Parallax

24 July, 1704

Gibraltar surrenders to an Anglo-Dutch fleet

An admiral with nothing to show for a summer’s cruise turned his guns on a half-manned Spanish fortress. It fell in three days, in the name of an Austrian archduke, and almost every inhabitant walked out rather than stay.

Gibraltar

Sir George Rooke had been at sea since the spring with some sixty English and Dutch warships and not much luck. An attempt to raise Barcelona for the Habsburg claimant to the Spanish throne had failed, and the French fleet had slipped past him. In mid-July by the English calendar, off the Moroccan coast, his council of war looked for something achievable and settled on Gibraltar, which was known to be weakly held.

It was weaker than they knew. The governor, Diego de Salinas, had about a hundred guns but hardly any gunners, and perhaps eighty regular soldiers, eked out with a few hundred militia from a town of some four thousand people. On 21 July Prince George of Hesse-Darmstadt, the archduke’s representative with the fleet, landed with about 1,800 marines on the sandy isthmus and cut the Rock off from the mainland. He sent in a letter calling on the town to acknowledge Charles III as its lawful king. Salinas and the council answered that they had sworn loyalty to Philip V and would die as his faithful subjects.

Contrary winds delayed the ships for a day. At dawn on 23 July they opened fire, and in five or six hours put something like fifteen thousand shot into the town and its batteries. Women and children had fled south along the shore to the shrine of Our Lady of Europa at the tip of the peninsula. Towards noon, seeing the guns on the New Mole silenced, sailors rowed in to seize it. A powder magazine blew up as the first boats landed, killing or wounding about a hundred men, but the next wave held the mole and with it the road between the town and the shrine.

The defenders now had their families on the wrong side of the enemy. Salinas asked for terms that evening and signed them the next day, 24 July, which was 4 August in the calendar used in Spain and most of Europe. The capitulation was generous on paper: the garrison would march out with arms and baggage, and any inhabitant who took an oath to Charles III could stay with property and religion untouched.

Hardly anyone accepted. Before the terms were signed, sailors and marines had begun looting houses, assaulting women and breaking up churches, and the officers hanged some of their own men to stop it. On 27 July, which was 7 August by the Spanish reckoning, behind the banner of the city and carrying its records and its statue of the Virgin, about four thousand people filed out across the isthmus. Some seventy stayed behind.

How it came to this

Charles II of Spain died childless in 1700, leaving his empire to Philip of Anjou, grandson of Louis XIV. England, the Dutch Republic and Austria, unwilling to see France and Spain under one family, went to war in support of a rival candidate, the Archduke Charles, whom they styled Charles III. The naval powers wanted a base from which to keep a fleet in the Mediterranean year round. Cadiz had been attacked without success in 1702; Minorca and Gibraltar had both been discussed in London for decades, and Cromwell had considered the Rock in the 1650s.

Gibraltar had been Castilian since 1462, when it was taken from the Muslim kingdom of Granada, having been held by Moorish rulers for most of the seven and a half centuries since Tariq ibn Ziyad landed there in 711 and gave it his name: Jabal Tariq, the mountain of Tariq. Its walls had been strengthened under Charles V, but by 1704 Spain was fighting on several fronts with an empty treasury, and Salinas’s appeals for men and powder had gone unanswered.

How each side saw it

Spain

Spanish governments of every kind since 1704 have held that Gibraltar was taken by a force acting for one Spanish king against another and then kept by a third party. They accept that Article X of the Treaty of Utrecht in 1713 ceded the town, castle, port and fortifications, but argue that it gave no jurisdiction over the isthmus, where the airport now stands, or the surrounding waters, and that it gives Spain first refusal if Britain ever relinquishes the place. Spain also points to the United Nations list of territories awaiting decolonisation, on which Gibraltar has stood since 1946.

The people who left

The exiles expected to be home within months. Most settled a few miles away around the hermitage of San Roque, which Philip V recognised in 1706 as the seat of the city of Gibraltar residing in its countryside; the town still keeps the old banner, the council records and the royal charter of 1502. The priest Juan Romero de Figueroa, who stayed behind to guard the church of St Mary, left notes in its registers describing the sack. The eighteenth-century historian Ignacio Lopez de Ayala drew on such testimony for the account of the plunder and of the desecration of the shrine that Spanish readers know.

Britain

The capture caused little excitement in London, where Marlborough’s victory at Blenheim three weeks later eclipsed it, and Rooke, a Tory, was soon pushed out of his command. Ministers offered several times in the eighteenth century to trade the Rock back, for Florida or for Spanish help, and were stopped each time by parliamentary and public opinion. What made it a national symbol was the Great Siege of 1779-83. The British position today rests on Utrecht for title and on the principle that sovereignty will not change against the wishes of the inhabitants.

Gibraltarians

The present population descends not from the people of 1704 but from those who replaced them: Genoese, Maltese, Portuguese, Sephardic Jews from Morocco, British and, despite everything, Spaniards. They speak English and a local Andalusian-based vernacular, Llanito. In a 1967 referendum they voted by 12,138 to 44 to remain British, after which Spain closed the land frontier from 1969 until the 1980s. In 2002 they rejected shared sovereignty by nearly ninety-nine per cent. Their own argument is neither London’s nor Madrid’s: that three centuries make a people, and a people decides for itself.

