Parallax

7 September, 1812

Borodino: the bloodiest day of Napoleon’s wars

A quarter of a million men fought for twelve hours over a few low earthworks seventy-five miles from Moscow. Both commanders reported a victory, and the one who kept the field had lost the campaign.

Borodino, west of Moscow, Russia

The sun came up clear over the Russian lines at about half past five, and Napoleon, who had been awake most of the night with a heavy cold and a bladder complaint, is reported by his aide Philippe de Segur to have greeted it as the sun of Austerlitz. He had spent the previous day studying a portrait of his infant son, newly arrived from Paris, and reading a dispatch announcing Wellington’s victory at Salamanca. He had also turned down a proposal from Marshal Davout to march round the Russian left by night. He wanted a battle, not a manoeuvre, and after ten weeks of pursuing an army that would not stand, he finally had one in front of him.

The Russians under Mikhail Kutuzov, about 120,000 regulars with Cossacks and militia besides, held a line of low hills behind the Kolocha stream. Its strongpoints were a large battery in the centre, known afterwards as the Raevsky redoubt, and three arrow-shaped earthworks on the left held by Prince Bagration. Napoleon had roughly 130,000 men and 587 guns. His plan was a frontal assault.

The guns opened at six. For the next six hours French, Polish, German and Italian infantry stormed the left-hand earthworks, lost them, and stormed them again, some accounts say seven or eight times, across ground so covered with bodies that horses refused to cross it. Around ten o’clock a shell splinter smashed Bagration’s leg. He was carried off, and the Russian left gave way as far as the ruined village of Semyonovskoe.

The redoubt in the centre was taken in the afternoon, after a Russian cavalry raid round the French left had delayed the attack by two hours, in a charge by cuirassiers who rode in through the back of the work. Their commander, Auguste de Caulaincourt, was killed at the entrance. The Russian line bent back about a mile and stayed there, re-forming under fire. Ney, Murat and Davout sent to ask for the Imperial Guard, 18,000 fresh men, to finish it. Napoleon refused. He would not, he is said to have replied, have his last reserve destroyed eight hundred leagues from Paris.

By six in the evening the firing had died away. The French artillery had fired some 60,000 rounds. Between them the armies had lost something like 70,000 killed and wounded, a figure not equalled in a single day of European war for a century. Kutuzov reported that the enemy had nowhere gained a foot of ground and ordered an attack for the morning. Then the returns came in showing that a third or more of his army was gone, and during the night he withdrew towards Moscow.

How it came to this

Napoleon had crossed the river Niemen in June 1812 with the largest army Europe had seen, more than 450,000 men in the first wave, of whom fewer than half were French. His quarrel with Tsar Alexander I was over Russia’s withdrawal from the blockade of British trade, and his aim was a quick, crushing battle near the frontier followed by a dictated peace. The Russian armies, outnumbered, declined to give him one. They fell back for 500 miles, burning stores as they went, while heat, hunger, typhus and desertion cut the invading main force to a third of its strength.

The retreat was the policy of the war minister, Barclay de Tolly, from a Baltic German family of Scottish descent, whom many Russian officers called a coward or a traitor for it. After the loss of Smolensk in August, Alexander gave way to opinion and appointed the sixty-six-year-old Kutuzov, a pupil of Suvorov and a Russian of the Russians, to the supreme command. Kutuzov privately thought Barclay had been right. But Moscow could not be given up without a fight, and he chose his ground at Borodino.

How each side saw it

Russia

Kutuzov’s dispatch to the tsar claimed that the army had held its position, and Alexander made him a field marshal. Te Deums were sung in St Petersburg. The claim became the national tradition, given its lasting form by Tolstoy, who argued in War and Peace that Borodino was a moral victory in which the French, for the first time, met a will stronger than their own and were mortally wounded. Soviet historians went further and called it a Russian victory outright. The anniversary is an official Day of Military Glory, and the field is one of the oldest preserved battlefield museums in the world.

The French command

Napoleon’s bulletin announced a complete victory at what the French call the battle of the Moskova, and Ney was made Prince of the Moskova for it. Among his officers the verdict was cooler. Segur’s history, published in 1824, portrays an emperor sunk in lethargy and illness who let the Russian army escape by withholding the Guard. General Gourgaud thought this a libel, wrote a rebuttal and fought a duel with Segur over it. On St Helena, Napoleon is reported to have called it the most terrible of his battles, in which the French showed themselves worthy of victory and the Russians of being invincible.

The other nations in the Grande Armee

Much of the army that attacked at Borodino was not French. Poniatowski’s Poles fought on the right, hoping for a restored Poland. Westphalians, Wurttembergers, Bavarians and Italians were in the assaults, and the cuirassiers who took the great redoubt included Saxon and Polish regiments. They served because their rulers were Napoleon’s allies or vassals. Their memoirs, such as the diary of the Wurttemberg conscript Jakob Walter, describe hunger, plunder and survival rather than glory. Within a year most of their states had changed sides, and German nationalist tradition came to remember 1812 as a sacrifice in a foreign cause.

Barclay de Tolly and Kutuzov’s critics

Barclay commanded the Russian right and centre that day in full dress uniform, had several horses killed under him, and by many accounts was seeking death. His written defence of his strategy argues that the retreat he was vilified for is what destroyed the invasion. Clausewitz, who served on the Russian staff, described Kutuzov at Borodino as almost inert, approving whatever was proposed to him. Later Russian writers were divided between those who saw a patient strategist husbanding his army and those who saw an old courtier who inherited another man’s plan and the credit for it. Dominic Lieven gives more weight to the army’s professional staff than to either general.

