Parallax

18 September, AD 96

Domitian is stabbed in his bedroom

The emperor had mirrors of polished stone set into his colonnades so that no one could come up behind him. The man who killed him walked in through the front, with a bandaged arm and a document to show.

The Palatine, Rome

According to Suetonius, who was a young man in Rome at the time, Domitian had long been told the day and even the hour of his death: the fifth hour of 18 September. The day before, he ordered some apples kept for tomorrow, adding ‘if I am spared’. On the morning itself he sat in judgment, scratched a wart on his forehead until it bled, and said he hoped that was all the blood required. Then he asked the time. His attendants, who were in the plot, told him it was the sixth hour. Relieved, he went off to bathe.

His chamberlain Parthenius turned him back. A man had come with urgent news that could not wait. The man was Stephanus, a steward in the household of Domitian’s niece Flavia Domitilla, who had recently been exiled, and he was himself under suspicion of embezzlement. For several days he had worn his left arm wrapped in wool and bandages as though injured. A dagger was inside the wrapping. Alone with the emperor in the bedchamber, he handed over a paper that claimed to expose a conspiracy and, while Domitian read it, stabbed him in the groin.

The wound did not kill him. Domitian was forty-four, a big man, and he fought. He dragged Stephanus to the floor, tried to wrench the dagger away and clawed at his eyes with fingers cut to the bone. He shouted to a slave boy, who was in the room tending the household shrine, to fetch the blade he kept under his pillow and call the servants. The boy found only a hilt, and every door shut. Suetonius says he had this from the boy himself.

Then the others came in: Clodianus, a junior officer; Maximus, a freedman of Parthenius; Satur, a senior chamberlain; and a gladiator from the imperial school. They finished him with seven wounds. Stephanus is said by Cassius Dio to have been killed in the scuffle or just after it by men who were not in the plot.

No one of rank claimed the body. Public undertakers carried it out on a common bier, and his old nurse Phyllis cremated it at her villa on the Via Latina, then secretly took the ashes to the temple of the Flavian family and mixed them with those of his niece Julia, whom she had also nursed. By nightfall the Senate had a new emperor, the elderly and childless senator Nerva, whose readiness suggests he had been sounded out beforehand. The senators, Suetonius writes, were so overjoyed that they sent for ladders and had Domitian’s shields and images torn down and smashed on the floor of the house.

How it came to this

Domitian was the younger son of Vespasian, the general who won the civil war of AD 69, and the brother of Titus, who died in 81 after a reign of two years. He had been kept away from real responsibility by both, and governed for fifteen years as an open autocrat who saw no reason to flatter the Senate. He was an attentive administrator: he restored the silver content of the coinage, raised army pay by a third, policed provincial governors and rebuilt a Rome scarred by fire, including the palace on the Palatine in which he died.

After a revolt by the governor of Upper Germany in 89, his suspicion hardened. Treason trials multiplied from 93. Senators and philosophers were executed or banished, among them Helvidius Priscus and Arulenus Rusticus. In 95 he put to death his cousin Flavius Clemens, whose sons he had named as heirs, and then the freedman Epaphroditus, on the grounds that he had once helped Nero to die. That, the sources agree, is what frightened his own household into acting.

How each side saw it

The Senate and its writers

Nearly everything said about Domitian was written by senators or their clients after he was safely dead. Tacitus, whose father-in-law Agricola served him, describes years in which the Senate sat silent while its members were led to execution, and admits the shame of having survived by keeping quiet. Pliny the Younger, in his speech of thanks to Trajan, recalls the pleasure of seeing the golden statues hacked apart. Both men had held office under Domitian and prospered. The Senate condemned his memory, and his name was chiselled out of inscriptions across the empire.

The soldiers

The army took it differently. Suetonius says the troops were deeply grieved, at once tried to have him declared a god, and would have avenged him if they had had leaders. A year later the Praetorian Guard found them: under their prefect Casperius Aelianus they besieged Nerva in the palace and forced him to hand over Parthenius and the former prefect Petronius Secundus, who were killed. Nerva was made to thank the mutineers in public. The humiliation is the usual explanation of why he quickly adopted Trajan, a general the legions respected.

Domitia Longina, the empress

Suetonius lists his wife among those who knew of the conspiracy, and Cassius Dio, writing over a century later, adds a tale in which she found a tablet of names marked for death and warned the others. She left no word of her own. What survives is indirect and points the other way: brick stamps from her estates, decades after the murder, still style her ‘Domitia, wife of Domitian’, a name the Senate had ordered erased. Brian Jones and other modern biographers doubt that she took part.

Jews and Christians

Domitian enforced the tax imposed on Jews after the destruction of the Temple so harshly that Suetonius remembered seeing a ninety-year-old man stripped in court to see whether he was circumcised; Nerva’s coins advertise the end of such abuses. Clemens and Domitilla were charged with ‘atheism’ and drifting into Jewish ways, which later Christians took to mean that they were converts. From the second century, church writers named Domitian as the second persecutor after Nero and placed the Book of Revelation in his reign. Most historians now find little evidence of an organised persecution.

