Parallax

21 July, 1403

Hotspur falls at Shrewsbury

The family that had put Henry IV on the throne tried to take him off it. The battle was the first in which English longbowmen shot at each other in mass, and it left a sixteen-year-old prince with an arrowhead six inches deep in his face.

Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England

Henry Percy, known to the Scots and then to everyone as Hotspur, rode south from Northumberland in early July 1403 with a small following and raised an army in Cheshire, a county of archers that had been loyal to the deposed Richard II. He let it be said at first that Richard was alive. Then he and his uncle Thomas Percy, Earl of Worcester, issued a defiance accusing King Henry of perjury, of starving Richard to death, and of keeping the true heir, the young Earl of March, from the crown.

Henry IV was in the Midlands, on his way north, as it happened, to help the Percys against the Scots. He turned west and covered the distance fast enough to reach Shrewsbury on 20 July, hours ahead of Hotspur, who had counted on taking the town and with it the king’s eldest son, Prince Henry, who commanded there. Hotspur’s father, the Earl of Northumberland, was still in the north with his own forces. The Welsh leader Owain Glyndwr was far away in the south-west.

The two armies faced each other across a field of ripening peas about three miles north of the town. Most of Saturday 21 July went in negotiation, with the abbot of Shrewsbury carrying offers between the lines. It was late afternoon before the king’s vanguard advanced up the slope. The Cheshire archers shot it to pieces. The chronicler Thomas Walsingham wrote that the king’s men fell like leaves in autumn. The Earl of Stafford, leading them, was killed, and part of the royal army ran.

Hotspur and the Scottish Earl of Douglas, his prisoner turned ally, then charged with a picked company straight at the royal standard to kill the king. They cut down the standard-bearer, Sir Walter Blount, and by some accounts more than one knight dressed in the king’s arms as a decoy. Henry had been pulled back out of the press. On the other wing the prince, hit below the eye by an arrow, refused to leave the field and brought his division round on to the rebels’ flank.

Somewhere in the crush Hotspur was killed, by whom nobody knew; a later tradition says he had lifted his visor for air. When the shout went up that he was dead, his army broke. The fighting had lasted perhaps three hours and ended in the dark. Worcester was beheaded in Shrewsbury two days afterwards. Hotspur’s body, at first given burial, was dug up, propped between two millstones in the market place so that no one could claim he lived, and then quartered.

How it came to this

In 1399 Henry Bolingbroke had returned from exile while Richard II was in Ireland, landing in Yorkshire with a few dozen men. The Percys, the greatest family of the north, met him at Doncaster, where, they later said, he swore on the sacrament that he had come only to recover his confiscated duchy of Lancaster. Within three months Richard had been deposed and Bolingbroke crowned. Richard died in Pontefract castle early in 1400. The Percys were rewarded with offices on the Scottish border and in Wales.

The partnership soured over money and prisoners. The crown, nearly bankrupt, owed the Percys large sums for defending the marches. When they destroyed a Scottish army at Homildon Hill in 1402, Henry demanded the captured nobles for himself, denying them the ransoms. At the same time he refused to ransom Hotspur’s brother-in-law, Sir Edmund Mortimer, taken by Glyndwr, and Mortimer, uncle of the boy with the better hereditary claim to the throne, married Glyndwr’s daughter and joined the Welsh revolt.

How each side saw it

The Percys and Richard’s old adherents

The rebels’ case survives in the manifesto they sent the king before the battle, preserved by the chronicler John Hardyng, who served in Hotspur’s household and was on the field. It is a legal indictment: Henry broke his Doncaster oath, murdered his anointed king, taxed without consent and packed parliaments. The Dieulacres chronicle, written in a Staffordshire abbey with Cheshire sympathies, tells the story from the same side and treats the dead as men who fought for Richard’s right. For Cheshire the battle was a catastrophe that killed a large part of its gentry.

The Lancastrian court

To the king’s supporters the Percys were ingrates who had been given more than any subject and turned traitor when denied still more. Walsingham, the monk of St Albans whose chronicle is the fullest account, writes of Hotspur’s courage and of his treachery in the same breath. Henry founded a chantry on the battlefield, where a church still stands, to pray for the dead of both sides. The victory was also the making of the prince, the future Henry V, and Lancastrian writers lingered on the wounded boy who would not leave the field.

The surgeon

One participant left a first-hand technical record. John Bradmore, a London surgeon, was called to Kenilworth after others had failed to remove the arrowhead lodged in the bone beside the prince’s nose. In his Latin treatise, the Philomena, he describes widening the wound over several days with probes of elder pith wrapped in linen and soaked in honey, then designing a pair of hollow tongs with a screw through the middle to grip the socket of the arrowhead and draw it out. He cleaned the wound with wine and dressed it with honey for twenty days. The prince carried the scar for life.

