Parallax

6 July, 1535

Thomas More goes to the block

Henry VIII’s former Lord Chancellor, the author of Utopia and a hunter of heretics, was beheaded for refusing to say that the king was head of the Church. He joked on the scaffold.

Tower Hill, London

Early on the morning of 6 July 1535 a court official, Sir Thomas Pope, came to Thomas More’s cell in the Tower of London to tell him he would die before nine and that the king wished him to say little at his execution. More thanked him for the news. He had been a prisoner for nearly fifteen months, was fifty-seven, grey-bearded and unwell. The day before, he had written to his daughter Margaret Roper with a piece of charcoal, since his pens had been taken away, sending back his hair shirt and saying that tomorrow would be a fitting day for him to go to God: it was the eve of the feast of St Thomas Becket.

He had been tried five days earlier in Westminster Hall under a new law that made it treason to deny the king’s title as Supreme Head of the Church of England. For more than a year More had refused to swear to it and had refused, with a lawyer’s care, to say why, arguing that silence could not be treason. The Crown’s case rested on Richard Rich, the Solicitor General, who testified that in a conversation in the Tower More had said Parliament could not make the king head of the Church. More told the court that Rich was a perjurer. The jury took about a quarter of an hour. Only then, condemned, did More say openly that no English statute could override the universal Church.

The sentence of hanging, drawing and quartering was commuted by the king to beheading. At Tower Hill the scaffold was rickety, and according to his son-in-law William Roper, More said to the Lieutenant of the Tower: ‘I pray you, Master Lieutenant, see me safe up, and for my coming down let me shift for myself.’ He asked the crowd to pray for him and to bear witness that he died in and for the faith of the Catholic Church. A report circulating in Paris within weeks has him say that he died the king’s good servant and God’s first.

He knelt, recited the psalm Miserere, and told the executioner to take courage and mind his aim, because his neck was short. He bandaged his own eyes. One stroke was enough.

The body was buried in the Tower chapel of St Peter ad Vincula. The head was parboiled and set on a pole on London Bridge, where it replaced that of Bishop John Fisher, executed two weeks before for the same refusal. Margaret Roper is said to have bribed the man whose job it was to throw it in the river.

How it came to this

More, a London lawyer’s son, had made a European name as a humanist scholar, the friend of Erasmus and author in 1516 of Utopia, the account of an imaginary island with no private property. He rose in royal service to become Lord Chancellor in 1529, a layman in a post usually held by churchmen, after Cardinal Wolsey fell for failing to obtain the annulment of Henry’s marriage to Katherine of Aragon. More never supported the annulment and stayed silent about it. In office he devoted his energy to the campaign against Lutheran heresy, in print and through the courts.

When the clergy submitted to the king’s authority in May 1532 he resigned the next day. Henry married Anne Boleyn, and Parliament passed acts settling the succession on her children and declaring the king Supreme Head of the Church. In April 1534 More was summoned to Lambeth to take the oath attached to the succession act. He would swear to the succession, he said, but not to the preamble rejecting papal authority. He was sent to the Tower. A few weeks before his trial, Carthusian monks who had refused the same oath were dragged past his window to be disembowelled at Tyburn.

How each side saw it

The Crown

To Henry and his minister Thomas Cromwell, More was a subject defying a law made by king and Parliament, and a dangerous one because of his fame abroad. Cromwell visited him repeatedly to seek a form of words he could accept, which suggests the government would have preferred his submission to his death. The London chronicler Edward Hall, a supporter of the king’s proceedings, was exasperated by a man who could not die without a jest, and wrote that he did not know whether to call More a foolish wise man or a wise foolish man. Parliamentary sovereignty in religion, the principle More died denying, became the foundation of the English state.

English Protestants

Those More had pursued remembered him differently. Six people were burned for heresy during his chancellorship, and he was closely involved in at least three of the cases; in print he defended the burnings as just and necessary. John Foxe’s Book of Martyrs accused him of having suspects whipped at a tree in his Chelsea garden. More denied that in his Apology of 1533, admitting only to having had a boy and a madman beaten. William Tyndale, whom More attacked across half a million words of polemic, was strangled and burned near Brussels the year after More’s own death.

The Catholic tradition

The family, led by Margaret Roper, preserved his letters from the Tower, and lives by Roper and by Nicholas Harpsfield circulated in manuscript under Elizabeth, when to own them was risky. For English Catholics he was the layman who would not let the state define his conscience, and across Catholic Europe his death, with Fisher’s, was taken as proof of Henry’s tyranny. Roper reports the Emperor Charles V saying he would rather have lost his best city than such a counsellor. More was beatified in 1886 and canonised in 1935. In 2000 Pope John Paul II named him patron of statesmen and politicians.

Modern historians

R. W. Chambers in 1935 drew the saintly More who then reached millions through Robert Bolt’s play A Man for All Seasons. Geoffrey Elton and, in 1984, the biographer Richard Marius pushed back with a harsher, more anguished figure: ambitious, obsessed with heresy, more interested in obedience than in freedom of conscience as now understood. Hilary Mantel’s novel Wolf Hall carried that version to a wide public. John Guy has argued that the evidence is too thin and too coloured by both camps to settle the matter, and that More’s notion of conscience meant fidelity to the Church’s consensus, not private judgment.

