The cabinet was called for noon on Monday 22 September 1862. Abraham Lincoln opened by reading aloud a comic sketch by the humorist Artemus Ward about a showman whose waxwork of Judas is attacked by an indignant citizen of Utica. Most of the room laughed. The Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton, did not. Then Lincoln put the book down and, as the Treasury Secretary Salmon Chase recorded in his diary that night, took a graver tone.
He reminded them of the paper he had shown them on 22 July, which he had set aside on the advice of William Seward, the Secretary of State, that to free slaves in the middle of a string of defeats would look like a government’s last shriek on the retreat. Since then things had gone worse: a second defeat at Bull Run, and Robert E. Lee’s army across the Potomac into Maryland. When the rebels were at Frederick, Lincoln said, he had determined that if they were driven out he would issue the proclamation. He had said nothing to anyone, but he had made the promise to himself and, with some hesitation, to his Maker. The navy secretary, Gideon Welles, wrote down the same words.
On 17 September the two armies had met at Antietam Creek and left some 23,000 men dead, wounded or missing in a day. It was not the victory Lincoln wanted, and George McClellan let Lee get away, but Lee had gone back to Virginia. Lincoln told the cabinet he was not asking their advice on the main point. That was settled. He would hear suggestions on the wording.
The text he read was dry and legal. It restated that the war was for the Union. It promised to ask Congress again for money to compensate any loyal state that freed its slaves, and to pursue the voluntary settlement of freed people abroad. Then came the sentence that mattered: on the first day of January 1863, all persons held as slaves within any state, or part of a state, then in rebellion against the United States ‘shall be then, thenceforward, and forever free’. The armed forces would recognise and maintain that freedom. A state that returned to the Union before the date would be exempt.
Seward suggested small changes. The Postmaster General, Montgomery Blair, said he agreed with the principle but feared the effect on the border states and the autumn elections. Lincoln signed that afternoon, the State Department sealed it, and the newspapers printed it on the 23rd. Serenaders came to the White House the next evening. He told them he could only trust in God that he had made no mistake.
How it came to this
When the war began in April 1861 Lincoln insisted that its purpose was to restore the Union, not to interfere with slavery where it existed. He believed he had no constitutional power to do more, and he could not afford to lose Kentucky, Maryland, Missouri and Delaware, slave states that had stayed loyal. He revoked emancipation orders issued by two of his own generals. As late as August 1862 he wrote to the editor Horace Greeley that if he could save the Union without freeing any slave he would do it, and if he could save it by freeing all he would do that.
Events on the ground moved faster. From the first weeks, enslaved people walked into Union lines, and commanders, beginning with Benjamin Butler at Fort Monroe, declined to send them back, calling them contraband of war. Congress ended slavery in Washington in April 1862 and in July authorised the seizure of rebels’ slaves. The border states rejected every offer of gradual, paid emancipation Lincoln made. His authority to act now rested on his powers as commander in chief: slave labour sustained the enemy’s armies.