Parallax

9 September, 1087

The Conqueror dies and his household runs for it

William of Normandy took a kingdom by force and held it for twenty-one years. Within an hour of his death his servants had stripped the room, and at his funeral a local man stood up to say the grave was on stolen land.

Rouen, Normandy

In the last days of July 1087 William, Duke of Normandy and King of the English, rode into the French border town of Mantes while his soldiers burned it. He was about fifty-nine, very heavy, and angry: the garrison of Mantes had been raiding Normandy, and the King of France was said to have made a joke about his size. Somewhere in the burning streets he was badly hurt. One chronicler says his horse jumped a ditch and threw him against the iron pommel of the saddle; another says only that the heat and effort brought on a sickness. Either way he was carried back to Rouen in pain.

The city was too noisy for a dying man, so he was moved to the priory of Saint-Gervais on a hill outside the walls. He lay there for about six weeks, clear in his mind, attended by the Bishop of Lisieux and the Abbot of Jumieges, both of them trained physicians. He gave money to churches and to the poor, and ordered that the clergy of Mantes be paid to rebuild what he had burned.

Then he divided what he had. Normandy went to his eldest son, Robert, who was at that moment in rebellion and living with his father’s enemies. England he said he did not dare leave to anyone, since he had won it by bloodshed, but he hoped that his second surviving son, William Rufus, would have it, and sent him across the Channel with a sealed letter for Archbishop Lanfranc. The youngest, Henry, received five thousand pounds of silver and is said to have gone straight off to have it weighed. Pressed by his barons, William released his political prisoners, including, with great reluctance, his own half-brother Bishop Odo.

Early on Thursday 9 September he was woken by the great bell of Rouen cathedral ringing for the first service of the day. He asked what it was, was told, raised his hands, commended himself to the Virgin, and died.

What happened next was recorded by the monk Orderic Vitalis as a lesson in the worth of worldly power. The great men present mounted at once and rode off to guard their own castles. The lesser attendants took the weapons, plate, linen and furniture and left the body almost naked on the floor. A country knight named Herluin paid out of his own pocket to have it taken by river and sea to Caen. There a fire broke out in the town as the procession passed and most of the mourners ran to fight it. During the funeral in the abbey church of Saint-Etienne a man named Ascelin shouted that the ground had been his father’s, taken by force to build the abbey, and had to be paid sixty shillings before the burial could go on. Finally the swollen corpse would not fit the stone coffin. When the attendants forced it, the body burst, and the service was finished in a hurry through a stench that incense could not cover.

How it came to this

William was the illegitimate son of Duke Robert of Normandy and Herleva, a woman of Falaise whose father was probably a tanner or an undertaker. He inherited the duchy as a child of seven or eight and survived a boyhood in which several of his guardians were murdered. By his thirties he had made Normandy the best organised military power in northern France. In 1066, claiming that his cousin Edward the Confessor had promised him the English throne and that Harold Godwinson had sworn to support him, he crossed the Channel, killed Harold at Hastings and was crowned at Westminster on Christmas Day.

Holding England took longer than winning it. Risings in 1068-70 were put down with a severity that shocked even Norman writers, above all the devastation of Yorkshire and the north in the winter of 1069-70. The English aristocracy was almost entirely replaced, castles went up in every shire town, and in 1086 the survey later called Domesday Book set down who held every estate in the kingdom. His last years were spent mostly in Normandy, fighting his neighbours and his own eldest son.

How each side saw it

The English, in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle

The Peterborough version of the Chronicle carries an obituary by an Englishman who says he had looked on the king and once lived at his court. It is the nearest thing to a verdict from the conquered. He grants that William was wise, powerful and kept such good order that a man could cross the kingdom with his bosom full of gold. Then he lists the cost: castles built by forced labour, poor men oppressed, a greed for silver that knew no limit, and forest laws under which whoever killed a deer was blinded. The king, he writes, loved the stags as if he were their father.

Orderic Vitalis, monk of Saint-Evroul

Orderic was born in Shropshire in 1075 to a Norman father and an English mother and sent to a Norman monastery at ten. Writing some fifty years after the event, he gives William a long deathbed confession in which the king admits he took England by slaughter, not by hereditary right, and that he fell on the people of the north like a raging lion, leaving thousands to starve. The speech is Orderic’s composition, in the classical manner. It shows what a thoughtful Anglo-Norman monk believed the Conqueror ought to have had on his conscience.

The Norman court tradition

William of Poitiers, the duke’s chaplain, and William of Jumieges wrote of a lawful heir punishing a perjurer with the blessing of the Pope, who had sent a banner. A short anonymous text, On the Death of William, shows a model Christian ruler making an orderly end. Scholars have shown that much of it is lifted word for word from ninth-century lives of Charlemagne and Louis the Pious, so it tells us how Normans wished their duke remembered. In Normandy he was above all the founder of the two great abbeys at Caen and the man who had kept the peace.

Modern historians

Verdicts have swung with the times. Victorian writers such as Edward Freeman saw the Conquest as a brief interruption of English liberty; twentieth-century scholars led by David Douglas stressed the administrative ability of the Normans. More recent work, including David Bates’s biography, treats William as a ruler who was conventionally pious, legally careful and capable of calculated mass violence, and asks how far the north of England was really emptied. Marc Morris and others point out that he abolished the slave trade in English captives and ended the killing of defeated nobles, while dispossessing a whole ruling class.

