Parallax

10 September, 1419

Murder on the bridge at Montereau

The Duke of Burgundy knelt to the sixteen-year-old heir of France in the middle of a bridge, and did not get up. The killing handed the French crown to Henry V of England.

Montereau-Fault-Yonne, France

By the late summer of 1419 Henry V of England held Normandy and his outriders were within sight of Paris. France had two governments. One, in the name of the mad King Charles VI, was controlled by John the Fearless, Duke of Burgundy, who held Paris and the queen. The other was led by the king’s last surviving son, the Dauphin Charles, a boy of sixteen surrounded by men who had sworn vengeance on Burgundy. Everyone could see that unless the two joined forces the English would take the kingdom.

They had met once already, in July, on a causeway near Melun, and had sworn friendship and exchanged the kiss of peace. Nothing followed from it. A second meeting was fixed for the bridge over the Yonne at Montereau, where the dauphin was lodged in the town and the duke was given the castle on the opposite bank. Carpenters built a fenced enclosure in the middle of the bridge with a gate at each end. Each prince was to enter with ten companions.

John hesitated for days at Bray-sur-Seine. His advisers warned him that the dauphin’s household was full of his enemies. He came all the same, and at about five in the afternoon of Sunday 10 September walked onto the bridge. The gate was shut behind his party.

On what happened inside there are two stories. All agree that the duke took off his velvet hat and knelt to the dauphin, and that some words passed about why he had not yet made war on the English. Burgundian witnesses said that as he rose, a hand on his sword hilt to steady himself, Tanguy du Chastel, the dauphin’s chief captain, struck him in the face with a battle-axe, and that others then finished him on the ground with swords. The dauphin’s men said the duke had drawn his sword, or tried to seize the prince. One of the duke’s companions was mortally wounded and the rest were made prisoner. The dauphin was hurried away.

John’s son and heir, Philip, heard the news at Ghent; his wife was the dauphin’s own sister. Within three months he had made an alliance with Henry V. In May 1420, at Troyes, the Burgundians had the sick king sign a treaty that disinherited the dauphin on account of his ‘horrible and enormous crimes’, married Henry to the king’s daughter Catherine, and made the Englishman regent and heir of France.

A century later, the story goes, a Carthusian monk at Dijon showed the duke’s broken skull to King Francis I and told him that this was the hole through which the English had entered France.

How it came to this

Charles VI of France suffered from 1392 onwards from bouts of insanity during which he did not know his wife or his own name. Power fell to his relatives, and above all to two of them: his brother Louis, Duke of Orleans, and his cousin John of Burgundy, who also ruled Flanders and was the richest prince in the west. In November 1407 John had Louis hacked to death by hired men in a Paris street, then admitted it and commissioned a theologian, Jean Petit, to argue in public that killing a tyrant was a virtuous act.

The result was a civil war between Burgundians and the Orleanist party, known as Armagnacs after their leader. Both sides at different times asked the English for help. Henry V invaded in 1415 and destroyed a largely Armagnac army at Agincourt, where John did not appear. In 1418 the Burgundians took Paris, and mobs massacred Armagnac prisoners by the thousand. The young dauphin was carried out of the city in his nightshirt by Tanguy du Chastel. The men around him at Montereau had lost masters, relatives and property to Burgundy.

How each side saw it

The Burgundians

For Philip the Good and the chroniclers who wrote under Burgundian patronage, chief among them Enguerrand de Monstrelet, Montereau was a planned ambush of an unsuspecting prince who had come in good faith to make peace, carried out under a sworn truce and in the dauphin’s presence. The duke’s widow, Margaret of Bavaria, gathered sworn statements from survivors and petitioned the king and the Pope for justice. The anonymous Parisian diarist known as the Bourgeois of Paris, a Burgundian sympathiser, records the horror in the capital and held the Armagnacs guilty of ruining the kingdom.

The dauphin’s party

On the day after the killing letters went out in the dauphin’s name to the towns of France. They said that Burgundy had spoken insolently, put his hand to his sword and tried to lay hold of the prince’s person, and had been struck down by loyal servants in the scuffle. The chronicler Jean Juvenal des Ursins, close to this side, repeats that version. Many of the dauphin’s followers plainly thought the death deserved in any case: John was the confessed murderer of the king’s brother and had never been punished. Charles himself always denied having ordered it.

The English

Henry V had been negotiating with both French factions at once and had got little from either. The murder solved his problem. English envoys were talking to Philip within weeks, and the Treaty of Troyes gave Henry by agreement what he could not have taken by siege in a lifetime. English writers of the time treated the French civil war as proof of divine judgment on a kingdom whose crown rightfully belonged to their own king. The legal fiction of the ‘dual monarchy’ of England and France rested from then on upon Burgundian consent.

