Parallax

24 September, 1435

Isabeau of Bavaria dies in an occupied Paris

The widow of a mad king died almost forgotten in a city held by the English. Within a few generations she had become the queen who sold France, a reputation that modern historians have largely taken apart.

Hotel Saint-Pol, Paris, France

She died in the rambling royal residence of Saint-Pol on the right bank of the Seine, aged about sixty-five, having outlived her husband by thirteen years and eight of her twelve children. Paris in September 1435 was governed for the boy king Henry VI of England, her grandson. Her one surviving son, whom she had not seen for seventeen years, was king of France at Bourges and at war with the city she lived in. Three days before her death the Duke of Burgundy made his peace with that son at Arras. Whether she was told is not recorded.

Her funeral says a good deal about her position. The body was put on a boat and taken down the Seine to the royal abbey of Saint-Denis with only a handful of attendants, because the country outside the walls was not safe for a procession. She was laid beside Charles VI. The marble effigy made for her is still there.

She had come to France from Bavaria in 1385, a girl of about fourteen named Elisabeth, and married the sixteen-year-old Charles three days after he first saw her. For seven years it was a brilliant court. Then, in August 1392, riding through the forest near Le Mans, the king suddenly attacked his own escort and killed four men. For the rest of his life he passed in and out of insanity, forty-odd attacks in thirty years. At times he believed he was made of glass. At times he did not know her, or ran from her, or struck her.

During his absences someone had to hold the government, and Charles in his lucid intervals named his wife to preside over the council and arbitrate between his relatives. This placed a foreign-born queen with no army between the king’s brother Louis of Orleans and the dukes of Burgundy, who were competing for the treasury. She leaned towards Orleans until the Duke of Burgundy had him murdered in a Paris street in 1407, and after that the quarrel was a civil war. In 1417 the Orleanist party, then in control of the king and of her son the Dauphin, seized her treasure and sent her under guard to Tours. Burgundy freed her, and she set up a rival government in his camp.

Two years later the Dauphin’s men cut down the Duke of Burgundy at a parley on the bridge of Montereau. His heir allied with Henry V of England, whose armies already held Normandy. On 21 May 1420, at Troyes, Isabeau and the Burgundians put their seals, with the helpless king’s, to a treaty that married her daughter Catherine to Henry and made him heir to France.

How it came to this

The Treaty of Troyes is the centre of the case against her. It set aside her own son, the future Charles VII, and handed the succession to a conqueror. But the document gives its reason plainly: the ‘so-called Dauphin’ was excluded for his ‘horrible and enormous crimes’, meaning the murder at Montereau. It says nothing about his birth. The story that Isabeau declared him a bastard, and the linked story that she had been the lover of her brother-in-law Orleans, cannot be found in any source from the years when it is supposed to have happened.

Contemporary criticism of her was of a different kind. In 1405 an Augustinian friar preached before her against the extravagance of the court, and the monk of Saint-Denis who kept the official chronicle reported complaints that she and Orleans raised taxes and neglected the royal children. Burgundian pamphlets attacked her handling of money. The charge of adultery appears in writing only from the 1420s, in the propaganda of the Anglo-Burgundian side, where it served to explain why Henry VI and not Charles was the rightful king.

How each side saw it

The party of Charles VII

For those who fought for the disinherited prince, Troyes was the ‘shameful treaty’ and the queen a mother who had signed away her child. A saying went round, later attached to Joan of Arc, that France had been lost by a woman and would be saved by a maid. Yet Charles VII never condemned his mother in any public act, and when he recovered Paris in 1436 her tomb was left in honour. The darkest version of her belongs to later centuries, above all to nineteenth-century patriots such as Michelet, for whom she made a foreign foil to Joan.

A Parisian diarist

The anonymous clerk known as the Bourgeois of Paris, who favoured the Burgundians, mentions the old queen rarely and without malice. He notes that she was kept short of money by the English regency and lived shut away in Saint-Pol. In December 1431, when the ten-year-old Henry VI rode into Paris to be crowned king of France, the procession passed her window; the boy took off his hood to her, she bowed, and turned aside in tears. He records her death in a few lines, mainly to remark how meanly a queen of France was carried to her grave.

Modern historians

Since the 1980s R. C. Famiglietti, Rachel Gibbons and Tracy Adams have gone back to the household accounts, letters and ordinances. They describe a queen who was given authority by her husband, used it to mediate between armed princes for fifteen years with some success, and failed when mediation became impossible. Gibbons called her a historical villainess created after the fact. Adams argues that the legend of the greedy, lustful foreigner follows a standard pattern for attacking women who govern. Not everyone goes so far: Jonathan Sumption still finds her self-interested and politically shallow.

What is disputed

Her adultery with Louis of Orleans is unproven and now widely doubted; the child born in 1407, sometimes named as its fruit, died within hours, and the future Charles VII was born in 1403 during a period when the king was well. Whether she ever questioned her son’s legitimacy is equally unsupported, though Charles himself is said to have feared it. Stories that she abandoned the mad king are contradicted by the births of children into the 1400s, but she did live apart from him later, and a mistress, Odette de Champdivers, was provided. How much freedom she had at Troyes, in a town full of Burgundian and English soldiers, is an open question.

