Parallax

19 September, 1356

A king of France is taken at Poitiers

The Prince of Wales was trying to get home with his plunder when the French army caught him. By evening he was serving supper to its king, who was his prisoner.

Nouaille-Maupertuis, near Poitiers, France

Edward of Woodstock, Prince of Wales, known to later ages as the Black Prince, was twenty-six and had been riding through central France for six weeks, burning as he went. His army of about 6,000 English and Gascons was slowed by wagons of loot when King John II of France, with a force perhaps twice as large, got across his road south-east of Poitiers. The prince drew up on a wooded slope behind hedges, vines and marshy ground near the abbey of Nouaille.

Sunday 18 September was spent talking. Cardinal Talleyrand of Perigord rode between the camps on the pope’s behalf, and the prince, by several accounts, offered a great deal: his prisoners, his plunder, the towns he had taken and a truce of seven years. John wanted the prince himself and a hundred of his knights as captives. The talks failed. The English used the day to dig ditches.

On Monday morning the French attacked in successive divisions. Advised by a Scottish knight, William Douglas, that horses were helpless against archers, John had most of his men-at-arms dismount, keeping a few hundred picked horsemen under his two marshals to ride the bowmen down. That charge broke up in the hedged lane; Marshal Clermont was killed and Marshal Audrehem taken. The Dauphin’s division then came on foot, in armour, uphill, and fought for perhaps two hours before it gave way. The next division, under the king’s brother the Duke of Orleans, saw the Dauphin being led off the field and followed him without striking a blow.

That left the king’s own division, fresh and still larger than the tired English line. The chronicler Geoffrey le Baker has a man near the prince cry out that they were beaten, and the prince answer that he lied while his lord was alive. The archers were out of arrows and pulling them from the dead. The prince then did two things at once. He sent the Gascon lord Jean de Grailly, the Captal de Buch, with a small mounted party round a hill to appear in the French rear under the banner of St George, and he ordered his own men forward.

The French division was surrounded and ground down. Geoffroi de Charny, carrying the sacred Oriflamme, was killed with it in his hands. John fought on foot with a battle-axe, his fourteen-year-old son Philip beside him, by tradition calling out which side the next blow was coming from. When the king finally offered to yield, a crowd of men tore at him, each claiming the ransom, until the Earl of Warwick pushed through and led him away. Some 2,500 French men-at-arms were dead and about 2,000 were prisoners. That night, Froissart says, the prince waited on the king at table and told him he had won the day’s prize for valour.

How it came to this

The war had begun in 1337 as a quarrel over Gascony, which the kings of England held as dukes and vassals of the French crown, and grew when Edward III claimed that crown through his mother. He beat the French at Crecy in 1346 and took Calais, then the Black Death halted everything. When fighting resumed, the English method was the chevauchee: a mounted raid that destroyed crops, mills and towns across a wide front, enriched the raiders, ruined the enemy’s tax base and showed that his king could not protect him.

In 1355 the prince rode from Bordeaux to the Mediterranean and back, burning the suburbs of Carcassonne and Narbonne. The raid of 1356 went north toward the Loire, where he hoped to join another English army; the bridges were broken and he turned for home. John II, crowned in 1350, had a reputation for courage and a treasury emptied by debasement and war. He had raised taxes on the promise of a battle, and he could not let the prince go a second time.

How each side saw it

The English and Gascons

The prince’s own letter to the city of London, written a month later, is brisk: he gives God the credit and lists the captured. Chandos Herald, who wrote a verse life of the prince, and Geoffrey le Baker tell it as a triumph of discipline and of a commander who kept his head. For the Gascon lords, who made up much of the army and supplied the decisive flank attack, it was a victory for their own duke against a king in Paris they had never accepted. For everyone it was a fortune: ransoms from Poitiers built English castles and founded families.

French commoners

In France the anger turned on the nobility. The Carmelite friar Jean de Venette, who had seen the countryside burned, wrote that the nobles had grown soft and proud and preyed on the peasants they were supposed to defend. An anonymous verse lament on the battle accused them outright of treachery for leaving their king. Men who fled the field were jeered in the towns. In Paris the Estates-General, led by the merchants’ provost Etienne Marcel, demanded control of taxation and the dismissal of royal councillors. In 1358 peasants north of Paris rose in the Jacquerie and killed nobles in their houses.

The raided provinces

The people through whose country the prince rode left almost no testimony of their own; we know what happened to them mostly from the raiders. Sir John Wingfield, the prince’s steward, wrote home after the 1355 raid with satisfaction that the lands destroyed had yielded the French king more revenue than half his kingdom. Petitions for tax relief and church inquiries from Languedoc and Berry, some made decades later, record villages still empty. Chivalric courtesy at Poitiers applied to men worth a ransom. It did not extend to the foot soldiers who were killed, or to the population.

