Parallax

30 June, 1908

The sky splits over Tunguska

Something from space exploded above the Siberian forest with the force of a large hydrogen bomb, flattening an area the size of a great city. It left no crater, and nobody went to look for nineteen years.

Podkamennaya Tunguska River, central Siberia, Russia

A little after seven on a clear morning, people along several hundred miles of central Siberia saw a body brighter than the sun cross the sky from the south-east, trailing a column of dust. Passengers on the Trans-Siberian railway are reported to have seen it. So did peasants in villages along the Angara, some of whom fell to their knees. A few minutes later came a series of detonations like artillery, and a blast of wind.

At the trading post of Vanavara, about forty miles from the centre, a farmer named Semyon Semyonov was sitting on his porch. He later said the sky split in two and the whole northern part of it, above the forest, seemed covered in fire. He felt a heat as if his shirt were burning, then was thrown several yards and knocked senseless. Windows broke and the ground shook.

Much nearer, Evenki reindeer herders were asleep in their tents. Two brothers, Chuchancha and Chekaren, told an ethnographer years afterwards that they were woken by whistling and wind, saw the forest falling and burning around them, and heard five thunderclaps, with a second sun appearing before each. Their tent was blown away. Herds of reindeer were killed and storehouses burned. Evenki testimony speaks of at least one old man who died, and possibly others. No official ever counted.

The rest of the world noticed without knowing what it had noticed. Seismographs at Irkutsk recorded a tremor. Sensitive barographs in England traced the air wave as it passed. For two or three nights the sky over Europe stayed so bright that people in London read newspapers outdoors at midnight, and astronomers wrote to the journals about it.

Russia, between a lost war and a revolution, sent no one. In 1921 Leonid Kulik, a mineralogist collecting meteorites for the Soviet Academy of Sciences, came across the old newspaper reports, and in 1927, after weeks of travel by sledge and raft with reluctant Evenki guides, he climbed a ridge and looked out over the wreckage. Trees lay in their millions, stripped and scorched, all pointing away from one place. At the centre a stand of dead trunks still stood upright like telegraph poles, their branches torn off from above.

Kulik was sure a giant iron meteorite lay under the swamp. He drained and bored the round pools he took for craters through four expeditions and found nothing. He died in a German prison camp in 1942, still believing it was there.

How it came to this

The Earth is struck constantly. Dust and pebbles burn up as shooting stars; a body a few metres across arrives every year or so and usually explodes high and harmlessly. Objects in the range of fifty metres, large enough to devastate a region, are thought to arrive at intervals of some centuries to a few thousand years, though the estimates are loose because there is so little evidence to count. In 1908 the idea that stones fell from the sky had been accepted by science for barely a century, and the origin of the Moon’s craters was still argued over.

The place it happened was among the emptiest in Eurasia: swampy taiga on permafrost, hundreds of miles north of Irkutsk and the railway, inhabited by a few hundred Evenki, then called Tungus, who hunted and herded reindeer and traded furs at posts like Vanavara. The date was 17 June in the Julian calendar Russia still used. The news reached Siberian newspapers within days, garbled, including a report of a meteorite landing beside the railway that turned out to be invention.

How each side saw it

The Evenki

For the people who lived there it was not a scientific puzzle. Accounts gathered in the 1920s by the ethnographer Innokenty Suslov, who had grown up among them, describe the event as a visitation by Agdy, the thunder god, who appears as iron birds with fiery eyes. Some said shamans of one clan had called him down on another in a feud. The devastated ground was held to be cursed and people avoided it, which is one reason Kulik had trouble hiring guides. Families lost the reindeer and stores on which they depended. Almost all of this was recorded second-hand, in Russian, nearly two decades later.

The comet and asteroid schools

Once it was clear there was no crater, astronomers proposed in the 1930s that the object was a small comet, a loose mass of ice and dust that would leave nothing behind; Soviet scientists generally favoured this, and some linked it to a meteor stream shed by Comet Encke. From the 1980s Western researchers argued that an icy body could not have penetrated so deep, and a 1993 study by Christopher Chyba and colleagues showed that a stony asteroid some fifty or sixty metres across would shatter and explode at about the right height. That is now the majority view, without being settled.

The Soviet public and the dissenters

In 1946 the engineer and writer Alexander Kazantsev published a story in which the blast was the nuclear engine of an alien spacecraft, an idea suggested by the upright trees at Hiroshima. It caught the imagination of a generation. From 1959 volunteers from Tomsk and other cities mounted annual expeditions, half hoping to find the ship, and in the process produced most of the careful mapping of the fallen forest. Other minority proposals have come from physicists: a lump of antimatter, a tiny black hole, an eruption of natural gas from below. None has explained the fireball that witnesses saw arrive.

What is disputed

The time is usually given as about 7.14 a.m. locally, though some accounts say later. Estimates of the energy have ranged from 3 to 30 megatons; ten to fifteen is most often quoted, while computer modelling by Mark Boslough suggests a smaller, more focused blast would do the same damage. The height is put at five to ten kilometres. Whether anyone died rests on Evenki recollection alone. Italian researchers proposed in 2007 that Lake Cheko, five miles from the centre, is an impact crater made by a fragment; Russian teams dispute this, arguing that the lake is older. Claims of recovered fragments remain unconfirmed.

