Parallax

16 July, 1212

Three Christian kings defeat the Almohad caliph at Las Navas de Tolosa

A crusading army found its way through a blocked mountain pass, by a shepherd’s path, and overran the caliph’s camp in an afternoon. Whether the battle decided the fate of Muslim Spain is a question historians answer differently.

Las Navas de Tolosa, Sierra Morena, Spain

The crusade assembled at Toledo in the spring of 1212, and was in trouble before it left. Knights and foot soldiers from France, led by the archbishops of Narbonne and Bordeaux, had answered the pope’s call in such numbers that the city could not feed them, and some of them attacked Toledo’s Jews until Castilian knights drove them off. On 20 June Alfonso VIII of Castile led them south, with Peter II of Aragon and the military orders.

The first fortress, Malagon, was stormed by the French and its garrison slaughtered. At the second, Calatrava, Alfonso accepted a surrender on terms and let the Muslim defenders walk away. The northerners were disgusted. Complaining of the heat, the food and the leniency, most of them turned for home on 3 July, and Toledo shut its gates against them as they passed. Sancho VII of Navarre, an old enemy of Castile, arrived late with two hundred knights to make up a little of the loss.

The Almohad caliph, Muhammad al-Nasir, waited on the far side of the Sierra Morena with a larger army, and held the one obvious pass. The Christian leaders were debating retreat when, according to the letter Alfonso sent the pope and the chronicle written by Archbishop Rodrigo of Toledo, who was there, a local shepherd came to the camp and offered to show them another way. He led them by a track over the heights to a tableland above the Muslim position. They camped there on Saturday 14 July, declined battle on the Sunday, and at dawn on Monday 16 July came down in three columns, Castile in the centre, Aragon on the left and Navarre on the right.

The Almohad light troops gave way, drew the Christian vanguard on, and then the main body counter-attacked and came close to breaking it. Rodrigo records that Alfonso turned to him and said, ‘Archbishop, let us die here, you and I.’ The archbishop told him they would win instead. Alfonso committed his reserve, the line held, and the three kings’ cavalry drove uphill to the palisade round the caliph’s red tent. When it was breached, al-Nasir mounted and rode for Jaen. His army dissolved, and the pursuit went on until dark.

The victors spent two days gathering plunder. Then they took Baeza, which was empty, and Ubeda, which was not: its people offered a ransom, the bishops forbade any bargain with infidels, and the town was sacked and its inhabitants enslaved. Dysentery spread through the camp, and the army went home.

How it came to this

Muslim armies had conquered most of the Iberian peninsula after 711, and for three centuries al-Andalus, ruled from Cordoba, was the richest and most learned society in western Europe. When the caliphate broke up after 1009 the Christian kingdoms of the north began to push south, taking Toledo in 1085. Twice Berber movements from Morocco crossed the strait to stop them and to impose stricter religion: the Almoravids from 1086 and then the Almohads, who taught an uncompromising doctrine of God’s unity and ruled an empire from Marrakesh that reached Tripoli.

In 1195 the Almohad caliph Yaqub al-Mansur crushed Alfonso VIII at Alarcos, and Castile lost its southern frontier. The Christian kings spent the following years fighting each other. Alfonso waited for his truces to expire and then provoked a new war. In 1211 al-Nasir crossed with a great army and took Salvatierra, the castle of the knights of Calatrava. Pope Innocent III, urged by Archbishop Rodrigo, granted the indulgences of a crusade and ordered the Spanish kings to keep peace among themselves. The kings of Leon and Portugal stayed away, though some of their knights came.

How each side saw it

Castile and the Church

Alfonso’s letter to Innocent III presents the victory as a miracle. It claims the caliph had 185,000 horsemen, that 100,000 Muslims fell and that only twenty-five or thirty Christians died. Archbishop Rodrigo’s history, written a generation later, makes the same case with more art: God led the army through the mountains and broke a host no human force could have beaten. The pope had the letter read aloud in Rome. The Spanish church kept 16 July as the feast of the Triumph of the Holy Cross, and a banner said to be the caliph’s hangs in the convent of Las Huelgas at Burgos.

