The first election had been held on 7 and 8 April 1378, the first conclave in Rome for seventy-five years. Sixteen cardinals went in, eleven of them French. Outside, a crowd filled the square and shouted that they wanted a Roman, or at least an Italian. Men got into the palace, beat on the floor of the conclave from the room below with pikes, and broke into the papal wine cellar. On the morning of the 8th the cardinals settled, quickly, on a man outside their own number: Bartolomeo Prignano, archbishop of Bari, a Neapolitan who had run the papal chancery at Avignon and was thought a safe, dutiful official.
Before he could be told, the crowd burst in. The frightened cardinals pushed forward the aged Roman cardinal Tebaldeschi, put the papal mantle on him and let the people venerate him while they slipped away, the old man protesting that he was not the pope. The next day they came back, enthroned Prignano as Urban VI, and at Easter crowned him. For weeks they treated him as pope, wrote to the courts of Europe announcing him and asked him for the usual favours.
Then Urban began to reform them. He told the cardinals in open consistory that they lived like princes on bribes and must be content with one dish at table. He called one a fool, told another to stop his chatter, and by one report had to be held back from striking a third. He would not go back to Avignon, and he threatened to swamp the college with Italians. Even witnesses on his side described rages that startled them.
As the Roman summer came on, the French cardinals left one by one for Anagni. On 2 August they issued a declaration that the April election had been made in fear of death and was null, and called on Urban to step down. He refused and, in a single day, created twenty-nine new cardinals. The dissidents moved to Fondi, under the protection of its count, Onorato Caetani, and of Queen Joanna of Naples.
There, on 20 September, they elected Robert of Geneva, aged thirty-six, a cousin of the king of France. He took the name Clement VII. The three Italian cardinals present did not vote, and did not object. Robert was able and well connected, but in Italy he was known for something else: as papal legate the year before he had commanded the mercenary army that sacked Cesena and massacred several thousand of its inhabitants. Each pope excommunicated the other. Clement tried to take Rome by force, was beaten at Marino in April 1379, and by June was installed at Avignon.
How it came to this
Since 1309 the popes had lived at Avignon on the Rhone, at first as a temporary refuge from the violence of Roman politics. Seven popes in a row were Frenchmen, the college of cardinals became largely French, and critics from Petrarch onward called it a Babylonian captivity under the eye of the French king. Rome decayed without its court. Italian opinion, and the visionaries Bridget of Sweden and Catherine of Siena, pressed the popes to go home.
Gregory XI did so in January 1377, entering a city his own mercenaries had been fighting to recover; the Papal States were in revolt, backed by Florence. He found Rome hostile and was planning to leave again when he died on 27 March 1378. Roman officials, knowing that a French pope would take the papacy straight back to Avignon, made sure the cardinals understood the mood of the city. What the cardinals understood, and how freely they then acted, became the question on which the schism turned.