Parallax

5 September, 1638

After twenty-two years, the queen of France has a son

The child who became Louis XIV was called ‘the God-given’ because nobody had expected him. A rainstorm, a nun and a captain of the guard are credited with his conception; the records of the court suggest something more ordinary.

Saint-Germain-en-Laye, France

A little before noon on Sunday 5 September 1638, in the new chateau at Saint-Germain-en-Laye west of Paris, Anne of Austria gave birth to a boy. She was a few weeks short of thirty-seven and had been married for almost twenty-three years. The birth took place, as royal births did, in front of witnesses: princes of the blood, great officers and ladies of the court crowded the room so that no one could later say a child had been substituted. The king, Louis XIII, was fetched from his dinner and knelt to give thanks.

The news went to Paris by relays of horsemen and was passed across the Seine, where the bridge was down, by a prearranged signal: men on the far bank were to stand with folded arms for a girl and wave their hats for a boy. The city lit bonfires in every street, fired cannon, rang bells for a day and a night and set wine running from fountains. The Te Deum was sung at Notre-Dame. The child was named Louis and at once nicknamed Dieudonne, the gift of God.

He was large and vigorous, and he was born with two teeth, to the cost of a series of wet nurses. Hugo Grotius, then Sweden’s ambassador in Paris, remarked in a dispatch that France’s neighbours might take warning from so early an appetite.

The gratitude was real because the marriage had seemed finished. Louis and Anne had been wed at fourteen and had been estranged for most of the years since. She had miscarried at least three times. A year before the birth she had been caught in secret correspondence with her brother, the king of Spain, with whom France was at war, and had been interrogated by the chancellor and made to sign a confession. The king’s affections were given to male favourites and, chastely, to a maid of honour named Louise de La Fayette, who had lately entered a convent in Paris.

From that convent comes the celebrated explanation. On 5 December 1637, the story runs, Louis visited Louise on his way to his lodge at Saint-Maur and stayed talking until a violent storm made the roads impassable. His own bed and household had gone ahead. The captain of his guard, Guitaut, pointed out that the queen was at the Louvre nearby with a supper and a bed. The king resisted, the rain continued, and he went. Nine months later to the day, France had a dauphin.

How it came to this

The stakes were dynastic and immediate. Louis XIII was thirty-six, in poor health, and had no child. His heir was his younger brother Gaston, duke of Orleans, a charming and unreliable man who had spent twenty years joining plots against the king’s chief minister, Cardinal Richelieu, and betraying his fellow plotters when they failed. Every faction opposed to Richelieu’s policies, his taxes and his war looked to Gaston’s accession for relief. For Richelieu a dauphin meant survival, and for the Bourbon line, only two generations old on the throne, it meant continuity.

France had entered the Thirty Years War openly in 1635 against the Habsburgs of Spain and Austria, the queen’s own family. In 1636 a Spanish army had come within reach of Paris. Anne, Spanish by birth and upbringing despite her title, was distrusted at court and was kept from influence. Her position depended on producing an heir, and by 1637 there was talk at court of repudiating her.

How each side saw it

The devout

To Catholic France the birth was an answered prayer and was officially treated as one. In February 1638, with the queen’s pregnancy known, Louis XIII issued a declaration placing his kingdom under the protection of the Virgin and ordering a procession every 15 August, which was kept up, with interruptions, into the nineteenth century. A Parisian friar, Brother Fiacre, was credited with having foreseen the birth in a vision and prescribed the novenas that obtained it, and he was received by the queen. Anne fulfilled a vow of her own by building the church of the Val-de-Grace, whose first stone the boy laid at the age of six.

Gaston of Orleans and the opposition

The duke of Orleans had been heir presumptive for the whole of his brother’s reign. He attended the birth, as protocol required, and contemporaries noted that he examined the child’s sex for himself and went pale. The king is said to have paid his debts as consolation. For the great nobles who had gathered round Gaston, the event closed off the prospect of a change of government by inheritance. Their discontent did not disappear. It returned ten years later, during the boy’s minority, as the civil wars of the Fronde, in which Gaston once again took part.

Madrid

Anne’s brother Philip IV was at war with her husband, and the Spanish court had reasons to regret a healthy French heir. Yet it was also a nephew’s birth, and it was answered within the week: on 10 September 1638 Philip’s queen bore a daughter, Maria Theresa. The two cousins were married in 1660 to seal the peace between the crowns. Through that marriage a grandson of the child born at Saint-Germain inherited the Spanish throne in 1700, which was the reverse of anything the Habsburgs had intended, and Europe fought a thirteen-year war over it.

The king’s enemies, later

A birth so late and so convenient invited rumour. During Louis XIV’s wars, pamphlets printed in Holland and circulated in Protestant Europe claimed that he was not Louis XIII’s son and named various fathers, among them Cardinal Mazarin, who became Anne’s minister and intimate after 1643. Mazarin was in Italy when the child was conceived. No contemporary evidence supports any of the candidates, and the publicity of the royal bedchamber made concealment hard. The stories fed into the legend of the Man in the Iron Mask, whom Voltaire made an elder brother and Dumas a twin.