Almohad and Andalusi writers

Muslim historians called the battle al-Iqab and treated it as a catastrophe with human causes. Abd al-Wahid al-Marrakushi, writing in 1224, says the troops had not been paid and fought without conviction, some not drawing their swords, in resentment at the caliph’s viziers. He and Ibn Idhari report that al-Nasir had executed the Andalusi commander who surrendered Calatrava, a respected frontier veteran, and that the Andalusi contingents never forgave it. The later Moroccan chronicler Ibn Abi Zar gives vast and unreliable numbers. All agree that the caliph shut himself away afterwards in Marrakesh, where he died the next year.

The crusaders from beyond the Pyrenees

The French who left before the battle were mocked by Spanish writers ever after, but they had their own view, visible in the letter of Arnaud Amalric, the archbishop of Narbonne, who stayed, and in northern chronicles. They had come from the war against heretics in Languedoc expecting to give no quarter to God’s enemies, and found a king who spared Muslim garrisons, kept Muslim subjects and protected Jews. The frontier’s habits of truce, tribute and surrender on terms, which had governed Spanish warfare for centuries, looked to them like collusion. To the Castilians the newcomers were dangerous guests.

Modern historians

Spanish national history long made Las Navas the turning point of the Reconquest, and Ambrosio Huici Miranda’s reconstruction of the campaign remains a foundation. Francisco Garcia Fitz and Martin Alvira Cabrer have since cut the armies to perhaps 12,000 Christians and 20,000 to 30,000 Almohads, and stressed how much of the story was shaped by the liturgy and propaganda that followed. Others question the frame itself: the word Reconquista is modern, and the idea of a single eight-century war of recovery flattens long periods of alliance across the religious line, including Sancho of Navarre’s own earlier dealings with the Almohads.

What is disputed

The claim that the battle ended Muslim power in Spain overstates it. The Christian kings could not follow up, Alfonso died in 1214, and the Almohad empire collapsed a decade later through disputed successions and revolt in Morocco. The great conquests of Cordoba and Seville came in 1236 and 1248, and Granada lasted until 1492. The shepherd is anonymous in the earliest sources; his name, Martin Alhaja, and his identification with Saint Isidore are later. The story that the caliph’s tent was ringed by chained slave guards, and that Navarre’s coat of arms shows those chains, is first told long afterwards, and the Las Huelgas banner may be a later textile.

What followed

Al-Nasir died in 1213, leaving a boy as heir, and the Almohad state broke apart in the 1220s. Andalusi leaders turned against their Berber rulers, and Ferdinand III of Castile and James I of Aragon took the Guadalquivir valley, Valencia and the Balearics within a generation, expelling or subjecting large Muslim populations. Only the emirate of Granada survived, as a tributary of Castile. In Spain the battle has been claimed in turn by the Church, by liberal nationalists and by Franco’s regime, and its eighth centenary in 2012 prompted both commemoration and argument about what was being commemorated.

Read further

  • Joseph F. O’Callaghan, Reconquest and Crusade in Medieval Spain (2003)
  • Francisco Garcia Fitz, Las Navas de Tolosa (2005)
  • Martin Alvira Cabrer, Las Navas de Tolosa, 1212: idea, liturgia y memoria de la batalla (2012)
  • Hugh Kennedy, Muslim Spain and Portugal: A Political History of al-Andalus (1996)
  • Ambrosio Huici Miranda, Las grandes batallas de la Reconquista durante las invasiones africanas (1956)

Same day, other years

AD 622

The day from which the Muslim calendar is counted

Mecca and Medina, ArabiaMiddle East

The Islamic era begins on the first day of the month of Muharram in the year Muhammad left Mecca for the oasis of Yathrib, later Medina. By the usual conversion that day was Friday 16 July 622 in the Julian calendar. It is not the date of the journey itself. Muhammad and Abu Bakr slipped out of Mecca about two months later and reached the edge of Medina in late September. The reckoning was fixed some seventeen years afterwards, when the caliph Umar, needing a common system for dating letters and accounts across a new empire, consulted the Prophet’s companions. They chose the year of the emigration, the founding of the community, over his birth or first revelation.

