Parallax

25 September, 1396

The knights who charged uphill at Nicopolis

The largest crusading army Latin Europe sent east in a century met the Ottoman sultan on the Danube, and its proudest contingent lost the battle by insisting on going first.

Nicopolis (Nikopol), on the Danube, Bulgaria

By the second week of September 1396 the crusaders had been sitting outside Nicopolis for about a fortnight. They had come down the Danube from Buda in high spirits, taken Vidin without a fight and stormed Rahovo, where they killed much of the population. But at Nicopolis, a walled town on a bluff above the river, they found that nobody had brought siege engines. Ladders were made, mines were started, and the knights passed the time in feasting while the Ottoman commander, Dogan Bey, waited for relief.

It came faster than anyone in the camp believed possible. Sultan Bayezid, called Yildirim, the Thunderbolt, broke off his blockade of Constantinople and marched north with his household troops, his provincial cavalry and a contingent of heavy horse under his Serbian vassal Stefan Lazarevic. When scouts reported him close, the crusaders killed the prisoners they had taken at Rahovo, a fact recorded by their own chroniclers, and drew up for battle.

Then came the argument that decided the day. Sigismund, King of Hungary, who knew the Ottomans, wanted his Wallachian and Hungarian foot to go forward first and absorb the light troops that the sultan always put in front. The French refused. John of Nevers, the twenty-four-year-old son of the Duke of Burgundy, nominally led them, but the real voices were the Constable, Philip of Artois, Count of Eu, and Marshal Boucicaut, who held that to follow peasants into battle would shame them. Older men, Enguerrand de Coucy and the Admiral Jean de Vienne, urged caution and were overruled.

On the morning of 25 September the French and Burgundian knights charged up the slope. They scattered the light horsemen, rode into a belt of sharpened stakes, dismounted and pushed on through the Ottoman infantry on foot, in heavy armour, uphill. When they reached the crest, exhausted, they found the sultan’s sipahi cavalry fresh and waiting. Jean de Vienne died holding the banner. Most of the rest were killed or taken.

Sigismund’s army behind them came up too late and in disorder, and Lazarevic’s Serbs struck it in the flank. The Wallachians and Transylvanians on the wings withdrew. Sigismund reached the river and escaped on a Venetian galley, going home the long way round by the Black Sea, Constantinople and the Adriatic.

The next day Bayezid, who had lost many men, had the prisoners brought before him. Some of the greatest lords were set aside for ransom. Several thousand of the others were beheaded over the course of the day. A Bavarian squire of about sixteen, Johann Schiltberger, was spared for his youth, spent more than thirty years as a captive in the Ottoman and then the Timurid world, and lived to write down what he had seen.

How it came to this

In 1396 the Ottomans were a Balkan power as much as an Anatolian one. They had crossed into Europe in the 1350s, defeated the Serbs at Kosovo in 1389 and taken the Bulgarian capital, Tarnovo, in 1393. The last tsar at Tarnovo, Ivan Shishman, died in 1395, probably executed. Hungary now bordered the sultan directly, and Sigismund spent two years asking the courts of the West for help.

He found a willing audience. The Hundred Years War was in a truce, Burgundy wanted prestige, and the papacy, split between Rome and Avignon, saw a crusade as something both popes could bless. The French and Burgundian knights who answered were the flower of a chivalric culture that prized individual prowess and the honour of the first blow. They joined German, English, Bohemian and other knights, the Hospitallers of Rhodes and a Venetian fleet on the Danube. Their stated aim was to clear the Balkans and, in the most ambitious version, to march on to Jerusalem.

How each side saw it

French chroniclers and moralists

Jean Froissart and the anonymous Monk of Saint-Denis wrote within a few years, from the accounts of survivors and ransomed lords. Both blame French pride: young knights who would not take advice and saw the battle as a tournament. The old soldier and crusade propagandist Philippe de Mezieres went further in his Epistre lamentable of 1397, arguing that the disaster was God’s judgement on the vanity, luxury and indiscipline of the knightly class. For these writers Nicopolis was a moral lesson as much as a military one.

Ottoman chroniclers

The Ottoman historians who wrote in the later fifteenth century, among them Asikpasazade and Nesri, treat the battle as a victory of the ghazis, warriors of the faith, and a proof of Bayezid’s energy. They say less about the killing of prisoners than the Western sources, and some later Ottoman tradition presents it as retaliation for the crusaders’ slaughter at Rahovo. The poet Ahmedi, who served Bayezid’s family, celebrated his campaigns in verse. The battle confirmed Ottoman possession of the lower Danube for the next four and a half centuries.

Johann Schiltberger, a captive

Schiltberger’s account is the only one written by someone who stood in the line of prisoners. He describes the beheadings going on from morning until the hour of vespers, until, he says, the sultan’s own lords pleaded for the killing to stop. He was taken into Bayezid’s service as a runner, captured again by Timur at Ankara in 1402, and taken across Central Asia before escaping home in the 1420s. His book, written in German, gives the view of a minor man to whom the battle happened.

Bulgarian national memory

In Bulgarian tradition the defeat at Nicopolis closed the last hope of outside help and opened the long period called the Ottoman yoke, ending only in 1878. That view, shaped by nineteenth-century nationalists, stresses the destruction of the medieval nobility and Church, and the devshirme levy of boys. Historians such as Maria Todorova have argued that the yoke framing compresses five varied centuries into a single story of oppression and leaves out the Bulgarians who lived, traded and rose within the Ottoman system.

