Parallax

22 November, 1428

The birth of Warwick the Kingmaker

Richard Neville put one king of England on the throne, imprisoned him, restored the king he had deposed, and died in the fog fighting the first. Whether he ever made anyone king is another matter.

England

Richard Neville was born on 22 November 1428, the eldest son of the Earl of Salisbury and a member of the most prolific noble family in the north of England. At about seven he was married to Anne Beauchamp, daughter of the Earl of Warwick. Nobody expected her to inherit. But her brother died young, then his infant daughter, and in 1449 the husband of the surviving heiress found himself, at twenty, Earl of Warwick and master of estates in more than twenty counties.

His aunt Cecily was married to Richard, Duke of York, and when York challenged the men around the feeble Henry VI the Nevilles went with him. At St Albans in 1455 it was Warwick’s men who broke into the town through the back gardens. His reward was the captaincy of Calais, the Crown’s only standing garrison, and he used its ships to attack Spanish and German merchant fleets in the Channel, which made him a hero in London and Kent.

In the summer of 1460 he landed from Calais, took London and captured the king at Northampton. That winter York and Warwick’s own father were killed at Wakefield, and Warwick himself was beaten at St Albans. He joined York’s eighteen-year-old son Edward, they entered London together, and Edward was acclaimed king in March 1461. Three weeks later the two of them won the largest battle of the wars, at Towton in the snow.

For three years Warwick ran much of the kingdom, and foreign envoys wrote as if he were its ruler. Then, in 1464, while he was negotiating a French royal bride, Edward disclosed that he had secretly married Elizabeth Woodville, a widow with a large family to provide for. The king began to make his own policy, favouring Burgundy over France. In 1469 Warwick married his daughter Isabel to the king’s brother Clarence, raised a rebellion, captured Edward and beheaded the queen’s father and brother. He found that he could not govern through a captive king, and let him go.

A second rising failed and he fled to France. There Louis XI brought about the least likely alliance of the age: Warwick knelt before Margaret of Anjou, Henry VI’s queen, whom he had spent ten years fighting, and betrothed his younger daughter to her son. He invaded in September 1470; Edward fled abroad and Henry was led out of the Tower to be king again. It lasted six months. Edward returned, Clarence changed sides, and on Easter morning, 14 April 1471, the armies met at Barnet in thick fog. Warwick’s line collapsed amid cries of treason. He was caught making for his horse and killed. He was forty-two.

How it came to this

The wars later named after the roses grew from the collapse of royal authority under Henry VI, who came to the throne as a baby in 1422 and proved, as an adult, incapable of governing. England lost its French conquests by 1453, and in that year the king fell into a stupor that lasted more than a year. Power was contested between the court party around Queen Margaret and the Duke of Somerset, and Richard of York, the richest magnate and a man with a claim to the throne arguably better than the king’s.

Great lords in this period kept large followings of gentry and paid retainers who wore their badge; Warwick’s was the bear and ragged staff. Private feuds fed the national one. The Nevilles of Salisbury’s line were at war with the Percy earls of Northumberland in Yorkshire, and Warwick had a bitter inheritance dispute with Somerset over the Beauchamp lands. When York needed allies and the Nevilles needed protection, the alliance followed. It turned a political quarrel into a military one, because between them they could put thousands of men in the field.

How each side saw it

Anne Beauchamp, his countess

Everything that made Warwick great came through his wife, who was Countess of Warwick in her own right. When he was killed she was in sanctuary at Beaulieu Abbey, from where she wrote petitions in her own hand to the king, the queen, the king’s mother and the royal dukes, protesting that she had done no wrong and asking for her inheritance. Edward’s brothers Clarence and Gloucester, married to her two daughters, wanted it for themselves. In 1474 an Act of Parliament divided her lands between them and declared that it should be as if she were ‘naturally dead’. She lived until 1492.

The Yorkist court

The official account of Edward’s return, the Historie of the Arrivall of Edward IV, written by one of the king’s servants within weeks of Barnet, presents Warwick as a rebel and traitor to the prince who had honoured him, and reports that he was killed ‘somewhat fleeing’. Edward had the body exposed for days in St Paul’s so that no one could claim the earl was still alive. In this view Edward owed his crown to his own right and his own victories, and Warwick’s grievance was that of a subject who could not bear to be one.

Margaret of Anjou and the Lancastrians

Warwick had driven Margaret’s husband from the throne, paraded him through London as a prisoner, and helped spread the story that her son was a bastard. French accounts of the meeting at Angers say she kept the earl on his knees for a quarter of an hour before she would pardon him, and she would not let her son sail with him until England was secure. Her caution cost her everything: she landed on the day of Barnet. Lancastrians never trusted him, and their western army made no move to join him in time.

Continental observers

Much of Warwick’s fame was made abroad. The Burgundian chronicler Jean de Waurin met him and admired his manner; Philippe de Commynes, who served both Burgundy and France, wrote that the earl could almost be called the king’s father for the services he had done him, and also that he took a pension from Louis XI. To the French king he was a tool for keeping England divided and away from an alliance with Burgundy. A Milanese envoy had reported in 1461 that he seemed to be everything in the kingdom.

