Parallax

16 September, 1498

The first Grand Inquisitor dies at Avila

Tomas de Torquemada ate no meat, wore a hair shirt and built the machinery that tried tens of thousands of Spaniards for secret Judaism. How many died, and what he was really after, has been argued for five centuries.

Avila, Castile

The Dominican friar who died at the monastery of Santo Tomas in Avila on 16 September 1498 was about seventy-eight and had been failing for years. Four years earlier the Pope had appointed four bishops to share his duties on account of his age and infirmities. He had paid for the monastery himself, out of property confiscated from the people his tribunals convicted, and he was buried in its church.

Tomas de Torquemada came late to power. For twenty-two years he was prior of a Dominican house in Segovia, known for his austerity; he slept on a board and refused a bishopric. He was also one of the confessors of the young Princess Isabella, and after she became Queen of Castile he was among the churchmen who urged her to act against the conversos, the descendants of Jews baptised over the previous century, many of whom were believed to practise Judaism in secret.

In 1478 Pope Sixtus IV allowed Isabella and her husband, Ferdinand of Aragon, to name inquisitors of their own. The first tribunal began work in Seville in 1480 and burned six people the following February. Torquemada was made an inquisitor in 1482 and, in 1483, Inquisitor General for Castile and then for Aragon too, the only office whose authority ran across both of the monarchs’ kingdoms.

What he supplied was organisation. He set up a governing council, placed tribunals in the main cities, and in 1484 issued the first of several sets of written instructions. A tribunal arriving in a town proclaimed a period of grace in which people could confess and be reconciled with a penance. After that came denunciations. The accused was imprisoned, his property seized at once to pay for his keep and the court’s costs, and he was not told who had accused him. Torture was permitted to obtain a confession. Those who confessed lost their goods and wore a penitential tunic; those who would not, or who relapsed, were handed to the royal officers and burned.

Resistance was strongest in Aragon. In 1485 the inquisitor of Zaragoza was stabbed to death while praying in the cathedral, and the reprisals broke the leading converso families of the city. Torquemada is said to have travelled thereafter with an escort of fifty horsemen and two hundred foot. In 1491 his courts convicted a group of conversos and Jews of crucifying a Christian child at La Guardia; no child had been reported missing and no body was found. Months later, on 31 March 1492, the monarchs signed the order he had long pressed for, giving all professing Jews four months to accept baptism or leave Spain.

How it came to this

Medieval Spain had the largest Jewish population in Europe. In 1391 mobs attacked the Jewish quarters of Seville, Valencia, Barcelona and dozens of other towns, and offered the survivors baptism or death. Further mass conversions followed a campaign of preaching and legal pressure in the 1410s. By the middle of the fifteenth century there were perhaps a quarter of a million conversos, or New Christians. Freed from the restrictions on Jews, many rose fast in the Church, the law, royal finance and city government, and married into the nobility.

Their success was resented. Riots against conversos broke out in Toledo in 1449, where the city council passed the first statute barring anyone of Jewish descent from office, and elsewhere in the 1460s and 1470s. The accusation was always that they were Christians in name only. Some certainly kept Jewish customs; how many is the heart of the historical argument. Church law gave the Inquisition authority only over the baptised, so professing Jews were outside its reach. That is the reasoning the edict of 1492 gave: as long as Jews remained, the converts would be drawn back.

How each side saw it

Jews and conversos

Jewish accounts of the expulsion come from exiles: Isaac Abravanel, the royal financier who pleaded with the monarchs and then left for Italy, and later chroniclers such as Solomon ibn Verga and Samuel Usque, who describe families robbed and drowned on the roads and ships. Among the conversos the royal secretary Hernando del Pulgar, himself of Jewish descent, protested in a letter to the Archbishop of Seville that thousands of ignorant people were being burned who had never been properly taught the faith they were accused of betraying. Converso families petitioned Rome repeatedly against secret witnesses and confiscation.

The Crown and the Inquisition’s defenders

To Isabella, Ferdinand and the clergy around them, heresy was treason against God and a danger to the souls of the whole kingdom, and they believed the evidence of secret Judaism was overwhelming. The priest and chronicler Andres Bernaldez, who watched the first trials in Seville, wrote of the conversos with open hostility and thought the fires deserved. A later Dominican chronicler, Sebastian de Olmedo, called Torquemada the hammer of heretics, the light of Spain and the saviour of his country. Defenders also noted that the Inquisition followed written procedure at a time when ordinary criminal courts used torture freely.

The papacy

Rome’s attitude was mixed. Sixtus IV had granted the monarchs their inquisitors, but in a bull of April 1482 he complained that in Aragon the tribunals were moved by lust for wealth instead of zeal for the faith, and that true Christians were being imprisoned, tortured and condemned on the word of enemies and slaves. He ordered that the accused be told the names of witnesses and allowed appeals to Rome. Ferdinand answered that he would not permit the bull to take effect, and the Pope suspended it. Later popes sold individual absolutions to conversos, which the Spanish Inquisition refused to honour.

Modern historians

They disagree about the facts underneath. Yitzhak Baer and Haim Beinart, working from trial records, concluded that many conversos were indeed attached to Judaism and that the inquisitors were, on their own terms, pursuing something real. Benzion Netanyahu argued the opposite: most conversos were sincere Christians, the charges were largely invented, and the driving force was racial hatred and envy of their position. Henry Kamen has argued that the Inquisition was smaller, poorer and less feared than its legend, and that Torquemada’s part in the expulsion has been overstated at the expense of Ferdinand’s.

