Parallax

7 July, 1937

Shots in the dark at the Marco Polo Bridge

A Japanese soldier went missing for twenty minutes during a night exercise outside Beijing. He turned up unhurt. By then the two armies were on their way to a war that lasted eight years and killed millions.

Lugouqiao (Marco Polo Bridge), Wanping, China

On the night of 7 July 1937 a company of Japanese infantry was practising a night attack on waste ground beside the Yongding River, about ten miles south-west of the city then called Beiping. A few hundred yards away stood the small walled town of Wanping and, beyond it, the long stone bridge with its hundreds of carved lions that Marco Polo had admired six centuries before. Both were held by soldiers of the Chinese 29th Army. At about twenty to eleven a few rifle shots came out of the darkness from the direction of the river bank.

The company commander, Captain Shimizu Setsuro, halted the exercise and called the roll. One man, Private Shimura Kikujiro, did not answer. Shimizu sent a rider to his battalion commander, Major Ichiki Kiyonao, who telephoned the regiment in Beiping. By the time Japanese officers arrived at the gate of Wanping to demand entry to search for their soldier, Shimura had rejoined his unit; he seems simply to have lost his way. The demand was not withdrawn. The Chinese garrison refused to open the gate.

Through the small hours officers from both sides, with the county magistrate Wang Lengzhai, argued inside the town about a joint investigation. Outside, the Japanese brought up the rest of the battalion and some guns. Around five in the morning, after more shots, and with the approval of the regimental commander, Colonel Mutaguchi Renya, Ichiki ordered an attack. The Chinese at the bridge, under orders from their regimental commander Ji Xingwen to hold, fought back, and there was fighting around the bridge and the town through the following day.

This need not have gone further. The local commanders, who had patched up several such clashes before, agreed a ceasefire on 11 July under which the Chinese would apologise and pull back from the town. But the same day in Tokyo the cabinet of Prince Konoe approved sending reinforcements from Korea, Manchuria and Japan itself, and announced it publicly. In China, Chiang Kai-shek ordered divisions north and on 17 July declared at the mountain resort of Lushan that the limit of endurance had been reached: if war came, every person, north or south, young or old, had a duty to resist.

At the end of July the Japanese army in north China, by then heavily reinforced, attacked in strength. Beiping and Tianjin fell within three days. In August the fighting spread to Shanghai, and there was no more talk of an incident.

How it came to this

Japanese troops had a legal right to be near Beijing. The protocol imposed on China after the Boxer uprising of 1901 allowed foreign powers to station guards along the railway from the capital to the sea, and Japan’s China Garrison Army, a separate force from the Kwantung Army in Manchuria, had recently been enlarged to several thousand men. What had changed was everything around them. In 1931 officers of the Kwantung Army staged an explosion on a railway at Mukden and used it to seize Manchuria, which became the client state of Manchukuo. Further pressure in 1933 and 1935 pushed Chinese government forces and party offices out of much of the north.

Chiang Kai-shek had given ground for years, holding that China must first defeat its Communists and build an army. In December 1936 his own generals kidnapped him at Xi’an and obliged him to agree to a united front against Japan. By the summer of 1937 the Japanese had occupied the rail junction at Fengtai, and the line across the Marco Polo Bridge was the last one linking Beiping to the rest of China. Neither side’s local soldiers could afford another retreat.

How each side saw it

China

In both the People’s Republic and Taiwan, 7 July is the day the War of Resistance became a whole nation’s war, and the defenders of Wanping are honoured in a large museum beside the bridge. The Chinese view is that who fired the first shots matters little: a foreign army was exercising at night next to a Chinese garrison town and used a trivial pretext to attack it, exactly as at Mukden. Since 2017 mainland textbooks have dated the war from 1931, making it fourteen years long and placing the Marco Polo Bridge in the middle of a single story of invasion, not at the beginning of a new one.

Japan’s government and army in 1937

Tokyo called the fighting the ‘North China Incident’ and then the ‘China Incident’, never a war, in part to avoid American neutrality laws. The official position was that Chinese troops had fired unlawfully on a legitimate exercise and that Japan sought only a local settlement and an apology. Inside the army there was a real split. General Ishiwara Kanji of the General Staff, who had planned the seizure of Manchuria, argued against sending troops, warning that China would swallow the army as Spain had swallowed Napoleon’s. He was overruled by officers who expected one sharp blow to bring Chiang to terms within months.

Japanese historians since the war

The Tokyo war crimes tribunal could not establish who fired first. The most detailed Japanese research, by Hata Ikuhiko, concluded that the first shots were probably fired by nervous soldiers of the 29th Army and that, unlike Mukden, the clash was not a plot by the Japanese army; the responsibility for turning it into a war lay with decisions taken afterwards, in Tokyo above all. A nationalist strand of Japanese writing goes further and blames Chinese Communist agents for firing on both sides. Most historians in Japan and elsewhere find the evidence for that thin.

