Parallax

20 September, 1378

The cardinals elect a second pope

Five months after choosing a pope in Rome with a mob at the door, the same cardinals met in a small town to the south, declared that election void and chose another. For forty years Catholic Europe did not know who its pope was.

Fondi, Kingdom of Naples

The first election had been held on 7 and 8 April 1378, the first conclave in Rome for seventy-five years. Sixteen cardinals went in, eleven of them French. Outside, a crowd filled the square and shouted that they wanted a Roman, or at least an Italian. Men got into the palace, beat on the floor of the conclave from the room below with pikes, and broke into the papal wine cellar. On the morning of the 8th the cardinals settled, quickly, on a man outside their own number: Bartolomeo Prignano, archbishop of Bari, a Neapolitan who had run the papal chancery at Avignon and was thought a safe, dutiful official.

Before he could be told, the crowd burst in. The frightened cardinals pushed forward the aged Roman cardinal Tebaldeschi, put the papal mantle on him and let the people venerate him while they slipped away, the old man protesting that he was not the pope. The next day they came back, enthroned Prignano as Urban VI, and at Easter crowned him. For weeks they treated him as pope, wrote to the courts of Europe announcing him and asked him for the usual favours.

Then Urban began to reform them. He told the cardinals in open consistory that they lived like princes on bribes and must be content with one dish at table. He called one a fool, told another to stop his chatter, and by one report had to be held back from striking a third. He would not go back to Avignon, and he threatened to swamp the college with Italians. Even witnesses on his side described rages that startled them.

As the Roman summer came on, the French cardinals left one by one for Anagni. On 2 August they issued a declaration that the April election had been made in fear of death and was null, and called on Urban to step down. He refused and, in a single day, created twenty-nine new cardinals. The dissidents moved to Fondi, under the protection of its count, Onorato Caetani, and of Queen Joanna of Naples.

There, on 20 September, they elected Robert of Geneva, aged thirty-six, a cousin of the king of France. He took the name Clement VII. The three Italian cardinals present did not vote, and did not object. Robert was able and well connected, but in Italy he was known for something else: as papal legate the year before he had commanded the mercenary army that sacked Cesena and massacred several thousand of its inhabitants. Each pope excommunicated the other. Clement tried to take Rome by force, was beaten at Marino in April 1379, and by June was installed at Avignon.

How it came to this

Since 1309 the popes had lived at Avignon on the Rhone, at first as a temporary refuge from the violence of Roman politics. Seven popes in a row were Frenchmen, the college of cardinals became largely French, and critics from Petrarch onward called it a Babylonian captivity under the eye of the French king. Rome decayed without its court. Italian opinion, and the visionaries Bridget of Sweden and Catherine of Siena, pressed the popes to go home.

Gregory XI did so in January 1377, entering a city his own mercenaries had been fighting to recover; the Papal States were in revolt, backed by Florence. He found Rome hostile and was planning to leave again when he died on 27 March 1378. Roman officials, knowing that a French pope would take the papacy straight back to Avignon, made sure the cardinals understood the mood of the city. What the cardinals understood, and how freely they then acted, became the question on which the schism turned.

How each side saw it

Urban VI and his supporters

The Roman case was simple. The cardinals had elected Urban, crowned him, taken communion from him and petitioned him for benefices for three months without a word about fear; they discovered their scruples only when he touched their incomes. Catherine of Siena wrote to the three Italian cardinals that they were liars and idolaters, and called the electors of Fondi devils in human form. She also wrote to Urban himself, more than once, begging him to restrain his temper. England, the Empire, Hungary, Poland, Flanders and most of Italy recognised him.

The cardinals of Fondi

The cardinals’ declaration, and the sworn depositions later collected for the kings of Castile and Aragon, describe armed men in the palace, cries of death and a choice made to get out alive. Their behaviour afterwards, they said, was no evidence of consent, because they were still in Rome and still in danger. Canon law did hold an election made under grave fear to be void. Several also argued that Urban’s conduct showed him to be unfit, even deranged, and so incapable of having been validly chosen. France, Scotland, Naples, Castile and Aragon accepted Clement, and the Dominican preacher Vincent Ferrer defended him.

Princes and ordinary believers

Rulers mostly followed their alliances: France’s friends went one way and her enemies the other, and some sold their obedience more than once. For lay people and parish clergy the division was a matter of conscience they had no means to settle. Religious orders split and elected rival generals, a diocese on a frontier might have two bishops, and each side declared the other’s sacraments tainted. Writers as different as Jean Gerson in Paris and the Aragonese visionary Constance of Rabastens record the anxiety. The University of Paris spent thirty years proposing ways out.

What is disputed

The Catholic Church has never formally ruled which line was legitimate; the Council of Constance deliberately avoided the question. Its official lists follow the Roman line, and Clement is counted an antipope. Historians divide on how real the fear was. Walter Ullmann thought the cardinals’ legal case weak but their political grievance genuine, and raised the possibility that Urban was mentally unbalanced. Joelle Rollo-Koster has shown that pillaging and tumult were customary at papal vacancies and may have been misread. The older view that King Charles V of France engineered the break is now generally rejected: he followed his cardinals.

