Since April 1327 Edward of Caernarfon, no longer king, had been held at Berkeley Castle above the Severn estuary. His keepers were Thomas, Lord Berkeley, and Berkeley’s brother-in-law John Maltravers, both of whom had suffered under his rule, and they were paid five pounds a day for his upkeep. The accounts show wine, wax, spices and capons being bought for him. A later chronicler says he was kept above a pit of rotting carcasses in the hope that the stench would kill him. The accounts and the chronicler cannot both be right.
What is certain is that he was dangerous to keep. That summer a gang led by two brothers from Warwickshire, Stephen Dunheved and the Dominican friar Thomas Dunheved, broke into the castle, plundered it and, according to a letter by Berkeley himself, seized the prisoner for a time. In early September another plot, among Welsh supporters led by Sir Rhys ap Gruffydd, was betrayed. Word of it was sent to Roger Mortimer, who governed England with Queen Isabella in the name of her fourteen-year-old son.
On the night of 23 September a messenger reached the young Edward III at Lincoln with news that his father had died at Berkeley on the 21st, the feast of St Matthew. The messenger was Thomas Gurney, one of the household at the castle. The court announced a natural death. The body was embalmed by a local woman and watched for a month, then carried to the abbey of St Peter at Gloucester, where it lay in state. At the funeral on 20 December, attended by Isabella and the king, a carved wooden figure of Edward in his robes lay on the coffin, the first such effigy known at an English royal burial. The embalmed face beneath was probably covered.
Rumour started early. The chronicler Adam Murimuth, who was in the west of England that autumn, wrote that it was commonly said he had been killed by a trick, suffocated. Within about a decade a London chronicle added the detail that has stuck: a horn pushed into his body and a red-hot iron passed through it, so that no mark would show. Geoffrey le Baker, writing around 1350, worked this into a full martyrdom, with a heavy table pressed on the victim and screams heard in the town.
In 1330 Edward III overthrew Mortimer, who was hanged for, among other things, having the old king murdered. Gurney and a man named William Ockley were condemned for the act. Lord Berkeley, questioned in Parliament, made the strange reply that he had not known of the death until that very Parliament, and was eventually cleared.
How it came to this
Edward II came to the throne in 1307 and quarrelled with his barons for twenty years, chiefly over the men he loved and enriched. The first, the Gascon knight Piers Gaveston, was seized and killed by a group of earls in 1312. Two years later Edward lost the battle of Bannockburn to Robert Bruce and with it English control of Scotland. In the 1320s he gave the same unlimited trust to Hugh Despenser the younger, who used it to extort land across England and Wales and to push aside the queen, Isabella, daughter of the king of France.
Sent to Paris in 1325 to negotiate, Isabella refused to come back while Despenser remained, and formed an alliance, and by most accounts a liaison, with the exiled marcher lord Roger Mortimer. They landed in Suffolk in September 1326 with a small force. The regime collapsed in weeks. Despenser was executed at Hereford, and in January 1327 a Parliament declared Edward unfit to rule. A deputation at Kenilworth obtained his tearful agreement to give up the crown to his son.