Parallax

2 July, 1937

Amelia Earhart’s last radio call

Seven thousand miles from finishing a flight around the world, the most famous woman pilot alive was heard by a ship that could not make her hear it. Nobody has proved what happened next.

Near Howland Island, central Pacific

At ten in the morning on 2 July 1937 a twin-engined Lockheed Electra, heavy with more than a thousand gallons of fuel, used almost the whole of the grass runway at Lae in New Guinea before it lifted over the sea. Amelia Earhart was at the controls. Behind her sat Fred Noonan, a former Pan American navigator who had helped survey the airline’s Pacific routes. They had flown some 22,000 miles eastwards from California in six weeks. Ahead lay the hardest leg: about 2,550 miles of open ocean to Howland Island, a strip of coral a mile and a half long and a few feet high, where the United States had scraped out a runway for her.

The Coast Guard cutter Itasca waited off Howland to guide her in with radio and a column of smoke. Through the night its operators heard her now and then, faint at first, then loud. At 7.42 in the morning, ship’s time, her voice came in at full strength: ‘We must be on you, but cannot see you, but gas is running low. Have been unable to reach you by radio. We are flying at 1,000 feet.’

The radio arrangements had gone wrong from the start. Earhart could not hear the Itasca’s voice transmissions on the frequencies she was using. She asked the ship to send signals so that she could take a bearing with her loop antenna, but on a frequency too high for that equipment to work. The ship’s own direction finder could not get a fix on her brief calls. Neither she nor Noonan was practised in Morse code, which carried further than speech.

At 8.43 she was heard once more, saying they were on the line 157-337, a navigator’s sun line running north-west to south-east, and were flying along it north and south. Then nothing. The Itasca steamed north-west, where there had been cloud. Within days the battleship Colorado and the aircraft carrier Lexington joined the search, which covered about a quarter of a million square miles and cost some four million dollars. It was called off on 18 July.

Her husband, the publisher George Palmer Putnam, paid for further searches of the Gilbert and Phoenix islands. In January 1939 a California court declared her legally dead. Before an earlier flight she had left him a letter: ‘Please know I am quite aware of the hazards,’ she wrote. ‘Women must try to do things as men have tried. When they fail, their failure must be but a challenge to others.’

How it came to this

Earhart, born in Kansas in 1897, became famous in 1928 as the first woman to cross the Atlantic by air, though as a passenger: she said afterwards she had been baggage. Putnam, who had organised that flight’s publicity and later married her, turned her into a brand, with books, lecture tours and a clothing line. She earned the fame in 1932 by flying the Atlantic alone, from Newfoundland to a field in Northern Ireland, and in 1935 by flying solo from Hawaii to California. She used her standing to argue for women in aviation and at work generally.

The world flight was to be her last long-distance record, paid for partly by Purdue University, which bought the Electra as a ‘flying laboratory’. A first attempt, westwards, ended in March 1937 when the aircraft ground-looped on take-off in Hawaii and was badly damaged. After repairs she reversed the direction because of the season’s winds, which put the long Pacific crossing and the search for Howland at the end, when crew and machine were most worn.

How each side saw it

The Coast Guard and Navy

The official reports, chiefly that of the Itasca’s captain, Commander Warner Thompson, put the loss down to the flight’s radio planning. Earhart had not agreed a clear schedule of frequencies with the ship, was reported to have left behind the long trailing antenna that would have given her better range, and never acknowledged a single message from the cutter. The Navy concluded that the aircraft ran out of fuel and came down in the sea somewhere north-west of Howland. Later critics have replied that Thompson’s report also served to deflect blame from his own ship’s handling of the direction-finding equipment.

Pacific islanders

In the Marshall Islands and on Saipan, both under Japanese rule in 1937, people told American servicemen and later researchers of a woman flier and a man held by the Japanese before the war. The broadcaster Fred Goerner gathered many such accounts in the 1960s, and the Marshall Islands issued commemorative stamps in 1987 showing a crash at Mili Atoll. The testimony was collected decades afterwards, often through interpreters and from people asked leading questions, and no document or wreckage supports it. Those who tell it regard the dismissal of island memory as a familiar habit of outsiders.

Japan

The Japanese government has always denied that it captured Earhart, and no record of her has been found in Japanese naval or colonial archives opened after 1945. Japanese vessels, including the survey ship Koshu, took part in the 1937 search at American request. The theory that she was spying on Japanese fortifications in the mandated islands flourished in wartime America and after; historians of the Japanese navy point out that there was little to photograph in the Marshalls in mid-1937 and that her route lay hundreds of miles to the south.

Fellow fliers

Opinion among pilots who knew her was divided then and is now. Some, including her technical adviser Paul Mantz, worried that she was under-prepared and that her schedule was driven by publicity. The record-setting pilot Elinor Smith said for decades that Earhart’s skills had been oversold. Others, and the women’s flying organisation the Ninety-Nines, of which she was first president, answer that she had flown the Atlantic and the Pacific alone, that finding Howland was a severe test for any crew in 1937, and that male pilots who died attempting records were not asked whether they deserved their fame.