What is disputed

The storm story comes from memoirs written decades afterwards and was fixed in its familiar form by the Jesuit historian Griffet in the eighteenth century. Biographers including Ruth Kleinman and Jean-Christian Petitfils argue that the king and queen had been lodging together at Saint-Germain in the weeks before, and that the court physicians’ reckoning did not depend on a single night, so the conception may have had no drama about it. The neat interval of exactly nine months is itself suspicious. The count of Anne’s earlier miscarriages varies between three and four. The paternity rumours are political inventions of the 1690s.

What followed

Louis XIII died in May 1643 and his son became king at four years and eight months. He reigned for seventy-two years, the longest of any monarch of a sovereign state whose dates are securely known, built Versailles, revoked the toleration of Protestants, and fought wars that left France enlarged and exhausted. Anne governed as regent with Mazarin and brought her son through the Fronde. The circumstances of his birth mattered to him: he was raised to believe himself a gift of Providence to France, and he governed accordingly.

Read further

  • Ruth Kleinman, Anne of Austria: Queen of France (1985)
  • A. Lloyd Moote, Louis XIII, the Just (1989)
  • John B. Wolf, Louis XIV (1968)
  • Francoise de Motteville, Memoires pour servir a l’histoire d’Anne d’Autriche
  • Jean-Christian Petitfils, Louis XIII (2008)

Same day, other years

1877

Crazy Horse is bayoneted at Fort Robinson

Camp Robinson, Nebraska, United StatesThe Americas

Four months after he led some 900 hungry Oglala Lakota in to surrender, the war leader who had fought at the Rosebud and the Little Bighorn was living uneasily near the Red Cloud Agency. Rumours reached the army that he meant to break away or to kill General Crook, one of them resting on an interpreter’s rendering of a remark about the Nez Perce campaign. He was arrested and brought to Camp Robinson on 5 September. When he saw that he was being led into a guardhouse with barred cells he pulled back and drew a knife. An old comrade, Little Big Man, seized his arms, and a soldier of the guard drove a bayonet into his back. He died that night, aged about thirty-seven.

Seen from elsewhere. The army recorded an accident during a struggle. Lakota accounts gathered from witnesses over the next fifty years blame jealousy among rival leaders at the agencies and disagree about who was responsible, including about Little Big Man. Whether the interpreter mistranslated on purpose is unknown. His parents buried him in a place never disclosed, and no authenticated photograph of him exists.

1905

Russia and Japan make peace, and Tokyo riots

Kittery, Maine, and TokyoAsia

The treaty that ended the Russo-Japanese War was signed at the Portsmouth navy yard on the coast of New England, where President Theodore Roosevelt had brought the two sides together. Japan had sunk the Russian fleet and taken Port Arthur and Mukden, but was close to bankruptcy. Russia, shaken by revolution at home, conceded the lease of Port Arthur, the railway through southern Manchuria, the southern half of Sakhalin and a free hand for Japan in Korea, but refused to pay an indemnity. In Tokyo, where the public had been told only of victories, a protest rally in Hibiya Park on the same day turned into three days of rioting. Seventeen people were killed and martial law was declared.

Seen from elsewhere. The lands disposed of were Chinese and Korean, and neither country was at the table. Korea’s emperor appealed to Washington under an 1882 treaty of friendship and was ignored; Japan imposed a protectorate that November and annexed the country in 1910. Roosevelt received the Nobel Peace Prize. Across Asia the war was read as proof that a European empire could be beaten.

1960

Congo’s president dismisses Patrice Lumumba

Leopoldville (Kinshasa), CongoAfrica

Sixty-seven days after independence from Belgium, with the army in mutiny, Belgian troops back in the country and the mineral province of Katanga in secession, President Joseph Kasavubu went on the radio in the evening and announced that he had removed the prime minister. Patrice Lumumba reached the same microphone within the hour and announced that he had removed the president. Parliament backed Lumumba. United Nations officials then closed the radio station and the airports, which hurt Lumumba more than his rival. On 14 September the army chief of staff, Joseph Mobutu, set both men aside. Lumumba was put under guard, escaped, was caught, and was shot in Katanga in January 1961.

Seen from elsewhere. Kasavubu and Western governments cited Lumumba’s request for Soviet aircraft and the killing of civilians by his troops in Kasai. His supporters saw the elected leader of a new state removed with foreign help. A United States Senate inquiry in 1975 documented a CIA plan to poison him, and a Belgian parliamentary commission in 2001 found that Belgium bore moral responsibility for his death.

1972

Hostages are taken at the Munich Olympics

Munich, West GermanyEurope

At about half past four in the morning, eight members of the Palestinian group Black September climbed the fence of the Olympic Village and forced their way into the Israeli team’s apartments at 31 Connollystrasse. They killed the wrestling coach Moshe Weinberg and the weightlifter Yossef Romano and held nine other athletes and officials, demanding the release of more than 200 prisoners held by Israel. The Games continued for most of the day. Late that night the West German police attempted an ambush at the Furstenfeldbruck airfield with too few marksmen and no radios. All nine hostages, a policeman and five of the attackers died. After a one-day pause the Games resumed.

Seen from elsewhere. Black September said it had acted to force the world to notice Palestinian prisoners and refugees. Israel bombed bases in Syria and Lebanon within days, killing many, and began a campaign of assassinations that included an innocent waiter in Norway. The three surviving attackers were freed after a hijacking weeks later. The victims’ families reached a compensation agreement with Germany only in 2022.

Also on 5 September