Parallax

15 September, 1814

Europe’s rulers gather in Vienna

In the middle of September 1814 the ministers of the powers that had beaten Napoleon began meeting in private in Vienna. The congress they were preparing never formally opened, sat for nine months, and redrew the map of a continent.

Vienna, Austria

The peace treaty signed in Paris in May 1814 had dealt with France and left almost everything else for later. One article said that all the powers engaged in the war would send representatives to Vienna within two months to complete the settlement. Nobody had worked out what that meant. By September the roads into the Austrian capital were full of carriages: two emperors, four kings, the envoys of more than two hundred states, cities, orders and princely houses, publishers seeking copyright laws, Jewish communities seeking civil rights, and a great many people who had come for the parties.

The British foreign secretary, Lord Castlereagh, arrived on 13 September. Within a couple of days he, the Austrian minister Prince Metternich, the Prussian chancellor Hardenberg and the Russian Count Nesselrode had begun to confer in Metternich’s rooms, and it is from these first conversations, around 15 September, that the congress is conventionally dated. Their intention was to settle the main questions among the four victors and present the rest of Europe with the result.

That plan lasted until the French representative, Talleyrand, was shown it on 30 September. He asked by what right four powers called themselves ‘the allies’ now that the war was over, and who had authorised them to decide for everyone. The opening, fixed for 1 October, was put off to 1 November and then abandoned. There was never a plenary session. Business was done in committees, in a directing group of the five great powers once France had talked its way in, and at dinner.

The host, Emperor Francis I, housed the sovereigns in his own palace and laid on balls, hunts, sleigh rides, tournaments in medieval dress and a concert at which Beethoven conducted. The old Prince de Ligne remarked that the congress danced but did not advance. Meanwhile the Austrian secret police opened letters, bribed servants and emptied wastepaper baskets, and filed daily reports that still survive.

The real work nearly ended in war. Tsar Alexander, whose army occupied Poland, wanted all of it as a kingdom under his own crown; Prussia would be compensated with the whole of Saxony. Austria and Britain would not have it, and on 3 January 1815 they signed a secret defensive treaty with France against their own allies. The compromise gave Russia most of Poland and Prussia two-fifths of Saxony together with a large block of territory on the Rhine. In March came the news that Napoleon had left Elba. The delegates declared him an outlaw, kept negotiating, and signed the Final Act on 9 June 1815, nine days before Waterloo.

How it came to this

Between 1792 and 1814 France had been at war with most of Europe almost without a break. Its armies had abolished the Holy Roman Empire, a thousand years old, and reduced some three hundred German states to about forty. They had created and destroyed kingdoms in Italy, Spain, Holland and Poland, and carried legal equality and conscription wherever they went. Something like five million Europeans had died. When Napoleon abdicated in April 1814 after the allied armies entered Paris, there was no agreed map to go back to, and many of the old rulers no longer existed.

The four powers that had finally combined to defeat him wanted different things. Russia, with the largest army, wanted Poland and a voice in the west. Prussia wanted territory. Austria, with unruly nationalities of its own, feared Russia and feared revolution more. Britain wanted the Low Countries kept out of French hands, its colonial conquests confirmed, and no single power dominant on the Continent. All of them had treated France generously in May, restoring the Bourbon king and the frontiers of 1792, in the hope that a satisfied France would stay quiet.

How each side saw it

The Poles

Poland had been partitioned out of existence in 1795 and partly revived by Napoleon as the Duchy of Warsaw, for which tens of thousands of Poles had fought. Prince Adam Czartoryski, the Polish friend and adviser of the Tsar, came to Vienna hoping for a restored kingdom under Alexander. What emerged was a small ‘Congress Kingdom’ with a constitution and a Russian king, while Prussia and Austria kept their shares; Poles came to call it the fourth partition. The constitution was ignored within a few years. Risings in 1830 and 1863 were crushed, and no Polish state reappeared until 1918.

Liberals and nationalists in Germany and Italy

Those who had answered their rulers’ calls to rise against the French in 1813 expected a reward in the form of constitutions and some kind of national union. The congress produced a loose German Confederation of thirty-nine sovereign states, presided over by Austria, and handed Lombardy and Venice to Vienna. The ancient republics of Genoa and Venice, which sent delegates to plead for their restoration, were given to other rulers. A statistical committee counted the inhabitants of territories as ‘souls’ to be balanced between crowns. To the generation of Mazzini and the German student movement, Vienna meant the bargain of princes against peoples.

Enslaved Africans and the abolitionists

In the summer of 1814 the British public sent Parliament some eight hundred petitions, with around three-quarters of a million signatures, demanding that the peace abolish the Atlantic slave trade. Castlereagh pressed the matter at Vienna against the resistance of Spain, Portugal and France, and obtained in February 1815 a declaration that the trade was repugnant to humanity, with no date and no means of enforcement. The people being shipped had no voice there. Haiti, independent since 1804, was not invited or recognised. Slavery itself was not discussed, and the trade to Brazil and Cuba went on for decades.

The statesmen and their modern defenders

Metternich and Castlereagh spoke of equilibrium: no power strong enough to dominate, none so aggrieved that it would overturn the order. Henry Kissinger’s study of them praised a settlement that even the defeated accepted as legitimate. Paul Schroeder argued that Vienna went further and replaced the competitive balance of the eighteenth century with a system of shared rules and restraint. Critics such as Adam Zamoyski answer that the peacemakers suppressed political change for a generation, and that the forces they refused to accommodate returned in 1848 and, more destructively, in the wars of national unification.

