Parallax

31 July, 1914

Jean Jaures is shot at the Cafe du Croissant

The leader of French socialism had spent the week trying to stop a European war. A young nationalist put two bullets through a cafe window, and the next afternoon France mobilised.

Paris, France

Jean Jaures came back to Paris from Brussels on 30 July 1914. The day before, at an emergency meeting of the Socialist International, he had stood on a platform with the German socialist leader Hugo Haase and told a packed hall that the workers of Europe would not be led to slaughter. He still believed the French government wanted peace and could be made to restrain its ally Russia, whose mobilisation was the step most likely to bring Germany in.

He spent Friday 31 July trying to find out what the government was doing. At the Chamber of Deputies he heard that Germany had proclaimed a state of imminent danger of war. In the early evening he led a socialist delegation to the foreign ministry, where the premier was unavailable and a junior minister, Abel Ferry, received them. Jaures warned that if France let itself be dragged in behind Russia the socialists would say so publicly. By one later account Ferry replied that he would be killed at the first street corner.

From there he went to the office of L’Humanite, the newspaper he had founded, meaning to write a leading article for the morning that would name those responsible. First he took his colleagues to eat. The Cafe du Croissant, on the corner of the rue Montmartre, was a journalists’ restaurant a few doors away. It was a hot night and the windows were open to the street, with only a curtain across them. Jaures sat on a bench with his back to one.

At about twenty to ten, as he was looking at a photograph of another journalist’s small daughter, a hand moved the curtain and two shots were fired from the pavement. One struck him in the head. He died within minutes on a table in the restaurant. The gunman, who was seized outside, was Raoul Villain, 28, an unstable and devout young man from Reims who belonged to a league for the recovery of Alsace-Lorraine and had been following Jaures for days.

Ministers feared a rising in the working-class districts and kept cavalry in the capital overnight. It did not come. Crowds gathered in silence. The premier, Rene Viviani, had posters put up calling the murder an abominable crime and appealing for unity. The next afternoon, 1 August, the mobilisation order went out, and on 3 August Germany declared war on France. On the 4th the union leader Leon Jouhaux, speaking at the graveside, pledged the labour movement to the defence of the country.

How it came to this

Jaures was born in 1859 at Castres in the south-west, became a philosophy teacher and then a deputy, and was converted to socialism by a miners’ strike at Carmaux in his own constituency. He was the best orator in French politics. He took the side of Captain Dreyfus when many socialists thought the affair a quarrel among the bourgeoisie, and in 1905 he brought the rival socialist groups into a single party, which by the spring of 1914 held about a hundred seats.

He was not a pacifist in the strict sense. His book L’Armee nouvelle, published in 1911, proposed to defend France with a citizen militia on the Swiss pattern. But he held that a general war would be a catastrophe, and from 1905 he worked to make the Socialist International an instrument for preventing one, if necessary by simultaneous strikes in every country concerned. In 1913 he led the opposition to the law extending military service to three years. The nationalist press called him a traitor and a German agent; the writer Charles Peguy had suggested that in wartime his voice should be drowned by drums, as in the tumbrils of the Revolution.

How each side saw it

Raoul Villain and the nationalist right

Villain wrote to his brother from prison that he had struck down the standard-bearer, the great traitor of the period of the three-year law. He belonged to no large organisation and acted alone, but he had read for years that Jaures was in German pay. The royalist Action Francaise and other papers that had printed such things condemned the murder and denied responsibility. Many on the right sincerely believed that Jaures’s campaigns had weakened the army in the face of a Germany preparing to attack, and when Villain was finally tried in March 1919 the jury, in the mood of victory, acquitted him.

The French labour movement

Socialists and trade unionists lost the one leader who might have told them what to do, and almost all of them chose national defence. Jouhaux’s speech at the funeral, the unanimous socialist vote for war credits the same day and the entry of two socialists into the government in late August were justified as what Jaures would have wanted against an invading army. The government for its part decided not to arrest the militants listed in its file of suspects, the Carnet B. After the war the divided left fought over him: Socialists and Communists each claimed his inheritance, and both marched when his ashes were moved to the Pantheon in 1924.

The German Social Democrats

The German party was the largest in the International and had demonstrated against war in the last week of July. On 1 August it sent Hermann Muller to Paris to concert a common line; he found the French socialists in mourning and certain to vote for credits if France were attacked. Three days later the German deputies voted for theirs, persuaded that Germany faced invasion by tsarist Russia. Each party thus saw its own war as defensive. Those who refused that logic, Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht in Germany and a small minority in France, regarded August 1914 as the death of the International.

What is disputed

Whether Jaures could have altered anything is the great unanswerable question. Admirers have imagined him rallying a strike against mobilisation; most historians, Jean-Jacques Becker among them, think that once Germany attacked he would have supported the war, as his writings on national defence imply, while pressing for a negotiated peace. Suspicions that Villain was the tool of the Russian embassy or of a French faction have never been supported by evidence. The exchange with Abel Ferry is known from recollections written afterwards and its wording varies. He was shot at dinner, not at lunch as some popular accounts say, and Germany had not yet ordered general mobilisation when he died.

