Parallax

27 July, 1675

A cannonball kills Marshal Turenne

Louis XIV’s best general rode forward to look at a battery position before a battle he expected to win. One shot from an imperial gun ended his life and the French campaign in Germany with it.

Sasbach, Baden, Holy Roman Empire

For two months in the summer of 1675 two old soldiers had manoeuvred against each other on the right bank of the Rhine opposite Strasbourg. Henri de La Tour d’Auvergne, vicomte de Turenne, was 63 and commanded the army of Louis XIV. Raimondo Montecuccoli, an Italian in the emperor’s service and two years older, commanded the imperial army. Each was trying to cut the other off from his bridges and his bread without risking a battle on bad terms. Military writers studied the campaign for the next century as a model of the art.

By late July Turenne had the better of it. The imperial army was short of supplies and falling back towards the Black Forest, and near the village of Sasbach Turenne found it in a position he thought he could attack. On the afternoon of 27 July he rode along his line to see where the guns should go. The story told afterwards is that an officer warned him he was under fire and that he answered he had no wish to be killed that day.

His artillery commander, the marquis de Saint-Hilaire, came up to show him a battery site and raised his arm to point. A ball from an imperial gun took off Saint-Hilaire’s arm and struck Turenne in the body. His horse carried him a few paces and he fell dead without speaking. Saint-Hilaire’s young son ran to his father in tears, and the general, according to the son’s own later memoir, told him it was not for him that he should weep but for that great man.

The officers tried to hide the death and failed. The two lieutenant-generals disputed the command, and the army, which had been about to attack, retreated to the Rhine. Montecuccoli followed and caught it at the crossing at Altenheim, where the French fought a hard rearguard action to get back into Alsace. He is said to have remarked on hearing the news that a man had died who did honour to mankind.

At court the shock was complete. Madame de Sevigne’s letters that August describe ministers and servants weeping and a king visibly shaken by the loss. Louis named eight new marshals at once, and Paris wits called them the small change for Monsieur de Turenne. He was buried, by the king’s order, in the abbey of Saint-Denis among the kings of France.

How it came to this

Turenne was born at Sedan in 1611, a younger son of the Protestant duke of Bouillon, and learned his trade as a teenager in the Dutch army of his uncles, the princes of Orange. He rose in French service during the Thirty Years’ War, became a marshal in 1643 and, with the prince of Conde, won the campaigns in Germany that brought the war to an end. In the civil wars of the Fronde he fought first against the crown and then for it, beating Conde outside Paris in 1652 and the Spanish at the Dunes in 1658. In 1668, after long discussion with Bossuet, he gave up Calvinism for Catholicism.

In 1672 Louis XIV attacked the Dutch Republic. The invasion stalled at the flooded polders, and by 1674 the emperor, Spain and several German princes had joined the Dutch. Turenne was given a small army to hold Alsace. He did it by attacking: he beat the imperial forces at Sinsheim, laid waste the Palatinate to deny them food, and in midwinter marched behind the Vosges to surprise them at Turckheim in January 1675. That campaign made his European reputation.

How each side saw it

The Palatinate

In the Rhineland Turenne was remembered for the summer of 1674, when his troops burned towns and villages across the Palatinate. Voltaire later wrote that the Elector Karl Ludwig could see two towns and twenty-five villages burning from his castle. The Elector sent Turenne a furious letter challenging him to a duel, which Turenne politely declined, replying that his soldiers had been provoked by peasants who had murdered and mutilated French stragglers. German pamphlets of the time and later German historians treated the devastation as a deliberate policy of terror, and as the rehearsal for the far larger French destruction of the Palatinate in 1689.

Montecuccoli and the imperial army

From the imperial side Sasbach was a deliverance. Montecuccoli’s own writings on war, which circulated widely after his death, set out the cautious doctrine he had followed all summer: preserve the army, live on the enemy’s country and wait for a mistake. His admirers held that he had never been as near defeat as the French claimed. Within weeks he had crossed the Rhine and was besieging Haguenau, and Louis had to send Conde to hold Alsace. Both commanders left the field for good that year, and Vienna counted the campaign a success bought with one lucky shot.

French Protestants

Huguenots had looked on Turenne as the greatest living member of their church, and his conversion in 1668 was a heavy blow. Catholic writers presented it as a triumph of Bossuet’s arguments. Protestant contemporaries suspected ambition or weariness, though he had held out for decades when, it was said, conversion would have brought him the highest military office in France. His example was used to press other Protestant nobles to follow. Ten years after his death Louis XIV revoked the Edict of Nantes, and members of Turenne’s old church were dragooned, imprisoned or driven abroad.