What is disputed

Premeditation is the question. Richard Vaughan and Bertrand Schnerb, the duke’s modern biographers, think the dauphin’s councillors, though perhaps not the boy himself, planned the killing; the enclosed space and locked gate are hard to explain otherwise. Others allow that a tense meeting between armed enemies may have exploded without a plan. Who struck first is not agreed, and Tanguy du Chastel always denied it was he. The remark about the hole in the skull is first reported long after 1521 and is usually treated as a good story. It also flatters Burgundy: the English were already in France.

What followed

Henry V died in 1422, weeks before Charles VI, leaving a baby as king of both realms. The dauphin, mocked as the ‘King of Bourges’, held the south, and in 1429 Joan of Arc took him to be crowned at Reims. The war could not be won while Burgundy backed England. In 1435, at Arras, Charles VII formally disavowed the murder, promised masses and a monument at Montereau, and Philip changed sides. Paris fell to Charles the next year. By 1453 the English held nothing in France but Calais.

Read further

  • Richard Vaughan, John the Fearless: The Growth of Burgundian Power (1966)
  • Bertrand Schnerb, Jean sans Peur: le prince meurtrier (2005)
  • Jonathan Sumption, Cursed Kings: The Hundred Years War IV (2015)
  • Enguerrand de Monstrelet, Chronicles
  • A Parisian Journal, 1405-1449, translated by Janet Shirley (1968)

Same day, other years

1509

The ‘Lesser Judgment Day’ earthquake

Constantinople (Istanbul)Middle East

Late in the evening an earthquake under the Sea of Marmara shook the Ottoman capital for what witnesses felt as several minutes. More than a thousand houses and over a hundred mosques were destroyed or badly damaged, long stretches of the sea walls fell, and the new mosque of Sultan Bayezid II lost its dome. Aftershocks went on for more than a month. The sultan camped in a tent in the palace gardens and then moved the court to Edirne. The following spring he conscripted tens of thousands of builders from across the empire and had the city repaired in a few months.

Seen from elsewhere. Ottomans called it the Lesser Judgment Day, and some preachers blamed the sins of the sultan’s ministers. Death tolls in the sources run from about a thousand to thirteen thousand. The seismologist Nicholas Ambraseys argued that early accounts exaggerated its size; the question matters because it bears on what the next great Istanbul earthquake may be like.

1897

The Lattimer massacre

Lattimer, Pennsylvania, United StatesThe Americas

About four hundred striking coal miners, nearly all recent immigrants from Poland, Slovakia and Lithuania, walked along a public road towards the Lattimer mine to call out the men there. They were unarmed and carried an American flag. The county sheriff, James Martin, and some hundred and fifty deputies, many of them employees of the coal companies, were waiting. After a scuffle at the head of the column the deputies opened fire and kept firing as the marchers ran. Nineteen men were killed and several dozen wounded, many of them shot in the back.

Seen from elsewhere. At the trial the defence described a threatening foreign mob, and the sheriff and all his deputies were acquitted. The government of Austria-Hungary, whose subjects most of the dead were, asked for compensation and was refused. In the coalfield the effect was the opposite of the one intended: thousands of Slavic miners joined the United Mine Workers within months.

1960

Abebe Bikila wins the Olympic marathon barefoot

Rome, ItalyAfrica

The marathon at the Rome Olympics was run in the evening to avoid the heat, finishing by torchlight at the Arch of Constantine. Abebe Bikila, a soldier of the Ethiopian Imperial Bodyguard who had been added to the team late, ran it without shoes because the pair he had been given hurt his feet. He stayed level with the Moroccan Rhadi Ben Abdesselam until the last mile, pulled away, and won in a world best of 2 hours 15 minutes 16 seconds. He was the first Black African to win an Olympic gold medal. Four years later in Tokyo he won again, in shoes.

Seen from elsewhere. Italy had invaded Ethiopia in 1935. Bikila made his final move close to the obelisk of Axum, which Italian troops had carried off to Rome in 1937, and Ethiopians have read the race ever since as an answer. His Swedish-Finnish coach said the monument was simply a convenient landmark. Italy returned the obelisk in 2005.

1974

Portugal recognises Guinea-Bissau

Guinea-BissauAfrica

Portugal formally recognised the independence of its West African colony after eleven years of guerrilla war. The independence movement, the PAIGC, had been built by the agronomist Amilcar Cabral, who was assassinated in 1973, months before his party declared a state in the liberated zones. By then it controlled much of the countryside and had anti-aircraft missiles. The war did as much to change Portugal as Guinea: the officers who overthrew the dictatorship in Lisbon in April 1974 had largely learned their politics in that campaign. It was the first of Portugal’s African territories to have its independence recognised.

Seen from elsewhere. The old regime had insisted that Guinea was an overseas province of Portugal, not a colony. Thousands of Africans had fought in Portuguese uniform, including elite commando units. After the handover the new government had hundreds of them shot, a matter that was not publicly admitted for years and that is still little discussed in either country.

Also on 10 September