Parallax

29 September, 1941

The Jews of Kyiv are marched to Babi Yar

Ordered to report with their documents and warm clothes, they expected to be deported. Over two days German units shot 33,771 of them in a ravine on the edge of the city.

Babi Yar (Babyn Yar), Kyiv, Ukraine

The German army took Kyiv on 19 September 1941. Five days later explosions began to tear apart the main street, Khreshchatyk, where the occupiers had set up offices. The charges had been laid by Soviet engineers before the retreat. Fires burned for days. At a meeting on 26 September the city’s military commander, the SS and police leaders and the commander of Sonderkommando 4a, Paul Blobel, agreed on what they called retaliation: the killing of the city’s Jews.

Notices went up around the city in Russian, Ukrainian and German. All Jews of Kyiv were to appear at eight in the morning on Monday 29 September at a corner near the Jewish cemetery, with documents, money, valuables and warm clothing. Anyone who disobeyed would be shot. Most of the young men had left with the Red Army or been mobilised, so those who came were mainly old people, women and children. Many assumed they were to be resettled. Rumours in the city spoke of trains.

The column walked out along Melnykova Street past the cemeteries. Near the ravine of Babi Yar it passed through a cordon of German soldiers and Ukrainian auxiliary police. Beyond that point no one was allowed back. People were made to leave their bags, then to undress, and were beaten through a corridor of men with sticks and dogs. They were taken in groups to the edge of the ravine, or down into it, and shot by members of the Sonderkommando and two Order Police battalions. The next groups were made to lie on the bodies of the last.

The shooting went on through 29 September and all of the next day. On 2 October the Einsatzgruppe’s report to Berlin recorded that 33,771 Jews had been executed. Afterwards the sides of the ravine were blown in to cover the bodies, and the clothing was sorted and handed to German welfare organisations and ethnic Germans.

A few people climbed out. Dina Pronicheva, an actress at a puppet theatre, threw herself into the ravine before the shots reached her, lay still while men walked over the bodies and shot the living, and crawled out after dark. She gave evidence at a Soviet trial in Kyiv in 1946 and at a West German trial of members of the Sonderkommando in 1967.

Babi Yar remained a killing site for the rest of the occupation. Roma, Soviet prisoners of war, patients from a psychiatric hospital, Ukrainian nationalists who had fallen out with the Germans and hostages were shot there. In the summer of 1943, with the Red Army approaching, prisoners from the nearby Syrets camp were made to dig up and burn the bodies. On 29 September 1943, two years to the day, some of them broke out.

How it came to this

Germany invaded the Soviet Union on 22 June 1941. Behind the advancing armies came the Einsatzgruppen, mobile units of the SS security police and SD, supported by Order Police battalions and, as the summer went on, by local auxiliary police. At first they shot mainly Jewish men described as Communists or saboteurs. By August they were killing whole Jewish communities, women and children included, and the scale grew from hundreds to thousands at a time, as at Kamianets-Podilskyi at the end of August.

Kyiv had more than 200,000 Jewish residents at the 1939 census. Most left with the evacuation or were mobilised, and several tens of thousands stayed. Those who remained were disproportionately elderly, female and poor. Under Soviet rule the city had suffered the famine of 1932-33 and the purges, and some non-Jewish residents greeted the Germans with hope. The Wehrmacht’s Sixth Army, whose commander Walter von Reichenau ordered his men to show understanding for harsh measures against Jews, controlled the city and supported the operation.

How each side saw it

Victims and survivors

The voices of the murdered survive through the few who escaped, notably Dina Pronicheva, and through neighbours. Anatoly Kuznetsov, who was twelve and lived nearby in Kurenivka, heard the firing and later collected testimony, including Pronicheva’s, for his documentary novel Babi Yar. Jewish memory insisted that this was a crime against Jews as Jews, the largest single shooting of the Holocaust in the occupied Soviet Union to that date, and long fought for that to be acknowledged at the site itself.

The perpetrators’ record

The Germans documented the killing themselves. Operational Situation Report USSR No. 101 gave the figure of 33,771, and later reports referred to the operation in routine language. Paul Blobel was tried in the Einsatzgruppen case at Nuremberg and hanged in 1951. In the Darmstadt trial of 1967-68 members of Sonderkommando 4a described the corridors and the shooting, while presenting themselves as men who had followed orders and had found the work hard to bear.

The Soviet state

The Soviet Extraordinary State Commission investigated after Kyiv was retaken in 1943 and described the victims as peaceful Soviet citizens. For decades the state discouraged any memorial that singled out Jews. Yevgeny Yevtushenko’s poem Babi Yar of 1961, which opened with the line that there was no monument over Babi Yar, and Shostakovich’s Thirteenth Symphony, which set it, were attacked for that reason. The monument erected in 1976 named Soviet citizens and prisoners of war, not Jews.

Ukrainian memory

Independent Ukraine placed a menorah at the site in 1991 and has built a growing memorial complex. The role of local auxiliary police in the cordons, and the fate of Ukrainian nationalists such as the poet Olena Teliha, shot at Babi Yar in 1942, have made the site a place of competing memories. Ukrainian historians and the memorial centre have worked to tell both histories without letting one stand in for the other.

