The emperor was a boy, perhaps twelve or fourteen, and he had reigned for ten months without doing anything, because his father did it for him. He was called Romulus, after the founder of Rome, and Augustus, after the founder of the empire. His subjects shortened the second name to Augustulus, ‘little Augustus’, and Greek speakers twisted the first into Momyllus, ‘little disgrace’. His father, Orestes, was a Roman from Pannonia who had once served as secretary to Attila the Hun and had risen to command the army of Italy. In 475 Orestes had turned that army on the reigning emperor, Julius Nepos, chased him across the Adriatic, and put his own son on the throne at Ravenna.
The army of Italy by then was Roman only in name. It was made up of Heruli, Sciri, Rugi and other peoples from beyond the Danube, serving under their own officers for pay. In 476 they asked for something more permanent. Elsewhere in the west, barbarian soldiers had been settled on a share of Roman land, and they demanded a third of Italy. Orestes refused.
One of his officers, Odoacer, a man in his forties whose father had also served Attila, told the troops that he would grant what Orestes had denied. On 23 August they raised him as their king. Orestes shut himself in Pavia. The city was stormed and sacked, and he was taken to Piacenza and beheaded on 28 August. His brother Paulus tried to hold Ravenna and was killed in the pine woods outside the walls on 4 September.
Odoacer then entered the city and found the emperor. A sixth-century chronicle says that he took pity on the boy’s youth and was moved by his good looks. He deposed him, granted him 6,000 gold pieces a year, and sent him with his relatives to live at the villa that had once belonged to the general Lucullus, on the Bay of Naples.
What he did not do was appoint a successor. Instead a delegation of Roman senators travelled to Constantinople, to the eastern emperor Zeno, carrying the imperial regalia of the west. Their message, preserved by the historian Malchus, was that one emperor was now enough for both halves of the world, and that Odoacer was a suitable man to manage Italy with the rank of patrician. Zeno replied that the west already had a lawful emperor in Nepos, and that they should take him back. But he addressed his letter to Odoacer as patrician.
How it came to this
The Roman empire had been governed in two halves, by co-emperors in east and west, for most of the previous century. The western half had been losing territory since 406, when Vandals, Alans and Sueves crossed the Rhine. By the 470s Britain had been abandoned, Visigoths ruled most of Spain and southern Gaul, Burgundians held the Rhone valley, and the Vandals had taken North Africa, whose grain and taxes had paid for the western army. A great fleet sent to recover Africa in 468 was destroyed. What was left to the emperor in Ravenna was Italy and not much else.
Real power had long since passed to the commanders of the army, usually men of barbarian or frontier origin who could not or would not take the throne themselves and ruled through emperors of their choosing. Between 455 and 476 there were nine western emperors. Most were made and unmade by generals, and several were never recognised in Constantinople. Romulus was one of those.