Parallax

13 September, 1759

A quarter of an hour on the Plains of Abraham

After a summer of failure a sick young general put his army up a cliff path in the dark. The battle next morning lasted about fifteen minutes, killed both commanders, and is still argued over in Canada.

Quebec, New France

Major General James Wolfe was thirty-two, thin, red-haired and in poor health when he arrived before Quebec in late June 1759 with about 9,000 soldiers and a quarter of the Royal Navy. The capital of New France stood on a rock above the St Lawrence, and its commander, the Marquis de Montcalm, had entrenched some 15,000 regulars, militia and Indigenous allies along the shore below the town. All Montcalm had to do was hold on until the river began to freeze and the British fleet had to leave.

For ten weeks Wolfe got nowhere. A frontal attack near the Montmorency falls on 31 July cost him over four hundred men. He shelled the town into ruins from across the river and sent rangers and light infantry to burn the farms and villages along both banks, well over a thousand buildings by the end. In August he was confined to bed with fever and what he took for kidney stones, and wrote home that he had no hope of success. His three brigadiers, who disliked him, proposed moving the army upriver to cut the French supply line. Wolfe accepted the idea and then chose his own landing place: a small cove, the Anse au Foulon, less than two miles from the walls, where a track climbed a cliff about 175 feet high.

In the early hours of 13 September the boats drifted down on the ebb tide. French sentries on the shore had been told to expect a supply convoy that night, and when one challenged, a French-speaking Highland officer answered well enough to pass. Light infantry under Colonel William Howe scrambled up the cliff face, scattered the picket at the top, and opened the path. By daylight some 4,500 British troops stood in line on the Plains of Abraham, a stretch of pasture named after an early settler, with their backs to the river.

Montcalm rode over from his lines east of the town and decided to attack at once, before the British could dig in and without waiting for a detached force of 3,000 picked men that was some hours’ march to the west. At about ten o’clock roughly the same number of French and Canadians advanced, cheering. Regulars and militia had been mixed in the ranks and the line lost its order; they fired at too long a range. The British, each musket loaded with two balls, held their fire until the distance was about forty yards. Two volleys and a bayonet charge broke the attack.

Wolfe, leading on the right, was hit in the wrist, the body and the chest and died on the field within minutes. Montcalm was shot through the body during the retreat and died in the town before dawn. Each side lost about 650 men. Canadian militia and Indigenous marksmen in the woods on the flanks covered the retreat and inflicted much of the British loss. Quebec surrendered five days later.

How it came to this

France and Britain had been fighting in North America since 1754, two years before their war began in Europe. The French colony along the St Lawrence had perhaps 70,000 settlers against more than a million in the British colonies to the south, and survived through its alliances with Indigenous nations and its hold on the rivers and lakes of the interior. In the first years it won most of the battles. Then William Pitt, directing the war in London, committed tens of thousands of regular troops and the navy to conquering Canada outright. Louisbourg, the fortress guarding the river mouth, fell in 1758, with Wolfe prominent in the siege.

New France was short of food and its leadership divided. The governor, the Marquis de Vaudreuil, was Canadian-born and believed in the raiding warfare the colony had always practised with its allies. Montcalm, a professional soldier from France, thought little of militia, less of the governor, and expected defeat. The harvests of 1757 and 1758 had failed, the British blockade let few ships through, and the townspeople of Quebec were on a ration of a few ounces of bread a day.

How each side saw it

French Canadians

In Quebec the events of 1759-60 are simply la Conquete. The habitants whose farms were burned left few written accounts; the siege is known from within through the journals of nuns, priests and townspeople. Historians of the mid-twentieth-century Montreal school, among them Guy Fregault and Maurice Seguin, argued that the Conquest cut a young society off from its elite and its metropolis and explains its later subordination. The Laval school replied that the Church, the land system and the language carried on much as before. A re-enactment planned for the 250th anniversary in 2009 was cancelled after protests.

Montcalm, Vaudreuil and the French command

Vaudreuil wrote to Versailles within days blaming Montcalm for attacking in haste, with half the available force, instead of waiting a few hours for the troops upriver. Montcalm’s own journal and those of his officers show a commander who had long predicted disaster and held the colonial government corrupt and its militia unreliable. French officers also criticised the mixing of militia into regular battalions, since men trained to fire from cover threw themselves down to reload and broke the line. France, for its part, valued its sugar islands above Canada and did not fight hard to get it back.

Indigenous nations

Well over a thousand warriors, Abenaki, Huron-Wendat, Odawa, Ojibwe and others, fought as allies of the French at Quebec, and none left a written account; their part is known through French officers’ journals and later diplomacy. They were not subjects of France and did not consider themselves conquered. The Huron-Wendat of Lorette obtained a safe conduct from General Murray in 1760 that the Supreme Court of Canada recognised as a treaty in 1990. When British commanders in the interior stopped the customary gifts and took posts without consent, the result was the war named after the Odawa leader Pontiac in 1763.

British officers and later historians

Wolfe died a national hero, fixed in memory by Benjamin West’s painting of 1770, in which almost none of the figures shown was actually present. His brigadiers were less impressed. George Townshend, who took over command, thought the plan reckless and resented the cult. The Canadian military historian C. P. Stacey judged in 1959 that Wolfe was a fine regimental officer and a poor strategist who was rescued by luck and by Montcalm’s mistake. Stephen Brumwell’s later biography is kinder, crediting him with picking the one point where surprise was possible.