What is disputed

Who fired the first shots is unknown and probably unknowable. Popular accounts often say a Japanese soldier was killed; in fact the missing man returned unharmed, and the unit involved belonged to the China Garrison Army, not the Kwantung Army, and was present under the 1901 protocol, not a 1933 treaty. Historians also disagree about inevitability: some, like James Crowley, stress Tokyo’s miscalculation, others the pressure on Chiang after Xi’an to fight at last. Rana Mitter and many Chinese scholars argue the Second World War began here, two years before Poland. Chinese deaths in the war are estimated at anything from fourteen to twenty million.

What followed

The war that followed brought the battle for Shanghai, the massacre at Nanjing in December 1937, the bombing of Chongqing and years of occupation and famine. It tied down more than half a million Japanese troops, pushed Japan towards the alliance with Germany and the attack on Pearl Harbor, and so wrecked Chiang’s government and economy that the Communists, who numbered a few tens of thousands in 1937, were able to win the civil war in 1949. Disagreement over how Japan remembers these years remains a live issue between Beijing, Seoul and Tokyo.

Read further

  • Rana Mitter, China’s War with Japan, 1937-1945: The Struggle for Survival (2013)
  • James B. Crowley, Japan’s Quest for Autonomy: National Security and Foreign Policy, 1930-1938 (1966)
  • James W. Morley (ed.), The China Quagmire: Japan’s Expansion on the Asian Continent, 1933-1941 (1983)
  • Hans van de Ven, China at War: Triumph and Tragedy in the Emergence of the New China (2017)
  • Mark Peattie, Edward Drea and Hans van de Ven (eds), The Battle for China (2011)

Same day, other years

1456

Joan of Arc’s conviction is annulled

Rouen, FranceEurope

Twenty-five years after Joan was burned in the market place at Rouen, a church court sitting in the archbishop’s palace of the same city declared on 7 July 1456 that her trial had been tainted by fraud, malice and errors of law, and was null. A copy of the charges was torn up in public. The inquiry had been opened by the Pope at the petition of her elderly mother, Isabelle Romee, and pressed by King Charles VII, who had every reason not to owe his crown to a condemned heretic. It heard 115 witnesses, from village neighbours to soldiers and the clerks of the first trial.

Seen from elsewhere. Nobody spoke for the judges of 1431: Bishop Cauchon was dead and the English had been driven out. Witnesses who had served the first court had strong reasons, a quarter of a century on, to blame the dead. The verdict cleared Joan of heresy without declaring her holy; the Church canonised her only in 1920.

1520

Cortes fights his way out at Otumba

Otumba, central MexicoThe Americas

A week after being driven out of Tenochtitlan with the loss of most of their men, horses and plunder, the Spaniards under Hernan Cortes and their Tlaxcalan allies were limping towards the safety of Tlaxcala when a large Mexica army barred the way on the plain near Otumba. By the Spanish accounts, after hours of fighting Cortes and a handful of horsemen charged the enemy commander, conspicuous in his feathered battle standard, and a soldier named Juan de Salamanca killed him and seized it. The Mexica army drew off. The survivors reached Tlaxcala, and returned the next year to besiege the city.

Seen from elsewhere. The date, usually given as 7 July, and the numbers come from the victors; Cortes’s and Bernal Diaz’s figures of a hundred thousand or more opponents are not believed. Nahua accounts collected by Sahagun treat the fight briefly. The Tlaxcalans, in their own painted history, appear as partners in the victory. Smallpox was already spreading in Tenochtitlan.

1990

Saba Saba: Kenyans defy a one-party state

Nairobi, KenyaAfrica

Two former cabinet ministers, Kenneth Matiba and Charles Rubia, had called a rally for 7 July 1990, the seventh day of the seventh month, ‘Saba Saba’ in Swahili, at the Kamukunji grounds in Nairobi to demand the return of multi-party politics. President Daniel arap Moi’s government banned it and detained both men without trial, along with Raila Odinga. Thousands came anyway. Police broke up the crowd with batons, tear gas and live rounds, and rioting spread through Nairobi and towns of central Kenya for several days. The government acknowledged about twenty deaths. Seventeen months later Moi allowed opposition parties.

Seen from elsewhere. Moi argued that parties would divide Kenya along ethnic lines and blamed the unrest on hooligans. Violence in the Rift Valley before the 1992 election, which killed some 1,500 people, seemed to bear him out; a later judicial inquiry found that figures in his own party had organised it. Kenyan protesters still gather on Saba Saba.

2005

Suicide bombers attack London’s transport system

London, EnglandEurope

At about ten to nine on a Thursday morning three bombs exploded within a minute on Underground trains near Aldgate, Edgware Road and Russell Square. Almost an hour later a fourth destroyed a bus in Tavistock Square. Fifty-two people of many nationalities were killed and more than seven hundred injured. The four bombers, who also died, were British: three young men of Pakistani descent from West Yorkshire and one Jamaican-born convert. London had been celebrating, the day before, its selection to host the 2012 Olympic Games. It was the first suicide attack in Britain.

Seen from elsewhere. In a video released later the group’s leader, Mohammad Sidique Khan, said he was avenging Muslims killed by Western governments; ministers long resisted any link with the Iraq war. Two weeks afterwards police hunting other bombers shot dead an innocent Brazilian, Jean Charles de Menezes. British Muslims reported a sharp rise in abuse and attacks.

Also on 7 July