Parallax

4 July, 1826

Jefferson and Adams die on the fiftieth Fourth of July

The man who drafted the Declaration of Independence and the man who argued it through Congress, allies, then enemies, then friends by letter, died within about five hours of each other on its fiftieth anniversary.

Monticello, Virginia, and Quincy, Massachusetts

Both men had been asked to the jubilee celebrations in Washington and both were too frail to go. Thomas Jefferson, eighty-three, sent the organisers a letter on 24 June that he plainly meant as a last word, hoping the day would remind the world that the mass of mankind had not been born with saddles on their backs, nor a favoured few booted and spurred to ride them. John Adams, ninety, received a delegation from his town of Quincy who asked for a toast to be read at their dinner. He gave them two words: ‘Independence forever.’ Asked if he would add anything, he said, ‘Not a word.’

At Monticello Jefferson had been sinking for a week with an intestinal and urinary illness. On the evening of 3 July he woke and asked those at his bedside whether it was the Fourth yet. His doctor, Robley Dunglison, recorded the question and his own reply that it soon would be. Offered his usual dose of laudanum during the night, Jefferson declined it. He died at about ten to one on the afternoon of the Fourth, as the bells of Charlottesville were ringing for the anniversary.

Five hundred miles north, Adams had collapsed in his chair that morning. In the afternoon he roused himself enough to speak, and the family understood him to say something about Thomas Jefferson. The usual version is ‘Thomas Jefferson survives’. He died at about twenty past six, during a thunderstorm. No news had come from Virginia, and none could have: the fastest riders took days.

The two had met in the Continental Congress in 1775. Adams, the abler speaker, pushed for independence on the floor; Jefferson, the better writer, was given the drafting. They served together as diplomats in Europe and were close friends. Then politics divided them. Jefferson’s supporters beat Adams in the bitter presidential election of 1800, and Adams left Washington before dawn on the day of his rival’s inauguration. They did not write to each other for eleven years.

A mutual friend, the physician Benjamin Rush, coaxed them back into contact in 1812. Over the next fourteen years they exchanged 158 letters on religion, history, aristocracy, old age and their own quarrels. ‘You and I ought not to die,’ Adams wrote in 1813, ‘before we have explained ourselves to each other.’ When word of the double death spread through the country in July 1826, a great many Americans, including Adams’s son, President John Quincy Adams, took it as a visible sign of divine favour.

How it came to this

By 1826 the revolutionary generation was almost gone. Of the fifty-six signers of the Declaration only three were alive at the start of that summer: Adams, Jefferson and Charles Carroll of Maryland. The republic they had launched with thirteen states on the Atlantic seaboard now had twenty-four and reached beyond the Mississippi. The anniversary was treated as a national jubilee, with orations, parades and dinners in almost every town.

The two men had come to stand for the country’s two founding parties and its two sections. Adams, the Massachusetts lawyer, was a Federalist who distrusted pure democracy and never owned a slave. Jefferson, the Virginia planter, wrote that all men are created equal and held some six hundred people in bondage over his lifetime. He died about 107,000 dollars in debt, having petitioned the Virginia legislature that spring for permission to dispose of his property by lottery. The dispute over slavery in Missouri in 1820 had already alarmed him, he wrote, like a fire bell in the night.

How each side saw it

The enslaved community at Monticello

For about 130 people Jefferson’s death meant the auction block. His will freed five men, all members of the Hemings family, among them Madison and Eston Hemings, his sons by Sally Hemings according to Madison’s own account, published in an Ohio newspaper in 1873. Everyone else was sold in January 1827 and afterwards to pay his creditors. Joseph Fossett, the blacksmith, was freed and then watched his wife Edith and their children sold to different buyers. His son Peter, sold at eleven, recalled in an 1898 newspaper interview being put up on the block ‘like a horse’. Their recollections are the main record from the other side of the house.

The providential reading

Daniel Webster, speaking for two hours at Faneuil Hall in Boston that August, said the coincidence was proof that the country and its founders were objects of Heaven’s care. Newspapers of every party agreed. The eulogies smoothed over thirty years of party hatred and presented the pair as joint authors of a single achievement, which neither would quite have accepted in life. Historians such as Andrew Burstein and Merrill Peterson have shown how useful the story was: at a moment of sectional strain it gave Americans a shared civil religion, with the Fourth as its holy day and two saints who had died upon it.

Black Americans and abolitionists

Free Black communities in the North had long been wary of the Fourth, a day when drunken white crowds were dangerous and the rhetoric of liberty excluded them. When New York’s abolition law took final effect on 4 July 1827, Black New Yorkers held their main celebrations on the 5th. Frederick Douglass made the argument famous at Rochester in 1852, in a speech delivered on 5 July, asking what the Fourth of July meant to the American slave and answering that it revealed to him, more than any other day, the injustice to which he was the constant victim. Douglass nonetheless claimed the Declaration’s principles as his own.