What is disputed

Wolfe is said to have recited Gray’s ‘Elegy’ in the boats and declared he would sooner have written it than take Quebec. The tale comes from one man, told decades later; silence had been ordered on the river, and if it happened at all it was probably the day before. His dying words exist in several versions; the best known is in Captain John Knox’s journal. Who answered the sentry is not settled. Whether the landing was inspired or a desperate throw that should have failed is the oldest argument about the campaign, and the order to burn the parishes remains a charge against him.

What followed

The battle did not settle the war. In April 1760 the Chevalier de Levis beat the British garrison outside Quebec at Sainte-Foy and besieged the town; the first ships up the river in May were British, and that decided it. Montreal capitulated in September, and France ceded Canada in 1763. The cost of the war and of garrisoning the new territory led London to tax its American colonies, with consequences that arrived in 1775. The Quebec Act of 1774 guaranteed French civil law and the Catholic religion, the basis on which a French-speaking society has continued in North America.

Read further

  • C. P. Stacey, Quebec, 1759: The Siege and the Battle (1959)
  • Fred Anderson, Crucible of War: The Seven Years’ War and the Fate of Empire in British North America, 1754-1766 (2000)
  • Stephen Brumwell, Paths of Glory: The Life and Death of General James Wolfe (2006)
  • D. Peter MacLeod, Northern Armageddon: The Battle of the Plains of Abraham (2008)
  • John Knox, An Historical Journal of the Campaigns in North America (1769)

Same day, other years

1847

The storming of Chapultepec

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

United States troops under Winfield Scott assaulted the castle of Chapultepec, on a rocky hill guarding the western approach to Mexico City. The building housed the military academy, and several dozen cadets, some as young as thirteen, had stayed with the garrison of under a thousand. After a day’s bombardment the attackers went up the slopes with scaling ladders and took the castle in about two hours. Six cadets died and are honoured in Mexico as the Boy Heroes. The capital fell the next day. By the treaty that ended the war in 1848 Mexico lost about half its territory, from Texas to California.

Seen from elsewhere. The story that the cadet Juan Escutia wrapped himself in the flag and leapt from the ramparts appears only later, and historians doubt it, as they doubt the remains identified as the cadets’ in 1947. On the American side Ulysses Grant, who fought there, later called the war one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger nation against a weaker.

1948

India invades Hyderabad

Hyderabad State, IndiaAsia

Hyderabad was the largest of the princely states, the size of a European country, with a Muslim ruler, the Nizam, and some sixteen million mostly Hindu subjects. When British rule ended in 1947 the Nizam declined to join India and sought independence. A year of failed talks followed, during which an armed Muslim militia, the Razakars, terrorised opponents and a communist peasant rising spread in the Telangana countryside. On 13 September the Indian army entered from several directions in what Delhi called a police action. The state’s forces surrendered within five days and Hyderabad was absorbed into India.

Seen from elsewhere. A team sent by Nehru under Pandit Sunderlal reported that between 27,000 and 40,000 people, overwhelmingly Muslims, were killed in reprisals during and after the operation, some with the participation of soldiers and police. The report was withheld from the public until 2013. Supporters of the action point to Razakar killings of Hindus beforehand; the anniversary is still marked both as liberation and as mourning.

1971

Lin Biao dies in a plane crash

Ondorkhaan, MongoliaAsia

A Chinese air force Trident jet came down on the Mongolian steppe in the small hours, killing all nine people on board. Among them were Marshal Lin Biao, China’s defence minister and the man named in the Communist Party’s constitution as Mao Zedong’s successor, his wife Ye Qun and their son Lin Liguo. The Chinese public was told nothing for months. The official account, when it came, said that Lin had plotted to assassinate Mao, had been discovered, and was fleeing to the Soviet Union when the aircraft ran out of fuel. For many Chinese the news destroyed what faith remained in the Cultural Revolution.

Seen from elsewhere. Much of that account is doubted. Frederick Teiwes and Warren Sun, and Jin Qiu, whose father was a general purged in the affair, portray a sick and passive man drawn along by his wife and son, and question whether he boarded willingly. The relevant Chinese archives remain closed, and the crash itself has never been independently explained.

1993

The handshake on the White House lawn

Washington, DC, United StatesMiddle East

Israel’s prime minister, Yitzhak Rabin, and the chairman of the Palestine Liberation Organisation, Yasser Arafat, shook hands in front of President Bill Clinton after their deputies signed a Declaration of Principles. The text had been negotiated in secret in Norway. Israel recognised the PLO as the representative of the Palestinians; the PLO recognised Israel’s right to exist and renounced violence. A Palestinian authority was to govern parts of the West Bank and Gaza for five years while the hardest questions, Jerusalem, refugees, settlements and borders, were settled. They never were. Rabin was shot dead by an Israeli opponent of the agreement in 1995.

Seen from elsewhere. Edward Said called the accord a Palestinian Versailles that conceded recognition in return for no promise of a state or a halt to settlement. Hamas rejected it and turned to suicide bombings. The Israeli right argued that it handed territory and weapons to an enemy. The settler population of the West Bank is now several times what it was in 1993.

Also on 13 September