Parallax

8 September, 1935

Huey Long is shot in the capitol he built

The senator who ran Louisiana like a private estate and meant to take the White House from Franklin Roosevelt met a young doctor in a marble corridor. One shot, then sixty, and an argument about what happened that has never quite closed.

Baton Rouge, Louisiana, United States

On the evening of Sunday 8 September 1935, Huey Long was on the floor of the Louisiana House of Representatives, where he had no right to be. He was a United States senator, not a member of the legislature. But he had called it into special session, the fourth that year, and he prowled the chamber telling members how to vote on dozens of bills he had written. The first of them redrew a judicial district so as to unseat Benjamin Pavy, a judge who had opposed him for years.

At about twenty past nine he left the chamber and walked quickly down the main corridor towards the governor’s office, his bodyguards hurrying behind as usual. The building was his own monument, a thirty-four-storey tower he had put up in a little over a year. Near a pillar stood a slight man in a white linen suit and spectacles: Carl Austin Weiss, twenty-eight, an ear, nose and throat specialist, and Judge Pavy’s son-in-law. He had spent the day at church, at a family lunch and by the river with his wife and their baby, and had left home saying he had a call to make.

By the bodyguards’ testimony, Weiss stepped forward, raised a small automatic pistol and fired once into Long’s body. One guard grappled with him. The others emptied their weapons into him. The coroner found some sixty bullet wounds. Long, clutching his side, ran down a flight of stairs and was driven to a hospital nearby, telling the man who helped him only that he had been shot.

The bullet had passed through his abdomen. The surgeon on hand, Arthur Vidrine, a political appointee of Long’s, operated that night and repaired the intestine but, it is generally thought, missed a wound to the kidney. Long bled internally through the following day while politicians crowded the corridors. He died a little after four in the morning on 10 September, aged forty-two. The last words attributed to him are ‘God, don’t let me die. I have so much to do’, though the accounts of the bedside differ.

He was buried in the capitol grounds in front of a crowd put at well over 100,000, many of them farmers who had come in from the parishes by truck. Weiss was buried the same week, after a funeral that drew a large and respectable attendance of its own. He had said nothing to anyone about what he intended, and left no explanation.

How it came to this

Long had risen from the poor hill country of north Louisiana to the governorship in 1928 on a promise to break the hold of the planters, the New Orleans machine and Standard Oil. He delivered free schoolbooks, thousands of miles of paved road, bridges, a state university and charity hospitals, and abolished the poll tax. He also took control of the legislature, the courts, the election machinery and the state police, financed his organisation by deductions from public employees’ salaries, and survived impeachment in 1929 by getting enough senators to sign a pledge in advance. After moving to the Senate in 1932 he continued to govern the state through a compliant successor.

Nationally he had broken with Roosevelt and launched the Share Our Wealth movement, which proposed to cap private fortunes and guarantee every family a home and a minimum income. Its clubs claimed more than seven million members. A secret poll taken for the Democratic Party in 1935 suggested that as a third-party candidate he might draw several million votes. He had written a book about his first days in the White House.

How each side saw it

Long’s people

To the small farmers, sharecroppers and working people who voted for him, Long was the first governor who had given them anything. He had put their children in school with books, paved the roads to their towns and treated their sick. They called him the Kingfish with affection and saw his methods as the only ones that had ever worked against people who had always run the state for themselves. Many believed, and some still do, that he was killed by a conspiracy of the rich. His machine governed Louisiana for decades on his memory, and his brother and son both held high office.

The anti-Longs

His opponents, who included most of the press, the old political families and many reformers, regarded him as an American dictator. They pointed to laws that let him appoint every teacher, policeman and poll commissioner in the state, to troops sent into New Orleans, and to the use of the militia against an armed protest in Baton Rouge in January 1935. Some had talked openly of killing him, and Long had read out in the Senate what he said was a transcript of such a discussion at a New Orleans hotel. After his death a number of them called Weiss a martyr, quietly.

The Weiss family

Weiss’s widow, his parents and later his son, who was three months old at the time, never accepted the official account. They described a gentle, devout and successful young doctor with no interest in politics and everything to live for. In their view he went to remonstrate with Long, perhaps struck him, and was shot by the bodyguards, one of whose bullets hit the senator. They note that there was no autopsy on Long, no inquest worthy of the name, and that every witness was on Long’s payroll. Carl Weiss junior pressed for the case to be re-examined into the 1990s.

Washington and Black Louisiana

Roosevelt is reported by his adviser Rexford Tugwell to have called Long one of the two most dangerous men in the country, and his administration cut off federal patronage and set tax investigators on the Long organisation. Historians such as Alan Brinkley see Share Our Wealth as a pressure that pushed the New Deal leftwards in 1935. Black Louisianans, almost wholly barred from voting, benefited from the hospitals, the literacy classes and the end of the poll tax, and Long avoided the race-baiting common among his rivals. He did nothing to challenge segregation or disfranchisement, and said so.

What is disputed

Whether Weiss fired the fatal shot is the main question. T. Harry Williams, Long’s principal biographer, concluded that he did. The forensic scientist James Starrs exhumed Weiss’s body in 1991, and the pistol and police files, missing for decades, turned up in private hands; a Louisiana State Police review in 1992 reaffirmed the original finding, and doubters remained unconvinced. Motive is also unsettled. The Pavy gerrymander is the usual explanation, with a rumour that Long was about to repeat a racial slur against the Pavy family. Weiss had no known link to any plot. The number of wounds on his body is given variously, most often as 61.

