Parallax

30 September, 1399

England’s empty throne is filled in Westminster Hall

Richard II was not in the room when his crown was taken. His cousin Henry stood up in front of an empty throne and claimed it in English.

Westminster Hall, London, England

On the morning of Tuesday 30 September 1399 the lords spiritual and temporal and the representatives of the commons crowded into Westminster Hall. At the front stood the throne, empty and draped in cloth of gold. The man who had sat there for twenty-two years was a prisoner in the Tower of London, and the man who had put him there, his cousin Henry Bolingbroke, Duke of Lancaster, sat in his own place among the lords.

The proceedings were run by Henry’s allies. The Archbishop of York read out a document said to have been signed by Richard in the Tower the day before. In it the king released his subjects from their oaths, renounced the crown, and declared himself insufficient and unworthy to rule. The official record, which the new regime wrote, says that he had read it aloud with a cheerful face and wished his cousin to succeed him. The assembly accepted the resignation. Then, to make doubly sure, thirty-three articles of accusation against Richard were read, listing his breaches of law and his coronation oath, and commissioners pronounced him deposed.

Henry stood, made the sign of the cross, and spoke. In English rather than the French of the court, he challenged the realm and crown of England as the descendant, he said, of Henry III, and as one whom God had sent to recover a kingdom that was being undone through lack of good government. He did not mention conquest, though everyone in the hall knew that was how he had come. The two archbishops took him by the hands and led him to the throne, and Thomas Arundel, Archbishop of Canterbury, preached on the theme that a man, not a boy, would now rule.

Nine days earlier the chronicler Adam Usk, a lawyer who had sat on the committee that found the legal grounds for deposition, had visited Richard in the Tower. He recorded the fallen king, at dinner, talking bitterly about how many kings England had exiled and killed and how fickle the land was. Usk wrote that he left deeply moved.

Henry was crowned on 13 October, the feast of Edward the Confessor, and anointed with an oil that the Virgin was said to have given to Thomas Becket. Richard was moved secretly to Pontefract Castle. After a group of his former favourites tried to kill Henry in the Epiphany Rising of January 1400, Richard’s survival became too dangerous. He was dead by about 14 February, and his body was shown publicly in London with the face uncovered, to prove it.

How it came to this

Richard was ten when he succeeded his grandfather Edward III in 1377. At fourteen he faced down the rebels of the Peasants’ Revolt at Smithfield, the moment of his reign he never forgot. As an adult he gathered favourites, above all Robert de Vere, and in 1387-88 five great lords, the Lords Appellant, among them Henry Bolingbroke, defeated de Vere at Radcot Bridge and had the king’s friends executed or exiled in the Merciless Parliament.

Richard waited nearly ten years. In 1397 he struck: his uncle Gloucester was murdered in Calais, the Earl of Arundel beheaded and Warwick exiled. The two younger Appellants, Bolingbroke and Thomas Mowbray, then accused each other of treason, and in 1398 Richard stopped their duel at Coventry and exiled both. When Henry’s father, John of Gaunt, died in February 1399, Richard made the exile permanent and seized the Lancastrian estates, the greatest inheritance in England. He then sailed to Ireland. Henry landed at Ravenspur in early July, claiming only his rights, and the country came over to him.

How each side saw it

The Lancastrian record

The Record and Process entered on the parliament roll is the new government’s account of the deposition, written to show a voluntary resignation followed by a lawful judgement. The St Albans chronicler Thomas Walsingham, writing in the same spirit, presents Richard as a tyrant who had broken the law, packed parliaments and extorted blank charters from whole counties. The thirty-three articles became the case for the prosecution that most English historians accepted for centuries.

Richard’s French sympathisers

Richard’s second wife was Isabella of Valois, a child of the French king, and French writers told a different story. Jean Creton, a squire who was with Richard in Wales, wrote a verse chronicle describing how the Earl of Northumberland swore on the sacrament at Conwy that Richard would keep his crown, and then led him into an ambush. The chronicle called the Traison et Mort makes Richard a betrayed and pious king. In these accounts there is nothing voluntary about the abdication.

Modern historians

Nigel Saul’s biography sees a king with a high and sincere idea of royal authority whose methods in 1397-99 frightened every property owner in England. Caroline Barron described those years as a tyranny. Earlier writers who diagnosed Richard as mentally unstable are now little followed. Chris Given-Wilson’s edition of the chronicles shows how deliberately both sides shaped their stories, and Ian Mortimer has argued that Henry’s claim and character have been misjudged in the shadow of Shakespeare.

What is disputed

The book has Richard declaring his abdication before Parliament in Westminster Hall; he was absent, and his resignation was read for him. Whether he resigned freely is doubtful; the cheerful face rests on the Lancastrian record alone. The assembly was arguably not a parliament, since it met under writs in Richard’s name, and lawyers then and since have argued whether he abdicated or was deposed. How he died is unknown: Lancastrian sources say he starved himself, others that he was starved, and the story of murder by Sir Piers Exton is a later legend made famous by Shakespeare.