What is disputed

Numbers are the main quarrel. Chroniclers gave each side 100,000 men or more; Aziz Atiya, writing in 1934, still accepted large figures, while modern military historians such as David Nicolle suggest perhaps 15,000 to 20,000 on each side. The number of prisoners killed is given as anything from 300 to 10,000. The killing of the Rahovo prisoners before the battle rests on Western sources and is generally accepted. The book’s claim that Bayezid killed Ivan Shishman when he took Nicopolis in 1395 is uncertain: Shishman’s death is traditionally linked to Nicopolis, but how and where he died is not securely known.

What followed

John of Nevers and about two dozen great lords were ransomed for some 200,000 ducats, a sum that strained Burgundian finances for years; Coucy and the Count of Eu died in captivity. Nevers, later Duke John the Fearless, carried his reputation from the crusade into French politics. No large Western army tried again until the Varna crusade of 1444, which also failed. Six years after his victory Bayezid was defeated and captured by Timur at Ankara, and died a prisoner.

Read further

  • Aziz Suryal Atiya, The Crusade of Nicopolis (1934)
  • David Nicolle, Nicopolis 1396: The Last Crusade (1999)
  • Johann Schiltberger, The Bondage and Travels of Johann Schiltberger, translated by J. Buchan Telfer (1879)
  • Barbara Tuchman, A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century (1978)
  • Norman Housley, The Later Crusades, 1274-1580: From Lyons to Alcazar (1992)

Same day, other years

1066

Harold Godwinson destroys the Norwegian army at Stamford Bridge

Stamford Bridge, near York, EnglandEurope

Harald Hardrada, King of Norway, had landed in the north with perhaps 300 ships, joined by Harold of England’s exiled brother Tostig. They beat the northern earls at Fulford on 20 September and took the submission of York. Five days later, while they waited at Stamford Bridge for hostages, many of them without their mail shirts, King Harold arrived from the south after a forced march of about 180 miles. In a long fight both Hardrada and Tostig were killed. The survivors were allowed to sail home, reportedly in two dozen ships. Three days later William of Normandy landed in Sussex, and Harold had to turn south again.

Seen from elsewhere. The fullest account is Snorri Sturluson’s saga of Harald, written in Iceland some 170 years later, with its famous offer of seven feet of English ground. The tale of one Norwegian holding the bridge alone comes from a later addition to one manuscript of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle. Both are good stories and doubtful evidence.

1513

Balboa sees the Pacific from a ridge in Darien

Isthmus of Darien, PanamaThe Americas

Vasco Nunez de Balboa, a debtor who had escaped Hispaniola as a stowaway and taken over the Spanish settlement at Santa Maria la Antigua del Darien, set out on 1 September 1513 with some 190 Spaniards and many Indigenous guides and porters, looking for the southern sea and the gold that local leaders said lay beyond it. On 25 September, by the usual reckoning, he climbed a ridge alone and saw the ocean. A few days later he waded into a gulf he named San Miguel and claimed the water and its shores for the crown of Castile. Among his men was Francisco Pizarro.

Seen from elsewhere. The Cueva and other peoples of the isthmus knew the sea well and guided Balboa to it. On the way he fought the cacique Torecha and, according to Peter Martyr, set dogs on about forty men. Some accounts date the sighting to 27 September, and the book’s 26 September matches neither.

1957

Federal troops escort nine Black students into Little Rock Central High

Little Rock, Arkansas, United StatesThe Americas

Three years after the Supreme Court ruled school segregation unconstitutional, Governor Orval Faubus used the Arkansas National Guard to keep nine Black students out of Little Rock’s Central High School. When they finally got in on 23 September, a mob outside forced the police to take them out again. President Eisenhower, no enthusiast for desegregation but unwilling to see federal court orders defied, put the Guard under federal command and sent the 101st Airborne. On 25 September soldiers walked the students through the front door. Troops stayed all year. Ernest Green graduated in 1958; Faubus then closed the city’s high schools for a year rather than integrate them.

Seen from elsewhere. Faubus and his supporters argued that he was preventing violence and defending the rights of the states against federal power. The students’ own memoirs, notably Melba Pattillo Beals’s, describe daily harassment inside the school that the soldiers could not stop, and the organiser Daisy Bates paid for her role with threats and the loss of her newspaper.

1964

FRELIMO opens its war against Portuguese rule in Mozambique

Chai, Cabo Delgado, MozambiqueAfrica

The Front for the Liberation of Mozambique had been founded in exile in Dar es Salaam in 1962 under Eduardo Mondlane, a sociologist who had studied and worked in the United States. Portugal, under the Estado Novo dictatorship, treated its African territories as overseas provinces of a single nation and would not discuss independence. On 25 September 1964 a small FRELIMO group led by Alberto Chipande attacked the Portuguese administrative post at Chai in the far north. The date became the official start of an armed struggle that lasted ten years, ended only by the 1974 revolution in Lisbon, and brought independence in June 1975.

Seen from elsewhere. Lisbon called the guerrillas terrorists directed from abroad and fought a heavy counter-insurgency that included the Wiriyamu massacre of 1972. Historians note that the Chai story is FRELIMO’s founding narrative and that its details are hard to check; after independence FRELIMO ruled as a single party and fought a long civil war with RENAMO.

Also on 25 September