What is disputed

Who won depends on the measure: the French took the ground and the road to Moscow, the Russians kept an army in being. Casualties are estimates. French losses are usually put at 28,000 to 35,000 and Russian at 40,000 to 45,000, with some Russian archival counts higher. Whether committing the Guard would have ended the war is argued to this day. The line about the sun of Austerlitz and the remark about the Guard come from memoirs written years later. The date was 26 August in the Russian calendar of the time; Russia’s official anniversary falls on 8 September through a conversion error.

What followed

Kutuzov gave up Moscow without another battle on 14 September. The city burned, the tsar refused to negotiate, and after five weeks Napoleon began a retreat that winter, hunger and Russian pursuit turned into the destruction of his army. Fewer than a tenth of the men who had crossed the Niemen came back in formed units. Bagration died of his wound. The coalition that reached Paris in 1814 was built on that outcome. Borodino entered Russian culture through Lermontov, Tolstoy and Tchaikovsky’s 1812 Overture, and the same field was fought over again in October 1941.

Read further

  • Dominic Lieven, Russia Against Napoleon: The Battle for Europe, 1807 to 1814 (2009)
  • Adam Zamoyski, 1812: Napoleon’s Fatal March on Moscow (2004)
  • Alexander Mikaberidze, The Battle of Borodino: Napoleon Against Kutuzov (2007)
  • Carl von Clausewitz, The Campaign of 1812 in Russia
  • Philippe-Paul de Segur, History of the Expedition to Russia Undertaken by the Emperor Napoleon in the Year 1812 (1824)

Same day, other years

1191

Arsuf: Richard’s column turns on Saladin

Arsuf, coast of PalestineMiddle East

After taking Acre, Richard I marched the army of the Third Crusade south along the coast towards Jaffa, the fleet keeping pace offshore with supplies. For two weeks Saladin’s mounted archers harried the column, trying to provoke it into breaking formation. On 7 September, on the plain north of Arsuf, Saladin attacked in full strength. Richard held his knights back behind the infantry for hours, waiting for the enemy to commit. The Hospitallers at the rear, losing horses to arrows, finally charged without orders, and Richard threw the whole line forward after them. Saladin’s army was driven from the field with heavy loss. Richard reached Jaffa three days later and rebuilt its walls.

Seen from elsewhere. Saladin’s secretary Baha al-Din, who was present, describes the rout frankly and the sultan’s distress that evening, but notes that the army had reassembled by the next day. The Latin sources’ figure of 7,000 Muslim dead is not credible. Saladin lost a battle and kept Jerusalem, which Richard twice approached to within a day’s march and never attacked.

1822

A prince declares Brazil independent

Sao Paulo, BrazilThe Americas

Pedro, heir to the Portuguese throne and regent in Brazil, was returning from Santos to Sao Paulo when a courier reached him beside the Ipiranga stream. The letters reported that the parliament in Lisbon had annulled his acts and ordered him home, and that his wife Leopoldina and his minister Jose Bonifacio advised an immediate break. By the accounts of those with him, he tore the Portuguese colours from his uniform, drew his sword and swore ‘Independence or death’. He was acclaimed emperor in October and crowned in December. Portuguese garrisons held out in Bahia and the north until 1823, and Lisbon recognised the new state in 1825 in return for a large payment.

Seen from elsewhere. The scene rests on recollections set down years later, and the heroic painting of it dates from 1888. Leopoldina, acting as regent, had already presided over the council that decided on separation five days earlier. Independence kept the monarchy and kept slavery, which bound perhaps a third of the population and lasted until 1888. Bahia celebrates its own date, 2 July.

1901

The Boxer Protocol is signed in Beijing

Beijing, ChinaAsia

A year after an eight-nation army relieved the besieged foreign legations, the elderly statesman Li Hongzhang and Prince Qing signed, on behalf of the Qing court, the terms dictated by eleven powers. China was to pay an indemnity of 450 million taels of silver over thirty-nine years, which with interest came to more than twice that and far exceeded the government’s annual revenue. Officials who had supported the Boxers were to be executed or exiled. Foreign troops would be stationed permanently between Beijing and the sea, the forts guarding the capital were to be razed, and arms imports were banned for two years. Li died two months later.

Seen from elsewhere. The Boxers had killed tens of thousands of Chinese Christians and more than two hundred foreign missionaries and their families. The allied troops in turn looted Beijing and killed large numbers of Chinese civilians in punitive expeditions. In the People’s Republic the Boxers were long honoured as patriotic peasants; some Chinese historians have challenged that view, and been censured for it.

1936

The last known thylacine dies in a zoo

Hobart, Tasmania, AustraliaOceania

The thylacine, or Tasmanian tiger, was a striped, dog-sized marsupial carnivore that had vanished from mainland Australia some three thousand years ago and survived only in Tasmania. Settlers blamed it for killing sheep. A private company paid bounties on it from 1830, and between 1888 and 1909 the Tasmanian government paid for 2,184 carcasses. By the 1920s it was rarely seen. The last captive animal, trapped in the wild a few years earlier, died at the Beaumaris Zoo in Hobart on the night of 7 September 1936, apparently after being shut out of its sleeping quarters in a cold spell. Tasmania had given the species legal protection fifty-nine days before.

Seen from elsewhere. The zoologist Robert Paddle has argued that the sheep losses were mostly the work of dogs and poor management, and that the bounty served farming interests looking for a scapegoat. The animal’s popular name, Benjamin, is probably a later invention. Unconfirmed sightings have continued ever since, and a 2023 study suggested the species may have persisted in remote country for decades.

Also on 7 September