Parallax

4 September, AD 476

A boy emperor is pensioned off, and the western empire stops

Nobody at the time announced the fall of Rome. A general killed a rival, sent a teenager to the seaside with an allowance, and posted the imperial robes to Constantinople with a note saying they were no longer required.

Ravenna, Italy

The emperor was a boy, perhaps twelve or fourteen, and he had reigned for ten months without doing anything, because his father did it for him. He was called Romulus, after the founder of Rome, and Augustus, after the founder of the empire. His subjects shortened the second name to Augustulus, ‘little Augustus’, and Greek speakers twisted the first into Momyllus, ‘little disgrace’. His father, Orestes, was a Roman from Pannonia who had once served as secretary to Attila the Hun and had risen to command the army of Italy. In 475 Orestes had turned that army on the reigning emperor, Julius Nepos, chased him across the Adriatic, and put his own son on the throne at Ravenna.

The army of Italy by then was Roman only in name. It was made up of Heruli, Sciri, Rugi and other peoples from beyond the Danube, serving under their own officers for pay. In 476 they asked for something more permanent. Elsewhere in the west, barbarian soldiers had been settled on a share of Roman land, and they demanded a third of Italy. Orestes refused.

One of his officers, Odoacer, a man in his forties whose father had also served Attila, told the troops that he would grant what Orestes had denied. On 23 August they raised him as their king. Orestes shut himself in Pavia. The city was stormed and sacked, and he was taken to Piacenza and beheaded on 28 August. His brother Paulus tried to hold Ravenna and was killed in the pine woods outside the walls on 4 September.

Odoacer then entered the city and found the emperor. A sixth-century chronicle says that he took pity on the boy’s youth and was moved by his good looks. He deposed him, granted him 6,000 gold pieces a year, and sent him with his relatives to live at the villa that had once belonged to the general Lucullus, on the Bay of Naples.

What he did not do was appoint a successor. Instead a delegation of Roman senators travelled to Constantinople, to the eastern emperor Zeno, carrying the imperial regalia of the west. Their message, preserved by the historian Malchus, was that one emperor was now enough for both halves of the world, and that Odoacer was a suitable man to manage Italy with the rank of patrician. Zeno replied that the west already had a lawful emperor in Nepos, and that they should take him back. But he addressed his letter to Odoacer as patrician.

How it came to this

The Roman empire had been governed in two halves, by co-emperors in east and west, for most of the previous century. The western half had been losing territory since 406, when Vandals, Alans and Sueves crossed the Rhine. By the 470s Britain had been abandoned, Visigoths ruled most of Spain and southern Gaul, Burgundians held the Rhone valley, and the Vandals had taken North Africa, whose grain and taxes had paid for the western army. A great fleet sent to recover Africa in 468 was destroyed. What was left to the emperor in Ravenna was Italy and not much else.

Real power had long since passed to the commanders of the army, usually men of barbarian or frontier origin who could not or would not take the throne themselves and ruled through emperors of their choosing. Between 455 and 476 there were nine western emperors. Most were made and unmade by generals, and several were never recognised in Constantinople. Romulus was one of those.

How each side saw it

Constantinople

The eastern court never accepted Romulus and went on treating Julius Nepos as its western colleague until he was murdered in Dalmatia in 480. The idea that something had ended in 476 appears first in the east, a generation later. The chronicler Marcellinus, writing in Constantinople around 520, states that the western empire of the Roman people perished with this Augustulus. The historian Brian Croke has argued that the date was given its significance there, at a time when the emperor Justinian’s circle wanted Italy understood as a lost province awaiting reconquest rather than a Roman land under a lawful deputy.

Odoacer and his soldiers

No account from Odoacer’s side survives, and his people left no written history. He is known through Roman and Gothic sources, most of them composed after the Ostrogothic king Theoderic had murdered him at a banquet in 493 and needed him remembered as a tyrant. His actions suggest a man who wanted to be a Roman official rather than to abolish anything. He struck coins in the names of Nepos and Zeno, kept the senate, the consulship and the civil service, and repaired the Colosseum. His soldiers had wanted land and security in the country they were already defending, and they got it.

The senators of Italy

The great landed families carried on. They went on holding the old offices, staging games and writing to each other in polished Latin under Odoacer and then under Theoderic, and the writings of Ennodius and Cassiodorus from the following decades treat Roman government as a going concern. From where they sat, the removal of a usurper’s child by a competent general who respected their property was less alarming than the previous twenty years had been. It was the eastern empire’s war of reconquest in the 530s and 540s, and the Lombard invasion after it, that destroyed their world.

Modern historians

Whether Rome fell or was transformed is one of the oldest arguments in the discipline. Walter Goffart described the settlement of barbarians as an accommodation, an imaginative experiment that got a little out of hand. Peter Heather replies that the western empire was destroyed by armed outsiders it could no longer defeat or pay off. Bryan Ward-Perkins points to the archaeology, to the disappearance of good pottery, tiled roofs and coinage, as evidence of a real collapse in living standards. Guy Halsall locates the cause in Roman politics, with barbarian armies as instruments of rival Roman factions.

