Parallax

1 September, 1281

A typhoon destroys Kublai Khan’s armada off Japan

The largest seaborne invasion the world had yet seen spent a summer failing to get ashore in Kyushu. Then the wind got up, and Japan acquired a word that it would use again in 1944.

Takashima and Hakata Bay, Kyushu, Japan

By the summer of 1281 the stone wall along Hakata Bay had been five years in the building. It ran for some twenty kilometres along the shore of northern Kyushu, two to three metres high, raised by the landholders of the island in proportion to their rice income, and behind it waited the warriors of the Kamakura shogunate. They knew what was coming. Kublai Khan’s first fleet had landed on this beach in 1274 and gone away after a day’s fighting. Since then the regent Hojo Tokimune had answered two Mongol embassies by cutting off the envoys’ heads.

Kublai, who had finished off the Song dynasty in 1279 and now ruled all China, planned the second attempt on a scale meant to settle the matter. An Eastern Route Army of perhaps 40,000 Mongol, northern Chinese and Korean troops would sail from Korea in 900 ships. A Southern Route Army, said by the Chinese record to be 100,000 strong in 3,500 vessels and made up largely of recently surrendered Song soldiers, would cross from the ports near the mouth of the Yangzi. The two were to meet off Iki island and fall on Kyushu together.

They did not. The eastern fleet sailed in early summer, overran the islands of Tsushima and Iki, and reached Hakata Bay in late June without waiting. The wall kept it off the beach. It anchored at Shika island, where Japanese warriors rowed out at night in small boats to board, burn and take heads. One of them, Takezaki Suenaga of Higo province, later had the whole thing painted on scrolls to support his claim for a reward. Disease broke out in the crowded ships and the fleet fell back to Iki. The southern armada, delayed by the illness of its commander, did not arrive until high summer, and it was August before the combined force gathered at Takashima in Imari Bay, west of the wall, to try again.

Around the middle of August a typhoon came up from the south and blew for two days. The ships were packed into a bay open to the wind, and many are said to have been lashed together against boarding raids. They broke against each other and against the shore. The senior commanders, among them the Song defector Fan Wenhu, got away on the soundest vessels. The men left on Takashima cut timber to build boats and were attacked before they could finish.

The Yuan dynasty’s own history says that the Japanese killed the Mongols, Koreans and northern Chinese they captured and kept the southern Chinese alive as slaves. The Korean annals count about 7,600 of some 27,000 Korean soldiers and sailors as not returning, and the Chinese sources suggest far worse for the southern army. In Japan the storm was credited to the gods, whose shrines and temples had been praying for months by order of the court, and it was given a name: kamikaze, the divine wind.

How it came to this

Kublai, grandson of Chinggis Khan, had been Great Khan since 1260 and proclaimed a Chinese-style dynasty, the Yuan, in 1271. The empire he claimed reached from Korea to the Black Sea steppe, though by his time its western khanates obeyed him in name only. Korea had submitted after thirty years of invasions and its king was now his son-in-law. From 1266 Kublai sent letters to ‘the King of Japan’ proposing friendly relations and hinting at war if they were refused. The court in Kyoto drafted a reply. The shogunate in Kamakura, which held the real power, would not let it be sent.

The expedition of 1274, variously put at between 15,000 and 40,000 men, sacked Tsushima and Iki, fought for a day at Hakata and re-embarked that night. Japanese tradition says a storm then wrecked it. Some historians think its commanders simply judged their force too small and their arrows too few. Either way Kamakura spent the next seven years preparing: the wall, a standing rota of coastal guard duty for the warriors of Kyushu, and orders that shrines and temples across the country pray for the enemy’s destruction.

How each side saw it

The warriors of Kyushu

The fullest eyewitness record from the Japanese side is the set of picture scrolls commissioned around 1293 by Takezaki Suenaga, a minor landholder who fought in both invasions. They show him boarding an enemy ship and cutting a man’s throat, and they are careful to name the witnesses to each deed, because their purpose was to prove his entitlement to reward. There is no divine wind in them. The shogunate’s surviving orders and petitions tell the same story of men who thought they had won by fighting, and who spent years afterwards asking to be paid for it.

The shrines, the temples and the court

The religious establishment recorded a different victory. The Hachiman Gudokun, written by priests of the Hachiman cult in the early fourteenth century, presents the destruction of the fleet as the work of the war god, answering prayer. The retired emperor Kameyama was said to have offered his own life at Ise in exchange for the country’s safety. Shrines and temples petitioned Kamakura for rewards on the same footing as warriors, arguing that their rites had done the decisive work, and many received them. From these texts grew the idea of Japan as a land under the particular protection of its gods.

The Yuan court and its conscripts

The official History of the Yuan, compiled under the following dynasty in 1370, is brief and unflattering: the generals quarrelled, the fleets failed to combine, the storm struck and the commanders abandoned their men. The southern army was drawn largely from Song troops who had surrendered two years earlier, and some historians suspect that Kublai was content to send a potentially troublesome soldiery overseas. No account by any of those men survives. Their side of the story is carried by the wrecks in Imari Bay, where divers have recovered anchors, helmets, ceramic bombs and a bowl inked with its owner’s name and rank.

Korea and the islands in between

For the kingdom of Goryeo the invasions were a tax paid in ships, grain and men to an overlord who could not be refused. Its official history, the Goryeosa, records the building of 900 vessels in a matter of months and the exhaustion of the southern provinces. It also records King Chungnyeol encouraging the project, which Korean historians have read variously as loyalty, calculation and self-protection. The people of Tsushima and Iki, who were killed or carried off in both invasions, left nothing in writing. The monk Nichiren, in letters written after 1274, repeats reports of what was done to them.