What followed

About 2,000 square kilometres of forest and an estimated 80 million trees were levelled, and the scar can still be traced. Had the object arrived a few hours later, the turning Earth would have put populated parts of Europe beneath it, a calculation that has made Tunguska the standard argument for watching the sky. The explosion over Chelyabinsk in 2013, about a thirtieth as powerful, injured some 1,500 people. Space agencies now catalogue near-Earth objects, a spacecraft deliberately shifted an asteroid’s orbit in 2022, and the United Nations marks 30 June as Asteroid Day.

Read further

  • E. L. Krinov, Giant Meteorites (1966)
  • John Baxter and Thomas Atkins, The Fire Came By: The Riddle of the Great Siberian Explosion (1976)
  • Christopher Chyba, Paul Thomas and Kevin Zahnle, ‘The 1908 Tunguska explosion: atmospheric disruption of a stony asteroid’, Nature (1993)
  • Surendra Verma, The Tunguska Fireball: Solving One of the Great Mysteries of the 20th Century (2005)
  • Vladimir Rubtsov, The Tunguska Mystery (2009)

Same day, other years

1520

Moctezuma dies and the Spaniards flee Tenochtitlan

Tenochtitlan (now Mexico City)The Americas

The ruler of the Mexica had been a hostage in his own city for seven months, held by Hernan Cortes and his men in a palace beside the great temple. In May one of Cortes’s captains massacred unarmed nobles dancing at a festival, and the city rose. Moctezuma died at the end of June, on the 29th or 30th. On the rainy night of 30 June the Spaniards and their Tlaxcalan allies tried to slip out along a causeway across the lake. They were seen. Hundreds of Spaniards and far more Tlaxcalans were killed or drowned, many weighed down by looted gold.

Seen from elsewhere. Cortes and Bernal Diaz say Moctezuma was stoned by his own people while appealing for calm. Nahua accounts gathered by the friars Sahagun and Duran say the Spaniards killed him once he was no use. Spain remembered the retreat as the Sad Night; Mexico City officially renamed its landmark the Victorious Night in 2021.

1860

Huxley and Wilberforce debate Darwin at Oxford

Oxford, EnglandEurope

Seven months after On the Origin of Species appeared, the British Association for the Advancement of Science met at Oxford’s new University Museum. On the Saturday several hundred people crowded a session at which Samuel Wilberforce, Bishop of Oxford, spoke against Darwin’s theory and the young anatomist Thomas Huxley defended it. According to the famous version, the bishop asked whether Huxley claimed descent from an ape on his grandfather’s side or his grandmother’s, and Huxley answered that he would rather have an ape for an ancestor than a man who used great gifts to obscure the truth. Darwin, ill, was not there.

Seen from elsewhere. No transcript exists, and the celebrated exchange was reconstructed from letters and memoirs, some written decades later. Wilberforce believed he had won; the botanist Joseph Hooker thought his own speech decided the day. Historians such as J. R. Lucas argue that the legend of science routing religion was built up afterwards, and that the bishop’s objections were largely scientific.

1934

The Night of the Long Knives

Bad Wiessee, Munich and Berlin, GermanyEurope

At dawn Adolf Hitler arrived with a pistol at a lakeside hotel in Bavaria and arrested Ernst Rohm, chief of the Nazi party’s brown-shirted militia, the SA, and one of his oldest comrades. Over the next three days SS squads working from prepared lists shot Rohm and dozens of SA leaders, and with them a range of other inconvenient people: the former chancellor Kurt von Schleicher and his wife, the Nazi dissident Gregor Strasser, conservative aides of the vice-chancellor, and the man who had crushed Hitler’s putsch in 1923. The government admitted to 77 dead, later documents name 85, and some estimates run to 200.

Seen from elsewhere. The regime announced that it had forestalled a coup by Rohm; no evidence of one has been found. The army, which feared the SA as a rival, approved, and President Hindenburg sent thanks. A law of 3 July declared the killings lawful self-defence of the state, and the jurist Carl Schmitt wrote that the Fuhrer protects the law.

1960

The Congo becomes independent and Lumumba answers the king

Leopoldville (now Kinshasa), CongoAfrica

Belgium granted independence to its vast central African colony after barely six months of preparation. At the ceremony King Baudouin praised the genius of his great-granduncle Leopold II and told the Congolese it was now for them to show themselves worthy of Belgium’s trust. President Joseph Kasavubu replied politely. Then the prime minister, Patrice Lumumba, who was not on the programme, rose and recalled forced labour, beatings, stolen land and the insults endured morning, noon and night because they were black. Congolese in the hall and listening by radio cheered. Within a week the army mutinied; within seven months Lumumba had been murdered.

Seen from elsewhere. Belgian officials were outraged at what they heard as ingratitude, and the king nearly left. Some Congolese politicians also thought the speech reckless on such a day. Leopold’s Congo Free State had cost millions of lives, a history Belgium long avoided. A Belgian parliamentary inquiry in 2001 accepted moral responsibility for Lumumba’s death.

Also on 30 June