Parallax

11 July, 1804

The Vice President shoots Alexander Hamilton

Two of the ablest men of the American founding rowed across the Hudson at dawn to settle fifteen years of enmity with pistols. Nobody has ever established who fired first, or what Hamilton meant to do.

Weehawken, New Jersey, United States

They crossed the Hudson separately, in rowing boats, so that the oarsmen could swear afterwards that they had seen nothing. Aaron Burr, Vice President of the United States, arrived first with his second, William Van Ness, and cleared the brush from a narrow ledge under the Palisades at Weehawken. Alexander Hamilton came about seven, with his second, Nathaniel Pendleton, and a physician, David Hosack, who waited below with the boatmen. Duelling was illegal in New York, and prosecuted less eagerly in New Jersey.

The seconds measured ten paces and drew lots. Pendleton won both the choice of position and the right to give the word. The pistols were Hamilton’s to supply: a pair belonging to his brother-in-law, John Church, the same pair his eldest son Philip had carried on the same ground in 1801, when he was killed in a duel defending his father’s name. Hamilton asked for a moment to put on his spectacles.

On the word, two shots were fired within a few seconds of each other. Hamilton’s ball went into the branch of a cedar some twelve feet up and well to one side. Burr’s struck Hamilton above the right hip, broke a rib, passed through the liver and lodged in the spine. He rose on his toes, turned and fell. Hosack, scrambling up the path, found him sitting in Pendleton’s arms, and recorded that he said ‘This is a mortal wound, Doctor’ before fainting. Burr started towards him and was hurried away by Van Ness behind an umbrella, to hide his face from the boatmen.

Hamilton came round in the boat. According to Hosack he warned them that his pistol was still loaded and cocked, and said that Pendleton knew he had not meant to fire at Burr. He was carried to a friend’s house in what is now Greenwich Village, paralysed below the waist. He asked for communion; the Episcopal bishop of New York, Benjamin Moore, at first refused a duellist, then relented when Hamilton declared that he abhorred the practice and forgave Burr. His wife, Eliza, was told at first that he was suffering spasms. Their seven surviving children were brought to the bedside. He died at about two in the afternoon on 12 July, thirty-one hours after the shot.

New York gave him the largest funeral it had seen. Burr, astonished at the public fury, was indicted for murder in two states and slipped away to the south. He returned to Washington that winter, and presided over the Senate until his term ran out.

How it came to this

The two men had been rivals in New York law and politics since the 1780s. Hamilton, born out of wedlock in the West Indies, had been Washington’s aide, the chief author of the Federalist essays and the first Treasury secretary, architect of the national bank and the federal debt. Burr, grandson of the theologian Jonathan Edwards, was a gifted lawyer and organiser who built the political machine that carried New York for Jefferson in 1800. When Burr and Jefferson tied in the electoral college, Hamilton urged Federalists in the House to choose Jefferson, a man with wrong principles, over Burr, whom he said had none.

By 1804 Burr had been dropped from Jefferson’s ticket and ran for governor of New York. Hamilton worked against him again, and Burr lost badly. That April an Albany newspaper printed a letter from one Charles Cooper reporting that Hamilton had called Burr dangerous at a dinner, and that Cooper could detail ‘a still more despicable opinion’ Hamilton had expressed. Burr demanded a disavowal. Hamilton answered that he could not be held to account for inferences drawn by a third party from fifteen years of political competition. The correspondence went on for a fortnight, each letter narrowing the way out, until the challenge was given and accepted.

How each side saw it

Aaron Burr and his second

Burr’s position, set out in the letters and in Van Ness’s statement, was that he had borne years of private slander and asked only what any gentleman might: a plain denial or an apology. Hamilton gave neither. Van Ness insisted that Hamilton fired first and that Burr answered. Burr never expressed public remorse and thought the mourning hypocritical; he is said to have referred in later life to ‘my friend Hamilton, whom I shot’. A remark attributed to him in old age, that had he read more Sterne and less Voltaire he would have known the world was wide enough for both, is second-hand.

Hamilton, in his own statement

The night before, Hamilton wrote a paper to be opened if he fell. He listed his reasons against duelling: his religion, his wife and children, his creditors, and the absence of ill will to Burr apart from politics. He admitted that his criticisms had been severe and might in some cases have been wrong. He wrote that he had resolved to reserve and throw away his first fire, and perhaps his second, to give Burr the chance to pause and reflect. He went because he believed that his future usefulness in public affairs depended on meeting the prevailing standard of honour.

The clergy and the anti-duelling movement

To many ministers both men were guilty, one of murder and the other of something close to suicide. Bishop Moore published an account of the deathbed stressing Hamilton’s repentance. At Albany the Presbyterian Eliphalet Nott preached a sermon against duelling that was reprinted for decades, and Lyman Beecher followed with another. They argued that a code which let gentlemen kill each other outside the law mocked both the gospel and a republic of equal citizens. The duel did much to discredit the practice in the northern states, though it persisted in the South until the Civil War.

