Ernest Hemingway was not a soldier. Poor eyesight in one eye kept him out of the army, by his own account, and he had reached Italy in June 1918 as a volunteer ambulance driver with the American Red Cross, a few months out of a cub reporter’s job on the Kansas City Star. Ambulance work in the hills behind the lines was too quiet for him. He asked for a transfer to the Red Cross canteen service on the lower Piave, where the Italian army had just beaten off the last Austro-Hungarian offensive of the war, and where a canteen man could bicycle up to the trenches with a haversack of chocolate, cigarettes and postcards.
Shortly after midnight on 8 July he was in a forward listening post on the river bank near the village of Fossalta, among Italian infantrymen, when an Austrian trench mortar bomb, a canister packed with scrap metal, landed a few feet away. One Italian was killed outright and another lost his legs. Hemingway’s own legs were riddled with fragments; the surgeons later counted more than two hundred.
What happened next is told in the citation for the Italian Silver Medal for Valour he was afterwards awarded: though gravely wounded, he gave help to Italian soldiers more seriously hurt before allowing himself to be moved. The version that went home, in a letter from his fellow driver Ted Brumback to Hemingway’s parents, was that he picked up a wounded man and carried him towards the command post, and on the way was hit in the knee and foot by machine-gun bullets. He was thirteen days short of his nineteenth birthday.
After a dressing station and a field hospital he was taken by train to the new American Red Cross hospital in Milan, where there were more nurses than patients. One of them was Agnes von Kurowsky, from Washington, twenty-six years old, tall and good-humoured. Hemingway fell in love with her over the months of operations and convalescence. She called him ‘Kid’ in her letters and seems to have half agreed to marry him.
He went home in January 1919 on crutches, a hero in the Chicago papers. In March she wrote to say that she was fond of him, more as a mother than a sweetheart, and expected to marry an Italian officer. Ten years later he published A Farewell to Arms, in which an American lieutenant in the Italian ambulance corps is blown up by a mortar while eating cheese in a dugout and loves an English nurse named Catherine Barkley, who dies.
How it came to this
Italy had entered the war in 1915 on the side of Britain and France, hoping to take Austrian territory in the Alps and on the Adriatic. For two and a half years its conscript army battered at mountain positions along the Isonzo river at a cost of hundreds of thousands of lives. In October 1917 a German and Austrian attack at Caporetto broke the front. The Italians lost some 300,000 men, most of them prisoners, and fell back seventy miles to the Piave, a short distance from Venice. There the line held.
The United States, at war since April 1917, sent almost no combat troops to Italy, and the Red Cross ambulance sections, staffed by college boys and would-be writers, were partly a gesture to show the Italians that America was with them. In June 1918 Austria-Hungary, its soldiers hungry and its empire coming apart, attacked across the Piave and was repulsed with heavy loss. Hemingway arrived as that battle ended. The retreat from Caporetto, the centre of his novel, had taken place while he was still in Kansas City.