Parallax

11 September, 1697

An Ottoman army is caught halfway across the Tisza

A thirty-three-year-old general whom Louis XIV had turned away as unfit for soldiering found the sultan’s army split by a river two hours before sunset, and attacked without waiting.

Zenta (Senta, Serbia)

Prince Eugene of Savoy had held the chief command of the Habsburg army in Hungary for barely two months. The force he took over in July 1697 was unpaid, hungry and scattered, and the Ottoman army coming north from Belgrade was led by Sultan Mustafa II in person, the first sultan in generations to take the field year after year. Through August the two armies manoeuvred across the plain between the Danube and the Tisza. The sultan’s council could not agree on a target and finally decided to cross the Tisza eastwards and march on Transylvania.

On 11 September Eugene’s hussars brought in a captured Ottoman officer. Under threat he told them what Eugene most wanted to know: the Ottomans had thrown a bridge of boats across the river at the small town of Zenta, the sultan, the cavalry and most of the guns were already on the far bank, and the infantry was still waiting on the near side behind a half-finished earthwork. Eugene rode ahead with his cavalry, saw for himself that it was true, and ordered the infantry to follow at a forced pace. They had already been marching for most of the day.

It was about four in the afternoon when his roughly 50,000 men were in position, drawn up in a half-circle that pinned the Ottoman foot against the water. There was no time for a bombardment. The Imperial left wing found that the river was low and that sandbanks along the shore let them wade round the end of the entrenchment. They got in behind the defenders and reached the bridgehead. With the only way out cut, the Ottoman line collapsed.

What followed was a massacre more than a battle. The janissaries, crowded onto the bridge and the bank, were shot down or driven into the river and drowned. Some turned on their own commanders, and the Grand Vizier, Elmas Mehmed Pasha, was killed, by most accounts by his own troops. The sultan watched from the opposite shore and could send no help. Eugene reported to the emperor that his men could stand on the heaped bodies as if on islands, and that the sun had seemed unwilling to set before it had seen the victory complete.

The Habsburg army lost perhaps four hundred and thirty dead. Ottoman losses are usually put at 25,000 to 30,000. The booty included the army’s pay chest, eighty-seven cannon, thousands of camels and, taken from the vizier’s body, the great seal of the empire, which no enemy had captured before. The sultan fled to Temesvar. Eugene, short of supplies and with the season late, did not pursue; in October he led a fast raid into Bosnia and burned Sarajevo.

How it came to this

The war had begun in 1683 when an Ottoman army besieged Vienna and was driven off. In the years that followed the Habsburgs and their allies in the Holy League, Poland, Venice and later Russia, took Buda, most of Hungary and for a time Belgrade. Then Louis XIV attacked in the west, the emperor moved his best troops to the Rhine, and the Ottomans recovered Belgrade in 1690. The eastern front settled into costly stalemate. Only in 1697, as the war with France was ending, could Vienna spare men and money again.

Eugene was a French subject by birth, the son of a Savoyard prince and of Olympia Mancini, a niece of Cardinal Mazarin who left France under suspicion in the Affair of the Poisons. Small and plain, he had been intended for the Church. When Louis XIV refused him a commission in 1683 he slipped out of France and offered himself to the emperor in time to fight at the relief of Vienna. He was a field marshal at twenty-nine. The Hungarian command came to him when the Elector of Saxony gave it up to become King of Poland.

How each side saw it

The Ottoman court

The fullest Ottoman account is by Silahdar Findiklili Mehmed Aga, a palace official who was with the sultan’s suite. Ottoman writers did not put the defeat down to Habsburg skill. They blamed divided counsel at Belgrade, where commanders argued for different objectives, and the Grand Vizier’s decision to pass a wide river in the presence of the enemy and to send the guns over first. The mutiny of the janissaries against their officers was read as a symptom of indiscipline at the centre of the state. The loss of the seal was felt as a particular humiliation.

Hungarians

Hungary was the prize, and Hungarians were on both sides. Many Protestant nobles and soldiers had fought with Imre Thokoly, the Ottoman-backed prince, because Habsburg rule had brought persecution of their churches and the suspension of their constitution. Thokoly himself was in the sultan’s camp in 1697. For them the ‘liberation’ meant a Catholic, absolutist government imposed by a German-speaking army that lived off the land; that very summer a peasant revolt had broken out in the Tokaj hills. In 1703 Francis Rakoczi led a national rising against Vienna that lasted eight years.

Serbs and other Balkan Christians

Tens of thousands of Serbs had moved north into Habsburg territory in 1690 under their patriarch, Arsenije III, after rising in support of the Imperial army and being left exposed when it withdrew. Serbian militia fought under Eugene at Zenta, and the town is in Serbia today. The emperor had promised the migrants freedom of worship and self-government. In practice they became soldiers on a military frontier, under steady pressure to accept union with Rome. Their own record of these years survives mainly in church annals and in the privileges they kept having to ask Vienna to confirm.

Modern historians of the Ottoman empire

Older European accounts treated Zenta as the moment the Ottoman empire entered irreversible decline. Historians such as Rhoads Murphey and Caroline Finkel reject that picture. They point out that the Ottoman state reformed its finances during this very war, defeated Peter the Great in 1711, retook the Peloponnese from Venice in 1715 and won Belgrade back from Austria in 1739. In this reading Zenta was a catastrophic tactical error at a river crossing, of a kind any army could make. It does not prove that Ottoman arms or institutions had fallen behind those of the west.

