Parallax

17 September, 1944

Thirty-five thousand men fall on Holland

On a clear Sunday afternoon the Allies dropped three airborne divisions along a single Dutch road, hoping to be across the Rhine in days and in Berlin by Christmas. Nine days later the survivors of the furthest division swam back.

Eindhoven, Nijmegen and Arnhem, the Netherlands

Churchgoers in the southern Netherlands came out of morning service on 17 September 1944 to a sky filling with aircraft. Around 1,500 transports and nearly 500 gliders crossed the coast in two streams, and from one o’clock parachutes opened over the heaths west of Arnhem, the woods around Nijmegen and the fields north of Eindhoven. The plan had two halves. ‘Market’ was the airborne carpet: the American 101st and 82nd Divisions and the British 1st Airborne were to seize the bridges over a string of canals and rivers. ‘Garden’ was the ground advance: the tanks of the British XXX Corps under Brian Horrocks were to drive 64 miles up one road and reach Arnhem, on the far side of the Rhine, in two to three days.

The first hours went well and then the timetable began to slip. At Son the canal bridge blew up in the faces of the 101st, and engineers needed a night to replace it. At Nijmegen the 82nd under James Gavin took the bridge at Grave and the high ground at Groesbeek, but sent too little too late to the great road bridge over the Waal, which German troops reinforced that evening. At Arnhem the British had landed up to eight miles from their objective because the air planners feared flak nearer the town. Their radios failed among the trees and houses, and the units marching into Arnhem ran into a blocking line thrown together within hours.

One battalion got through. John Frost’s 2nd Parachute Battalion slipped along the river road and took the northern end of the Arnhem bridge at dusk with about 740 men. They were expected to hold for two days. They held until the morning of 21 September, firing from burning houses against tanks and self-propelled guns, by which time the cellars were full of wounded and the ammunition was gone.

The Waal was not crossed until the afternoon of 20 September, when Major Julian Cook’s paratroopers of the 82nd paddled over in canvas boats under fire, some using rifle butts as oars, and British tanks rushed the road bridge. The tanks then halted for the night. Beyond lay a raised road across open polder, covered by German guns, and the infantry needed to clear it had not come up. To the paratroopers who had just lost half their number in the boats, the pause was unforgivable.

By then the rest of the 1st Airborne under Roy Urquhart was penned into a shrinking perimeter around the Hartenstein hotel at Oosterbeek. Stanislaw Sosabowski’s Polish brigade, delayed for days by fog in England, dropped south of the river on 21 September and could get only a few hundred men across. On the night of 25 September, in heavy rain, the survivors were ferried back. Of roughly 10,600 men who fought north of the Rhine, about 2,400 came out. Nearly 1,500 were dead and more than 6,000, many of them wounded, were prisoners.

How it came to this

In the last week of August 1944 the German army in the west appeared to be dissolving. Paris was freed on 25 August, Brussels on 3 September and Antwerp, with its docks intact, the day after. But the Allied armies were still supplied largely over the Normandy beaches, 300 miles behind them, and there was not enough fuel for everyone to advance at once. Dwight Eisenhower favoured a broad front. Bernard Montgomery, newly a field marshal, argued for one concentrated thrust in the north under his command, and Market Garden was the version of it that Eisenhower approved on 10 September.

The idea was to jump the river barriers, turn the northern end of the Siegfried Line and reach the Ruhr. It also offered a use for the First Allied Airborne Army, which had sat in England through a summer of cancelled operations. The warning signs were set aside. Dutch resistance reports and air photographs suggested armour near Arnhem; the 9th and 10th SS Panzer Divisions, battered in Normandy, were in fact refitting there. And the estuary leading to Antwerp, without which the port was useless, was left in German hands.

How each side saw it

The German defenders

Field Marshal Walter Model was at lunch in Oosterbeek when the British landed two miles away, and left at once, believing he was the target. Within hours he and Wilhelm Bittrich of II SS Panzer Corps had improvised battle groups from depot troops, sailors, airmen and the two understrength panzer divisions. Kurt Student, the airborne general who watched the fleet pass over his headquarters, later said a captured copy of the Allied plan reached him that afternoon. German accounts, collected by Robert Kershaw, describe a defensive success won by speed and local initiative, and record the truce at Oosterbeek on 24 September under which British wounded were passed into German hands.

The Dutch

People in Eindhoven and Nijmegen danced in the streets, and in Oosterbeek they brought the paratroopers tea and then sheltered their wounded in cellars as the houses were shot to pieces above them. The government in exile called a national railway strike on 17 September to help the operation. When it failed, the occupiers ordered Arnhem’s entire population, some 95,000 people, out of the city, which was then looted, and cut food shipments to the western provinces. In the ‘Hunger Winter’ that followed, about 20,000 people died. Dutch memory holds both things: gratitude that is renewed every September at the Oosterbeek cemetery, and the price.

The Polish brigade

Stanislaw Sosabowski had questioned the plan in briefings, asking what the Germans were expected to be doing. His brigade was dropped late, on the wrong side of the river, without its boats, and lost about a quarter of its strength trying to reinforce the British. Afterwards Montgomery and Frederick Browning reported that the Poles had fought badly and Sosabowski was removed from his command. Polish veterans regarded this as scapegoating by the men who had made the plan. In 2006 the Netherlands honoured the brigade with its highest military order and Sosabowski posthumously with the Bronze Lion.

