Parallax

10 July, 1099

El Cid dies in the city he took for himself

Rodrigo Diaz had fought for Christian kings and Muslim ones, and ended as the independent lord of Valencia. The legend that his corpse rode out to win one more battle came later, from the monks who kept his tomb.

Valencia, eastern Spain

Rodrigo Diaz died in Valencia in July 1099, aged about fifty-six, in his bed. For five years he had ruled the richest city on Spain’s eastern coast as a prince answerable to nobody, a Castilian nobleman governing a Muslim population with a mixed army of Christians and Muslims paid from the tribute of the surrounding lords. He had no kingdom behind him and no heir: his only son, Diego, had been killed two years earlier fighting the Almoravids at Consuegra.

He had taken the city by starving it. Valencia’s ruler, an ally who paid him for protection, was overthrown and killed in 1092 by a faction led by the city’s chief judge, Ibn Jahhaf, who looked to the Almoravids of Morocco for help. Rodrigo laid siege. Over twenty months he burned the suburbs, cut off the food, and drove those who tried to leave back inside the walls. Arabic accounts describe people eating rats and leather. The city surrendered in June 1094. Rodrigo promised to respect its laws, then had Ibn Jahhaf tortured for the whereabouts of the dead ruler’s treasure and burned alive.

That October an Almoravid army came to take Valencia back, and Rodrigo destroyed it at Cuarte, outside the walls, by a sortie that caught the besiegers between two forces. It was the first clear defeat the Almoravids had suffered in Spain. He beat them again at Bairen in 1097. In 1098 he turned the main mosque into a cathedral and installed a French bishop, Jerome of Perigord. The charter recording the gift calls him ‘prince Rodrigo the Campeador’.

After his death his widow, Jimena, held the city for three more years. In 1102, with the Almoravids closing in again, she appealed to Alfonso VI of Castile. The king came, judged Valencia too far away to keep, evacuated the Christians and burned it. Jimena carried her husband’s body north to the monastery of San Pedro de Cardena, near Burgos.

It was at Cardena, generations later, that the best-known story grew up. In the monks’ telling, the dying Cid had himself embalmed, and when a Moorish king named Bucar besieged Valencia the corpse was strapped upright on the warhorse Babieca, sword in hand, and led out at the head of the garrison. The enemy fled at the sight. No source written within a century of his death knows anything of this. It entered the great Castilian chronicle compiled for Alfonso X in the later thirteenth century, and from there it passed into ballads, plays and, in 1961, a Hollywood film.

How it came to this

Rodrigo was born around 1043 at Vivar, a village near Burgos, into the lesser Castilian nobility. He rose in the household of Sancho II of Castile, and after Sancho was murdered outside Zamora in 1072 he served Sancho’s brother and successor, Alfonso VI, who married him to a kinswoman, Jimena. In 1081, after Rodrigo led an unauthorised raid into the Muslim kingdom of Toledo, which was under Alfonso’s protection, the king exiled him.

Spain was then a patchwork. The caliphate of Cordoba had broken up earlier in the century into rival city states, the taifas, which paid Christian kings for protection and hired Christian soldiers. Rodrigo took his followers to the Muslim rulers of Zaragoza and fought for them for five years, against the Christian king of Aragon and the count of Barcelona among others. His men called him by the Arabic title sayyid, lord, which became Cid. Meanwhile Alfonso’s capture of Toledo in 1085 frightened the taifa kings into inviting the Almoravids, a Berber reform movement from the Sahara, who defeated Alfonso in 1086 and then began removing the taifa kings themselves. Rodrigo was briefly reconciled with Alfonso, exiled again in 1089, and from then on worked for himself.

How each side saw it

Arabic writers of al-Andalus

The fullest account of the siege was written by a Valencian who lived through it, Ibn Alqama, whose work survives in extracts copied by later chroniclers; its title is usually translated as a clear exposition of the disastrous tragedy. Ibn Bassam of Santarem, writing about a decade after Rodrigo’s death, calls him a dog and a tyrant, describes the burning of Ibn Jahhaf, and then adds that this man, by his appetite for glory, his prudence and his firmness, was one of the miracles of God. Both treat him as a calamity for Islam in Spain, and neither treats him as a crusader.

The Castilian tradition

The Latin Historia Roderici, probably written within a few decades of his death, is a soldier’s record that reports his service to Zaragoza without embarrassment. The vernacular epic, the Poem of the Cid, which survives in a copy made by one Per Abbat, turns him into the model vassal: wronged by his king, loyal anyway, a good husband and father who wins back his honour. From the nineteenth century he was made a national hero, and Ramon Menendez Pidal’s great study of 1929 presented him as the embodiment of Castile. Under Franco, who unveiled his statue at Burgos in 1955, he stood for the crusade against Spain’s enemies.

Jimena Diaz

Rodrigo’s wife left no account, and the epic gives her little to do but pray and be rescued. The documents suggest more. A marriage settlement survives, as do charters she issued in her own name as ruler of Valencia after 1099, including a grant to the cathedral in 1101. She held a frontier city against the Almoravids for three years with her husband’s soldiers, negotiated its evacuation, and organised the removal of his body. She was probably related to the royal house of Leon. She died some time after 1113 and was buried beside him at Cardena.

Modern historians

The Dutch orientalist Reinhart Dozy caused outrage in 1849 by using the Arabic sources to argue that the real Rodrigo was a cruel and faithless mercenary. Menendez Pidal spent a career answering him. Richard Fletcher’s account of 1989 set both aside: Rodrigo was a professional soldier of a kind common on that frontier, neither patriot nor traitor, because the Spain he is said to have fought for did not yet exist as an idea. More recent Spanish scholarship has concentrated on how the monks of Cardena built a cult around the tomb.

