Early on the morning of 6 July 1535 a court official, Sir Thomas Pope, came to Thomas More’s cell in the Tower of London to tell him he would die before nine and that the king wished him to say little at his execution. More thanked him for the news. He had been a prisoner for nearly fifteen months, was fifty-seven, grey-bearded and unwell. The day before, he had written to his daughter Margaret Roper with a piece of charcoal, since his pens had been taken away, sending back his hair shirt and saying that tomorrow would be a fitting day for him to go to God: it was the eve of the feast of St Thomas Becket.
He had been tried five days earlier in Westminster Hall under a new law that made it treason to deny the king’s title as Supreme Head of the Church of England. For more than a year More had refused to swear to it and had refused, with a lawyer’s care, to say why, arguing that silence could not be treason. The Crown’s case rested on Richard Rich, the Solicitor General, who testified that in a conversation in the Tower More had said Parliament could not make the king head of the Church. More told the court that Rich was a perjurer. The jury took about a quarter of an hour. Only then, condemned, did More say openly that no English statute could override the universal Church.
The sentence of hanging, drawing and quartering was commuted by the king to beheading. At Tower Hill the scaffold was rickety, and according to his son-in-law William Roper, More said to the Lieutenant of the Tower: ‘I pray you, Master Lieutenant, see me safe up, and for my coming down let me shift for myself.’ He asked the crowd to pray for him and to bear witness that he died in and for the faith of the Catholic Church. A report circulating in Paris within weeks has him say that he died the king’s good servant and God’s first.
He knelt, recited the psalm Miserere, and told the executioner to take courage and mind his aim, because his neck was short. He bandaged his own eyes. One stroke was enough.
The body was buried in the Tower chapel of St Peter ad Vincula. The head was parboiled and set on a pole on London Bridge, where it replaced that of Bishop John Fisher, executed two weeks before for the same refusal. Margaret Roper is said to have bribed the man whose job it was to throw it in the river.
How it came to this
More, a London lawyer’s son, had made a European name as a humanist scholar, the friend of Erasmus and author in 1516 of Utopia, the account of an imaginary island with no private property. He rose in royal service to become Lord Chancellor in 1529, a layman in a post usually held by churchmen, after Cardinal Wolsey fell for failing to obtain the annulment of Henry’s marriage to Katherine of Aragon. More never supported the annulment and stayed silent about it. In office he devoted his energy to the campaign against Lutheran heresy, in print and through the courts.
When the clergy submitted to the king’s authority in May 1532 he resigned the next day. Henry married Anne Boleyn, and Parliament passed acts settling the succession on her children and declaring the king Supreme Head of the Church. In April 1534 More was summoned to Lambeth to take the oath attached to the succession act. He would swear to the succession, he said, but not to the preamble rejecting papal authority. He was sent to the Tower. A few weeks before his trial, Carthusian monks who had refused the same oath were dragged past his window to be disembowelled at Tyburn.