What is disputed

The date first. No source puts the storm on 1 September; Japanese records place it at the turn of the intercalary seventh month, about 15-16 August 1281 in the Julian calendar, and the popular almanac tradition that files it here is simply loose. The numbers are doubtful too. The figure of 140,000 men comes from the Yuan history, and Thomas Conlan has argued that both armies were a fraction of the traditional size and that the defenders were already winning. Marine archaeologists including Kenzo Hayashida and Randall Sasaki have debated whether hasty construction left the southern ships unfit for open water. The storm of 1274 may never have happened.

What followed

Kublai ordered a third expedition, shelved it in 1286 and died in 1294. Kamakura kept the coastal guard standing for decades and could not reward its warriors, since a defensive war wins no land to distribute; the resentment helped bring the shogunate down in 1333. The belief in a god-protected country lasted longer. In October 1944 the Japanese navy gave the name of the divine wind to its first suicide air units. The wreck site at Takashima has been surveyed since the 1980s, a hull was located in 2011, and it is now a protected historic site.

Read further

  • Thomas D. Conlan, In Little Need of Divine Intervention: Takezaki Suenaga’s Scrolls of the Mongol Invasions of Japan (2001)
  • Morris Rossabi, Khubilai Khan: His Life and Times (1988)
  • James P. Delgado, Khubilai Khan’s Lost Fleet: In Search of a Legendary Armada (2008)
  • Stephen Turnbull, The Mongol Invasions of Japan 1274 and 1281 (2010)

Same day, other years

1859

An astronomer watches the Sun flare, and the telegraphs fail

Redhill, Surrey, EnglandWorldwide

At 11.18 on the morning of 1 September, Richard Carrington was sketching a large group of sunspots at his private observatory when two patches of intense white light appeared among them and faded within five minutes. Another amateur, Richard Hodgson, saw the same thing from north London. About seventeen hours later the strongest geomagnetic storm in the instrumental record reached the Earth. Auroras were seen as far south as Cuba and Hawaii. Telegraph lines in Europe and North America sparked, gave operators shocks, and in some cases carried messages with their batteries disconnected. It was the first solar flare ever observed and the first to be linked, tentatively, to effects on the ground.

Seen from elsewhere. Carrington himself warned against drawing the connection too quickly, remarking that one swallow does not make a summer, and Lord Kelvin later argued that the Sun could not possibly disturb the Earth’s magnetism. How large the storm was, and how much damage an equivalent one would do to modern power grids and satellites, remain matters of widely differing estimates.

1923

The Great Kanto earthquake, and the killings that followed

Tokyo and Yokohama, JapanAsia

Two minutes before noon, as charcoal stoves were lit for the midday meal, an earthquake of about magnitude 7.9 struck beneath Sagami Bay. Fires merged into firestorms that burned for two days. Around 105,000 people died, some 38,000 of them in a single open space in Tokyo’s Honjo district where refugees had gathered with their belongings. Within hours rumours spread that Koreans were poisoning wells and setting fires. Vigilante bands, and in places police and soldiers, killed Korean residents in the streets, along with several hundred Chinese and some Japanese mistaken for them. Military police used the emergency to murder the anarchists Osugi Sakae and Ito Noe and a six-year-old child.

Seen from elsewhere. A Japanese government count at the time acknowledged a few hundred Korean deaths; Korean investigators put the figure at more than 6,000, and most historians accept several thousand. The state has never formally apologised. Since 2017 the governor of Tokyo has declined to send the customary message to the annual memorial for the Korean victims, which Korean residents’ groups regard as denial.

1939

Germany invades Poland

PolandEurope

Before dawn the German air force bombed the small town of Wielun, and at 4.45 the old battleship Schleswig-Holstein, on a supposed courtesy visit, opened fire on the Polish depot at Westerplatte in Danzig. About one and a half million German troops crossed the frontier from three sides. The previous night SS men in Polish uniforms had staged an attack on a German radio station at Gleiwitz to supply a pretext. Britain and France declared war two days later but mounted no serious offensive. On 17 September the Red Army entered from the east under the secret terms of the pact Molotov and Ribbentrop had signed in August, and Poland was partitioned.

Seen from elsewhere. Hitler told the Reichstag that Germany was returning fire. The Soviet Union described its own entry as the protection of Ukrainians and Belarusians in a collapsed state, and Russian tradition still dates the war from June 1941. In China the war is counted from 1937 or 1931, so the idea that it began on this day is itself a European one.

1969

Junior officers overthrow the king of Libya

Benghazi and Tripoli, LibyaAfrica

While King Idris was in Turkey for medical treatment, a group of about seventy young army officers seized the radio station, barracks and airports in Benghazi and Tripoli in a few hours and almost without bloodshed. The crown prince renounced his claim on air. The voice that announced the Libyan Arab Republic belonged to a 27-year-old signals officer, Muammar Gaddafi, who was promoted to colonel and stayed in power for forty-two years. Within a year the new government had closed the American and British air bases and expelled the remaining Italian settlers, and it soon forced the oil companies to accept higher prices, a precedent other producers followed.

Seen from elsewhere. For four decades 1 September was Libya’s national day, the anniversary of the Fateh Revolution against a monarchy its makers called corrupt and subservient. Supporters of the Senussi order, strongest in the east, saw a legitimate king deposed by conspirators. After 2011 the holiday was abolished and the monarchy’s flag restored.

Also on 1 September