What is disputed

The opening date is a convention. Nothing ceremonial happened on 15 September; some accounts start the congress with the sovereigns’ entry on 25 September, others on 1 October or 1 November. The larger argument is over the claim that Vienna gave Europe a century of peace. There was no general war among all the great powers until 1914, but the Crimean War and the wars of 1859, 1866 and 1870 were fought between them, and the congress system of regular meetings had broken down by the 1820s. How much of the long peace is owed to the settlement, and how much to exhaustion and British naval supremacy, is debated.

What followed

The Final Act created a Kingdom of the Netherlands that included Belgium, guaranteed Swiss neutrality, opened the Rhine and other international rivers to navigation and fixed the rules of diplomatic rank that are still in use. The great powers went on meeting in congresses for some years and intervened against revolutions in Naples and Spain. Belgium broke away in 1830. Prussia’s new Rhineland provinces, with their coal and iron, turned out to be the foundation of its later power in Germany. The peacemakers of 1919 studied Vienna closely, and chose to exclude the defeated.

Read further

  • Adam Zamoyski, Rites of Peace: The Fall of Napoleon and the Congress of Vienna (2007)
  • Paul W. Schroeder, The Transformation of European Politics, 1763-1848 (1994)
  • Brian E. Vick, The Congress of Vienna: Power and Politics after Napoleon (2014)
  • Harold Nicolson, The Congress of Vienna: A Study in Allied Unity, 1812-1822 (1946)
  • Henry Kissinger, A World Restored: Metternich, Castlereagh and the Problems of Peace, 1812-22 (1957)

Same day, other years

1821

Central America declares independence

Guatemala CityThe Americas

The Spanish captain-general, Gabino Gainza, called the officials, clergy and leading citizens of Guatemala City to the palace to discuss the news that Mexico had broken with Spain. A crowd gathered outside. By the afternoon the meeting had voted for independence and Gainza had agreed to stay on as head of the new government. No shot was fired. The act covered the whole Captaincy General, the present Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua and Costa Rica. Its text says frankly that independence was being declared to forestall the consequences that would be fearful if the people were to proclaim it themselves.

Seen from elsewhere. For the Maya majority little changed: tribute and forced labour continued under new names, and the K’iche’ rising against tribute at Totonicapan a year earlier had been put down by the same elite. The provinces soon quarrelled. They were annexed to Mexico within months, formed a federation in 1823, and had separated into five republics by 1841.

1935

The Nuremberg Laws

Nuremberg, GermanyEurope

The German parliament, summoned to the Nazi party rally, passed two laws by acclamation. The Reich Citizenship Law reduced Jews from citizens to subjects of the state. The Law for the Protection of German Blood and German Honour forbade marriage and sexual relations between Jews and other Germans, and barred Jews from employing German women under forty-five as servants. Officials had drafted the texts over the preceding two days on Hitler’s sudden instruction. A decree in November defined a Jew as anyone with three or four Jewish grandparents, whatever their own religion. The laws were soon applied to Roma and to Black Germans as well.

Seen from elsewhere. After a summer of street violence, the representative body of German Jews said it hoped the laws might at least make a tolerable, regulated existence possible; the regime encouraged that reading. Historians differ on how far the laws were improvised. James Whitman has shown that Nazi jurists studied American race statutes while drafting, and judged some of them too severe to copy.

1950

The landing at Inchon

Inchon, KoreaAsia

Three months into the Korean War, United Nations forces held only a pocket around Pusan in the far south-east. General Douglas MacArthur proposed to land far behind the North Korean lines at Inchon, the port of Seoul, where tides rise and fall by thirty feet and the approach runs through miles of mudflats. His own staff and the navy advised against it. Marines took the harbour island on the morning tide and went over the sea walls of the city on the evening one. Seoul was retaken within two weeks and the North Korean army in the south fell apart.

Seen from elsewhere. North Korea, which calls the conflict the Fatherland Liberation War, commemorates the defenders of the harbour island. South Korea’s truth commission found that American napalm strikes there days earlier killed dozens of villagers. Success encouraged MacArthur to push to the Chinese border despite Beijing’s warnings; China intervened, and the war lasted nearly three more years.

1963

The bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church

Birmingham, Alabama, United StatesThe Americas

On a Sunday morning a bundle of dynamite planted by members of the Ku Klux Klan exploded under the side steps of a Black church that had been the assembly point for that spring’s civil rights marches. It killed four girls who were in the basement changing for a service: Addie Mae Collins, Cynthia Wesley and Carole Robertson, all fourteen, and Denise McNair, eleven. More than twenty people were injured. In the disorder that followed that day two Black boys were shot dead, one by a policeman. The FBI had identified four suspects by 1965, and its director closed the case without charges.

Seen from elsewhere. Segregationist politicians blamed outside agitators; the governor, George Wallace, had said days earlier that the state needed a few first-class funerals. Some activists argued that the killings showed the limits of non-violence. One bomber was convicted in 1977 and two more in 2001 and 2002, nearly forty years on; the fourth died uncharged.

Also on 15 September