Parallax

3 September, 1886

Geronimo gives himself up at Skeleton Canyon

Five thousand soldiers had spent a summer failing to catch fewer than forty Apaches. In the end it took one lieutenant, two Apache scouts and a piece of news about their families.

Skeleton Canyon, Arizona Territory

In late August 1886 two Chiricahua Apache men, Kayitah and Martine, climbed towards a camp in the mountains above the Bavispe river in Sonora carrying a white flag made from a flour sack. They were scouts in the pay of the United States army and they had relatives in the camp. Its lookouts watched them come up for hours. Some of the men wanted to shoot them. Geronimo let them in, heard them out, and agreed to meet the officer who had sent them.

That officer was Lieutenant Charles Gatewood, who was ill, disliked his commanding general and was one of the few Americans the band trusted. He met them the next day beside the river, handed round tobacco, and delivered the message of General Nelson Miles: surrender, be sent to Florida with your families, and await the decision of the President. Geronimo asked for the reservation back instead. Then Gatewood told them something they had not known. The Chiricahuas who had stayed peacefully on the reservation in Arizona, their kin among them, were all being removed to Florida. There was nothing left to go back to.

The band talked through the night. Geronimo asked Gatewood what he would do in their place, and Gatewood said he would trust Miles. They agreed to travel north and give themselves up to the general in person, keeping their weapons until then. It was a nervous journey of several days, with an American cavalry troop riding alongside and a Mexican force at one point demanding to take the Apaches over.

Miles reached the meeting place, Skeleton Canyon in the Peloncillo Mountains just inside Arizona, on the afternoon of 3 September. Geronimo rode down from his camp in the rocks, shook his hand and, through two interpreters, heard the terms. He agreed that day. Naiche, son of Cochise and the band’s hereditary chief, was away in the hills, grieving for a brother he feared had been killed, and came in the next morning, when the surrender was made formal. Geronimo later said they had placed a stone on a blanket and sworn an oath to last until the stone crumbled to dust.

There were between thirty and forty of them, fewer than half of them fighting men. Miles took the leaders ahead to Fort Bowie. On 8 September the band was put on a train at Bowie Station while the regimental band of the Fourth Cavalry, by several accounts, played ‘Auld Lang Syne’. Kayitah and Martine, who had brought them in, were put on the train as prisoners with them.

How it came to this

The Chiricahuas were a few thousand people at most, living in the mountains on both sides of what became the border between the United States and Mexico. They had been at war with Mexicans for generations, raiding for livestock and captives and being hunted for scalp bounties in return. Geronimo, born in the 1820s and called Goyahkla, was not a chief but a war leader and a man credited with spiritual power. He dated his own hatred to a day in the 1850s when Mexican troops attacked a camp near Janos and killed his mother, his wife and his three children.

After the United States took the region, the Chiricahuas were promised a reservation in their own country, then moved in 1876 to San Carlos, a hot river flat they shared with other Apache groups. Geronimo left it and came back several times. His last breakout, in May 1885, took about 140 people into Mexico. General George Crook talked most of them into surrendering in March 1886, but Geronimo and Naiche bolted after a night of drinking, Crook resigned, and Miles replaced him with a quarter of the entire army.

How each side saw it

Geronimo

In the account he dictated in 1905 to S. M. Barrett, through the interpreter Asa Daklugie, Geronimo said Miles promised that he would be with his family within five days, that his past deeds would be wiped out, and that he would have land, houses and stock. He was instead held at hard labour at Fort Pickens, apart from his family, for months. ‘I looked in vain for General Miles to send me to that land of which he had spoken,’ he said. He told the same story for the rest of his life, and according to Daklugie died regretting that he had not fought on.

The Chiricahuas who had kept the peace

About three-quarters of the Chiricahuas had never left the reservation, and many of their men had served as army scouts against Geronimo. All of them, close to 500 people, were shipped to Florida as prisoners of war. Their accounts survive in Jason Betzinez’s memoir and in the testimony Eve Ball collected at Mescalero from the 1940s. They are bitter about the government’s betrayal of the scouts, and many are bitter about Geronimo too, whom they blamed for bringing ruin on a people most of whom had wanted quiet. Naiche’s descendants and others defended him as the last man to refuse confinement.

Arizona, New Mexico and northern Mexico

For settlers, miners and ranchers on both sides of the line, and for the O’odham and Mexican villagers who had been raided for far longer, Geronimo was a killer. The band’s last sixteen months cost dozens of civilian lives in the United States and probably more in Sonora and Chihuahua, where records are thinner. Arizona newspapers demanded that the leaders be handed to the civil courts and hanged, and President Cleveland initially wanted the same. The Mexican state governments, which still paid for Apache scalps, regarded the American reservations as a sanctuary from which raiders came and went.

The army, divided

Crook believed that only Apaches could catch Apaches and that promises made to them had to be kept. Miles relied publicly on regular troops and a chain of heliograph stations, and gave Gatewood little credit. What exactly Miles promised at Skeleton Canyon was investigated by the War Department within weeks, because Washington had ordered unconditional surrender and the prisoners plainly believed they had terms. Crook spent the last years of his life campaigning to have the Chiricahuas, and especially the scouts, moved somewhere they could survive. Gatewood was passed over for promotion and died in 1896.