What is disputed

The portrait of a paranoid monster comes from a hostile tradition, and since the work of Brian Jones and Pat Southern in the 1990s many historians have treated him as a capable, cold ruler whose real offence was contempt for the senatorial class. Whether he demanded to be addressed as ‘lord and god’ is doubtful: no official document uses the title. The involvement of the empress and of the Praetorian prefects rests on Dio. Nerva’s foreknowledge is inferred, not recorded. The omens and the exact hour belong to the conventions of imperial biography, though the date itself is secure.

What followed

The Flavian dynasty ended with him. Nerva lasted sixteen months and by adopting Trajan began a run of emperors chosen by adoption that later ages called the best the empire had. The writers who flourished under them, Tacitus, Pliny and Suetonius, fixed Domitian’s reputation for eighteen centuries. His buildings outlasted it: the outline of his stadium is the Piazza Navona, and his palace housed emperors for another three hundred years.

Read further

  • Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars, Life of Domitian
  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, Book 67
  • Tacitus, Agricola
  • Brian W. Jones, The Emperor Domitian (1992)
  • Pat Southern, Domitian: Tragic Tyrant (1997)

Same day, other years

1810

Santiago forms a junta in the king’s name

Santiago, ChileThe Americas

With Spain occupied by Napoleon and King Ferdinand VII a prisoner in France, several hundred leading citizens of Santiago met in open assembly and replaced the Spanish governor with a governing junta. Its president was Mateo de Toro Zambrano, a local grandee in his eighties, and its members swore to hold Chile for the captive king. Many of them meant it. Others saw a first step, and within a year the junta had opened the ports to free trade and called a congress. Full independence was declared only in 1818, after a Spanish reconquest and a liberating army that crossed the Andes from Argentina. Chileans nonetheless keep 18 September as their national day.

Seen from elsewhere. Royalists, strong in the south, saw sedition behind a loyal mask and fought it for a decade. The Mapuche beyond the Biobio river were no part of the assembly: they held their land under treaties with the Spanish crown, and many sided with the king’s forces. The republic conquered their territory between 1861 and 1883.

1898

Kitchener’s gunboats reach Fashoda

Fashoda (Kodok), on the White Nile, South SudanAfrica

Two weeks after destroying the Mahdist army at Omdurman, Herbert Kitchener steamed 400 miles up the Nile with five gunboats and found a French flag flying over a ruined fort. Jean-Baptiste Marchand had got there in July with a handful of French officers and about 120 Senegalese riflemen, after fourteen months crossing the continent from the Atlantic. Each man claimed the upper Nile for his government. They did so politely, over drinks, and agreed to leave the matter to London and Paris. For six weeks the two countries talked of war. France, weaker at sea and split by the Dreyfus affair, ordered Marchand out in November.

Seen from elsewhere. In France, Fashoda became a byword for humiliation by Britain, though the settlement cleared the way for the Entente of 1904. The Shilluk, whose kingdom it was, appear in the record only as signatories: their king put his mark to a treaty with Marchand and then told Kitchener he had not meant it.

1931

A small explosion on a Manchurian railway

Mukden (Shenyang), ChinaAsia

At about twenty past ten at night, Japanese officers of the Kwantung Army set off a charge beside the track of the Japanese-owned South Manchuria Railway, just north of Mukden. The damage was so slight that an express passed over the spot minutes later. The army announced that Chinese troops had attacked the line, shelled the nearby barracks and occupied the city by morning. The plot was the work of two staff officers, Ishiwara Kanji and Itagaki Seishiro, acting without orders from Tokyo. The government there failed to stop them. Within five months Japan held all of Manchuria and set up the state of Manchukuo under the last Qing emperor, Puyi.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan called it self-defence and left the League of Nations in 1933 when the Lytton Commission disagreed. The Chinese commander, Zhang Xueliang, had been told not to resist, a decision still argued over. In China ‘9.18’ is a day of national humiliation marked with sirens, and since 2017 textbooks date the war with Japan from it, making fourteen years, not eight.

1961

The UN Secretary-General’s plane comes down near Ndola

Ndola, Northern Rhodesia (Zambia)Africa

Dag Hammarskjold was flying by night to meet Moise Tshombe, leader of the breakaway Congolese province of Katanga, where UN troops were fighting Tshombe’s forces and their European mercenaries. Shortly after midnight his DC-6 crashed in forest nine miles short of the runway. Fifteen people died at the scene; the sixteenth, an American security officer, lived for a few days and spoke of sparks in the sky. The wreck was not officially located for some fifteen hours. A Rhodesian inquiry blamed pilot error. A UN inquiry in 1962 could not rule out sabotage or attack.

Seen from elsewhere. African charcoal burners who said they saw a second aircraft and a flash were discounted by the colonial inquiry. Katanga’s mining interests, Rhodesian settlers and several Western services all had reason to want the UN checked. A UN investigation reopened in 2015 under the Tanzanian judge Mohamed Chande Othman has found an outside attack or threat plausible, and says some governments are still withholding records.

Also on 18 September