Parallax

3 July, 1423

A son for the ‘King of Bourges’

He was born heir to a kingdom his father did not control, rebelled at sixteen, spent years as a guest of his family’s greatest rival, and died having swallowed that rival’s lands. His enemies called him the universal spider.

Bourges, France

On 3 July 1423, in the archbishop’s palace at Bourges, Marie of Anjou gave birth to a son. He was baptised Louis in the cathedral of Saint-Etienne next door, with the Duke of Alencon as godfather. His father, Charles, called himself King of France, but Paris was held by the English, Reims, where kings were crowned, was out of reach, and a treaty signed three years earlier had disinherited him in favour of the infant Henry VI of England. His enemies mocked him as the ‘King of Bourges’. The court was so short of money that the celebrations were modest.

The boy was brought up largely apart from his parents in the castle of Loches, and was six when Joan of Arc led his father to be crowned. At twelve he was married to Margaret of Scotland, whom he disliked. At sixteen he lent his name to a nobles’ revolt against his father, the Praguerie, and was forgiven. Sent in 1447 to govern the Dauphine, he ran it as his own state, married Charlotte of Savoy without permission, and never saw his father again. When a royal army finally came for him in 1456 he fled to the court of Philip the Good, Duke of Burgundy, and lived on Burgundian charity for five years. Charles VII is said to have remarked that his cousin was sheltering a fox that would one day eat his chickens.

He became king in 1461, at thirty-eight. Louis XI dressed plainly, rode constantly about his kingdom with a small household, preferred the company of townsmen and clerks to that of great lords, and trusted paid information more than honour. In 1465 a league of princes fought him to a standstill at Montlhery, and he gave them what they asked and then took it back piece by piece. In 1468 he walked into a meeting at Peronne with Philip’s son, Charles the Bold, while his own agents were stirring revolt in Liege. Charles held him prisoner and made him ride with the Burgundian army to watch Liege destroyed.

He did not make that kind of mistake again. In 1475 he bought off an invading English army under Edward IV with cash and pensions at Picquigny. He subsidised the Swiss and the Duke of Lorraine, who between them beat Charles the Bold three times and left him dead in the snow outside Nancy in January 1477. Louis seized the duchy of Burgundy and Picardy at once.

He spent his last years shut up at Plessis-les-Tours, afraid of plots and of death, sending for relics and for the Calabrian hermit Francis of Paola. He died there on 30 August 1483 and was buried, by his own wish, not with the kings at Saint-Denis but at Notre-Dame de Clery.

How it came to this

The France into which Louis was born had been at war with England, on and off, since 1337, and with itself since 1407, when the Duke of Burgundy had the king’s brother murdered in a Paris street. The feud between Burgundians and Armagnacs let Henry V of England win at Agincourt and conquer Normandy. In 1419 men of the dauphin Charles killed the Duke of Burgundy in turn, on the bridge at Montereau, and the new duke, Philip the Good, allied with the English. By the Treaty of Troyes of 1420 the mad King Charles VI made Henry V his heir.

Both kings died in 1422. North of the Loire a regent ruled for the baby Henry VI; south of it the dauphin held court at Bourges and Poitiers, kept going largely by his mother-in-law, Yolande of Aragon. Burgundy, meanwhile, was growing into something close to a separate kingdom, stretching from Dijon to the rich cities of Flanders and Holland. Louis’s life’s work would be to break it.

How each side saw it

Philippe de Commynes

The fullest portrait comes from a man who changed sides. Commynes was a Burgundian courtier, present at Peronne, who deserted Charles the Bold for Louis in 1472 and was richly rewarded. His Memoires, written after the king’s death, present Louis as the wisest prince he had known: humble in speech, tireless in winning men over, quick to recover from his own blunders, and better at getting out of trouble than at staying out of it. Commynes does not hide the fear and cruelty of the last years, including the iron cages in which prisoners were kept, one of which he later occupied himself for some months.

The Burgundian chroniclers

To the writers paid by the dukes of Burgundy, Georges Chastellain and his successor Jean Molinet, Louis was an ungrateful guest who repaid five years’ shelter by ruining the house that fed him. It is from this tradition that the image of the ‘universal spider’ comes. They set his slyness against the knightly code their own court prized, and saw the fall of Charles the Bold as treachery bought with French gold. Thomas Basin, the bishop of Lisieux whom Louis drove into exile, went further in his Latin history and painted a tyrant who taxed his people into misery and broke every oath he swore.

The townspeople of Arras and Liege

Those on the receiving end left few words of their own, and we know them mainly through chroniclers and royal orders. Liege, encouraged by Louis to rise and then abandoned, was sacked in 1468 with the king looking on. Arras, taken from Burgundy in 1477, rebelled; in 1479 Louis expelled its inhabitants, brought in settlers from other French towns and renamed the place Franchise. The scheme failed and was reversed after his death. The main direct tax more than tripled over the reign, and the Estates General that met at Tours in 1484 was loud with complaint about them.

Later historians

For Walter Scott in Quentin Durward and Victor Hugo in Notre-Dame de Paris, Louis was a superstitious schemer with a hangman at his elbow, and that picture stuck. Nineteenth-century French historians such as Michelet recast him as the bourgeois king who tamed the nobles and built the nation. Paul Murray Kendall’s 1971 biography is frankly admiring. More recent scholars, among them Jean Favier, are cooler: they stress that he inherited an army and a tax system from his father, that luck and other people’s soldiers destroyed Burgundy, and that half the Burgundian inheritance went to the Habsburgs.

