Parallax

30 July, 1898

Bismarck dies at Friedrichsruh

The man who made the German Empire spent his last eight years on a country estate, sniping at the emperor who had dismissed him. He chose an epitaph that left that emperor out.

Friedrichsruh, near Hamburg, Germany

Otto von Bismarck died at about eleven at night on 30 July 1898, aged 83, in his house in the Sachsenwald, the forest east of Hamburg that a grateful Wilhelm I had given him after the war with France. He had been in pain for months from gangrene in one foot and could no longer walk in his woods. His wife Johanna had died in 1894. His family and his physician, Ernst Schweninger, who had kept the old man alive for fifteen years by controlling what he ate and drank, were in the house.

He had not gone quietly into retirement. Wilhelm II, who came to the throne in 1888 at the age of 29, wanted to rule as well as reign, and in March 1890 forced the chancellor to resign. Bismarck was made Duke of Lauenburg, a title he said he would use when travelling incognito. From Friedrichsruh he fed a Hamburg newspaper a stream of unsigned criticism of his successors, received delegations of admirers, and in 1896 revealed the existence of the secret treaty with Russia that the new government had let lapse.

He also dictated his memoirs to his old assistant Lothar Bucher. They are brilliant, selective and unreliable, and the volume dealing with Wilhelm II was held back by the family until after the monarchy had fallen. The emperor made public gestures of reconciliation and paid a last visit in December 1897. Bismarck is reported to have told him that the crown was safe so long as the officer corps stayed loyal, and to have said privately that the crash would come twenty years after his own departure if things went on as they were.

Wilhelm, cruising off Norway when the news came, hurried back and proposed a state funeral and burial in Berlin Cathedral beside the Hohenzollerns. The family declined, on the dead man’s instructions. Bismarck had chosen a site on a rise opposite his house and written his own inscription: ‘A loyal German servant of Emperor Wilhelm I.’

One episode from the death chamber came out only later. Two Hamburg photographers bribed a forester, got into the room hours after the death and photographed the body, unshaven in a disordered bed. They tried to sell the plates for a large sum. The family went to court, the plates were confiscated and the men were sent to prison. The picture was not published until the 1950s.

How it came to this

Bismarck was a Prussian landowner, born in 1815, who made his name as a reactionary in the revolution of 1848 and then spent a decade as a diplomat. In 1862 King Wilhelm I, locked in conflict with a liberal parliament that would not vote funds for army reform, appointed him minister-president. Bismarck governed without a legal budget and told the deputies that the great questions of the day would be decided not by speeches and majority votes but by iron and blood. Three short wars followed, against Denmark in 1864, Austria in 1866 and France in 1870-71, and in January 1871 the German Empire was proclaimed at Versailles.

As chancellor for nineteen years he kept the peace he had broken, tying Austria, Russia and Italy into alliances designed to isolate France. At home he gave the empire universal male suffrage and a parliament with limited powers, fought the Catholic Church in the 1870s and outlawed socialist organisations in 1878, then introduced state insurance against sickness, accident and old age, the first such system anywhere. In 1884-85 he hosted the Berlin Conference on Africa and acquired colonies he had previously said Germany did not need.

How each side saw it

Wilhelm II

The emperor’s account, given in his memoirs of 1922 and in his letters at the time, was that the chancellor had become impossible. Bismarck wanted to renew the anti-socialist law in a harsher form and was prepared, Wilhelm believed, to provoke a confrontation and tear up the constitution; the young emperor did not wish to open his reign by shooting his subjects and favoured laws to protect workers. He also resented being told that ministers might not see him without the chancellor’s leave. Wilhelm insisted he honoured the founder of the empire. He was 31 at the time of the dismissal.

The Social Democrats

For German socialists Bismarck was the man of the ‘exceptional law’ of 1878-90, under which their meetings and newspapers were banned, some 1,500 people were imprisoned and hundreds of families were expelled from their home towns. August Bebel, who had been jailed, and the party paper Vorwarts declined to join the national mourning. They regarded the insurance laws as a bribe that workers had seen through. Their best argument was arithmetic: the party Bismarck tried to destroy won more votes than any other in 1890, the election that preceded his fall, and went on growing.

Catholics and Poles

In the Kulturkampf of the 1870s Prussia expelled the Jesuits, put clerical education under state control and jailed or exiled bishops; by the middle of the decade about a quarter of Prussian parishes had no priest. Catholic Germans answered by building the Centre Party, which Bismarck in the end had to work with. For Prussia’s Polish subjects the same laws were an attack on nationality as well as faith. In 1885-86 some 30,000 Poles and Jews without Prussian citizenship were expelled, and a state commission was funded to buy Polish estates for German settlers. Polish memory of Bismarck is of a Germaniser.