What is disputed

Numbers are estimates from chroniclers who inflated them; modern figures of about 6,000 against 11,000 or more are reasoned guesses. The central argument is over intent. Older accounts, and in part Jonathan Sumption, see a prince caught while trying to escape. Clifford Rogers argues that the English wanted a battle on ground of their choosing and that the ‘retreat’ at dawn may have been a lure. The exact site is not agreed. Froissart, the most quoted source, wrote a generation later and prized a good scene: the supper, and the boy’s warning cries, may be improved in the telling.

What followed

John was taken to Bordeaux and then London. The Treaty of Bretigny in 1360 set his ransom at three million gold crowns and gave Edward III about a third of France in full sovereignty in return for dropping his claim to the throne. John went home, but when a son held hostage for the payment broke parole, he returned to captivity and died in London in 1364. The Dauphin who had been led from the field became Charles V and won most of the territory back by refusing ever to fight such a battle.

Read further

  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume 2: Trial by Fire (1999)
  • Clifford J. Rogers, War Cruel and Sharp: English Strategy under Edward III, 1327-1360 (2000)
  • Richard Barber, Edward, Prince of Wales and Aquitaine (1978)
  • Jean Froissart, Chronicles
  • Jean de Venette, The Chronicle of Jean de Venette, translated by Jean Birdsall (1953)

Same day, other years

1676

Rebels burn Virginia’s capital

Jamestown, VirginiaThe Americas

Nathaniel Bacon, a young planter not long arrived from England, had raised an army of small farmers, indentured servants and enslaved Africans against the governor, Sir William Berkeley. Their grievances were low tobacco prices, heavy taxes and a governor’s circle that kept the best land and the fur trade for itself. Above all they wanted a free hand to make war on Native peoples along the frontier, which Berkeley refused. Having driven the governor out of Jamestown, Bacon’s men set fire to it, church and statehouse included, so that he could not return. Bacon died of dysentery five weeks later and the rising fell apart. Berkeley hanged twenty-three men.

Seen from elsewhere. Bacon’s first victims were peoples at peace with the colony. He attacked the Occaneechi and hunted the Pamunkey, tributary allies under their leader Cockacoeske, through the swamps, killing and enslaving them. Edmund Morgan argued that the planter elite, frightened by poor whites and blacks in arms together, afterwards turned to African slavery and a hardened colour line; others think that overstates it.

1893

New Zealand’s women win the vote

Wellington, New ZealandOceania

The governor, Lord Glasgow, signed an Electoral Act that made New Zealand the first self-governing country in which women could vote in national elections. It followed three great petitions organised by Kate Sheppard and the Women’s Christian Temperance Union; the last, pasted into a roll 270 metres long, carried nearly 32,000 signatures, about a quarter of the adult European women in the colony. The premier, Richard Seddon, opposed the measure and tried to defeat it in the upper house, where his manoeuvring so annoyed two councillors that they changed sides and it passed by 20 votes to 18. Ten weeks later most eligible women voted. They could not stand for parliament until 1919.

Seen from elsewhere. The liquor trade fought the bill, fearing prohibition, and ran its own petitions. Maori women were included in the act and voted in the four Maori seats. That year Meri Te Tai Mangakahia asked the separate Maori parliament to let women vote and sit as members, arguing that many held land in their own right. It did not act on her motion.

1985

Mexico City falls down at 7.19

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

The earthquake began under the Pacific coast of Michoacan, some 350 kilometres away, with a magnitude of about 8. Mexico City stands on the soft bed of a drained lake, which shook like jelly for more than two minutes. Hundreds of buildings collapsed, among them hospitals, schools, a thirteen-storey block of the Tlatelolco housing estate and garment workshops where seamstresses had already started their shift. The government of Miguel de la Madrid was slow to appear and at first said outside help was not needed. Neighbours, students and volunteers dug with their hands. Newborn babies were pulled alive from the ruins of two hospitals after as long as a week.

Seen from elsewhere. The official death toll settled at a few thousand and later rose towards 10,000; journalists, rescue groups and some officials put it at 20,000 or more. Many of the buildings that failed were public ones. Mexican writers such as Elena Poniatowska date the growth of independent civic movements, and the weakening of seven decades of one-party rule, from those days.

2006

Tanks in Bangkok while the prime minister is away

Bangkok, ThailandAsia

Thaksin Shinawatra was in New York for the UN General Assembly when armoured vehicles rolled up to Government House on a rainy Tuesday evening. General Sonthi Boonyaratglin announced that the army had taken power, scrapped the constitution and cancelled the coming election. No shots were fired. It was Thailand’s first coup in fifteen years, and it removed a telecoms billionaire who had won two elections by large margins on the strength of cheap health care and village credit. The generals accused him of corruption, abuse of power and disrespect to the monarchy. The king endorsed the new council the following day.

Seen from elsewhere. Many in Bangkok welcomed the soldiers with flowers; critics recalled the thousands killed in Thaksin’s 2003 anti-drug campaign. In the rural north and north-east, voters concluded that their ballots counted for less than the capital’s wishes. The split between ‘red shirts’ and ‘yellow shirts’ led to street killings in 2010 and another coup in 2014.

Also on 19 September