What is disputed

The Historia Roderici says only that he died in Valencia in July 1099; the day, 10 July, comes from later tradition and cannot be checked. The posthumous victory is legend, first told at Cardena in the thirteenth century. The date of the Poem of the Cid is argued over: the surviving manuscript carries a date equivalent to 1207, and scholars differ on whether that is when it was composed or copied, and whether an oral epic lay behind it. The famous oath he supposedly forced on Alfonso VI at Burgos, swearing innocence of his brother’s murder, appears in no early source and is generally regarded as invention.

What followed

Valencia stayed in Muslim hands until James I of Aragon took it in 1238. Rodrigo’s daughters married into the ruling houses of Navarre and Barcelona, so that later kings of Castile and many European dynasties descend from him. His bones, moved several times and scattered during the Napoleonic occupation, were reburied under the crossing of Burgos Cathedral in 1921. The argument about him has outlasted every regime that tried to claim him, and he remains a test of how Spain chooses to remember eight centuries in which Christians and Muslims fought, traded and governed alongside one another.

Read further

  • Richard Fletcher, The Quest for El Cid (1989)
  • Simon Barton and Richard Fletcher, The World of El Cid: Chronicles of the Spanish Reconquest (2000)
  • Ramon Menendez Pidal, La Espana del Cid (1929)
  • The Poem of the Cid, translated by Rita Hamilton and Janet Perry (1975)

Same day, other years

1553

Lady Jane Grey is proclaimed Queen of England

Tower of London, EnglandEurope

Edward VI died on 6 July 1553, aged fifteen. In his last weeks he had drawn up a document setting aside his half-sisters, Mary and Elizabeth, as illegitimate and leaving the crown to his Protestant cousin Jane Grey, sixteen, recently married to a son of the Duke of Northumberland, who ran the government. On 10 July Jane was brought by barge to the Tower and proclaimed queen by heralds in a silent city. Mary, meanwhile, had ridden to East Anglia and raised her standard. The gentry, the fleet and finally the council went over to her, and on 19 July she was proclaimed in London to bonfires. Jane was beheaded the following February.

Seen from elsewhere. Mary’s supporters held that she was heir by her father’s will and by statute, which a dying boy could not overturn. The older view made Jane the puppet of Northumberland’s ambition. Eric Ives argued instead that the scheme was Edward’s own, and that Jane, who refused to make her husband king, had the better claim in law.

1806

Indian soldiers rise against the East India Company at Vellore

Vellore, Madras Presidency, IndiaAsia

In the early hours of 10 July 1806, sepoys of the Madras Army garrisoning the fort at Vellore turned on the British troops quartered with them, killing more than a hundred officers and men in their barracks and beds. New dress regulations had ordered the sepoys to wear a round hat resembling a European’s, shave their beards and remove caste marks and earrings on parade, which many took as a first step to forced conversion. The sons of Tipu Sultan, held in the fort since their father’s defeat in 1799, were proclaimed, and the flag of Mysore was raised. By mid-morning cavalry under Rollo Gillespie had ridden from Arcot, blown in the gate and killed several hundred sepoys.

Seen from elsewhere. British inquiries split between blaming the regulations and blaming a conspiracy by Tipu’s family; the governor of Madras, William Bentinck, and the commander-in-chief were both recalled. In India, and in Tamil Nadu especially, Vellore is remembered as a first war of resistance, half a century before 1857. The sepoys left no testimony of their own beyond what courts martial recorded.

1941

The Jews of Jedwabne are murdered by their neighbours

Jedwabne, German-occupied PolandEurope

Jedwabne is a small town in north-eastern Poland that had been under Soviet occupation from 1939 until the German invasion in June 1941. On 10 July, a group of Polish men from the town and nearby villages rounded up their Jewish neighbours in the market square, beat and humiliated them, killed some on the spot, and drove the rest into a barn on the edge of town, which was then set alight. German police were present. For sixty years a memorial stone blamed the Gestapo. In 2000 the historian Jan Gross published an account based largely on post-war trial records and survivor testimony, and a national argument began.

Seen from elsewhere. Gross put the dead at 1,600. Poland’s Institute of National Remembrance, after an investigation and a partial exhumation halted on religious grounds, concluded that Poles carried out the killing with German encouragement and estimated at least 340 victims. President Kwasniewski apologised at the site in 2001. Some Polish politicians and historians still hold that Germans were the real perpetrators.

1985

French agents sink the Rainbow Warrior

Auckland, New ZealandOceania

The Greenpeace ship Rainbow Warrior was moored in Auckland, preparing to lead a protest flotilla to Moruroa atoll in French Polynesia, where France tested nuclear weapons. Shortly before midnight on 10 July 1985 two limpet mines attached to the hull by divers exploded a few minutes apart. The crew got off after the first, but Fernando Pereira, a Portuguese-born Dutch photographer, went below for his cameras and drowned when the second went off. New Zealand police arrested two officers of the French foreign intelligence service travelling as a Swiss couple. Paris denied involvement for two months, until Le Monde showed a third team had planted the bombs. The defence minister resigned.

Seen from elsewhere. French governments of the time regarded the tests as essential to an independent deterrent and Greenpeace as a threat to them. The two agents, convicted of manslaughter, were moved to a French atoll under a UN-brokered deal and home within three years. Polynesians have long argued that the larger wrong was the 193 tests themselves and their effect on islanders’ health.

Also on 10 July