What followed

Henry IV spent much of his reign putting down rebellions, including that of the Percys, who claimed in 1403 that he had broken an oath at Doncaster to seek only his duchy. Rumours that Richard was alive in Scotland persisted for years. Henry V gave him an honourable reburial in Westminster Abbey in 1413. The precedent of deposing an anointed king, and the Lancastrian title it created, fed the dynastic quarrel that became the Wars of the Roses.

Read further

  • Nigel Saul, Richard II (1997)
  • Chris Given-Wilson (ed. and trans.), Chronicles of the Revolution, 1397-1400: The Reign of Richard II (1993)
  • Adam Usk, The Chronicle of Adam Usk, 1377-1421, edited and translated by Chris Given-Wilson (1997)
  • Michael Bennett, Richard II and the Revolution of 1399 (1999)
  • Ian Mortimer, The Fears of Henry IV: The Life of England’s Self-Made King (2007)

Same day, other years

1520

Suleiman takes the Ottoman throne

Istanbul, Ottoman EmpireEurope

Sultan Selim I, who had conquered Syria, Egypt and the holy cities of Arabia in eight ruthless years, died on campaign in Thrace on 22 September 1520. His only surviving son, Suleiman, then governor of Manisa in western Anatolia, rode to the capital and on 30 September was enthroned. Unusually, there were no brothers to kill or fight. Over forty-six years he took Belgrade, Rhodes, most of Hungary after the battle of Mohacs, and Baghdad, besieged Vienna in 1529, and built a navy that contested the Mediterranean. His architect Sinan filled Istanbul with mosques.

Seen from elsewhere. Europeans called him the Magnificent; Ottomans remembered him as Kanuni, the lawgiver, for the codes issued in his name. Hungarians remember Mohacs as a national catastrophe. His reign also saw the execution of his grand vizier and friend Ibrahim and of his eldest son Mustafa, events Ottoman and Venetian observers explained very differently.

1938

The Munich Agreement gives the Sudetenland to Germany

Munich, GermanyEurope

In the early hours of 30 September Hitler, Neville Chamberlain, Edouard Daladier and Mussolini signed an agreement, dated the previous day, under which Czechoslovakia was to hand its German-speaking border regions to Germany within ten days. Czechoslovakia was not represented at the table and the Soviet Union was not invited. Later that day Chamberlain also got Hitler to sign a short declaration that Britain and Germany would never go to war again, and back in London he told the crowd outside Downing Street that he believed it was peace for our time. German troops entered the Sudetenland on 1 October.

Seen from elsewhere. Czechs call it the Munich betrayal, the decision about us without us. Germany occupied the rest of the Czech lands in March 1939. Some historians argue that Britain and France were not ready to fight in 1938 and used the year to rearm; others reply that Germany gained more from it than they did.

1965

A night of killings in Jakarta opens Indonesia’s mass slaughter

Jakarta, IndonesiaAsia

During the night of 30 September to 1 October 1965 a group of officers calling itself the 30 September Movement kidnapped six senior army generals and a lieutenant, and killed them; their bodies were thrown into a well at Lubang Buaya. General Nasution escaped, but his small daughter was fatally wounded. General Suharto, commander of the army’s strategic reserve, crushed the movement within a day and the army blamed the Indonesian Communist Party, then the largest outside the Communist bloc. In the following months the army and allied militias killed somewhere between 500,000 and a million people accused of communist links, and imprisoned hundreds of thousands more. Suharto took power and ruled until 1998.

Seen from elsewhere. The New Order taught that the killings were the nation’s defence against a communist coup and showed a film to that effect every year. Historians dispute who planned the movement: Benedict Anderson and Ruth McVey saw an internal army affair, while John Roosa points to a secret party bureau. Western governments welcomed Suharto’s rise and supplied names.

1966

Botswana becomes independent under Seretse Khama

Gaborone, BotswanaAfrica

The Bechuanaland Protectorate had been run by Britain for eighty years largely from Mafikeng, a town in South Africa, and at independence it was among the poorest countries in the world, with only a few miles of tarred road. Its first president, Seretse Khama, heir to the chieftaincy of the Bangwato, had been exiled by the British in the 1950s after marrying an Englishwoman, Ruth Williams, a decision pressed by apartheid South Africa. On 30 September 1966 the Republic of Botswana was proclaimed. Diamonds were found at Orapa the following year, and the country combined rapid growth with an unbroken record of multi-party elections.

Seen from elsewhere. Critics point out that one party, the Botswana Democratic Party, governed from 1966 until it lost the election of 2024, that national identity has favoured Tswana language and culture, and that San communities were moved out of the Central Kalahari Game Reserve, which the High Court ruled unlawful in 2006.

Also on 30 September