What followed

The settlement she sealed lasted on paper for fifteen years. Henry V and Charles VI both died in 1422, leaving an infant as king of two realms. Joan of Arc took Charles VII to his coronation in 1429, the peace of Arras detached Burgundy from England in the week Isabeau died, and Paris opened its gates to him in April 1436. Through her daughter Catherine, who later married Owen Tudor, Isabeau was an ancestor of the Tudor kings of England. The Marquis de Sade wrote a lurid ‘secret history’ of her in 1813, and it has taken two centuries to dislodge.

Read further

  • Tracy Adams, The Life and Afterlife of Isabeau of Bavaria (2010)
  • Rachel Gibbons, ‘Isabeau of Bavaria, Queen of France (1385-1422): The Creation of an Historical Villainess’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society (1996)
  • R. C. Famiglietti, Royal Intrigue: Crisis at the Court of Charles VI, 1392-1420 (1986)
  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume 4: Cursed Kings (2015)
  • A Parisian Journal, 1405-1449, translated by Janet Shirley (1968)

Same day, other years

1841

An English adventurer is made Rajah of Sarawak

Kuching, Sarawak, BorneoAsia

James Brooke, a former East India Company officer who had spent his inheritance on an armed schooner, arrived on the north-west coast of Borneo in 1839 to find the Sultan of Brunei’s governor facing a rebellion by local Malays and Dayaks. Brooke lent his guns to the sultan’s uncle, Raja Muda Hashim, helped end the rising, and pressed for the reward he had been promised. On 24 September 1841 Hashim invested him as governor, with the title of rajah, of a territory about the size of Yorkshire. The sultan confirmed it the next year. Brooke’s family ruled Sarawak as a private kingdom, enlarging it at Brunei’s expense, until the third rajah ceded it to Britain in 1946.

Seen from elsewhere. Brooke justified his rule as the suppression of piracy and head-hunting. In 1849 his force and Royal Navy ships killed several hundred Iban at Beting Maru; radical MPs in London called it a massacre, and an inquiry at Singapore cleared him. Brunei saw a guest who took a province. Many Sarawak Malays opposed the 1946 cession, and the second British governor was assassinated.

1877

Saigo Takamori’s last stand at Shiroyama

Kagoshima, JapanAsia

Saigo had been a principal leader of the revolution that restored the emperor in 1868, and then left the government it created. In early 1877 the former samurai of his home province, Satsuma, rose against Tokyo with him at their head. They failed to take Kumamoto castle and were hunted across Kyushu for seven months. By September a few hundred survivors were dug in on a hill above Kagoshima, ringed by some 30,000 imperial troops, conscripts with rifles and artillery. The assault began before dawn. Saigo was hit in the hip and thigh, and by the accepted account knelt facing the imperial palace while a follower, Beppu Shinsuke, struck off his head. The rest charged with swords and were shot down.

Seen from elsewhere. The government named him a traitor, then pardoned him in 1889 and put up his statue in Tokyo, and he became a model of selfless loyalty. The rebels fought to keep hereditary privileges that the new state had abolished. Saigo had resigned in 1873 after his colleagues rejected a plan for war with Korea, which complicates the gentle image.

1957

Eisenhower sends paratroops to a high school

Little Rock, Arkansas, United StatesThe Americas

Three years after the Supreme Court ruled segregated schools unconstitutional, nine Black teenagers were enrolled at Central High School in Little Rock under a federal court order. The governor, Orval Faubus, used the state’s National Guard to keep them out. When the Guard was withdrawn and the nine entered on 23 September, a crowd of more than a thousand gathered and police removed them for their safety. The next day President Eisenhower placed the Arkansas Guard under federal command, ordered in about a thousand men of the 101st Airborne Division and explained on television that mob rule could not be allowed to override the courts. On the 25th the students walked in between soldiers with fixed bayonets.

Seen from elsewhere. Faubus told Arkansans they were occupied territory, and Senator Richard Russell compared the troops to Hitler’s storm troopers. A year later Faubus closed all the city’s high schools sooner than integrate them, and voters backed him. The nine endured a year of daily abuse inside the building. Eisenhower never said he agreed with the court’s ruling, only that it must be obeyed.

1973

Guinea-Bissau declares itself independent in the bush

Madina do Boe, Guinea-BissauAfrica

A national assembly elected in the areas held by the liberation movement PAIGC met in the forest of the south-east, within range of Portuguese aircraft, and proclaimed the Republic of Guinea-Bissau. The movement had been fighting Portuguese rule since 1963 and controlled much of the countryside; that year it had acquired shoulder-fired missiles that ended Portugal’s command of the air. Its founder, the agronomist Amilcar Cabral, had planned the declaration but was shot dead in Conakry in January. His half-brother Luis became president. Within weeks more than seventy states had recognised the new republic. Portugal did so a year later, after officers who had served in Guinea overthrew the dictatorship in Lisbon.

Seen from elsewhere. Lisbon called it a fiction proclaimed in territory it still administered, and held the towns until 1974. Thousands of Africans had fought in Portuguese units; after independence many were executed without trial, as mass graves later confirmed. Resentment of the Cape Verdean-born leadership fed the coup that removed Luis Cabral in 1980.

Also on 24 September