What is disputed

Several famous sayings are doubtful. The prediction that the next European war would come from ‘some damned foolish thing in the Balkans’ reached print through Winston Churchill, quoting a shipowner’s recollection years later. The warning about a crash after twenty years is likewise remembered rather than recorded. Historians disagree more deeply about the man. Hans-Ulrich Wehler and others saw his system, with its weak parliament and its campaigns against ‘enemies of the Reich’, as the start of a German special path that ended in 1933. Lothar Gall called him a ‘white revolutionary’ who used radical means for conservative ends, and Jonathan Steinberg stresses how much depended on his hold over one old king.

What followed

Within a few years hundreds of Bismarck towers and monuments rose across Germany, built by subscription, and the cult served nationalists who thought his successors timid. Wilhelm II let the Russian treaty go, built a battle fleet and drifted into the encirclement Bismarck had worked to prevent. The empire fell in November 1918, twenty years and a few months after his death. The borders he drew lasted until 1945, and the social insurance system he founded still exists. So does the argument about whether he made Germany’s later catastrophes possible or would have avoided them.

Read further

  • Jonathan Steinberg, Bismarck: A Life (2011)
  • Lothar Gall, Bismarck: The White Revolutionary (1986)
  • Otto Pflanze, Bismarck and the Development of Germany (1990)
  • Otto von Bismarck, Gedanken und Erinnerungen (1898)
  • Hans-Ulrich Wehler, The German Empire, 1871-1918 (1985)

Same day, other years

AD 762

The caliph al-Mansur founds Baghdad

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

The Abbasid dynasty had overthrown the Umayyads in 750 and needed a capital of its own, away from Syria. The second Abbasid caliph, al-Mansur, chose a site on the west bank of the Tigris near the old Persian capital of Ctesiphon, where the river came closest to the Euphrates and trade routes crossed. His astrologers, the Persian Nawbakht and the Jewish scholar Mashallah, fixed the moment to begin, which later writers equated with 30 July 762. The plan was a perfect circle about two kilometres across, with four gates, double walls, and the palace and mosque at the centre. He named it the City of Peace. Within a century it was among the largest cities in the world.

Seen from elsewhere. Nothing of the Round City survives above ground, and it has never been excavated; it is known from writers such as al-Yaqubi and al-Tabari, working a century or more later. The date rests on a horoscope preserved by al-Biruni. The name Baghdad is older than Islam, and the design owed much to Persian models.

1419

Hussites throw Prague’s councillors from the window

Prague, BohemiaEurope

Four years after the reformer Jan Hus was burned at the Council of Constance, his followers in Prague were being pushed out of the churches by a king under pressure from Rome. On Sunday 30 July 1419 the radical preacher Jan Zelivsky led a procession from his church to the New Town Hall to demand the release of Hussite prisoners. The councillors refused, and the story goes that a stone was thrown from the building at the priest carrying the sacrament. The crowd stormed the hall and hurled the burgomaster and several councillors from the windows onto the pikes below. King Wenceslas IV died of a stroke seventeen days later. Fifteen years of war followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Catholic Europe saw murder and heresy, and the pope proclaimed crusades against Bohemia, all of which failed. Czech national historians from Palacky onward treated the day as a people’s rising for faith and nation. Scholars still debate whether it was a spontaneous riot or a coup planned by Zelivsky; sources differ on the number killed.

1811

Miguel Hidalgo is shot at Chihuahua

Chihuahua, New SpainThe Americas

Miguel Hidalgo was a parish priest of 57 who, on 16 September 1810, rang his church bell at Dolores and called his parishioners to rise against bad government. Within weeks he led tens of thousands of Indigenous and mixed-race villagers armed mostly with farm tools. They took Guanajuato and came within reach of Mexico City, then turned back. Beaten by royalist regulars at Calderon bridge in January 1811, the leaders fled north and were betrayed and captured in March. Hidalgo was tried by the army and by the Inquisition, stripped of his priesthood, and shot by firing squad on 30 July 1811. His head hung in an iron cage on the Guanajuato granary for ten years.

Seen from elsewhere. At Guanajuato his followers had slaughtered Spaniards who had taken refuge in that granary, and he later ordered hundreds of Spanish prisoners killed. This turned most American-born whites against the revolt. The royal authorities published a retraction in his name whose authenticity is disputed. Mexico honours him as father of the nation.

1980

The New Hebrides become Vanuatu

Port Vila, VanuatuOceania

For seventy-four years the New Hebrides in the south-west Pacific were ruled jointly by Britain and France under an arrangement that gave the islands two police forces, two school systems, two currencies and two sets of courts, and gave the islanders citizenship of nowhere. Residents called it the Pandemonium. On 30 July 1980 the flags came down and the country became independent as Vanuatu, with an Anglican priest, Walter Lini, as prime minister. A secession was already under way on the largest island, Espiritu Santo, led by Jimmy Stevens and encouraged by French settlers and American libertarian businessmen. Troops from Papua New Guinea ended it within weeks.

Seen from elsewhere. French-speaking islanders feared domination by Lini’s English-educated party, and France had delayed independence as long as it could. Stevens presented his movement as a defence of custom and land against outsiders; his son was killed and he spent eleven years in prison. The new constitution returned all land to its customary owners.

Also on 30 July