Seen from elsewhere. Astronomers’ tables begin the era a day earlier, on 15 July, which is the date many almanacs give. How the Meccan leaders saw the departure is known only from Muslim tradition written down generations later, chiefly Ibn Ishaq’s biography, and some modern scholars doubt that the early chronology can be recovered in detail.

1809

La Paz rises against Spanish rule

La Paz, Upper Peru (now Bolivia)The Americas

Napoleon had deposed the Spanish king in 1808, and across the empire people asked who now held authority. On the evening of 16 July 1809, during the procession of the Virgin of Carmen, conspirators in La Paz seized the barracks, forced the governor and the bishop to resign, and set up a governing council, the Junta Tuitiva, under Pedro Domingo Murillo, a mestizo lawyer and militia officer. It abolished debts to the treasury and called for representation of the Indian communities. A royalist army sent from Cuzco retook the city in October. Murillo and eight others were hanged in January 1810. Bolivia, which became independent in 1825, keeps the day as the anniversary of La Paz.

Seen from elsewhere. The junta proclaimed loyalty to the captive Ferdinand VII, and historians disagree on whether that was sincere or a mask for independence. A fiery proclamation attributed to it is of doubtful authenticity. Sucre, which rose on 25 May, disputes La Paz’s claim to the first cry of liberty. The Aymara majority took little part.

1942

French police round up the Jews of Paris

Paris, German-occupied FranceEurope

Before dawn on 16 July 1942 several thousand French policemen, working from a card index compiled by the Paris prefecture, began arresting foreign and stateless Jews across the city. In two days they took 13,152 people, of whom more than 4,000 were children. Single adults were sent to the camp at Drancy. Families, some 8,000 people, were shut in the Velodrome d’Hiver, an indoor cycling stadium near the Eiffel Tower, for five days in summer heat with almost no water, food or working lavatories. They were then moved to camps in the Loiret, where children were separated from their parents, and from there to Auschwitz. Fewer than a hundred of the adults came back, and none of the children.

Seen from elsewhere. The Germans demanded the arrests; Vichy’s police chief, Rene Bousquet, agreed that French police would make them, and Pierre Laval proposed including the children. The target had been about 27,000, and many were warned and hidden by neighbours and some policemen. Presidents from de Gaulle to Mitterrand held that Vichy was not France. Jacques Chirac acknowledged the state’s responsibility in 1995.

1945

The first atomic bomb is tested in New Mexico

Jornada del Muerto, New Mexico, United StatesThe Americas

At 5.29 on the morning of 16 July 1945, after a night of thunderstorms, a plutonium device hoisted on a steel tower in the New Mexico desert was detonated by the scientists of the Manhattan Project. The flash was seen more than 150 miles away. The explosion, equivalent to about 20,000 tons of TNT, vaporised the tower, fused the sand into green glass and sent a cloud eight miles high. The test director, Kenneth Bainbridge, told Robert Oppenheimer that now they were all sons of bitches. Oppenheimer said twenty years later that a line from the Bhagavad Gita had come to his mind: ‘Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds.’ Word was cabled to President Truman at Potsdam. Hiroshima was bombed three weeks later.

Seen from elsewhere. Tens of thousands of people, many of them Hispanic ranchers and Mescalero Apache, lived within fifty miles and were neither warned nor evacuated; ash fell on their cisterns, crops and cattle. Their descendants, the Tularosa Basin Downwinders, report generations of cancers, and were left out of the 1990 federal compensation law, which they campaigned for decades to change.

Also on 16 July