The Dominican friar who died at the monastery of Santo Tomas in Avila on 16 September 1498 was about seventy-eight and had been failing for years. Four years earlier the Pope had appointed four bishops to share his duties on account of his age and infirmities. He had paid for the monastery himself, out of property confiscated from the people his tribunals convicted, and he was buried in its church.
Tomas de Torquemada came late to power. For twenty-two years he was prior of a Dominican house in Segovia, known for his austerity; he slept on a board and refused a bishopric. He was also one of the confessors of the young Princess Isabella, and after she became Queen of Castile he was among the churchmen who urged her to act against the conversos, the descendants of Jews baptised over the previous century, many of whom were believed to practise Judaism in secret.
In 1478 Pope Sixtus IV allowed Isabella and her husband, Ferdinand of Aragon, to name inquisitors of their own. The first tribunal began work in Seville in 1480 and burned six people the following February. Torquemada was made an inquisitor in 1482 and, in 1483, Inquisitor General for Castile and then for Aragon too, the only office whose authority ran across both of the monarchs’ kingdoms.
What he supplied was organisation. He set up a governing council, placed tribunals in the main cities, and in 1484 issued the first of several sets of written instructions. A tribunal arriving in a town proclaimed a period of grace in which people could confess and be reconciled with a penance. After that came denunciations. The accused was imprisoned, his property seized at once to pay for his keep and the court’s costs, and he was not told who had accused him. Torture was permitted to obtain a confession. Those who confessed lost their goods and wore a penitential tunic; those who would not, or who relapsed, were handed to the royal officers and burned.
Resistance was strongest in Aragon. In 1485 the inquisitor of Zaragoza was stabbed to death while praying in the cathedral, and the reprisals broke the leading converso families of the city. Torquemada is said to have travelled thereafter with an escort of fifty horsemen and two hundred foot. In 1491 his courts convicted a group of conversos and Jews of crucifying a Christian child at La Guardia; no child had been reported missing and no body was found. Months later, on 31 March 1492, the monarchs signed the order he had long pressed for, giving all professing Jews four months to accept baptism or leave Spain.
How it came to this
Medieval Spain had the largest Jewish population in Europe. In 1391 mobs attacked the Jewish quarters of Seville, Valencia, Barcelona and dozens of other towns, and offered the survivors baptism or death. Further mass conversions followed a campaign of preaching and legal pressure in the 1410s. By the middle of the fifteenth century there were perhaps a quarter of a million conversos, or New Christians. Freed from the restrictions on Jews, many rose fast in the Church, the law, royal finance and city government, and married into the nobility.
Their success was resented. Riots against conversos broke out in Toledo in 1449, where the city council passed the first statute barring anyone of Jewish descent from office, and elsewhere in the 1460s and 1470s. The accusation was always that they were Christians in name only. Some certainly kept Jewish customs; how many is the heart of the historical argument. Church law gave the Inquisition authority only over the baptised, so professing Jews were outside its reach. That is the reasoning the edict of 1492 gave: as long as Jews remained, the converts would be drawn back.