea: The United States Marine Corps, 1775-1962 (1962)
  • Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774-1789, volume 3
  • Hans Schmidt, The United States Occupation of Haiti, 1915-1934 (1971)

Same day, other years

1659

Shivaji kills Afzal Khan

Pratapgad, western IndiaAsia

Afzal Khan, a veteran general of the Sultanate of Bijapur, had been sent with an army to bring in Shivaji Bhonsle, a young Maratha chief who had been seizing the sultanate’s hill forts. On 10 November 1659 the two met to parley in a tent below Shivaji’s fort of Pratapgad, each with a few attendants. They embraced. Within moments Afzal Khan was dying, torn open by the steel claws Shivaji wore on his fingers and by a dagger. Maratha troops hidden in the forest then fell on the Bijapur army and routed it. The victory made Shivaji a power, and he was crowned king in 1674.

Seen from elsewhere. Maratha chronicles say Afzal Khan struck first, gripping Shivaji’s neck and stabbing at a coat of mail hidden under his robe. Persian chroniclers such as Khafi Khan call it planned treachery. The historian Jadunath Sarkar judged it a preventive killing between two men who each meant murder. The general’s tomb at the site remains a point of communal tension.

1898

An elected city government is overthrown in Wilmington

Wilmington, North Carolina, United StatesThe Americas

Wilmington was North Carolina’s largest city, with a Black majority, Black aldermen, policemen and magistrates, and a governing alliance of Republicans and Populists. On 10 November 1898, two days after a state election won by fraud and intimidation, a mob of some two thousand armed white men led by a former Confederate officer, Alfred Moore Waddell, burned the office of the Black-owned Daily Record and then shot Black residents in the streets. The mayor, aldermen and police chief were forced to resign at gunpoint and Waddell was installed as mayor the same day. Prominent Black citizens and their white allies were marched to the station and banished.

Seen from elsewhere. The organisers called it a restoration of good government and published a ‘White Declaration of Independence’. For a century textbooks called it a race riot. A state commission reported in 2006 that it was a planned coup, and that the dead numbered at least fourteen and perhaps sixty or more. No one was ever prosecuted.

1945

The battle of Surabaya

Surabaya, Java, IndonesiaAsia

Indonesia had declared independence in August 1945, two days after Japan’s surrender. British and British Indian troops landed at Surabaya in late October to disarm the Japanese and free prisoners, and found a city held by tens of thousands of armed Indonesian youths. After Brigadier A. W. S. Mallaby was killed during a ceasefire, the British issued an ultimatum to surrender all weapons. It was ignored. At dawn on 10 November they attacked with tanks, naval guns and aircraft. The city fell after three weeks of street fighting. Indonesian deaths are estimated at between 6,000 and 16,000, and most of the population fled. The date is Indonesia’s Heroes’ Day.

Seen from elsewhere. The British saw a duty under the surrender terms to restore order and rescue internees, some of whom had been massacred. Indonesians saw the advance guard of returning Dutch rule. Who shot Mallaby has never been settled. Many of the Indian soldiers disliked the task, and Nehru protested at their use against another Asian independence movement.

1995

Ken Saro-Wiwa and eight others are hanged

Port Harcourt, NigeriaAfrica

Ken Saro-Wiwa was a novelist and television writer who led the Movement for the Survival of the Ogoni People, a campaign by a community of about half a million in the Niger Delta against the pollution of their land by oil production and for a share of its revenue. In 1994 four Ogoni chiefs who opposed his wing of the movement were killed by a mob. Nigeria’s military government, under General Sani Abacha, tried Saro-Wiwa and others before a special tribunal for inciting the murders. Nine were hanged in Port Harcourt prison on 10 November 1995, while Commonwealth leaders were meeting in New Zealand. Nigeria was suspended from the Commonwealth the next day.

Seen from elsewhere. The government insisted it was an ordinary murder case. Defence lawyers had withdrawn in protest, and two prosecution witnesses later swore they had been bribed. Shell denied any part in the trial; in 2009 it paid 15.5 million dollars to settle a suit by the families without admitting liability. The relatives of the four murdered chiefs have asked not to be forgotten either.

Also on 10 November