What is disputed

Shakespeare, following the chronicler Holinshed, made Hotspur and Prince Hal rivals of the same age and had the prince kill him. In fact Hotspur was thirty-nine, older than the king, and no source names his killer. Army sizes are guesses: the king perhaps had the larger force, and estimates for each side run from 5,000 to 14,000. Chroniclers’ figures for the dead are equally loose. Whether Northumberland held back deliberately or was simply too slow has never been settled, nor whether Worcester, as royalist writers claimed, misreported the king’s final offer to his nephew.

What followed

Hotspur’s head was set on Micklegate Bar in York, facing his own country. His father submitted, was pardoned, rebelled twice more and was killed at Bramham Moor in 1408. Glyndwr’s revolt outlasted them all. Henry IV kept his throne but spent the rest of his reign ill and short of money, and the doubt about the Lancastrian title that the Percys had put in writing resurfaced fifty years later as the Yorkist claim. English commanders drew a practical lesson from the day, and Henry V took armies of archers to France twelve years later.

Read further

  • Chris Given-Wilson, Henry IV (2016)
  • Ian Mortimer, The Fears of Henry IV: The Life of England’s Self-Made King (2007)
  • Thomas Walsingham, The St Albans Chronicle, edited by John Taylor, Wendy R. Childs and Leslie Watkiss
  • Philip Morgan, War and Society in Medieval Cheshire, 1277-1403 (1987)
  • John Hardyng, The Chronicle of John Hardyng

Same day, other years

1798

Bonaparte breaks the Mamluks in sight of the pyramids

Embaba, near Cairo, EgyptAfrica

Three weeks after landing at Alexandria, about 25,000 French soldiers reached the west bank of the Nile opposite Cairo and found the army of Murad Bey drawn up at the village of Embaba: several thousand Mamluk horsemen, among the finest cavalry in the world, and a larger body of ill-armed foot. The French formed five great hollow squares with cannon at the corners. The Mamluks charged them repeatedly and were shot down; many of the infantry drowned trying to cross the river. French losses were about 300, their opponents’ several thousand. The pyramids were some nine miles off. Bonaparte entered Cairo three days later. On 1 August Nelson destroyed his fleet at Aboukir.

Seen from elsewhere. The Cairo scholar Abd al-Rahman al-Jabarti recorded the panic in the city, and mocked the grammar and the sincerity of the French proclamation claiming to come as friends of Islam. Cairo rose in revolt that October. The line about forty centuries looking down comes from Napoleon’s own later telling.

1925

A Tennessee jury convicts John Scopes in nine minutes

Dayton, Tennessee, United StatesThe Americas

Tennessee had made it a crime in March to teach in a state-funded school that man descended from a lower order of animals. Businessmen in the small town of Dayton, hoping for publicity, persuaded a twenty-four-year-old teacher to stand as the defendant in a test case offered by the American Civil Liberties Union. William Jennings Bryan, three times a presidential candidate, came to prosecute and Clarence Darrow to defend, and the trial was broadcast live on radio. On the seventh day Darrow called Bryan himself to the stand as an expert on the Bible. The next morning, 21 July, the jury convicted and the judge fined Scopes $100. Bryan died in Dayton five days later.

Seen from elsewhere. Bryan’s objection was partly moral: the textbook at issue taught eugenics and ranked the human races, and he feared a creed of survival of the fittest. He also held that taxpayers decide what their schools teach. The conviction was quashed on a technicality, and the law stood until 1967.

1954

The Geneva accords divide Vietnam

Geneva, SwitzerlandAsia

In the early hours of 21 July, with the clocks in the Palais des Nations stopped so that the French prime minister could claim to have met his self-imposed deadline of the 20th, French and Viet Minh officers signed a ceasefire ending eight years of war. Ten weeks earlier the French garrison at Dien Bien Phu had surrendered. Vietnam was divided provisionally at the seventeenth parallel, with Ho Chi Minh’s forces regrouping to the north and French Union forces to the south, and a final declaration called for nationwide elections in July 1956. Laos and Cambodia were recognised as independent. Within a year perhaps 900,000 people, most of them Catholics, moved south.

Seen from elsewhere. The Viet Minh held most of the country and were pressed by China and the Soviet Union to accept half. The southern State of Vietnam and the United States refused to endorse the declaration, and the south declined to hold the elections, which Eisenhower later wrote Ho would have won.

1972

Bloody Friday in Belfast

Belfast, Northern IrelandEurope

On a busy Friday afternoon the Provisional IRA set off about twenty bombs across Belfast in little more than an hour, at bus and railway stations, a bridge, a hotel, a ferry terminal and shopping streets. Nine people were killed, six at the Oxford Street bus station and three outside a row of shops on the Cavehill Road. They included two soldiers, bus company workers, a mother of seven and three teenage boys. About 130 were injured. Television pictures of firemen shovelling remains into bags did the IRA lasting damage. Ten days later the British army moved in overwhelming force into the barricaded republican districts of Belfast and Derry.

Seen from elsewhere. The IRA said it had telephoned warnings for every bomb and accused the authorities of ignoring some to turn opinion against it; the security forces said they were swamped by real and hoax calls. The year had begun with soldiers shooting thirteen marchers dead in Derry. In 2002 the IRA apologised to the families of civilians it had killed.

Also on 21 July