What is disputed

The book places the surrender on 3 September, the day Miles arrived and Geronimo agreed. Most reference works give 4 September, when Naiche came in and the surrender was formally completed, so the event sits across two days. The terms are the larger argument: Miles’s reports, Gatewood’s account and Geronimo’s memory do not agree on what was promised, and historians such as Angie Debo and Robert Utley conclude that Miles said more than he was authorised to. Geronimo’s birth year (1823 or 1829) and the date of the Janos killings (1851 or 1858) are also uncertain.

What followed

The Chiricahuas were held as prisoners of war for twenty-seven years, in Florida, then Alabama, then at Fort Sill in Oklahoma. Roughly a quarter died within the first few years, mostly of tuberculosis, and many children were sent to the Carlisle school in Pennsylvania. Geronimo became a paid attraction at fairs, rode in Theodore Roosevelt’s inaugural parade in 1905, and died at Fort Sill in 1909, still a prisoner. The survivors were released in 1913. About two-thirds chose to join the Mescalero Apaches in New Mexico; the rest stayed in Oklahoma. None were allowed back to Arizona.

Read further

  • Geronimo, Geronimo’s Story of His Life, taken down and edited by S. M. Barrett (1906)
  • Angie Debo, Geronimo: The Man, His Time, His Place (1976)
  • Robert M. Utley, Geronimo (2012)
  • Eve Ball, Indeh: An Apache Odyssey (1980)
  • Jason Betzinez with Wilbur Sturtevant Nye, I Fought with Geronimo (1959)

Same day, other years

1189

A coronation ends in the killing of London’s Jews

Westminster and London, EnglandEurope

Richard I was crowned at Westminster Abbey in a ceremony described in more detail than any earlier English coronation. Women and Jews had been forbidden to attend. When leaders of England’s Jewish communities arrived at the banquet with gifts for the new king, they were beaten and thrown out by the crowd at the door. A rumour ran into the city that the king had ordered the Jews destroyed. Mobs attacked the Jewry, set fire to houses whose stone walls they could not break, and killed about thirty people, among them the scholar Rabbi Jacob of Orleans. Benedict of York was baptised by force and recanted the next day before the king.

Seen from elsewhere. The chronicler William of Newburgh condemns the rioters while sharing their dislike of their victims. Richard hanged three men, for offences against Christian property, and issued writs of protection. Ephraim of Bonn’s Hebrew memorial records the dead as martyrs. Once the king left for the crusade, attacks spread to Lynn, Stamford and Norwich and ended at York in March 1190.

1260

The Mamluks stop the Mongols at Ain Jalut

Ain Jalut, Jezreel Valley, PalestineMiddle East

Two years after the Mongols sacked Baghdad and killed the caliph, a Mongol army in Syria met the forces of the Mamluk sultan of Egypt, Qutuz, at the Spring of Goliath in Galilee. The Mongol commander Kitbuqa, a Christian of the Naiman people, had perhaps 10,000 to 20,000 men, because the main army had withdrawn east with Hulegu after the death of the Great Khan. The Mamluk vanguard under Baybars drew the Mongols forward with a feigned retreat, and the main force closed in from the hills. Kitbuqa was captured and killed. Within weeks the Mongols had lost Damascus and Aleppo. Qutuz was murdered on the road home, and Baybars took the throne.

Seen from elsewhere. The Persian historian Rashid al-Din, writing for Hulegu’s descendants, treats the defeat as that of a detachment and gives Kitbuqa a defiant speech before his death. Modern historians differ over whether the battle halted the Mongols or merely confirmed that Syria’s pastures could not feed a full Mongol army for long.

1838

Frederick Douglass boards a train north

Baltimore, Maryland, United StatesThe Americas

A twenty-year-old ship’s caulker, enslaved in Baltimore and hired out for wages he had to hand to his owner, jumped onto a northbound train at the last moment so that nobody would inspect him at the ticket window. He wore a sailor’s red shirt and tarpaulin hat and carried a free seaman’s protection papers, borrowed, describing a man who looked little like him. The conductor glanced at the eagle on the document and moved on. By train, ferry and steamboat he reached New York the following morning. Within days he had married Anna Murray and taken a new surname. He became the most celebrated American orator of his century.

Seen from elsewhere. Anna Murray, a free Black woman, paid for the journey from her savings and made the disguise. She could barely write and left no account; her part is known chiefly from their daughter Rosetta. In law Douglass remained another man’s property until British admirers bought his freedom in 1846, a purchase some abolitionists condemned as conceding that a person could be owned.

1879

The British mission in Kabul is wiped out

Kabul, AfghanistanAsia

Sir Louis Cavagnari had arrived in Kabul six weeks earlier as resident, under a treaty that the first phase of the Second Anglo-Afghan War had forced on the amir, Yaqub Khan, and which gave Britain control of Afghanistan’s foreign relations. On 3 September Afghan regiments newly arrived from Herat, who had been given a fraction of their arrears of pay, marched on the residency in the Bala Hissar citadel to demand the rest. Shots were fired and a day-long assault followed. Cavagnari, his three British companions and nearly all of his escort of about seventy-five Indian soldiers of the Corps of Guides were killed. A British army under Frederick Roberts occupied Kabul in October.

Seen from elsewhere. Yaqub Khan said he had been powerless to restrain his troops, and abdicated. To many Afghans a foreign envoy in the citadel was the proof of lost independence. Roberts set up military commissions that hanged close to a hundred Afghans, some for the attack and some simply for resisting his advance, which was denounced in Britain at the time.

Also on 3 September