What is disputed

Numbers above all. Juan Antonio Llorente, a former official of the Inquisition writing in 1817, put those burned under Torquemada at 8,800, a figure long repeated. Modern estimates from surviving records suggest about 2,000 executions across all tribunals up to 1530, with many more condemned in their absence. Estimates of Jews who left in 1492 have fallen from 200,000 to between 40,000 and 100,000. The scene in which Torquemada throws down a crucifix before the monarchs, to stop them accepting Jewish money, comes from later writers. Whether he himself had converso ancestors rests on a remark by Pulgar about his uncle, and is not established.

What followed

The Spanish Inquisition outlived him by more than three centuries. It turned in time against Muslims converted by force, Protestants, mystics, and ordinary people accused of blasphemy or bigamy, and was abolished for good in 1834. Statutes of ‘purity of blood’, which excluded people of Jewish or Muslim descent from offices and religious orders, spread through Spanish institutions and across the Atlantic. His tomb at Avila was broken open in 1836 and the remains scattered. The exiles of 1492 founded the Sephardic communities of the Ottoman empire, North Africa and Amsterdam. In 2015 Spain offered citizenship to their descendants.

Read further

  • Henry Kamen, The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision (1997)
  • Benzion Netanyahu, The Origins of the Inquisition in Fifteenth Century Spain (1995)
  • Haim Beinart, The Expulsion of the Jews from Spain (2002)
  • Joseph Perez, The Spanish Inquisition: A History (2004)
  • Yitzhak Baer, A History of the Jews in Christian Spain (1961-66)

Same day, other years

1810

The cry of Dolores

Dolores, Guanajuato, MexicoThe Americas

Miguel Hidalgo, the fifty-seven-year-old parish priest of the town of Dolores, learned in the night that a plot against Spanish rule in which he was involved had been betrayed. Before dawn he had the church bell rung, freed the prisoners from the jail, and called on the crowd of parishioners, most of them Indigenous and mixed-race labourers, to rise. Within weeks he led tens of thousands of people armed with machetes and slings under the banner of the Virgin of Guadalupe. They took the rich mining city of Guanajuato and reached the edge of Mexico City before turning back. Hidalgo was captured and shot in July 1811.

Seen from elsewhere. Nobody wrote down what he said; versions invoke the Virgin, King Ferdinand VII and death to bad government. At Guanajuato his followers killed hundreds of Spaniards and creoles who had taken refuge in the granary. The conservative historian Lucas Alaman, who saw it as a boy, described a race war. Independence came in 1821 under a royalist officer who had fought against Hidalgo.

1931

Omar Mukhtar is hanged

Suluq, Cyrenaica, LibyaAfrica

Omar Mukhtar, a teacher of the Quran in his seventies, had led the resistance of the Senussi order to Italian rule in eastern Libya for most of twenty years, fighting a guerrilla war from the Green Mountain. Wounded and captured on 11 September, he was taken to Benghazi, tried in a single afternoon and hanged the next morning at the Suluq concentration camp in front of some twenty thousand prisoners brought to watch. To cut the fighters off from support, the Italian commanders Badoglio and Graziani had by then driven around 100,000 people, most of the rural population of Cyrenaica, into desert camps. Tens of thousands died there.

Seen from elsewhere. Fascist Italy called the campaign the pacification of a colony and Mukhtar a rebel against lawful authority; the Italian officer assigned to defend him, who argued he was a prisoner of war, was disciplined. A 1981 film of his life was kept off Italian screens for years. Italy apologised for the colonial period in a treaty with Libya in 2008.

1982

The Sabra and Shatila massacre begins

Beirut, LebanonMiddle East

Two days after the assassination of Lebanon’s Christian president-elect, the Israeli army, which had invaded in June and had just occupied West Beirut, sealed off the Palestinian district of Sabra and the neighbouring Shatila refugee camp. On the evening of 16 September it allowed militiamen of the Lebanese Christian Phalange to enter, to root out fighters said to have remained after the PLO’s evacuation. Israeli flares lit the area through the night. The militiamen killed unarmed men, women and children until the morning of the 18th. An Israeli commission of inquiry found that Israel bore indirect responsibility and that the defence minister, Ariel Sharon, bore personal responsibility; he lost that post.

Seen from elsewhere. Counts of the dead range from about 460 in a Lebanese police report and 700 to 800 in Israeli intelligence estimates to more than 3,000 in Palestinian ones. The Phalangists spoke of revenge for their leader and for earlier massacres of Christians. No one was tried in Lebanon. The militia commander, Elie Hobeika, later a government minister, was killed by a car bomb in 2002.

1987

The Montreal Protocol is signed

Montreal, CanadaWorldwide

Delegates of two dozen countries and the European Community signed an agreement to halve their use of chlorofluorocarbons, the gases in refrigerators, aerosol cans and foam that were destroying the ozone layer which shields the Earth from ultraviolet radiation. Chemists had predicted the damage in 1974, and in 1985 British scientists in Antarctica reported a seasonal hole in the layer far larger than anyone expected. Later amendments turned the cuts into a ban. Every member state of the United Nations has ratified it, the first treaty of which that is true, and the ozone layer is expected to return to its 1980 condition around the middle of this century.

Seen from elsewhere. Manufacturers disputed the science for a decade and warned of heavy costs. India, China and other developing countries held back until 1990, arguing that those who had caused the damage should pay for the remedy; they obtained a fund and a longer timetable. Some of the replacement chemicals proved to be powerful greenhouse gases and needed a further agreement in 2016.

Also on 16 September