Parallax

21 September, 1327

The deposed Edward II dies at Berkeley Castle, or is said to

Eight months after being forced off the throne, the former king of England was reported dead in a Gloucestershire castle. How he died became one of the most repeated horror stories in English history, and a few historians think he did not die at all.

Berkeley Castle, Gloucestershire, England

Since April 1327 Edward of Caernarfon, no longer king, had been held at Berkeley Castle above the Severn estuary. His keepers were Thomas, Lord Berkeley, and Berkeley’s brother-in-law John Maltravers, both of whom had suffered under his rule, and they were paid five pounds a day for his upkeep. The accounts show wine, wax, spices and capons being bought for him. A later chronicler says he was kept above a pit of rotting carcasses in the hope that the stench would kill him. The accounts and the chronicler cannot both be right.

What is certain is that he was dangerous to keep. That summer a gang led by two brothers from Warwickshire, Stephen Dunheved and the Dominican friar Thomas Dunheved, broke into the castle, plundered it and, according to a letter by Berkeley himself, seized the prisoner for a time. In early September another plot, among Welsh supporters led by Sir Rhys ap Gruffydd, was betrayed. Word of it was sent to Roger Mortimer, who governed England with Queen Isabella in the name of her fourteen-year-old son.

On the night of 23 September a messenger reached the young Edward III at Lincoln with news that his father had died at Berkeley on the 21st, the feast of St Matthew. The messenger was Thomas Gurney, one of the household at the castle. The court announced a natural death. The body was embalmed by a local woman and watched for a month, then carried to the abbey of St Peter at Gloucester, where it lay in state. At the funeral on 20 December, attended by Isabella and the king, a carved wooden figure of Edward in his robes lay on the coffin, the first such effigy known at an English royal burial. The embalmed face beneath was probably covered.

Rumour started early. The chronicler Adam Murimuth, who was in the west of England that autumn, wrote that it was commonly said he had been killed by a trick, suffocated. Within about a decade a London chronicle added the detail that has stuck: a horn pushed into his body and a red-hot iron passed through it, so that no mark would show. Geoffrey le Baker, writing around 1350, worked this into a full martyrdom, with a heavy table pressed on the victim and screams heard in the town.

In 1330 Edward III overthrew Mortimer, who was hanged for, among other things, having the old king murdered. Gurney and a man named William Ockley were condemned for the act. Lord Berkeley, questioned in Parliament, made the strange reply that he had not known of the death until that very Parliament, and was eventually cleared.

How it came to this

Edward II came to the throne in 1307 and quarrelled with his barons for twenty years, chiefly over the men he loved and enriched. The first, the Gascon knight Piers Gaveston, was seized and killed by a group of earls in 1312. Two years later Edward lost the battle of Bannockburn to Robert Bruce and with it English control of Scotland. In the 1320s he gave the same unlimited trust to Hugh Despenser the younger, who used it to extort land across England and Wales and to push aside the queen, Isabella, daughter of the king of France.

Sent to Paris in 1325 to negotiate, Isabella refused to come back while Despenser remained, and formed an alliance, and by most accounts a liaison, with the exiled marcher lord Roger Mortimer. They landed in Suffolk in September 1326 with a small force. The regime collapsed in weeks. Despenser was executed at Hereford, and in January 1327 a Parliament declared Edward unfit to rule. A deputation at Kenilworth obtained his tearful agreement to give up the crown to his son.

How each side saw it

Isabella and Mortimer’s government

The official position was that the lord Edward, the king’s father, had died of natural causes, and the public display of the body and the costly funeral were meant to prove it. Isabella’s own case against her husband was on record from Paris: someone had come between them, she said, and she would dress as a widow until he was removed. She had been stripped of her lands and household in 1324. No document connects her with an order to kill. The charge of murder in 1330 was laid against Mortimer alone, and her son never accused her.

The chroniclers who made him a martyr

Baker’s patron had been present at the deposition and was sympathetic to the old king, and his chronicle turns Edward into a patient sufferer mocked like Christ, crowned with hay and shaved in ditch water. The red-hot iron fits this pattern as well as it fits any evidence: readers understood it as a death matched to the sin of which the king was suspected. A cult grew at the tomb in Gloucester, whose offerings paid for the rebuilding of the choir. In the 1390s Richard II, another king at odds with his nobles, petitioned Rome to have his great-grandfather made a saint.

Those who believed him alive

In 1330 Edward’s half-brother, the Earl of Kent, was beheaded for plotting to free him from Corfe Castle, three years after the funeral. Kent named many who shared his belief, including the Archbishop of York. A letter written to Edward III in the late 1330s by Manuele Fieschi, a papal notary and later a bishop, claims that the old king escaped from Berkeley, that a porter was buried in his place, and that he ended his days as a hermit in Lombardy. In 1338 a man called William the Welshman, who said he was the king’s father, was brought to Edward III at Koblenz at royal expense.

What is disputed

The date of 21 September is the one announced at the time; the book this series draws on gives the 22nd. Whether Edward was murdered is likely but unproven, and the method is unknown: the earliest reports speak of suffocation or grief, and the hot iron appears only in the 1330s. Most historians, including Seymour Phillips and Roy Haines, accept that he died at Berkeley in 1327. Ian Mortimer argues that the death was faked on Mortimer’s orders and that the Fieschi letter is substantially true; Kathryn Warner takes the possibility seriously. Whether his bonds with Gaveston and Despenser were sexual cannot be established. Pierre Chaplais proposed a compact of sworn brotherhood.