Montgomery and his critics

Montgomery wrote that the operation had been ninety per cent successful, since most of the corridor was held, and blamed the weather and a lack of support from Eisenhower. He conceded one error in his memoirs: underestimating the difficulty of opening Antwerp. American commanders, already impatient with him, took the result as proof that the single thrust had been a mistake. Prince Bernhard of the Netherlands is reported to have remarked that his country could never again afford the luxury of a Montgomery success.

What is disputed

Almost every link in the chain has been blamed. Cornelius Ryan stressed the ignored intelligence; Antony Beevor argues the plan was unsound from the start, resting on one road and three days of perfect luck. Others single out the air commanders, who refused two lifts on the first day and landing zones near the bridge, or Browning, who took 38 gliders for his own headquarters. Dutch writer R. G. Poulussen and others hold that the operation was lost at Nijmegen, when the Waal bridge was not seized on the first evening. The remark about going ‘a bridge too far’ was attributed to Browning by Urquhart years later and may never have been said.

What followed

The Rhine was not crossed in the north until March 1945, and Arnhem was not freed until April. The salient won in September was held through the winter at heavy cost. Antwerp’s approaches were cleared, mainly by Canadian troops, only in November. Total Allied losses in the nine days were around 15,000 to 17,000; German losses are uncertain and are usually put at between 6,000 and 9,000. The battle remains the standard case study in what happens when a plan depends on the enemy doing nothing.

Read further

  • Cornelius Ryan, A Bridge Too Far (1974)
  • Antony Beevor, Arnhem: The Battle for the Bridges, 1944 (2018)
  • Robert Kershaw, It Never Snows in September (1990)
  • Martin Middlebrook, Arnhem 1944: The Airborne Battle (1994)
  • R. E. Urquhart, Arnhem (1958)

Same day, other years

1894

Japan breaks the Chinese fleet off the Yalu

Korea Bay, off the mouth of the Yalu RiverAsia

China’s Beiyang Fleet under Admiral Ding Ruchang had just landed troops for the war in Korea when the Japanese Combined Fleet under Ito Sukeyuki found it around midday. On paper the two sides were close, and China had the only two true battleships in East Asian waters. But the Japanese cruisers were faster, carried quick-firing guns and kept formation, circling the Chinese line for nearly five hours. By dusk five Chinese ships were sunk or wrecked. Japan lost none, though its flagship Matsushima was badly damaged. Command of the sea let Japan invade Manchuria and take the fleet’s base at Weihaiwei, where Ding killed himself in February 1895.

Seen from elsewhere. Chinese accounts stress what the sailors were sent out with: too few shells, some of them reportedly filled with cement, and a navy starved of funds since 1888, by tradition because money went to the Empress Dowager’s Summer Palace. Historians dispute how much was diverted. Koreans, whose country the war was fought over, had no say in the outcome.

1939

The Red Army enters Poland from the east

Eastern PolandEurope

Sixteen days after Germany invaded Poland from the west, Soviet troops crossed the eastern frontier at dawn. In the small hours the Polish ambassador in Moscow had been read a note stating that the Polish state had ceased to exist and that the Soviet Union was taking the Ukrainians and Belarusians of the east under its protection. The Polish army, already fighting for its life, was ordered not to resist unless attacked, and the government crossed into Romania that night. The partition followed the secret protocol agreed by Molotov and Ribbentrop on 23 August. Some 22,000 captured Polish officers and officials were shot on Stalin’s order in 1940, and several hundred thousand civilians were deported east.

Seen from elsewhere. Soviet history called it a liberation campaign that reunited Ukrainian and Belarusian lands, and some inhabitants did at first welcome the troops. Moscow denied the secret protocol existed until 1989. For Poles it is the ‘stab in the back’. Numbers deported remain contested: Soviet records suggest about 320,000, older Polish estimates over a million.

1948

The UN’s mediator is shot dead in Jerusalem

JerusalemMiddle East

Count Folke Bernadotte, a Swedish diplomat who had negotiated the release of thousands of concentration camp prisoners in 1945, was the United Nations’ first mediator, sent to end the war that followed Israel’s declaration of independence. His convoy was stopped at a roadblock in the Katamon district by men in Israeli army uniforms. One pushed a gun through the car window and killed him and a French officer, Andre Serot. The killers belonged to Lehi, the underground group the British called the Stern Gang. Bernadotte had just completed a plan that would have given the Negev to the Arabs, put Jerusalem under UN control and affirmed the right of Palestinian refugees to return.

Seen from elsewhere. Lehi regarded him as an agent of British interests about to take Jerusalem from the Jewish state. Israel’s government condemned the murder and outlawed the group, but nobody was tried for it; Sweden protested for years. One of Lehi’s three leaders, Yitzhak Shamir, later became prime minister. Bernadotte’s refugee proposal passed into UN Resolution 194.

1978

Sadat and Begin sign at Camp David

Washington, D.C., United StatesMiddle East

After thirteen days shut away at the presidential retreat in Maryland, during which the Egyptian and Israeli leaders largely stopped speaking to each other and Jimmy Carter carried drafts between their cabins, Anwar Sadat and Menachem Begin signed two frameworks at the White House. One led to the peace treaty of March 1979, the first between Israel and an Arab state: Israel returned the Sinai peninsula, captured in 1967, and Egypt recognised Israel. The other promised autonomy talks for the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza, and produced nothing. Sadat and Begin shared that year’s Nobel Peace Prize.

Seen from elsewhere. Palestinians, who were not represented, saw a separate peace that removed the strongest Arab army from the conflict and left them under occupation. The Arab League suspended Egypt and moved its headquarters from Cairo. Sadat was assassinated by Egyptian Islamist soldiers in 1981. Israeli critics on the right opposed giving up Sinai and its settlements.

Also on 17 September