What is disputed

The scaffold sayings come from Roper, who was not present and wrote some twenty years later, and from Hall. The tale that More moved his beard clear of the block because it had committed no treason appears only in later tradition. His dying words survive in indirect speech, and the familiar wording with ‘but God’s first’ is a later polish. ‘A man for all seasons’ is the grammarian Robert Whittington’s English phrase of 1520, not Erasmus’s, though Erasmus had said something similar in Latin. Whether Rich lied at the trial cannot be proved; some legal historians think he reported a hypothetical discussion accurately and that it was fatal anyway.

What followed

Europe was shocked, and Henry’s standing abroad never fully recovered. At home the executions showed that no rank or reputation gave protection, and the dissolution of the monasteries followed within a year. Richard Rich prospered and became Lord Chancellor himself. More’s Utopia gave a word to every language, his prison writings are counted among the best English prose of the century, and both sides of every later argument about conscience and the state have wanted him. Soviet authorities listed him on a Moscow monument to forerunners of socialism; the Catholic Church made him a saint.

Read further

  • William Roper, The Life of Sir Thomas More (written c. 1557)
  • Peter Ackroyd, The Life of Thomas More (1998)
  • John Guy, Thomas More (2000)
  • Richard Marius, Thomas More: A Biography (1984)
  • R. W. Chambers, Thomas More (1935)

Same day, other years

1415

Jan Hus is burned at Constance

Constance, Holy Roman EmpireEurope

The Czech priest and Prague university master Jan Hus had come to the Council of Constance under a safe-conduct from the Emperor-elect Sigismund to defend his teaching on the Church, much of it drawn from the Englishman John Wyclif. He was arrested within weeks. On 6 July 1415, in the cathedral, he was condemned as a heretic, stripped of his priestly vestments and crowned with a paper hat painted with devils. He refused to recant opinions he said he had never held. He was burned outside the walls the same day and his ashes thrown into the Rhine.

Seen from elsewhere. The council held that a promise of safe passage could not shield a heretic from the Church’s own court. In Bohemia the burning set off a revolution and fifteen years of Hussite wars, and 6 July is a Czech public holiday. Pope John Paul II expressed deep regret for Hus’s cruel death in 1999.

1885

Pasteur tries his rabies vaccine on a boy

Paris, FranceEurope

Joseph Meister, aged nine, had been badly bitten by a rabid dog in Alsace two days before his mother brought him to Louis Pasteur’s laboratory. Pasteur was a chemist, not a licensed doctor, and his method, injecting emulsions of dried spinal cord from infected rabbits in increasing strength, had been used only on dogs. After consulting two physicians he agreed. One of them, Joseph Grancher, gave the first injection on the evening of 6 July 1885 and a dozen more over the following ten days. The boy stayed well. Within a year thousands had been treated, and public donations built the Pasteur Institute.

Seen from elsewhere. The historian Gerald Geison, reading Pasteur’s private notebooks in the 1990s, found that the method used on Meister had been tested on animals less thoroughly than Pasteur claimed in public. His collaborator Emile Roux refused to take part. Since most people bitten by rabid animals do not develop rabies, one survivor proved little by itself.

1887

Hawaii’s king signs the ‘Bayonet Constitution’

Honolulu, Hawaiian KingdomOceania

On 6 July 1887 King Kalakaua, faced with an armed militia controlled by a league of mostly American and European businessmen and lawyers, signed a constitution they had written in a few days. It took away his power to appoint the upper house and dismiss ministers and made the cabinet answerable to the legislature. It also rewrote the franchise. High property and income qualifications for the upper house shut out most Native Hawaiians, Asian immigrants were excluded altogether, and white foreign residents could vote without becoming subjects. Six years later the same men overthrew the monarchy.

Seen from elsewhere. The league called it reform of a corrupt and spendthrift court, pointing to a bribery scandal over an opium licence. Kalakaua’s sister and successor Liliuokalani wrote in her 1898 memoir that he signed under threat of death. Native Hawaiians petitioned in thousands for a new constitution, and the United States Congress formally apologised for the 1893 overthrow in 1993.

1967

Nigeria’s civil war begins

Northern border of Biafra, NigeriaAfrica

Federal Nigerian troops crossed into the breakaway Eastern Region on 6 July 1967 in what Lagos first called a police action. The east, under Colonel Odumegwu Ojukwu, had declared itself the Republic of Biafra five weeks earlier, after two military coups in 1966 and massacres of Igbo people in northern cities that killed many thousands and sent more than a million fleeing home. The war lasted thirty months. Biafra shrank to a blockaded enclave, and photographs of starving children reached televisions across the world. Estimates of the dead, most of them from hunger, range from one to three million.

Seen from elsewhere. General Gowon’s government fought, it said, to keep Nigeria one, and declared ‘no victor, no vanquished’ at the end. Biafrans accused it of genocide by starvation; federal leaders replied that Ojukwu refused supervised daylight relief to prolong the war. Britain and the Soviet Union armed Lagos. Nigeria has never agreed on how to remember it.

Also on 6 July