Parallax

1 July, 1898

Two hills above Santiago

In one hot afternoon outside Santiago de Cuba, an American army took the heights, a New York politician made himself a national hero, and the Cubans who had fought Spain for three years found they were no longer in charge of their own war.

San Juan Heights, near Santiago de Cuba

The American Fifth Corps had been ashore in Cuba for nine days when its commander, Major General William Shafter, ordered the attack. Shafter weighed some three hundred pounds, was ill with gout and heat, and directed the battle from a cot well to the rear. His plan for 1 July 1898 was simple. One division would take the fortified village of El Caney in a couple of hours, then swing round to join the main assault on the San Juan Heights, the last ridge before the city of Santiago.

Almost nothing went as planned. At El Caney about five hundred Spaniards under General Joaquin Vara del Rey held off more than six thousand Americans until late afternoon, and Vara del Rey died there. Meanwhile the main force, pushed down a single jungle track, piled up at the fords of the San Juan River. An army observation balloon towed along above the column showed the Spanish gunners exactly where to aim. Men lay in the stream bed for an hour or more under rifle fire from an enemy they could not see, since the Spanish Mausers used smokeless powder and the Americans’ older weapons did not.

On the right were the dismounted cavalry regiments: regulars, including the Black troopers of the 9th and 10th Cavalry, and the 1st United States Volunteer Cavalry, the ‘Rough Riders’, a regiment of cowboys, Ivy League athletes and lawmen raised by Theodore Roosevelt, who had resigned as Assistant Secretary of the Navy to go to war. Roosevelt was one of the few men on horseback, the horses having been left behind in Florida. Early in the afternoon, with or without clear orders, the cavalry went up the nearer rise, called Kettle Hill for the sugar-boiling vats on its top. The regiments were mixed together by the time they reached the crest.

To their left, infantry of Brigadier General Jacob Kent’s division faced San Juan Hill proper, with its blockhouse and trenches. What opened the way was a battery of Gatling guns under Lieutenant John Parker, which swept the Spanish trench line for several minutes. The infantry then climbed the slope, led in front by Lieutenant Jules Ord, who was killed at the top. Roosevelt brought men across from Kettle Hill to the northern end of the ridge.

By evening the Americans held the heights and were too exhausted to go further. The day’s two actions cost them well over a thousand killed and wounded. The Spanish, with a fraction of the numbers engaged, lost several hundred. Shafter briefly considered pulling back. Two days later the Spanish squadron in the harbour ran for the open sea and was destroyed, and Santiago surrendered on 17 July.

How it came to this

Cubans had been in arms against Spanish rule, for the second time in a generation, since 1895. The rebel army under Maximo Gomez and Antonio Maceo controlled much of the countryside. Spain’s answer, under General Valeriano Weyler, was to herd the rural population into garrisoned towns, where hunger and disease killed civilians in enormous numbers: most modern estimates run from 150,000 upwards. American newspapers reported the camps at length, and American investors in Cuban sugar wanted the war ended.

On 15 February 1898 the battleship USS Maine blew up in Havana harbour, killing about 260 of her crew. A naval inquiry blamed a mine, the press blamed Spain, and by late April the two countries were at war. Congress attached to its war resolution the Teller Amendment, which disclaimed any intention of annexing Cuba. Commodore Dewey destroyed a Spanish squadron at Manila on 1 May. In June an expedition of about 17,000 men, short of transport, tropical clothing and almost everything else, landed east of Santiago, where a Spanish fleet lay blockaded.

How each side saw it

The Cuban Liberation Army

General Calixto Garcia’s several thousand insurgents covered the American landing at Daiquiri, supplied guides and tied down Spanish reinforcements. They had been fighting for three years and regarded the Americans as allies in a Cuban war. American officers, many of whom despised the ragged and largely Black Cuban troops, used them as labourers and then barred them from entering Santiago at the surrender. Garcia wrote Shafter a letter of protest that was widely printed, saying his men were not savages and resigned his command. Cuban historians, and the American scholar Louis Perez, argue that the very name ‘Spanish-American War’ writes the Cubans out of their own independence struggle.

The Black regulars

Four regiments of Black regular soldiers fought in the campaign, and men of the 9th and 10th Cavalry were on Kettle Hill and San Juan Hill alongside the Rough Riders; white officers present, including the young John Pershing, praised them. In an 1899 magazine account Roosevelt wrote that Black infantrymen had begun drifting to the rear until he threatened them with his revolver. Sergeant Presley Holliday of the 10th Cavalry answered in a letter to the New York Age: the men had been ordered back to fetch ammunition and entrenching tools, and Roosevelt had been told so at the time. Black veterans felt their share had been taken from them.

Spain

Spanish accounts stress how few defenders there were on the heights, a few hundred men until reinforcements arrived, and treat Vara del Rey’s stand at El Caney as the honourable episode of a war the government in Madrid knew it could not win. The conscripts who fought it were mostly poor: families with money could legally buy their sons out of service. The defeat of 1898, known in Spain simply as ‘the Disaster’, ended four centuries of empire in the Americas and set off a long national argument among the writers later called the Generation of ‘98 about what had gone wrong with the country.