What followed

The Share Our Wealth movement fell apart within months under lesser leaders, and Roosevelt was re-elected in 1936 by a landslide. In Louisiana the heirs to the machine made peace with Washington and were then brought down by corruption prosecutions in 1939. Politics in the state divided into Long and anti-Long factions for a generation. Long remains the standard American case in arguments about populism: a politician who delivered real benefits to poor people and dismantled the restraints on his own power to do it. Robert Penn Warren’s novel All the King’s Men is drawn from his career.

Read further

  • T. Harry Williams, Huey Long (1969)
  • Alan Brinkley, Voices of Protest: Huey Long, Father Coughlin, and the Great Depression (1982)
  • William Ivy Hair, The Kingfish and His Realm: The Life and Times of Huey P. Long (1991)
  • Richard D. White Jr., Kingfish: The Reign of Huey P. Long (2006)
  • Huey P. Long, Every Man a King (1933)

Same day, other years

1565

Spain founds St Augustine, then kills its French neighbours

St Augustine, FloridaThe Americas

Pedro Menendez de Aviles came ashore with banners, trumpets and about 800 soldiers and settlers at a Timucua village on the Atlantic coast of Florida, heard Mass, and claimed the land for Philip II. He named the place for the saint on whose feast he had first sighted the coast. It is the oldest continuously occupied town of European origin in the mainland United States. His orders were to remove a colony of French Protestants established the year before at Fort Caroline, forty miles north. Within two weeks he had marched overland in a storm and taken the fort. He then put to death some 250 or more shipwrecked Frenchmen who had surrendered to him on the beach at an inlet still called Matanzas, ‘slaughters’.

Seen from elsewhere. French survivors’ accounts describe men killed after giving themselves up; Menendez reported to his king that he had executed heretics and intruders on Spanish territory. A French expedition hanged a Spanish garrison in reprisal in 1568. The Timucua, perhaps 200,000 people at contact by some estimates, were destroyed as a people within two centuries by disease, forced labour and slave raids.

1941

The siege of Leningrad begins

Leningrad (St Petersburg), Soviet UnionEurope

German troops took the town of Shlisselburg on Lake Ladoga and cut the last land route into the Soviet Union’s second city, with Finnish forces closing the approaches from the north. About two and a half million civilians were inside. Hitler had decided not to storm Leningrad or accept its surrender but to starve it and level it by bombardment. Warehouses burned in an air raid that same day. By December the daily ration for most residents was 125 grams of adulterated bread. The only supply line was across the lake, by barge and then by lorry over the ice. The blockade was not fully lifted until 27 January 1944, after 872 days. At least 800,000 civilians died, most of hunger and cold in the first winter.

Seen from elsewhere. The Soviet account stressed heroic endurance, and a museum that recorded the horror in detail was shut down in 1949. Diaries published since show cannibalism, theft of ration cards and well-fed officials alongside real solidarity. Whether Stalin should have evacuated more people sooner is still a sensitive question in Russia. Finland maintains that its army halted at the old frontier; Russians count it among the besiegers.

1945

American troops land in Korea, south of a line drawn on a map

Incheon, KoreaAsia

Three weeks after Japan’s surrender ended thirty-five years of colonial rule, the first units of an American army corps under General John Hodge came ashore at Incheon to occupy Korea below the 38th parallel. Soviet forces had been in the north since August. The line had been chosen in Washington in about half an hour on the night of 10 August by two colonels, Dean Rusk and Charles Bonesteel, working from a small-scale map, and Moscow had accepted it without comment. Koreans who gathered to welcome the Americans at the port were fired on by Japanese police, who had been told to keep order. Hodge accepted the Japanese surrender in Seoul the next day, and at first left Japanese officials in their posts.

Seen from elsewhere. Two days before the landing, Korean nationalists in Seoul had proclaimed a People’s Republic resting on local committees across the country. The Americans, suspecting communist control, refused to recognise it; the Soviets worked through the committees in the north. No Korean was consulted about the division. Historians dispute how representative the republic was, and which occupier did more to make the partition permanent.

1978

Black Friday in Tehran

Jaleh Square, Tehran, IranMiddle East

After months of growing demonstrations against the Shah, the Iranian government declared martial law in Tehran and eleven other cities early on the morning of Friday 8 September. Many people did not hear the announcement. Several thousand gathered as planned in Jaleh Square in the east of the capital, and when they did not disperse, soldiers opened fire. The opposition said that thousands had been killed, and the figure of 4,000 was repeated abroad. Whatever the number, the day ended hopes of a negotiated settlement between the Shah and the moderate opposition. Strikes spread to the oil fields that autumn. The Shah left the country in January 1979, and Ayatollah Khomeini returned two weeks later.

Seen from elsewhere. The government announced 86 or 87 dead. After the revolution Emadeddin Baghi, a researcher with access to the Martyrs Foundation’s files, counted 64 killed in the square and 88 in the city that day, a finding unwelcome to the Islamic Republic, for which the massacre is a founding event. A rumour that the shooting was done by Israeli soldiers was widely believed at the time.

Also on 8 September