What is disputed

The injury at Mantes is described differently by William of Malmesbury (the saddle pommel) and Orderic (illness from heat), and neither was there. The deathbed speech is literary. Whether William actually named Rufus as king or merely hoped for it is argued, as is his birth year, 1027 or 1028. Orderic’s figure of 100,000 dead from the Harrying of the North is not a count, and some historians think Domesday’s ‘waste’ entries overstate the damage. The claim that he was the last successful invader of England ignores 1326, 1485 and 1688, all of which succeeded with help from inside.

What followed

Rufus was crowned at Westminster within three weeks. Robert kept Normandy, mortgaged it to go on crusade, and lost it to the youngest brother, Henry, who had taken the English crown in 1100 when Rufus was killed hunting. The link between England and lands in France that William created shaped both kingdoms for four centuries. His tomb at Caen was opened in 1522, wrecked by Calvinists in 1562 and again in the Revolution. A single thigh bone, examined in the 1980s, is all that is thought to remain under the plain slab there now.

Read further

  • David Bates, William the Conqueror (2016)
  • David C. Douglas, William the Conqueror: The Norman Impact upon England (1964)
  • Orderic Vitalis, The Ecclesiastical History, edited and translated by Marjorie Chibnall (1969-80)
  • The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle: A Revised Translation, edited by Dorothy Whitelock, David C. Douglas and Susie I. Tucker (1961)
  • Marc Morris, The Norman Conquest (2012)

Same day, other years

1739

The Stono Rebellion

Stono River, South CarolinaThe Americas

Early on a Sunday morning about twenty enslaved men, led by a man the records call Jemmy, broke into a store by the Stono River bridge, killed the two storekeepers and took guns and powder. They marched south towards Spanish Florida, where the governor had promised freedom to fugitives from the British colonies, with drums beating and a banner flying. By the afternoon their number had grown to somewhere between sixty and a hundred and more than twenty white colonists were dead. Mounted militia caught them resting in a field near the Edisto River. Most were killed there or hunted down in the following weeks.

Seen from elsewhere. Every contemporary account was written by white colonists, who answered with the Negro Act of 1740, banning enslaved people from assembling, earning money or learning to write. The historian John Thornton has argued that many of the rebels were Catholic soldiers from the Kingdom of Kongo. A family tradition of the rising was recorded from a descendant, George Cato, in the 1930s.

1922

The Turkish army enters Smyrna

Smyrna (Izmir), TurkeyMiddle East

Turkish cavalry rode along the waterfront of Smyrna on the morning of 9 September, ending a war that had begun when Greek troops landed in the same port in May 1919 with the approval of the Allied powers. The Greek army had been broken two weeks earlier in the interior and had already left by sea. Smyrna was the largest city of Ottoman Christians, with big Greek and Armenian quarters. Within days the Greek Orthodox bishop, Chrysostomos, had been killed by a mob, and on 13 September a fire began that destroyed those quarters and drove hundreds of thousands onto the quay.

Seen from elsewhere. In Turkey 9 September is the Liberation of Izmir, the end of an occupation that opened with killings of Turkish civilians and closed with the retreating Greek army burning towns across western Anatolia. In Greece it is the Catastrophe. Most foreign eyewitnesses blamed Turkish troops for the fire; the Turkish account has long blamed Greeks and Armenians. Estimates of the dead run from 10,000 to 100,000.

1976

Mao Zedong dies

Beijing, ChinaAsia

The Chairman of the Chinese Communist Party died ten minutes after midnight, aged eighty-two, after months in which he could barely speak. He had led the party to victory in the civil war in 1949 and ruled the world’s most populous country for twenty-seven years. A million people filed past his body, which was embalmed and remains on display in Tiananmen Square. Less than a month later his widow, Jiang Qing, and three allies, the Gang of Four, were arrested by his chosen successor, Hua Guofeng. Within two years Deng Xiaoping was steering China away from almost everything Mao’s last decade had stood for.

Seen from elsewhere. The party’s own resolution of 1981 holds that his achievements were primary and his errors secondary. Historians such as Frank Dikotter attribute tens of millions of deaths to the famine of the Great Leap Forward, with estimates between 15 and 45 million, and more to the Cultural Revolution. Others stress that life expectancy and literacy rose sharply under his rule.

1990

Samuel Doe is captured in Monrovia

Monrovia, LiberiaAfrica

Samuel Doe had taken power in 1980 as a twenty-eight-year-old master sergeant, killing President William Tolbert and ending more than a century of rule by the descendants of freed American slaves. Ten years later rebels held most of the country and he was confined to his mansion. On 9 September he drove to the headquarters of the West African peacekeeping force at the port. Fighters loyal to the rebel commander Prince Johnson arrived, shot dozens of his bodyguards and took him away. He was tortured in front of a video camera while Johnson drank beer, and was dead by the next morning.

Seen from elsewhere. Doe’s own Krahn people were then hunted by his enemies. The Gio and Mano of Nimba County had been massacred by his army, most notoriously in a Monrovia church six weeks earlier. Why the peacekeepers let armed rebels into their compound has never been properly explained. Johnson was never tried and sat for years as an elected senator. The wars lasted, with a pause, until 2003.

Also on 9 September