Parallax

17 July, 1453

The guns of Castillon

An English commander in his sixties, riding without armour, charged a fortified French artillery park on the Dordogne. An hour later he was dead, and three centuries of English rule in Gascony went with him.

Castillon, Gascony, France

John Talbot, Earl of Shrewsbury, had been fighting the French for most of his adult life, and by the summer of 1453 he was somewhere between sixty-five and seventy. He had landed in the Medoc the previous October with about three thousand men, at the invitation of Bordeaux citizens who wanted the English back, and the city had opened its gates to him. Now three French armies were closing on Gascony. One of them, perhaps eight thousand strong, had laid siege to the small town of Castillon, upriver on the Dordogne, and the townsmen sent to Talbot for help.

The French had not simply sat down in front of the walls. Jean Bureau, the king’s master of artillery, laid out a fortified camp east of the town, with a ditch, an earth rampart and a palisade whose line followed the bed of a dry stream. Behind it he placed his guns, which the chroniclers number at three hundred, most of them probably small pieces and handguns. Talbot marched through the night of 16 July, and at dawn his advance guard scattered a party of French archers posted in a priory nearby.

Then a message came from the town that the French were leaving: a cloud of dust was rising from their camp. It was in fact the camp servants and horses being sent out of the way. Talbot did not wait for his infantry to come up. He ordered his men to dismount and attack the rampart, while he himself stayed in the saddle on a small horse, in a crimson gown and without armour. A tradition explains this by an oath he had sworn on his release from French captivity in 1450 never to wear armour against the French king again.

The assault ran straight into the guns. Fired at close range into packed men, a single shot is said to have killed several at once. The English and Gascons kept at the palisade for about an hour as their reinforcements arrived in pieces and were fed in. Then Breton cavalry, held in reserve to the north, struck their right flank, and the attack fell apart.

Talbot’s horse was brought down by a shot and pinned him. A French archer, named in one account as Michel Perunin, killed him with an axe. His son, Lord Lisle, died beside him. The next day a herald could identify the body only by a missing tooth. Castillon surrendered at once, and on 19 October Bordeaux, which had been governed from England since 1154, opened its gates to Charles VII. Nobody in either kingdom announced that a war had ended.

How it came to this

The English kings held Gascony not by conquest but by inheritance. Eleanor of Aquitaine brought it to Henry II in 1152, and for three hundred years its lords, towns and wine merchants looked to London. The long war that began in 1337 grew out of the awkward fact that the king of England was, for this duchy, a vassal of the king of France. Edward III’s answer was to claim the French crown itself. Henry V came close to making the claim good after Agincourt, and his infant son was crowned king of France in Paris in 1431.

After that the tide ran one way. Joan of Arc’s campaign and the coronation of Charles VII at Reims in 1429 restored the Valois cause, Burgundy changed sides in 1435, and Charles used a truce in the 1440s to build a paid standing army and the best artillery train in Europe. Normandy fell in 1450 after the battle of Formigny. Bordeaux surrendered in 1451, found French taxes and garrisons not to its liking, and within a year sent to England for Talbot.

How each side saw it

The French crown

For Charles VII’s chroniclers, Jean Chartier above all, Castillon completed the recovery of the kingdom. The Gascons were subjects who had broken the oaths they swore in 1451, and the king was restoring his own. Charles had medals struck to mark the expulsion of the English and ordered an annual thanksgiving. Later French tradition treated the battle as the end of a national war of liberation that began with Joan of Arc, although the men who won it were paid professionals and Bretons, and the king they served had let Joan burn without attempting a ransom.

The Gascons

Bordeaux did not think of itself as occupied. Its language was Gascon, not French, its wine went to English ports by the shipload, and its charters and privileges came from kings in Westminster who were too far away to interfere much. The men who invited Talbot in 1452 included leading nobles and citizens. After the surrender Charles VII fined the city, suspended its privileges, built two fortresses to overawe it and exiled the ringleaders. Many Gascon families emigrated to England. The wine trade collapsed for a generation, and French historians of the region have long noted that the conquest was felt there as a conquest.

The English

English chronicles are brief about Castillon and long about what followed. Talbot was mourned as the last of the old captains; the French themselves raised a chapel where he fell. In August 1453 Henry VI collapsed into a stupor that lasted more than a year, and contemporaries and many historians connect it to the news from Gascony, though no source says so directly. The loss fed the charge that the court had thrown away Henry V’s inheritance, a grievance Richard, Duke of York, turned into a political programme. English kings went on styling themselves kings of France until 1801.

What is disputed

The numbers are soft. French chroniclers give the English four thousand dead, which would be most of the force engaged; modern estimates are lower and uncertain. The three hundred guns are a chronicler’s figure and their size is unknown, so how far this was a victory of artillery rather than of a fortified position and a rash attack is debated. The story of Talbot’s oath rests on later tradition. The idea of a single Hundred Years’ War ending on this day is a nineteenth-century construction: no treaty was signed, Calais stayed English until 1558, and Edward IV invaded France in 1475.