What followed

The deposition of 1327 was the first of an anointed English king by his own subjects, and it supplied a method: Richard II in 1399, Henry VI and Edward V after him. Isabella lived in comfortable retirement until 1358 and was buried, it was said, with her husband’s heart. Her popular name, ‘she-wolf of France’, was attached to her only in the eighteenth century by the poet Thomas Gray. Marlowe’s play of about 1592 fixed the story of the murder, and it has since served as a touchstone for arguments about how the past treated same-sex love.

Read further

  • Seymour Phillips, Edward II (2010)
  • Roy Martin Haines, King Edward II: His Life, His Reign, and Its Aftermath, 1284-1330 (2003)
  • Ian Mortimer, The Greatest Traitor: The Life of Sir Roger Mortimer (2003)
  • Kathryn Warner, Edward II: The Unconventional King (2014)
  • Geoffrey le Baker, The Chronicle of Geoffrey le Baker, translated by David Preest (2012)

Same day, other years

1792

France abolishes its monarchy

Paris, FranceEurope

The National Convention, elected after the storming of the Tuileries palace in August, held its first public sitting the day after French guns stopped the Prussian invasion at Valmy. Late in the afternoon the former actor Collot d’Herbois proposed that royalty be abolished. A deputy suggested the matter deserved debate. The Abbe Gregoire replied that kings were in the moral order what monsters were in the physical, and that their history was the martyrology of nations. The motion passed without a dissenting voice. The next day was declared the first of Year One of the Republic. Louis XVI, held in the Temple prison with his family, was tried in December and guillotined in January 1793.

Seen from elsewhere. The Convention had been chosen by perhaps a tenth of the electorate, days after Parisian crowds killed more than 1,100 prisoners in the September massacres. Royalists and much of the Catholic west never accepted its authority, and the rising in the Vendee the next spring was put down at a cost of well over 100,000 lives.

1898

The Empress Dowager ends the Hundred Days

Beijing, ChinaAsia

For 103 days the Guangxu Emperor, aged twenty-seven and shaken by China’s defeat by Japan, had issued a stream of reforming edicts: an end to the classical ‘eight-legged’ examination essay, new schools and a university in Beijing, railways, a modern army, the abolition of sinecures. He was advised by the Cantonese scholar Kang Youwei. Officials whose posts were threatened appealed to his aunt, the Empress Dowager Cixi, who had ruled before him. At dawn she returned to the Forbidden City, announced that the emperor had asked her to resume the direction of government, and confined him to an island in the palace lakes. Six reformers, among them Tan Sitong, were beheaded a week later.

Seen from elsewhere. Kang escaped to Japan and wrote the version long accepted: a reactionary tyrant crushing China’s hope. Later research, including work by Mao Haijian, finds that Kang inflated his own role and that the reformers had planned to seize or kill Cixi, a plot the general Yuan Shikai disclosed. After 1901 she introduced most of the same reforms herself.

1972

Marcos puts his signature to martial law

Manila, PhilippinesAsia

Proclamation 1081, placing the whole of the Philippines under martial law, carries the date 21 September 1972. The country learned of it on the evening of the 23rd, when President Ferdinand Marcos went on television. By then soldiers had closed Congress, newspapers and broadcasters and arrested thousands of people, beginning with the opposition senator Benigno Aquino. The justification was a communist insurgency and a supposed ambush of the defence secretary’s car on the 22nd. Marcos, barred by the constitution from a third term, ruled by decree until 1981 and stayed in power until 1986. Amnesty International and later Philippine commissions counted some 70,000 people detained, 34,000 tortured and over 3,000 killed.

Seen from elsewhere. Marcos said he had saved the republic from communists and Muslim separatists and was building a disciplined ‘New Society’; many Filipinos remember the early years as orderly, and his son was elected president in 2022. The defence secretary, Juan Ponce Enrile, said in 1986 that the ambush was staged and later denied saying so. Even the date is questioned: Marcos favoured multiples of seven.

1976

A car bomb kills Orlando Letelier in Washington

Washington, D.C., United StatesThe Americas

Orlando Letelier had been Salvador Allende’s ambassador to the United States and then his foreign and defence minister. After the coup of 1973 he was held for a year in a prison camp on Dawson Island near the Antarctic, released under international pressure, and settled in Washington, where he lobbied against loans and arms for General Pinochet’s government. On a Tuesday morning a bomb fixed under his car went off as he drove round Sheridan Circle on Embassy Row. It killed him and a 25-year-old American colleague, Ronni Moffitt; her husband, in the back seat, survived. The bomb was planted by Michael Townley, an American working for the Chilean secret police, with Cuban exile accomplices.

Seen from elsewhere. Chile’s government denied any part and suggested the left had killed its own for a martyr. Townley’s confession led to the conviction in Chile, in 1993, of the secret police chief Manuel Contreras. US documents released in 2015 and 2016 show the CIA concluded that Pinochet personally ordered the killing. They also show Washington had word of planned assassinations abroad and withdrew a warning days before.

Also on 21 September