What is disputed

The date of 4 September is given in late Roman annals for the killing of Paulus at Ravenna, and the deposition is assumed to have followed at once. Romulus’s age is nowhere stated. Whether he was the last western emperor at all is doubtful, since Nepos held the better title until 480. His later life is a blank: a letter of Theoderic’s government, written about thirty years later and confirming a grant to a man named Romulus, may or may not concern him. Whether the soldiers demanded a third of the land itself or a third of its tax revenue is a technical dispute begun by Goffart.

What followed

Odoacer ruled Italy for seventeen years until Zeno sent Theoderic and the Ostrogoths against him. The eastern empire, which called itself Roman until 1453, reconquered Italy under Justinian at ruinous cost and lost most of it again within a generation. The year 476 became the conventional end of antiquity largely through Edward Gibbon, and every later age has read its own fears into it. The villa where Romulus was sent became a monastery, and its site is now the Castel dell’Ovo in Naples.

Read further

  • Anonymus Valesianus, Pars Posterior (sixth-century chronicle)
  • Peter Heather, The Fall of the Roman Empire: A New History (2005)
  • Bryan Ward-Perkins, The Fall of Rome and the End of Civilization (2005)
  • Guy Halsall, Barbarian Migrations and the Roman West, 376-568 (2007)
  • Walter Goffart, Barbarians and Romans, A.D. 418-584: The Techniques of Accommodation (1980)

Same day, other years

1479

Two crowns divide the Atlantic between them

Alcacovas, PortugalWorldwide

The Treaty of Alcacovas ended a four-year war over who should rule Castile. Afonso V of Portugal gave up the claim of his niece and wife Juana, and recognised Isabella and her husband Ferdinand. In exchange Castile accepted a clause with far longer consequences. Portugal was to have Madeira, the Azores, the Cape Verde islands and exclusive rights of trade and conquest along the African coast, ‘Guinea with its gold mines’, and in any lands found southwards from the Canaries. Castile kept the Canaries alone. It was the first agreement by which European kingdoms shared out seas and territories that neither of them possessed, and the model for Tordesillas fifteen years later.

Seen from elsewhere. Nobody on the African coast or in the Canary Islands was a party to it. The Guanches of the Canaries resisted Castilian conquest until 1496. The Portuguese monopoly it protected dealt in enslaved people as well as gold. Juana, set aside to make the peace, entered a convent in Coimbra and signed herself ‘I, the Queen’ until she died in 1530.

1774

Cook’s ship sights the island he names New Caledonia

Balade, New CaledoniaOceania

On his second Pacific voyage James Cook was sailing south from the New Hebrides when a midshipman on the Resolution saw high land ahead. Cook anchored the next day off Balade on the north-east coast and stayed a little over a week. He and the naturalists Johann and Georg Forster were received peaceably by the people of the district and their chief Tea Booma, exchanged cloth and nails, and noted irrigated taro terraces on the hillsides. Cook thought the mountains resembled Scotland and named the island accordingly. France annexed it in 1853, used it as a penal colony, and confined its people to reserves. It is still French territory.

Seen from elsewhere. The Kanak, whose ancestors had settled the islands some three thousand years earlier, had no writing, and the encounter survives on their side only in oral tradition. A major rising against French land seizures in 1878 was crushed. Independence was rejected in referendums in 2018, 2020 and 2021, the last boycotted by the independence parties, who do not accept its result.

1957

Elizabeth Eckford walks to school alone

Little Rock, Arkansas, United StatesThe Americas

Three years after the Supreme Court ruled segregated schools unconstitutional, nine Black teenagers were due to enter Central High School in Little Rock. Governor Orval Faubus surrounded the building with the Arkansas National Guard. The students had been told to arrive together, but fifteen-year-old Elizabeth Eckford’s family had no telephone and the message never reached her. She came alone by bus, in a dress she had made for the day, was turned back by soldiers with bayonets, and walked a block to a bus stop through a crowd shouting that she should be lynched. Photographs of that walk went round the world. President Eisenhower sent paratroopers three weeks later to escort the nine inside.

Seen from elsewhere. Faubus said he had acted to prevent bloodshed and to defend his state against federal dictation. He closed every high school in Little Rock for the following year rather than integrate them, and Arkansas voters re-elected him four more times. Many white residents presented themselves as moderates overtaken by outside agitators. The nine were harassed inside the school throughout the year.

1970

Chile votes for Salvador Allende

Santiago, ChileThe Americas

On his fourth attempt at the presidency, the Socialist doctor Salvador Allende, candidate of a coalition that included the Communist Party, came first in a three-way race with a little over 36 per cent, about 39,000 votes ahead of the conservative Jorge Alessandri. Since nobody had a majority, Congress had to choose between the top two in October. In Washington, President Nixon instructed the CIA to prevent Allende taking office. A plot to kidnap the army commander, General Rene Schneider, who insisted that the constitution be respected, ended with Schneider fatally shot. Congress confirmed Allende two days after the shooting. He was overthrown by the armed forces on 11 September 1973 and died in the presidential palace.

Seen from elsewhere. Allende’s opponents feared that a minority government meant to build a Marxist state by legal instalments, and by 1973 the Chamber of Deputies had accused him of repeatedly breaching the constitution. His supporters point to the documented American campaign against him. Historians still dispute how much the coup owed to Washington and how much to Chile’s own polarisation and economic crisis.

Also on 4 September