What followed

Villain spent the war in prison awaiting a trial that was repeatedly postponed. After his acquittal Jaures’s widow, as the losing civil party, was ordered to pay the costs, and a vast crowd marched through Paris in protest. Villain drifted to the island of Ibiza, where Republican militiamen shot him in 1936. Jaures’s only son, Louis, was killed at the front in 1918. Nearly every French town has a street, square or school named after Jaures, and politicians of very different parties quote him. The cafe is still in business, with a plaque by the window.

Read further

  • Harvey Goldberg, The Life of Jean Jaures (1962)
  • Jean-Jacques Becker, 1914: Comment les Francais sont entres dans la guerre (1977)
  • Gilles Candar and Vincent Duclert, Jean Jaures (2014)
  • Jean Jaures, L’Armee nouvelle (1911)
  • Christopher Clark, The Sleepwalkers: How Europe Went to War in 1914 (2012)

Same day, other years

1492

The deadline passes for the Jews of Spain

Castile and Aragon, SpainEurope

On 31 March 1492, three months after taking Granada, Ferdinand and Isabella signed an edict at the Alhambra giving every Jew in their kingdoms until the end of July to accept baptism or leave. Those who went could take no gold, silver or coin, and had to sell houses, vineyards and workshops for whatever a buyer would offer. The court financier Isaac Abravanel pleaded with the monarchs and chose exile; his colleague Abraham Seneor, the chief rabbi of Castile, was baptised with the king and queen as sponsors. By 31 July the roads to the ports and the Portuguese frontier had emptied. Communities that had lived in Spain since Roman times were gone.

Seen from elsewhere. The edict itself gives the crown’s reason: Jews were said to be drawing baptised converts back to Judaism. Numbers are disputed, from the 200,000 or more of older accounts to modern estimates of between 40,000 and 100,000 exiles, with many others converting. Jewish chroniclers remembered it as a second destruction. Spain revoked the edict formally in 1968.

1498

Columbus sights Trinidad

TrinidadThe Americas

On his third Atlantic crossing Columbus took a more southerly course than before and ran into the doldrums, where his three ships lay becalmed for days in heat that spoiled the stores. On 31 July 1498, with water running out, a sailor at the masthead saw three hills on the horizon. Columbus had vowed to name his first landfall for the Trinity, and took the three peaks as a sign. He watered on the south coast, then sailed into the Gulf of Paria, where the fresh water pouring from the Orinoco convinced him he was near a very large land. He had reached the mainland of South America, and wrote that it might be the site of the Earthly Paradise.

Seen from elsewhere. The island had been inhabited for some seven thousand years, by peoples speaking Arawakan and Cariban languages. Their own name for it is often given as Iere or Kairi, though the evidence is thin. From 1511 the Spanish crown licensed slave raids there. The Santa Rosa First Peoples Community in Arima maintains descent from the survivors.

1658

Aurangzeb takes the Mughal throne

Delhi, IndiaAsia

When the emperor Shah Jahan fell ill in 1657, his four sons went to war for the succession. The third, Aurangzeb, a seasoned general and a strict Sunni Muslim, defeated the heir, Dara Shukoh, at Samugarh, took Agra and confined his father in the fort there, where the old man lived more than seven years longer within sight of the Taj Mahal. Aurangzeb then arrested his ally and younger brother Murad after a feast. With Dara still at large, he held a hurried coronation in a garden outside Delhi on 31 July 1658 by the modern calendar, 21 July by the one then used in England, and took the title Alamgir, ‘world-seizer’. He ruled for forty-nine years.

Seen from elsewhere. Few rulers divide opinion so sharply. He reimposed the poll tax on non-Muslims, had some major temples demolished and executed the Sikh guru Tegh Bahadur, and many Hindus and Sikhs remember a persecutor. Historians such as Satish Chandra and Audrey Truschke stress that he employed more Hindu nobles than his predecessors and acted chiefly from political motives.

1941

Goering signs Heydrich’s authorisation

Berlin, GermanyEurope

On 31 July 1941, five weeks into the invasion of the Soviet Union, Hermann Goering put his signature to three sentences addressed to Reinhard Heydrich, the head of the SS security police. The text, drafted in Heydrich’s own office, extended a commission of 1939 to organise Jewish emigration. It charged him with making all necessary preparations for a ‘total solution of the Jewish question’ in the German sphere of influence in Europe, and with submitting an overall plan for the ‘final solution’. SS killing squads were already shooting Jewish men, and within weeks women and children, behind the eastern front. Heydrich produced the letter as his authority when he summoned officials to the Wannsee conference in January 1942.

Seen from elsewhere. At Nuremberg Goering insisted the words meant emigration and evacuation, not killing. Historians disagree about what the document shows: some, like Christopher Browning, see it as a step towards a decision for Europe-wide murder taken that autumn; others, including Christian Gerlach and Peter Longerich, place the decisive turn later or see no single moment.

Also on 31 July