Parallax

2 September, 31 BC

Actium: Antony and Cleopatra break out and lose the world

A naval battle off western Greece that may have been a planned escape rather than a fight to the finish ended a century of Roman civil wars and left one man, aged thirty-one, in charge of everything.

Off Actium, Gulf of Ambracia, Greece

By the end of August in 31 BC, Mark Antony’s position at Actium had become a trap. He had brought the largest fleet in the Mediterranean and nineteen legions to the mouth of the Gulf of Ambracia in western Greece, with Cleopatra, her squadron and her war chest beside him. Then Octavian’s admiral, Marcus Agrippa, had picked off the harbours behind him one by one: Methone, Leucas, Patrae, Corinth. The grain ships from Egypt stopped arriving. Fever and dysentery went through the camp on its marshy shore. Rowers died or ran, and the client kings and Roman senators who had followed Antony east began slipping across the strait to Octavian.

Antony burned the ships he could no longer man. That left about 230, including Cleopatra’s sixty, against an enemy fleet put by different ancient writers at 250 or 400. He gave two orders that his captains found strange. The treasure was to be loaded onto the Egyptian ships by night, and every vessel was to carry its sails into action, although warships normally left them ashore. He told the pilots it was to make pursuit easier.

For four days a gale kept both fleets in harbour. On the morning of 2 September the sea was calm, and Antony’s line rowed out through the narrows and stopped, its heavy ships close together with their flanks against the shore. Agrippa waited further out, declining to fight where he could not use his numbers. About midday the usual sea breeze got up and the wings began to move. As Agrippa stretched his line to get round the northern end, Antony’s ships followed, and the centre thinned.

Through that gap, in the afternoon, Cleopatra’s sixty ships hoisted sail and ran south before the wind. Antony left his flagship for a faster galley and went after her with a few dozen others. Plutarch says he was taken aboard her ship and sat alone in the bows for three days with his head in his hands. The rest of his fleet, hemmed in and unable to disengage, fought on until evening. Octavian’s lighter ships worked in groups against the big galleys and finally used fire. In the morning the survivors surrendered.

The army on shore held out for a week, bargaining for terms, until its commander Canidius Crassus slipped away by night and the legions went over. Octavian wintered in the east, raised money, and reached Egypt the following summer. Antony’s last troops deserted outside Alexandria on 1 August 30 BC. He stabbed himself and died in Cleopatra’s arms. She killed herself days later, and Octavian annexed her kingdom.

How it came to this

After Julius Caesar’s murder in 44 BC his heir Octavian and his lieutenant Antony had destroyed the assassins and divided the Roman world, Octavian taking the west and Antony the richer east. A marriage between Antony and Octavian’s sister Octavia was meant to hold the arrangement together. Instead Antony settled in Alexandria with Cleopatra VII, the last of the Macedonian dynasty that had ruled Egypt for three centuries, who had already borne a son she said was Caesar’s. Antony needed her money and ships for his wars. She needed Rome’s strongest general to preserve and enlarge her kingdom. They had three children.

In 34 BC, at a ceremony in Alexandria, Antony assigned eastern territories to Cleopatra and her children. Two years later he divorced Octavia. Octavian seized Antony’s will from the Vestal Virgins and read out a clause asking for burial in Alexandria. He then had war declared on Cleopatra alone, which let him present a struggle between two Roman warlords as the defence of Italy against a foreign queen.

How each side saw it

Octavian’s Rome

The victor’s version was written by the best poets in Latin. Horace’s ode on the news of Cleopatra’s death opens with a call to drink and dance, and describes a mad queen plotting ruin for the Capitol with her crew of eunuchs. Virgil put the battle on the shield of Aeneas: Italy’s gods and senate on one side, barking Anubis and a shameful Egyptian wife on the other. Antony is barely named. Octavian’s own summary of his career, the Res Gestae, says only that all Italy swore allegiance to him and demanded him as leader in the war he won at Actium.

Antony’s side

Antony wrote pamphlets in his own defence, including one answering the charge of drunkenness, and none survives. His case has to be recovered from hostile sources and from Plutarch, who wrote 150 years later with access to family memories from Greece: his great-grandfather used to tell how the citizens of Chaeronea were made to carry grain to the coast for Antony’s fleet under the whip. Antony’s supporters, who included both consuls of 32 BC and several hundred senators, saw him as Caesar’s senior heir and the legitimate governor of the east, and Octavian as a young man who had broken every agreement he made.

Cleopatra and Egypt

No Egyptian narrative of the war exists. Cleopatra was a Greek-speaking monarch, the first of her line said to have learned Egyptian, ruling a state that was rich, old and already dependent on Roman goodwill. From Alexandria the alliance with Antony was a rational policy that had restored much of the old Ptolemaic empire without a battle. Her flight at Actium saved the treasury, which was the one asset that could buy another army. Medieval Arabic writers, working from a tradition independent of Rome, remembered her as a scholar and builder rather than a seductress.

The Greek cities

Greece was the battlefield and paid for both armies. Antony’s requisitions stripped it of grain, money and men for the oars. After the victory Octavian founded Nicopolis, ‘victory city’, on the site of his camp and filled it by emptying older towns of Epirus, Acarnania and Aetolia, whose people and cult statues were moved there whether they wished it or not. He also distributed the grain left in Antony’s stores to cities that had been starved to fill them. Greek writers of the following generations generally accepted the new order, which at least ended the wars.