What is disputed

Neither set of last words is certain. Jefferson’s question about the date comes in slightly different forms from Dunglison and from his grandson-in-law Nicholas Trist. Adams’s ‘Thomas Jefferson survives’ depends on family report, and one witness said only the name could be made out. The date itself is open to argument: Congress voted for independence on 2 July 1776, the day Adams expected would be celebrated, approved the text on the 4th, and most delegates signed on 2 August. Some writers have wondered whether both men willed themselves to last until the anniversary; this cannot be shown. Jefferson’s paternity of Sally Hemings’s children, supported by a 1998 DNA study and accepted by most historians, is still rejected by a minority.

What followed

The fifth president, James Monroe, also died on 4 July, in 1831, which strengthened the legend. Monticello was sold out of the family; it is now a museum that presents the lives of the enslaved alongside Jefferson’s. The Adams-Jefferson correspondence, published in full in 1959, is read as one of the great American books. The double death of 1826 still supplies the standard closing scene for accounts of the founding, and the contrast between the two men, one of whom wrote the creed while the other never held a slave, still frames the argument about what that founding was.

Read further

  • Lester J. Cappon (ed.), The Adams-Jefferson Letters (1959)
  • Joseph J. Ellis, Founding Brothers: The Revolutionary Generation (2000)
  • Annette Gordon-Reed, The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family (2008)
  • Gordon S. Wood, Friends Divided: John Adams and Thomas Jefferson (2017)
  • Andrew Burstein, America’s Jubilee (2001)

Same day, other years

1054

A ‘guest star’ appears in the sky over China

Kaifeng, ChinaAsia

The court astronomers of the Song emperor Renzong recorded that on a day corresponding to 4 July 1054 a ‘guest star’ appeared in the east before dawn, near the star they called Tianguan, in what Western astronomy calls Taurus. It was bright enough to be seen in daylight for twenty-three days and remained visible at night for most of two years. They were watching a star destroy itself about 6,500 light years away. The expanding cloud of wreckage was catalogued by European astronomers in the eighteenth century and is known as the Crab Nebula.

Seen from elsewhere. The exact date rests on a single line of Chinese record, and a Japanese chronicle seems to place the first sighting weeks earlier. Why no European writer clearly mentions so bright an object is an old puzzle. A rock painting at Chaco Canyon in New Mexico is often said to show it, which can be neither proved nor disproved.

1187

Saladin destroys the army of Jerusalem

Horns of Hattin, GalileeMiddle East

King Guy of Jerusalem marched the largest army the crusader kingdom had ever raised, perhaps twenty thousand men, across dry hills in midsummer to relieve the besieged town of Tiberias. Saladin’s horse archers harried the column until it halted, without water, below the twin hills called the Horns of Hattin. On the morning of 4 July, with the scrub set alight to windward, the Frankish infantry broke ranks and the knights were overwhelmed. Guy was captured along with the relic of the True Cross. Almost every castle and town of the kingdom, stripped of its garrison, fell within months, Jerusalem on 2 October.

Seen from elsewhere. Saladin’s secretary Imad al-Din and the historian Ibn al-Athir record the day as God’s deliverance. Latin writers blamed bad counsel and the quarrels of their own leaders. Saladin spared Guy but killed Reynald of Chatillon with his own hand and had some two hundred captured Templars and Hospitallers beheaded, an episode his later admirers in the West tended to pass over.

1946

The Philippines becomes independent of the United States

Manila, PhilippinesAsia

In a ceremony at the Luneta in war-ruined Manila, the American flag was lowered and the Philippine flag raised, and Manuel Roxas took office as first president of the new republic. It ended forty-eight years of American rule, interrupted by three of Japanese occupation in which perhaps a million Filipinos died. Washington had promised independence in 1934 and chose its own national day to grant it. The terms were hard: in return for reconstruction money the Philippines had to give Americans equal rights to exploit its resources and accept American military bases on long leases.

Seen from elsewhere. Filipino nationalists date independence from 12 June 1898, when Emilio Aguinaldo proclaimed it, only for the United States to crush the new republic in a war that killed hundreds of thousands. In 1962 President Diosdado Macapagal moved Independence Day to 12 June. The Fourth of July was kept for a time as Philippine-American Friendship Day.

1976

Israeli commandos storm Entebbe airport

Entebbe, UgandaAfrica

An Air France airliner hijacked on 27 June by two Palestinians and two West Germans had been flown to Entebbe, where the Ugandan dictator Idi Amin received the hijackers. They released the non-Israeli passengers and held the rest, with the French crew who refused to leave, against the release of fifty-three prisoners. Shortly before midnight on 3 July, four Israeli transport aircraft landed after a flight of some 2,500 miles. In under an hour the raiders had freed 102 hostages. Three hostages died, as did all the hijackers, the Israeli commander Yonatan Netanyahu, and at least twenty Ugandan soldiers.

Seen from elsewhere. Uganda, backed by the Organisation of African Unity, protested to the UN Security Council that its sovereignty had been violated; the Council passed no resolution. A hostage left behind in a Kampala hospital, Dora Bloch, was murdered on Amin’s orders. Amin also had Kenyans living in Uganda killed in revenge for Kenya’s help to Israel.

Also on 4 July