What is disputed

The dying words sometimes given to Turenne cannot be right, since the witnesses agree he was killed outright; the remark about not wishing to die that day belongs, if it was said, to the minutes before. Montecuccoli’s tribute is reported only at second hand. Whether Turenne would have won the battle is unknowable, though French accounts assumed it. Voltaire, often cited on Turenne as if he had known him, was born nineteen years after his death. The burning of the Palatinate divides opinion still: John Lynn and others see the ordinary logic of seventeenth-century armies that lived off the land, while German tradition sees a calculated atrocity.

What followed

The war dragged on to the Peace of Nijmegen in 1678-79, which left France stronger but did not give Louis the Dutch defeat he had wanted. Turenne’s body had a strange afterlife. When revolutionaries emptied the royal tombs at Saint-Denis in 1793 they found it well preserved and spared it from the common pit; it was exhibited for some years in the natural history museum in Paris and then in a museum of monuments. In 1800 Napoleon, who told his officers to read and reread Turenne’s campaigns, had it moved with ceremony to the Invalides, where it remains.

Read further

  • Jean Berenger, Turenne (1987)
  • John A. Lynn, The Wars of Louis XIV, 1667-1714 (1999)
  • Madame de Sevigne, Correspondance (letters of July and August 1675)
  • Voltaire, Le Siecle de Louis XIV (1751)

Same day, other years

1214

Philip Augustus wins at Bouvines

Bouvines, FlandersEurope

On a hot Sunday beside a bridge between Lille and Tournai, Philip II of France turned to face a coalition that had been years in the making: the emperor Otto IV, the counts of Flanders and Boulogne, and an English contingent under the earl of Salisbury, all paid for by King John. The fighting lasted a few hours. Philip was dragged from his horse by Flemish foot soldiers and saved by his armour and his household knights. Then the allied line broke. Otto fled, leaving his eagle standard on the field, and the count of Flanders was led to Paris in chains. John, beaten in Poitou weeks earlier, went home to face the barons who would force Magna Carta on him.

Seen from elsewhere. The fullest account is by Philip’s own chaplain, William the Breton, who was present and wrote to glorify his king. The allies were criticised even by their own side for giving battle on a Sunday. Georges Duby showed how French memory rebuilt the day over centuries into a founding national victory.

1816

The ‘Negro Fort’ is blown up

Prospect Bluff, Spanish FloridaThe Americas

When British forces left the Gulf coast after the War of 1812 they handed a well-armed fort on the Apalachicola River to their Black allies, most of them people who had escaped slavery in Georgia and the Carolinas. Around it grew a farming settlement of several hundred, with some Choctaw. It lay in Spanish territory, sixty miles from the United States border. General Andrew Jackson ordered it destroyed and its people returned to their owners. On 27 July 1816 American gunboats exchanged fire with the fort, and a heated shot landed in the powder magazine. The explosion killed most of those inside, about 270 by the army’s count. The leader, Garcon, survived and was executed.

Seen from elsewhere. No account from inside the fort exists; what is known comes from American officers’ reports, and some historians think the death toll was inflated or that many residents had already left. Spain protested at the invasion of its soil. Survivors joined the Seminole, and Jackson invaded Florida again in 1818.

1880

An Afghan army destroys a British brigade at Maiwand

Maiwand, near Kandahar, AfghanistanAsia

In the second year of Britain’s second invasion of Afghanistan, Ayub Khan, a son of the late amir, marched from Herat on Kandahar with regular infantry, modern artillery and thousands of tribal fighters. Brigadier George Burrows went out to stop him with about 2,500 British and Indian troops and met him on an open plain in fierce heat on 27 July 1880. The Afghan guns outranged and outnumbered his. After some hours the Indian regiments on the left gave way, and the line collapsed. Nearly a thousand of Burrows’s men were killed, including a last group of the 66th Foot who fought to the end in a walled garden. The survivors struggled back to Kandahar.

Seen from elsewhere. Afghan losses were also heavy, perhaps several thousand. Afghan tradition credits the victory to Malalai, a young Pashtun woman said to have rallied wavering fighters with her veil as a banner before she was shot. She appears in no British account and in no Afghan source written at the time, but schools and hospitals carry her name.

1953

The guns stop in Korea

Panmunjom, KoreaAsia

At ten in the morning on 27 July 1953, in a hall built for the purpose at Panmunjom, the American general William Harrison and the North Korean general Nam Il signed eighteen copies of an armistice without exchanging a word. The fighting stopped twelve hours later. The talks had lasted two years, most of that time deadlocked over whether prisoners of war could refuse to be sent home. The line they fixed ran close to where the war had started, and a demilitarised zone four kilometres wide was drawn along it. Estimates of the dead run to between two and three million or more, the majority Korean civilians. No peace treaty has ever followed.

Seen from elsewhere. South Korea did not sign. Its president, Syngman Rhee, wanted to fight on for unification and had tried to wreck the talks by freeing some 27,000 prisoners. North Korea celebrates the day as a victory over the United States. China regards the war as having stopped an American advance to its border.

Also on 27 July