What followed

England kept only Calais. The soldiers and lords who came home from France brought their quarrels with them, and the first battle of the Wars of the Roses was fought at St Albans less than two years later. France emerged with something new: a king who could tax without consent and keep an army in peacetime. Historians of warfare often set Castillon beside the fall of Constantinople, seven weeks earlier, as evidence that gunpowder had begun to decide battles and sieges. The town is now called Castillon-la-Bataille.

Read further

  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume V: Triumph and Illusion (2023)
  • A. J. Pollard, John Talbot and the War in France, 1427-1453 (1983)
  • Malcolm Vale, English Gascony, 1399-1453 (1970)
  • Juliet Barker, Conquest: The English Kingdom of France, 1417-1450 (2009)
  • Jean Chartier, Chronique de Charles VII

Same day, other years

1918

The Romanovs are shot in a cellar

Yekaterinburg, RussiaEurope

In the early hours of 17 July the former tsar Nicholas II, his wife Alexandra, their five children and four retainers, among them the family doctor, were woken in the Ipatiev House, told they were being moved for their safety, and led to a basement room. A squad under the local Cheka officer Yakov Yurovsky read a short sentence and opened fire. The shooting and bayoneting took some twenty minutes. The bodies were stripped, burned with acid and petrol and buried in the forest. Anti-Bolshevik forces took the city eight days later. Most of the remains were found in 1979 and exhumed in 1991; those of Alexei and one sister were found in 2007.

Seen from elsewhere. The Soviet government announced only the tsar’s execution and for years said the family was safe. No written order from Lenin has been found, though Trotsky’s diary says the decision was taken in Moscow. The Russian Orthodox Church canonised the family in 2000 as passion-bearers and has been slow to accept the DNA identification of the bones.

1968

The Ba’ath Party takes Iraq without a shot

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Before dawn, army officers allied with the Ba’ath Party drove into the presidential palace and telephoned President Abd al-Rahman Arif to tell him he was no longer in office. He was put on a plane to London. General Ahmed Hassan al-Bakr became president. Thirteen days later the Ba’athists turned on the two non-party officers who had opened the palace gates for them and sent them abroad as well. Al-Bakr’s young kinsman Saddam Hussein, who organised the party’s security apparatus, became deputy chairman of the ruling council the following year and president in 1979.

Seen from elsewhere. The party called it the White Revolution because nobody died, and 17 July was Iraq’s national day until 2003. Iraqi Communists, Kurds and Shia religious activists remember the purges, show trials and public hangings that began within months. Claims of foreign intelligence backing for the coup have been made often and never documented.

1976

Indonesia declares East Timor its twenty-seventh province

Jakarta, Indonesia, and Dili, East TimorAsia

President Suharto signed the law incorporating the former Portuguese colony seven months after Indonesian troops had invaded it. The invasion of December 1975 came nine days after the Fretilin party declared independence and one day after Suharto met the American president and secretary of state in Jakarta. Jakarta presented the annexation as the answer to a petition from a People’s Assembly it had convened in Dili. The United Nations never recognised it. East Timor’s truth commission later estimated that at least 102,800 people died from killing, hunger and illness during the occupation, out of a population of well under a million. A referendum in 1999 produced a 78.5 per cent vote for independence.

Seen from elsewhere. Indonesia argued that Timorese leaders had asked for integration, that Portugal had abandoned the territory to civil war, and that a left-wing enclave in the archipelago was a danger. Australia recognised the annexation. Timorese who favoured integration existed, and some fought beside Indonesian forces, including in the militia violence of 1999.

1979

Somoza flies to Miami

Managua, NicaraguaThe Americas

Anastasio Somoza Debayle resigned before dawn and left with his family, his senior officers and the coffins of his father and brother. The Somozas had run Nicaragua since the 1930s through the National Guard, and had lost much of the middle class after relief money disappeared following the 1972 Managua earthquake and the opposition editor Pedro Joaquin Chamorro was murdered in 1978. The insurrection led by the Sandinista Front is usually said to have cost between 30,000 and 50,000 lives. The Guard dissolved within two days and Sandinista columns entered Managua on 19 July. Somoza was killed by an Argentine guerrilla team in Paraguay the following year.

Seen from elsewhere. Somoza’s memoir, Nicaragua Betrayed, blamed the Carter administration for abandoning an ally to Marxists. Many who fought him soon broke with the Sandinistas, some joining the US-funded Contra war. Critics of Daniel Ortega’s later rule, including former Sandinista commanders, argue that the revolution ended by reproducing the family government it overthrew.

Also on 17 July