What is disputed

The day itself is unusually secure: Cassius Dio gives it. What happened is not. The ancient accounts, shaped by Octavian’s propaganda, show Cleopatra fleeing in panic and Antony deserting his men for love. Johannes Kromayer argued in 1899 that the sails and the loaded treasure prove a planned breakout that partly succeeded, and most historians now agree. W. W. Tarn proposed instead that much of Antony’s fleet refused to fight. How hard the battle was is also unclear, since Plutarch’s casualty figure is modest and the poets describe a great conflagration. Fleet numbers differ from source to source.

What followed

Egypt became the personal property of the Roman ruler, and its grain fed the city of Rome for centuries. Octavian had Caesarion killed, paraded Cleopatra’s other children in his triumph, and in 27 BC accepted the name Augustus. The system he built, a monarchy dressed as a restored republic, lasted in the west for five hundred years. The month of Sextilis was renamed August partly because Alexandria had fallen in it. The image of Cleopatra fixed by her enemies has proved almost as durable as the empire.

Read further

  • Plutarch, Life of Antony
  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, books 50-51
  • Ronald Syme, The Roman Revolution (1939)
  • Duane W. Roller, Cleopatra: A Biography (2010)
  • Barry Strauss, The War That Made the Roman Empire: Antony, Cleopatra, and Octavian at Actium (2022)

Same day, other years

1192

Richard and Saladin make peace without meeting

Jaffa, PalestineMiddle East

After sixteen months of campaigning, Richard I of England was ill with fever at Jaffa and anxious about his brother John and the king of France at home. Saladin’s emirs were tired of a war that kept them from their own lands. Through intermediaries the two agreed a truce of three years and eight months. The crusaders kept the coast from Tyre to Jaffa. The fortifications of Ascalon, which Richard had spent a fortune rebuilding, were to be demolished. Jerusalem remained under Muslim rule, with unarmed Christian pilgrims free to visit. Richard declined to go himself. He sailed in October. The two men, linked ever after in legend, never met face to face.

Seen from elsewhere. Saladin’s secretary Baha al-Din ibn Shaddad records that the sultan disliked the truce and feared the Franks would use it to recover their strength, but accepted that his army would fight no longer. Many crusaders thought it a betrayal of their vow. Saladin died six months later, and the settlement outlived him by only a few years.

1666

The Great Fire of London begins

London, EnglandEurope

In the small hours of a Sunday, fire broke out in the bakery of Thomas Farriner in Pudding Lane, near London Bridge. A dry summer, a strong east wind and streets of timber houses did the rest. The Lord Mayor hesitated to pull down buildings in its path, and by the time the king’s brother took charge of demolition the flames had reached the riverside warehouses full of oil, tallow and spirits. In four days the fire destroyed about 13,200 houses, 87 parish churches and the medieval St Paul’s, most of the city within the walls. Samuel Pepys buried his wine and his Parmesan cheese in the garden and watched from the river.

Seen from elsewhere. Fewer than ten deaths were recorded, a figure many historians think too low to be believed. Londoners looked for culprits among foreigners, and mobs attacked Frenchmen and Dutchmen in the streets. A French watchmaker, Robert Hubert, confessed and was hanged, though he had not been in London when the fire began. From 1681 to 1830 the Monument carried an inscription blaming Catholics.

1898

Omdurman: machine guns against the Mahdist state

Karari, near Omdurman, SudanAfrica

On a plain beside the Nile north of Omdurman, an Anglo-Egyptian army of about 25,000 under Herbert Kitchener met some 50,000 followers of the Khalifa Abdullahi, successor to the Mahdi who had taken Khartoum in 1885. The Sudanese attacked across open ground at dawn into magazine rifles, artillery, gunboats and Maxim guns. By late morning around 11,000 of them were dead and perhaps 16,000 wounded. Kitchener lost 48 killed. A young Winston Churchill rode in the charge of the 21st Lancers, an episode that cost more British lives than the rest of the battle. Kitchener then had the Mahdi’s tomb shelled and his bones thrown into the river.

Seen from elsewhere. In Sudan the battle is called Karari and remembered as a martyrdom of men who walked into fire for their faith and their independence. The memoirs of Babikr Bedri, who fought there, describe the looting of Omdurman afterwards. Churchill’s own book criticised the killing of wounded Sudanese on the field and the desecration of the tomb, and questions were asked in Parliament.

1945

Ho Chi Minh declares Vietnam independent

Hanoi, VietnamAsia

In Ba Dinh Square, before a crowd of several hundred thousand, a thin man in a khaki tunic read a declaration that opened with the words of the American Declaration of Independence and the French Declaration of the Rights of Man. Ho Chi Minh’s Viet Minh had taken Hanoi two weeks earlier, in the gap left by Japan’s surrender, and the last emperor, Bao Dai, had abdicated. The north was just emerging from a famine that had killed between one and two million people under Japanese and Vichy French requisitions. The declaration listed France’s colonial record and announced the Democratic Republic of Vietnam. No foreign government recognised it.

Seen from elsewhere. France regarded Indochina as its own and sent troops back within weeks; full-scale war began in December 1946 and, with American involvement, lasted in one form or another until 1975. Vietnamese nationalists outside the Communist-led Viet Minh, many of whom were suppressed or killed in 1945-46, and later the southern republic, did not accept 2 September as the nation’s founding day.

Also on 2 September