What is disputed

Three explanations survive. The crash-and-sink view, argued in detail by Elgen Long, holds that the Electra ran dry near Howland; deep-sea sonar searches have found nothing, and a promising 2024 sonar image proved to be rock. The group TIGHAR, led by Ric Gillespie, argues that she landed on the reef at Gardner Island, now Nikumaroro, 400 miles south, and died a castaway. Bones found there in 1940 were judged male by a colonial doctor and then lost; a 2018 re-analysis of his measurements by the anthropologist Richard Jantz disagreed. The capture theory rests on late testimony. A photograph promoted in 2017 as showing her in the Marshalls had been published in 1935.

What followed

The disappearance fixed Earhart in memory more firmly than any completed flight could have. Navigation across the Pacific was soon made routine by the radio beacons and long-range aids whose absence had doomed her. Expeditions still go out most years, to the sea floor off Howland or the reef at Nikumaroro, and each claimed discovery makes headlines. Howland Island is uninhabited; the unused airstrip has long since been reclaimed by seabirds, and a small day beacon there carries her name.

Read further

  • Susan Butler, East to the Dawn: The Life of Amelia Earhart (1997)
  • Mary S. Lovell, The Sound of Wings: The Life of Amelia Earhart (1989)
  • Elgen M. Long and Marie K. Long, Amelia Earhart: The Mystery Solved (1999)
  • Ric Gillespie, Finding Amelia: The True Story of the Earhart Disappearance (2006)
  • Fred Goerner, The Search for Amelia Earhart (1966)

Same day, other years

1644

The king loses the north at Marston Moor

Near York, EnglandEurope

The largest battle of the English Civil War began at about seven on a summer evening, in a thunderstorm, when the Royalists had concluded there would be no fighting that day. Some 28,000 Parliamentarians and Scottish Covenanters attacked about 18,000 men under Prince Rupert and the Marquess of Newcastle on moorland west of York. Oliver Cromwell’s cavalry and David Leslie’s Scots broke the Royalist right, then wheeled across the field to destroy the rest. Newcastle’s infantry, the Whitecoats, refused quarter and died almost to a man. About four thousand Royalists were killed.

Seen from elsewhere. Royalists blamed one another. Rupert said a letter from the king had commanded him to fight; Newcastle, who thought the battle unnecessary, went abroad rather than face the court. The Scots, who supplied the larger part of the allied army, complained with some justice that Cromwell’s friends in London gave him all the credit.

1823

The Portuguese abandon Bahia

Salvador, BrazilThe Americas

Brazil’s independence, proclaimed by Prince Pedro in September 1822, was not settled in the north-east until a Portuguese garrison under General Madeira de Melo gave up Salvador, the old colonial capital, on 2 July 1823. The city had been besieged for months by a patched-together Brazilian army of militia, volunteers, freed and enslaved Black men and Indigenous fighters, and blockaded from the sea by a squadron under the British mercenary admiral Lord Cochrane. Among the soldiers was Maria Quiteria de Jesus, who had enlisted dressed as a man and was later decorated by the emperor.

Seen from elsewhere. Bahians hold that independence was won here by ordinary people in arms, not by a prince’s cry in Sao Paulo, and celebrate Dois de Julho with a parade led by Indigenous caboclo figures. Enslaved men who fought hoping for freedom were mostly disappointed: slavery in Brazil lasted until 1888.

1839

Captives seize the Amistad

Off the north coast of CubaThe Americas

On the night of 1-2 July 1839, fifty-three Africans being shipped along the Cuban coast on the schooner La Amistad broke their chains. Most were Mende people from what is now Sierra Leone, recently and illegally brought across the Atlantic. Led by a rice farmer named Sengbe Pieh, called Cinque by the Spanish, they killed the captain and the cook and ordered the two planters who had bought them to sail for Africa. The planters steered north by night instead, and after two months the ship was taken off Long Island by an American revenue cutter.

Seen from elsewhere. Spain demanded the return of ship and people as property and as murderers under a 1795 treaty, and President Van Buren was ready to comply. The Supreme Court freed the Africans in 1841 because they had been imported unlawfully, not because slavery was wrong; the same court ruled the captain’s enslaved cabin boy, Antonio, to be Spanish property.

1976

North and South Vietnam become one state

Hanoi, VietnamAsia

Fourteen months after North Vietnamese tanks entered Saigon, a National Assembly elected from both halves of the country met in Hanoi and on 2 July 1976 proclaimed the Socialist Republic of Vietnam. Hanoi became the capital and the North’s flag and anthem those of the whole country; Saigon was renamed Ho Chi Minh City. For the Communist Party this completed the task Ho had set in 1945 and ended a partition, imposed at Geneva in 1954, that it had never accepted as more than temporary. Collectivisation of the South’s economy followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Southern revolutionaries who had expected a gradual merger felt pushed aside; Truong Nhu Tang, a minister in the southern provisional government, described the disillusion in his memoir before fleeing by boat. Hundreds of thousands of people linked to the old southern state were held in re-education camps, some for more than a decade.

Also on 2 July