What is disputed

Numbers for the Ottoman army range from about 60,000 to over 100,000, and the casualty figures come from the victors. The story that a courier reached Eugene with orders from Vienna not to risk a battle, and that he pocketed the letter unopened, appears in later biographies and is not accepted by Derek McKay or other modern scholars. Whether the Grand Vizier was murdered by mutineers or fell fighting is not certain. Eugene’s age is often given as thirty-four; he was born in October 1663 and was still thirty-three.

What followed

By the Treaty of Karlowitz in January 1699 the sultan ceded Hungary, apart from the Banat, and Transylvania to the Habsburgs, the Peloponnese to Venice and Podolia to Poland. It was the first time the Ottoman empire had signed away large territories to Christian powers, and it made Austria a great power on the Danube. Eugene went on to fight the French alongside Marlborough at Blenheim and, on this same date in 1709, at the bloody battle of Malplaquet. He took Belgrade in 1717. The borders drawn after his wars still mark the northern edge of the Balkans.

Read further

  • Derek McKay, Prince Eugene of Savoy (1977)
  • Nicholas Henderson, Prince Eugen of Savoy (1964)
  • Caroline Finkel, Osman’s Dream: The Story of the Ottoman Empire 1300-1923 (2005)
  • Rhoads Murphey, Ottoman Warfare 1500-1700 (1999)
  • Michael Hochedlinger, Austria’s Wars of Emergence 1683-1797 (2003)

Same day, other years

1714

Barcelona falls to the Bourbons

Barcelona, SpainEurope

After a siege of fourteen months, French and Spanish troops under the Duke of Berwick stormed the breaches in Barcelona’s walls before dawn. The city had held out for the Habsburg claimant in the War of the Spanish Succession long after its British and Austrian allies had made peace and gone home. Rafael Casanova, the head of the city government, was shot in the thigh carrying the banner of Saint Eulalia into the fighting. By the afternoon the defenders had asked for terms. Two years later Philip V abolished the parliament, laws and institutions of Catalonia and imposed Castilian administration.

Seen from elsewhere. Catalonia has kept 11 September as its national day since the 1880s, and the independence movement treats 1714 as the loss of a state. Many Spanish historians reply that this was a dynastic and international war, that Catalans fought on both sides, and that Casanova was pardoned and practised law in peace until 1743.

1906

Gandhi and the oath at the Empire Theatre

Johannesburg, South AfricaAfrica

About three thousand Indians packed a Johannesburg theatre to protest against a draft Transvaal law requiring every Asian man, woman and child over eight to register, give fingerprints and carry a pass. A merchant, Haji Habib, proposed that they swear before God not to obey. Mohandas Gandhi, then a thirty-six-year-old lawyer, rose to warn that an oath was not a resolution: it might mean prison, flogging, the loss of property, and each person had to be ready to keep it alone. The whole meeting stood and swore. The campaign of mass civil disobedience that followed lasted eight years and gave him his method.

Seen from elsewhere. The Transvaal government called the law a control on illegal immigration. The word satyagraha was coined only later. Gandhi campaigned for Indians, not for the African majority, about whom his writings of these years use contemptuous language. Ashwin Desai and Goolam Vahed stress that record; Ramachandra Guha and others argue that his views changed.

1973

The coup in Chile

Santiago, ChileThe Americas

The Chilean armed forces rose against the elected government of Salvador Allende, a Marxist who had won the presidency in 1970. The navy took Valparaiso at dawn. By late morning tanks surrounded the presidential palace, La Moneda, and air force jets rocketed it. Allende refused a flight into exile, made a farewell broadcast on the one loyal radio station still on air, and died in the burning building; a forensic inquiry in 2011 confirmed that he shot himself. A junta led by General Augusto Pinochet ruled for seventeen years. State commissions later counted more than 3,000 people killed or disappeared and some 38,000 imprisoned or tortured.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters of the coup argued that Allende was governing outside the constitution, as the Chamber of Deputies had declared in August, amid shortages and street violence. Declassified files show Washington tried to block him in 1970 and financed his opponents; a United States Senate inquiry found no proof of a direct American hand in the coup itself.

2001

The attacks on New York and Washington

New York, Arlington and Shanksville, United StatesThe Americas

Nineteen men from the al-Qaeda network hijacked four airliners on a clear Tuesday morning. Two were flown into the twin towers of the World Trade Center, which burned and collapsed within two hours; one hit the Pentagon; the fourth came down in a Pennsylvania field after passengers fought for the cockpit. The attacks killed 2,977 people from more than ninety countries. Within a month the United States had invaded Afghanistan, where al-Qaeda’s leaders were sheltered by the Taliban. In 2003 it invaded Iraq, which had no part in the plot.

Seen from elsewhere. Osama bin Laden cited American troops in Saudi Arabia, sanctions on Iraq and support for Israel. Muslim authorities around the world condemned the killing of civilians. Critics of the response point to detention without trial at Guantanamo, the use of torture, and wars in which, by Brown University’s Costs of War estimate, more than 900,000 people died.

Also on 11 September