What is disputed

The figure of 33,771 for the two days comes from the perpetrators’ own report and is generally accepted. The total killed at Babi Yar during the whole occupation is uncertain, with estimates from about 70,000 to over 100,000. How far Ukrainian auxiliary police took part beyond the cordons, and whether units of the Bukovinian battalion of the nationalist OUN were present, is debated; historians such as Karel Berkhoff have examined the evidence closely and scholars weigh it differently. The exact spot of the shootings within the ravine was reshaped by later landfill.

What followed

In 1961 a dam holding brickworks waste in the ravine burst and buried part of the Kurenivka district in mud, killing many people. The ravine was largely filled and built over, and memorials came slowly and in pieces. Babi Yar became central to the study of the Holocaust by bullets, the shooting of Jews across the occupied east, which killed some one and a half to two million people and was long overshadowed by the death camps. In March 2022 a Russian missile strike hit the television tower beside the site.

Read further

  • Karel C. Berkhoff, Harvest of Despair: Life and Death in Ukraine under Nazi Rule (2004)
  • Anatoly Kuznetsov, Babi Yar: A Document in the Form of a Novel (1970)
  • Vladyslav Hrynevych and Paul Robert Magocsi (eds), Babyn Yar: History and Memory (2016)
  • Patrick Desbois, The Holocaust by Bullets (2008)
  • Raul Hilberg, The Destruction of the European Jews

Same day, other years

522 BC

Darius and six nobles kill the king they call an impostor

Sikayauvati fortress, Media, IranMiddle East

In 522 BC the Persian king Cambyses, son of Cyrus the Great, died on his way back from Egypt, and a man ruling as his brother Bardiya held the throne. According to the great inscription Darius later had carved on the cliff at Behistun, this king was really a Magian priest named Gaumata who had taken the dead prince’s identity, Cambyses having secretly had his brother killed. Darius, from a collateral branch of the royal family, and six other nobles surprised him at a fortress in Media and killed him. Darius took the throne, put down revolts across the empire in a year of fighting, and ruled until 486 BC.

Seen from elsewhere. Many historians suspect that the man killed was the real Bardiya and that the impostor story was Darius’s justification for a usurpation. Herodotus tells a version of the same tale. The date is a modern conversion of the Persian month named in the inscription.

1829

The Metropolitan Police walk their first beats in London

London, EnglandEurope

The Home Secretary, Sir Robert Peel, had pushed through Parliament an act creating a single paid, uniformed police force for the capital outside the City of London. On the evening of 29 September 1829 its first constables went on duty, about a thousand of them at the start, in blue tail coats and top hats, carrying wooden truncheons and rattles. Their headquarters opened on to a yard called Great Scotland Yard. The commissioners, Charles Rowan and Richard Mayne, stressed prevention of crime and restraint in the use of force. The model was copied across Britain and the empire.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Londoners saw the new force as a French-style threat to liberty and a standing army in disguise, and called the constables Peelers, Bobbies or worse. Radicals and working-class Londoners resented them; in Ireland Peel had already created a more military constabulary, and the colonial forces modelled on London were often armed.

1911

Italy declares war on the Ottoman Empire to seize Libya

Tripoli and Cyrenaica, LibyaAfrica

Italy had long considered the Ottoman provinces of Tripolitania and Cyrenaica its share of North Africa, and in September 1911 it sent the Ottoman government an ultimatum it could not accept. War was declared on 29 September. Italian troops landed at Tripoli in October and found that the Arab population did not welcome them as liberators. After Libyan and Ottoman fighters attacked Italian lines at Shar al-Shatt, Italian forces killed large numbers of civilians in reprisal. In November an Italian pilot dropped grenades on Ottoman positions, the first bombing from an aeroplane. The Ottomans ceded Libya in 1912.

Seen from elsewhere. Ottoman officers, among them the young Mustafa Kemal, helped organise local resistance, and the Sanusi order in Cyrenaica fought on for twenty years. Libyans remember a war of conquest that led to the camps of the 1930s and the hanging of Omar Mukhtar. The war also showed the Balkan states that the Ottomans could be beaten.

1923

The British Mandate for Palestine comes into force

Jerusalem, PalestineMiddle East

After the First World War the League of Nations gave Britain a mandate to govern the former Ottoman territory of Palestine. The text, approved by the League Council in July 1922, came into effect on 29 September 1923. It wrote into international law the Balfour Declaration of 1917, committing Britain to establish a national home for the Jewish people while protecting the civil and religious rights of the non-Jewish communities, who were then the large majority. It recognised a Jewish Agency to advise the administration and encouraged Jewish immigration. The territory east of the Jordan was excluded from those clauses and became the emirate of Transjordan.

Seen from elsewhere. Zionist leaders welcomed the mandate as international recognition. The Palestinian Arab leadership rejected it as denying the majority self-government, and boycotted the legislative council Britain proposed. Historians still argue whether its two promises could ever have been reconciled. Britain gave the mandate up in 1948.

Also on 29 September