What is disputed

The date depends on the calendar: 24 July is the Old Style date then used in England, and Spanish and most modern histories give 4 August. In whose name the Rock was held is the more serious question. The summons and the capitulation name Charles III. The story that Rooke had the English flag hoisted and claimed the place for Queen Anne appears only in later accounts and is doubted by George Hills and other historians; English control became fact gradually as the garrison did. How many inhabitants remained is variously given, and the scale of the sack is described more fully in Spanish than in English sources.

What followed

A Franco-Spanish army besieged the Rock that winter and failed, as did further sieges in 1727 and 1779-83. Britain obtained formal cession at Utrecht in 1713, on conditions that included a ban on Jews and Moors living there, which was ignored from the start. The base mattered in every naval war to 1945. The dockyard closed in 1984. In 2016 Gibraltar voted 96 per cent to stay in the European Union and left with the rest of the United Kingdom, and its frontier arrangements have been under negotiation between London, Madrid and Brussels ever since.

Read further

  • George Hills, Rock of Contention: A History of Gibraltar (1974)
  • William G. F. Jackson, The Rock of the Gibraltarians: A History of Gibraltar (1987)
  • Ignacio Lopez de Ayala, Historia de Gibraltar (1782)
  • Stephen Constantine, Community and Identity: The Making of Modern Gibraltar since 1704 (2009)

Same day, other years

1534

Cartier raises a cross at Gaspe

Gaspe Bay, Quebec, CanadaThe Americas

Jacques Cartier of Saint-Malo, sent by Francis I to look for a passage to Asia, had been trading knives and beads for furs along the Gulf of St Lawrence. At Gaspe he met a few hundred people from the village of Stadacona, far upriver, who had come to fish for mackerel. On 24 July his men set up a cross thirty feet high bearing a shield with three fleurs-de-lis and the words Long live the King of France. Their leader, Donnacona, came out in a canoe and made a long speech, pointing to the cross and then to the land all around. Cartier lured the canoe alongside and sailed for France with two of Donnacona’s sons.

Seen from elsewhere. Only Cartier’s narrative survives. He understood Donnacona to be saying that the country was his and the cross needed his leave, and replied, falsely, that it was only a landmark. In 1536 he carried off Donnacona himself and nine others; none saw home again. The St Lawrence Iroquoians had vanished from the valley by 1600.

1567

Mary, Queen of Scots, signs away her crown

Lochleven Castle, ScotlandEurope

Five weeks earlier the queen’s army had melted away at Carberry Hill and she had surrendered to a confederacy of Scottish lords, who shut her in a castle on an island in Loch Leven. There, days after miscarrying twins, she was visited by Lord Lindsay with documents resigning the throne to her thirteen-month-old son and naming her half-brother, the Earl of Moray, as regent. She signed on 24 July, by her own account under threat of death. The infant was crowned James VI at Stirling five days later, with John Knox preaching. Mary escaped the following spring, lost a battle and crossed into England, where she was held for nineteen years and then beheaded.

Seen from elsewhere. The lords justified themselves by her marriage to the Earl of Bothwell, the chief suspect in the murder of her husband Darnley three months before it. Their proof of her complicity, the Casket Letters, survives only in copies and has been called forged ever since. Catholic Europe regarded the abdication as void.

1911

Hiram Bingham is shown Machu Picchu

Urubamba valley, PeruThe Americas

A Yale lecturer searching for the last refuge of the Inca rulers was camped by the Urubamba river when a local farmer, Melchor Arteaga, said there were ruins on the ridge above and agreed to guide him for a silver sol. They crossed the river on a log bridge and climbed for over an hour in the rain. Near the top two families were farming the old terraces. A small boy led Bingham on to walls of fitted granite under the forest. On one he found a name and a date in charcoal: Lizarraga, 1902. Excavations with National Geographic backing followed, and thousands of objects went to Yale.

Seen from elsewhere. Peruvians point out that the site was never lost to those who lived on it, and that Agustin Lizarraga, a farmer from the valley, had been there nine years earlier. Bingham misidentified it as the Incas’ final capital; it is now thought a royal estate of the emperor Pachacuti. Yale returned the collection to Cusco from 2011 after a long dispute.

1923

The Treaty of Lausanne draws the borders of Turkey

Lausanne, SwitzerlandMiddle East

Three years earlier the victors of the First World War had imposed the Treaty of Sevres on the Ottoman sultan, carving Anatolia into zones and promising an Armenian state and Kurdish autonomy. Mustafa Kemal’s nationalist army refused it, defeated a Greek invasion and abolished the sultanate. At Lausanne his envoy Ismet, facing the British foreign secretary Lord Curzon over eight months, obtained recognition of a sovereign Turkey within roughly its present frontiers and the end of the legal privileges foreigners had enjoyed for centuries. A convention signed there in January provided for a compulsory exchange: about 1.2 million Orthodox Christians left Turkey for Greece and some 400,000 Muslims went the other way.

Seen from elsewhere. Turkey regards Lausanne as its title deed. The treaty mentions neither Armenians nor Kurds, both of whom date their statelessness to it. Greeks remember the exchange as part of the Asia Minor Catastrophe. Those exchanged were sorted by religion, not language, and many arrived as strangers in their supposed homelands.

Also on 24 July