Historians of honour culture

Joanne Freeman has shown that duels among politicians of this generation were a regular instrument of politics, timed after elections, in which showing up mattered more than shooting straight; Hamilton had been a party to ten earlier affairs of honour without a shot fired. On that reading, what went wrong at Weehawken is the puzzle. Nancy Isenberg argues that Burr has been judged through his enemies’ papers, since his own were largely lost at sea with his daughter in 1813, and that Hamilton’s final statement was written to shape the verdict of posterity, which it did.

What is disputed

The seconds agreed a joint statement that both men fired, within a few seconds, and openly disagreed on who fired first. Pendleton held that Hamilton’s pistol went off as he was hit, by reflex. Joseph Ellis thinks Hamilton fired first and deliberately wide, and that Burr, not knowing the intention, shot to hit. An examination of the pistols in 1976 found a concealed hair trigger, which some take as evidence that Hamilton sought an advantage and fired by accident, and others dismiss, since he reportedly declined to set it. Whether Burr aimed to kill is unknowable.

What followed

The murder charges against Burr were never brought to trial. In 1807 he was tried for treason over a murky expedition in the western territories, acquitted, and spent years in Europe before returning to practise law in New York, where he died in 1836. The Federalist party, having lost its strongest mind, faded within a decade. Eliza Hamilton lived another fifty years, founded an orphanage, and devoted herself to collecting her husband’s papers. The financial system he designed survived, and the argument between his vision of central power and Jefferson’s still organises American politics.

Read further

  • Joseph J. Ellis, Founding Brothers: The Revolutionary Generation (2000)
  • Joanne B. Freeman, Affairs of Honor: National Politics in the New Republic (2001)
  • Ron Chernow, Alexander Hamilton (2004)
  • Nancy Isenberg, Fallen Founder: The Life of Aaron Burr (2007)
  • Harold C. Syrett (ed.), The Papers of Alexander Hamilton, volume 26 (1979)

Same day, other years

1405

Zheng He’s first fleet is ordered to sea

Nanjing, Ming ChinaAsia

The Yongle emperor, who had seized the Ming throne from his nephew three years earlier, ordered a fleet to the countries of the ‘Western Ocean’ under a court eunuch, Zheng He, a Muslim from Yunnan captured as a boy and raised in the imperial household. The court record dates the order to 11 July 1405. Chinese sources give the fleet more than 300 vessels and nearly 28,000 men. It sailed by way of Champa, Java and Malacca to Calicut on the coast of India, carrying silk and porcelain and bringing back envoys, spices and tribute. Six more voyages followed by 1433, reaching Hormuz, Arabia and the East African coast.

Seen from elsewhere. China marks the date as Maritime Day and presents the voyages as peaceful diplomacy. Historians such as Geoff Wade point to the armed interventions, including the seizure of a Sri Lankan king in 1411, and describe them as coercive. The recorded length of the largest ships, well over a hundred metres, is doubted by many naval historians.

1882

The Royal Navy bombards Alexandria

Alexandria, EgyptAfrica

Egypt was bankrupt and its finances run by British and French controllers on behalf of European bondholders. A movement led by an army colonel of peasant origin, Ahmad Urabi, under the slogan ‘Egypt for the Egyptians’, forced the khedive to accept a nationalist ministry. In June 1882 a riot in Alexandria killed about fifty Europeans and many more Egyptians. On 11 July, after an ultimatum to stop strengthening the harbour forts, a British fleet under Admiral Seymour shelled them for more than ten hours. The French squadron had sailed away rather than take part. Fire then destroyed much of the city centre. In September a British army defeated Urabi at Tel el-Kebir. The occupation that was announced as temporary lasted, in one form or another, until 1956.

Seen from elsewhere. Egyptians blamed the fires on the shelling; the British blamed Urabi’s retreating soldiers and looters. Gladstone’s cabinet said it was restoring order and protecting the Suez route, and John Bright resigned from it in protest. Historians still argue over whether strategy or the bondholders’ money, some of it Gladstone’s own, decided the matter.

1995

Srebrenica falls to the Bosnian Serb army

Srebrenica, Bosnia and HerzegovinaEurope

Srebrenica, a town in eastern Bosnia crowded with Bosnian Muslim refugees, had been declared a United Nations safe area in 1993 and was guarded by a lightly armed Dutch battalion. On 11 July 1995 Bosnian Serb forces under General Ratko Mladic walked in after a five-day offensive; requested air strikes came late and were called off. Women, children and the elderly were put on buses. The men and boys were separated, or hunted down as they tried to walk through the woods to government-held territory. Over the following days more than 8,000 were shot and buried in mass graves, which were later dug up and scattered to hide them. Identification of remains by DNA is still going on.

Seen from elsewhere. The Yugoslavia tribunal and the International Court of Justice both ruled the killings genocide, and Mladic and Radovan Karadzic are serving life sentences. Leaders of Republika Srpska and Serbia have acknowledged a grave crime while rejecting that word, and point to earlier raids on Serb villages from the enclave. Dutch courts found the Netherlands partly liable for men its troops handed over.

Also on 11 July