What followed

The two lines continued after the first rivals died. A council at Pisa in 1409 deposed both popes and elected a third, which made three. The Council of Constance finally removed or accepted the resignation of all of them and elected Martin V in November 1417. The cure had lasting effects: the claim that a general council stands above a pope, the habit of national churches bargaining with Rome, and a damaged reverence for the office that reformers a century later could draw on.

Read further

  • Walter Ullmann, The Origins of the Great Schism (1948)
  • Joelle Rollo-Koster, Raiding Saint Peter: Empty Sees, Violence, and the Initiation of the Great Western Schism (2008)
  • Joelle Rollo-Koster and Thomas M. Izbicki (eds), A Companion to the Great Western Schism (2009)
  • Renate Blumenfeld-Kosinski, Poets, Saints, and Visionaries of the Great Schism, 1378-1417 (2006)
  • Catherine of Siena, Letters

Same day, other years

1519

Magellan’s five ships put to sea

Sanlucar de Barrameda, SpainWorldwide

Ferdinand Magellan, a Portuguese navigator who had fallen out with his own king, sailed from the mouth of the Guadalquivir in the service of Spain with five ships and some 240 to 270 men of a dozen nations. He was not trying to circle the globe. His contract was to reach the Spice Islands by sailing west and so prove they lay in the Spanish half of the world. He found the strait that bears his name, crossed the Pacific in ninety-nine days of scurvy and starvation, and was killed in the Philippines in April 1521. One ship, the Victoria, came home in September 1522 under the Basque Juan Sebastian Elcano with eighteen Europeans aboard.

Seen from elsewhere. Magellan died at Mactan attacking a chief, Lapulapu, who refused to submit to Spain’s local ally; the Philippines honours Lapulapu as its first resister of colonial rule. The only detailed account is by Magellan’s admirer Antonio Pigafetta. Enrique, the enslaved Malay interpreter Magellan had brought from Malacca, may have been the first person to return to his own part of the world by sailing round it.

1857

Delhi is retaken and emptied

Delhi, IndiaAsia

After a week of street fighting that began with the storming of the Kashmir Gate, British and loyal Indian troops took the last rebel positions in Delhi, the city that mutinous soldiers had made their capital in May by proclaiming the old Mughal emperor, Bahadur Shah Zafar, their sovereign. The emperor, aged eighty-two, surrendered the next day at Humayun’s tomb. On the day after that, Captain William Hodson shot three Mughal princes dead at a city gate. The army was given leave to plunder. Men suspected of rebellion were hanged or shot in large numbers and the population was driven out; Muslims were not allowed back for about two years.

Seen from elsewhere. British accounts presented retribution for the killing of European women and children. The poet Ghalib, who stayed in his house throughout, described in his diary Dastanbuy a city of the dead. Zafar was tried and exiled to Rangoon. Indian nationalists from V. D. Savarkar onward called 1857 the first war of independence; whether it was that, a mutiny or many local revolts is still debated.

1932

Gandhi begins a fast against separate electorates

Yerwada Central Jail, Poona, IndiaAsia

The British government had announced that in new Indian legislatures the ‘Depressed Classes’, the castes treated as untouchable, would elect their own representatives in separate constituencies, as Muslims and Sikhs did. Their leader, B. R. Ambedkar, had fought for this in London. Gandhi, in prison for civil disobedience, declared that he would fast to death against it, and began at noon. Four days of negotiation at his bedside produced the Poona Pact: a common Hindu electorate, with 148 seats reserved for the Depressed Classes in place of the 71 separate ones in the British award, and a primary stage in which they alone would choose candidates. Gandhi took orange juice on 26 September.

Seen from elsewhere. Gandhi held that separate electorates would fix untouchability in law and split Hindu society for good. Ambedkar signed, he said, because if Gandhi died his people would face reprisals across India. He later wrote that the fast was coercion, and that reserved seats filled by a general electorate returned Dalit members who answered to caste Hindu voters. Dalit politics in India still argues over the bargain.

1979

French paratroops remove Emperor Bokassa

Bangui, Central African RepublicAfrica

Jean-Bedel Bokassa, a former French army captain who seized power in 1966 and had himself crowned emperor in 1977 in a ceremony modelled on Napoleon’s, was visiting Libya when French troops landed at Bangui airport by night. They brought with them David Dacko, the president Bokassa had overthrown thirteen years before, who announced the restoration of the republic. The trigger was the killing, in April, of around a hundred schoolchildren arrested after protests against compulsory uniforms sold by a company the imperial family owned. A commission of African jurists found that Bokassa had almost certainly taken part. France, which had paid much of the cost of his coronation, acted within weeks of the report.

Seen from elsewhere. Bokassa said Paris had used him and discarded him, and revealed gifts of diamonds to President Giscard d’Estaing, a scandal that hurt Giscard in the 1981 election. Many Central Africans were glad to see him go and uneasy that a foreign army chose his successor. He returned in 1986, was convicted of murder, acquitted of cannibalism, freed in 1993 and officially rehabilitated in 2010.

Also on 20 September