What is disputed

The nickname is not contemporary. It first appears in Latin in the Scottish historian John Major in 1521 and became common in English much later; Shakespeare’s ‘proud setter up and puller down of kings’ fixed the image. Historians disagree about how far it is deserved, since Edward won Mortimer’s Cross without him and they won Towton together. His motives divide biographers: Charles Ross saw overweening ambition, Michael Hicks a magnate with real grievances and a consistent foreign policy, A. J. Pollard a politician who courted popularity as no noble had before. Whether he meant to make Clarence king in 1469 is unknown. His birthplace is not recorded.

What followed

Three weeks after Barnet, Edward destroyed Margaret’s army at Tewkesbury, where her son was killed; Henry VI died in the Tower within days. Warwick’s daughters carried his lands to the king’s brothers. Clarence was executed for treason in 1478. Anne Neville became queen in 1483 as wife of Richard III and died five months before Bosworth. Warwick’s grandson, the last male Plantagenet, was beheaded by Henry VII in 1499, and his granddaughter Margaret Pole by Henry VIII in 1541. His career is the standard case for what happens when a subject grows richer and better armed than the Crown, a lesson the Tudors took to heart.

Read further

  • Michael Hicks, Warwick the Kingmaker (1998)
  • A. J. Pollard, Warwick the Kingmaker: Politics, Power and Fame (2007)
  • Charles Ross, Edward IV (1974)
  • Philippe de Commynes, Memoirs: The Reign of Louis XI, translated by Michael Jones (1972)
  • Historie of the Arrivall of Edward IV in England, edited by John Bruce (1838)

Same day, other years

1718

Blackbeard is killed at Ocracoke

Ocracoke Inlet, North CarolinaThe Americas

Edward Teach, or Thatch, had blockaded the port of Charleston that spring with a captured French slave ship he had armed and renamed Queen Anne’s Revenge. He then accepted a royal pardon from the governor of North Carolina and settled, not very quietly, on its coast. The governor of neighbouring Virginia, Alexander Spotswood, sent two hired sloops under Lieutenant Robert Maynard of the Royal Navy to deal with him. They found him at anchor on 22 November, by the calendar then used in the British colonies. After a broadside that cut down many of Maynard’s men, the fight was finished hand to hand on deck. Teach’s head was hung from the bowsprit.

Seen from elsewhere. Spotswood had no authority in North Carolina, whose officials complained of an armed invasion and were themselves accused of sharing the pirate’s profits. Most of the legend, the smoking fuses in the beard included, comes from one colourful book of 1724, and there is no record that Teach killed anyone before his last fight.

1910

The Revolt of the Lash

Rio de Janeiro, BrazilThe Americas

Brazil had just bought two of the most powerful battleships in the world. The sailors who manned them were mostly Black or of mixed descent, many the sons of people freed from slavery only in 1888, and their white officers still punished them by flogging. After a seaman on the Minas Geraes was given 250 lashes, the crews of four warships mutinied on the night of 22 November, killed the battleship’s captain and several officers, and trained their guns on the capital. Their leader was a helmsman, Joao Candido Felisberto. They asked for an end to the lash, better food and pay, and an amnesty. Congress granted it within four days.

Seen from elsewhere. The navy regarded it as mutiny and murder. Once the ships were handed back, about two thousand sailors were dismissed; after a second rising, prisoners were shut in a cell where most suffocated, and others were shipped to the Amazon. Joao Candido survived and died poor in 1969. A posthumous amnesty came in 2008; the navy still objects to honouring him.

1943

Lebanon’s leaders are freed and independence stands

Beirut and Rashaya, LebanonMiddle East

France had governed Lebanon under a League of Nations mandate since 1920 and had promised independence in 1941 without delivering it. On 8 November 1943 the newly elected parliament deleted every reference to the mandate from the constitution. Three days later the French delegate-general had the president, Bechara el-Khoury, the prime minister, Riad al-Solh, and most of the cabinet arrested before dawn and held in the fortress of Rashaya. The country went on strike, Christians and Muslims together, and Britain, whose army was in occupation, threatened to intervene. On 22 November the prisoners were released and returned to Beirut in triumph. The date is Lebanon’s national day.

Seen from elsewhere. De Gaulle’s Free French saw a British plot to push France out of the Levant. Some Lebanese Christians feared the loss of French protection. The unwritten National Pact that underlay independence shared offices among the religious communities by fixed ratio, an arrangement its critics blame for the civil war of 1975-90.

1963

President Kennedy is shot in Dallas

Dallas, Texas, United StatesThe Americas

At half past twelve, as the presidential motorcade passed through Dealey Plaza, rifle shots struck John F. Kennedy in the back and head and wounded the governor of Texas, John Connally, who was sitting in front of him. Kennedy was declared dead at Parkland Hospital half an hour later. He was forty-six. Lee Harvey Oswald, a former Marine who had once defected to the Soviet Union and who worked in the book warehouse overlooking the route, was arrested that afternoon after a policeman was shot dead. Lyndon Johnson took the oath of office aboard the presidential aircraft with Jacqueline Kennedy beside him. Two days later Oswald was himself shot dead in police custody.

Seen from elsewhere. Oswald denied everything and never stood trial. The Warren Commission found in 1964 that he acted alone. A congressional committee in 1979 thought a conspiracy probable, relying on a sound recording later judged unreliable. Polls have consistently found that most Americans do not believe the lone-gunman account.

Also on 22 November