What is disputed

The date and place of birth are secure. The legends are not. Cardinal Balue, the minister imprisoned for eleven years for dealing with Burgundy, is traditionally said to have been kept in an iron cage of his own devising; cages existed, but that Balue invented or occupied one is doubted. Contemporaries accused Louis of poisoning his brother Charles of Guyenne in 1472, and there is no evidence that he did. The Latin tag about a ruler who cannot dissemble not knowing how to rule is attributed to him only by later writers. The ‘spider’ label is variously credited to Chastellain and to Molinet.

What followed

Louis added Burgundy, Picardy, Anjou, Maine and Provence to the crown, set up a system of royal post relays, and encouraged silk-weaving; the first French printing press was set up in Paris in his reign. But Charles the Bold’s daughter Mary married Maximilian of Habsburg, taking the Low Countries with her, and the contest between France and the Habsburgs over that inheritance ran for more than two centuries. His daughter Anne governed for the young Charles VIII. His other daughter, Jeanne, forced into marriage with the future Louis XII and later set aside, founded a religious order and was canonised in 1950.

Read further

  • Philippe de Commynes, Memoires
  • Paul Murray Kendall, Louis XI: The Universal Spider (1971)
  • Jean Favier, Louis XI (2001)
  • Richard Vaughan, Charles the Bold: The Last Valois Duke of Burgundy (1973)

Same day, other years

1608

Champlain builds at Quebec

Quebec, CanadaThe Americas

Samuel de Champlain, working for a French fur-trading company, landed on 3 July 1608 at a point where the St Lawrence narrows beneath a high cliff, a place the Algonquin called Kebec. He set his men to cutting timber for a ‘habitation’ of three buildings with a stockade and a ditch. The Iroquoian town of Stadacona that Jacques Cartier had seen there in 1535 had vanished. Of the twenty-eight men who wintered at the post, twenty died of scurvy and dysentery. It survived all the same, the first lasting French settlement in North America.

Seen from elsewhere. The Innu had agreed at Tadoussac in 1603 that the French might settle in return for help against the Haudenosaunee: an alliance, as they understood it, not a surrender of land. Champlain paid the price in 1609 by firing on Mohawk warriors, an act the Haudenosaunee did not forget. No treaty ever ceded the site.

1940

The Royal Navy fires on the French fleet

Mers-el-Kebir, AlgeriaAfrica

Eleven days after France signed an armistice with Germany, a British squadron under Vice-Admiral James Somerville appeared off the naval base of Mers-el-Kebir near Oran and gave Admiral Marcel-Bruno Gensoul a choice: join Britain, sail to a British or distant French port to be disarmed, or scuttle. After a day of talks failed, the British opened fire shortly before six in the evening. The old battleship Bretagne blew up and capsized; two more capital ships were disabled; the Strasbourg escaped to Toulon. In about ten minutes 1,297 French sailors were killed by their allies of a fortnight before.

Seen from elsewhere. The French navy had orders to scuttle rather than let Germany take its ships, and did exactly that at Toulon in 1942; to its officers the attack was murder, and Vichy used it for years. Churchill believed he could not gamble on a promise. Somerville privately called it a blunder that would shame the navy.

1988

An American cruiser shoots down Iran Air 655

Strait of Hormuz, Persian GulfMiddle East

Iran Air Flight 655, an Airbus A300 carrying 290 people from Bandar Abbas to Dubai, was seven minutes into a scheduled flight when two missiles from the cruiser USS Vincennes destroyed it. Everyone aboard died, 66 of them children. The Vincennes, under Captain William Rogers, was at that moment fighting Iranian gunboats and had crossed into Iranian waters. Its crew took the airliner, climbing in a recognised civil air corridor, for an Iranian F-14 fighter descending to attack. It was the last summer of the Iran-Iraq war, in which the United States was protecting shipping bound for Iraq’s allies.

Seen from elsewhere. Iran has always held the shooting to be deliberate and took the case to the International Court of Justice. Washington called it a tragic error in combat, though the ship’s own recordings contradicted early claims about the aircraft’s course. In 1996 the United States paid compensation to the families and expressed regret without admitting liability. The cruiser’s officers were later decorated.

2013

Egypt’s army removes its elected president

Cairo, EgyptAfrica

On the evening of 3 July 2013 the defence minister, General Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, announced on television that Mohamed Morsi was no longer president and that the constitution was suspended. Morsi, of the Muslim Brotherhood, had won Egypt’s first free presidential election a year earlier. Enormous crowds had been in the streets since 30 June demanding that he go, angry at fuel shortages, at a decree that had put him above the courts, and at a constitution pushed through by his allies. Sisi stood beside the head of al-Azhar, the Coptic pope and opposition politicians. Morsi was taken into custody.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters called it a second revolution carrying out the people’s will; the Brotherhood, and many governments, called it a coup. On 14 August security forces cleared protest camps in Cairo, killing at least 817 people at Rabaa al-Adawiya by Human Rights Watch’s count; officials gave lower figures. Morsi died in a courtroom in 2019.

Also on 3 July