What is disputed

Roosevelt’s own book made the charge his, and popular memory put him on San Juan Hill; he in fact led the assault on Kettle Hill and reached the main ridge afterwards. How far he acted on orders, and which regiment reached which crest first, were argued over by participants for years. The army denied him the Medal of Honor in 1898; it was awarded posthumously in 2001, a decision some military historians think owed more to fame than to the record. The cause of the Maine explosion is also unsettled: Admiral Hyman Rickover’s 1976 study concluded that a coal bunker fire, not a Spanish mine, was the likeliest explanation.

What followed

By the Treaty of Paris of December 1898 Spain gave up Cuba and ceded Puerto Rico, Guam and, for twenty million dollars, the Philippines, where an American war against Filipino independence forces began within weeks. Cuba was occupied until 1902 and then made independent under the Platt Amendment, which gave Washington a right of intervention and a naval base at Guantanamo Bay that it still holds. Roosevelt was elected governor of New York that November, became vice-president in 1901 and president six months later when William McKinley was assassinated.

Read further

  • Theodore Roosevelt, The Rough Riders (1899)
  • David F. Trask, The War with Spain in 1898 (1981)
  • Louis A. Perez Jr., The War of 1898: The United States and Cuba in History and Historiography (1998)
  • Edmund Morris, The Rise of Theodore Roosevelt (1979)
  • Philip S. Foner, The Spanish-Cuban-American War and the Birth of American Imperialism (1972)

Same day, other years

1867

Canada becomes a dominion

Ottawa, CanadaThe Americas

The British North America Act came into force on 1 July 1867, joining Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and the Province of Canada, which was divided into Ontario and Quebec, in a self-governing federation under the Crown. John A. Macdonald became its first prime minister. The union had been negotiated by colonial politicians at Charlottetown, Quebec and London over three years, driven by deadlock between English and French Canada, the need for a railway, and fear of the large American army left over from the Civil War. Bells rang and guns fired in Ottawa and Toronto.

Seen from elsewhere. In Halifax some shops hung black crepe: Nova Scotians had never been asked, and anti-confederation candidates took 18 of the province’s 19 federal seats that autumn. Indigenous nations were not consulted at all. The Act placed ‘Indians, and lands reserved for the Indians’ under federal authority, the basis for the Indian Act and the residential schools, and many now mark the day in mourning.

1916

The first day on the Somme

Picardy, FranceEurope

At 7.30 on a bright morning, after a week-long bombardment of about a million and a half shells, British and French infantry climbed out of their trenches along a front of some twenty-five miles. The shelling had been expected to destroy the German wire and dugouts. On much of the British front it had done neither, and machine-gunners came up from deep shelters to find lines of men walking towards them. By nightfall the British army had 57,470 casualties, 19,240 of them dead, the worst day in its history. The battle went on until November.

Seen from elsewhere. German regimental histories record the day as a defensive success bought at heavy cost, and the months that followed as the grinding down of their pre-war army. The French, to the south, took most of their objectives. Historians such as Gary Sheffield and William Philpott argue that the Somme taught the British how to fight; others still see needless slaughter.

1960

Two Somali territories unite

Mogadishu, SomaliaAfrica

The Italian-administered Trust Territory of Somaliland became independent on 1 July 1960 and united the same day with the former British Somaliland protectorate, which had been independent for five days. The new Somali Republic, with Aden Abdullah Osman as president and its capital at Mogadishu, was a rare African state built on a single language and people, and its flag’s five-pointed star stood for five Somali-inhabited lands, three of them outside its borders, in Ethiopia, Kenya and French Somaliland. That claim to the missing three shaped the region’s wars for a generation.

Seen from elsewhere. Northerners soon felt the union had been a takeover: the capital, presidency and most senior posts went south, and the north voted against the 1961 constitution. After Siad Barre’s forces bombed Hargeisa in 1988, the north declared in 1991 that it was restoring the independence of 1960. Somaliland has governed itself since, with almost no international recognition.

1997

Hong Kong returns to China

Hong KongAsia

At midnight on 30 June the Union flag came down in the Hong Kong convention centre and the flag of the People’s Republic went up, watched by Prince Charles, President Jiang Zemin and the last governor, Chris Patten. Britain had taken Hong Kong Island in 1842 after the First Opium War and Kowloon in 1860, but the New Territories were held on a 99-year lease that expired in 1997. Under the Joint Declaration of 1984 the territory was promised its own laws, courts and way of life for fifty years, the formula known as ‘one country, two systems’.

Seen from elsewhere. For Beijing the night closed a century of humiliation that began with the opium trade. Democrats led by Martin Lee protested from the legislature’s balcony as the elected chamber was replaced by an appointed one. Since the national security law of 2020 Britain says the Declaration has been breached; China says it is a historical document with no present force.

Also on 1 July