Parallax

15 July, 1099

The First Crusade storms Jerusalem

After three years on the road and five weeks under the walls, the crusaders broke into the holy city and killed most of the people they found there. Their own chroniclers recorded it with pride.

Jerusalem

The army that reached Jerusalem on 7 June 1099 was a remnant. Of the tens of thousands who had left Europe in 1096, perhaps 1,300 knights and 12,000 foot soldiers were left, with a crowd of pilgrims. They were short of water, because the Fatimid governor, Iftikhar al-Dawla, had poisoned or blocked the wells outside the city and driven off the flocks. He had also expelled the Christian inhabitants, who might have opened a gate. An assault on 13 June failed for want of ladders. There was almost no timber in the Judean hills to build anything else.

What saved the siege was the arrival of six Genoese and English ships at Jaffa, carrying ropes, nails, tools and men who knew how to use them. Wood was hauled from forests near Nablus on camels and the backs of prisoners. Over three weeks the crusaders built two wheeled siege towers, a ram and catapults. On 8 July, on the instruction of a priest who had seen a vision, the whole army fasted and walked barefoot in procession round the walls, to the jeers of the garrison, and heard sermons on the Mount of Olives.

The attack began on the night of 13 July at two points. Raymond of Toulouse pushed his tower against the southern wall by Mount Zion, where it was held off and badly burned. In the north Godfrey of Bouillon had his tower dismantled in darkness and rebuilt half a mile to the east, opposite a weaker stretch. All through Thursday the defenders hurled stones and burning pitch at it. On the morning of Friday 15 July the tower reached the wall. Towards midday a beam was pushed across, and two brothers from Tournai, Lethold and Engelbert, crossed first, with Godfrey close behind.

The defence collapsed. The crusaders opened the gates and spread through the streets, killing as they went. Thousands of Muslims fled to the Haram al-Sharif, the great platform holding the Dome of the Rock and the Aqsa mosque. Tancred, a Norman prince, took a ransom from those who climbed on to the mosque roof and gave them his banner as protection. The next morning other crusaders went up and killed them all. Iftikhar, who had withdrawn to the citadel, surrendered it to Raymond in return for safe conduct to Ascalon, and he and his guard were almost the only Muslims to leave alive.

Then, as the anonymous knight who wrote the Gesta Francorum puts it, they went rejoicing and weeping for joy to worship at the Sepulchre of the Saviour.

How it came to this

Jerusalem had been under Muslim rule since 638, and for most of that time Christian pilgrims had come and gone. In the 1070s Seljuk Turks, newly converted and expanding westwards, took Syria and Palestine from the Fatimid caliphs of Cairo and defeated the Byzantine Empire in Anatolia. The emperor Alexios I Komnenos asked the pope for soldiers. In November 1095, at Clermont in France, Urban II went much further, calling on the knights of the West to go to the aid of the eastern Christians and free Jerusalem, and offering remission of penance to those who took the cross.

The response surprised everyone. Bands led by popular preachers set out first, massacring Jewish communities in the Rhineland on the way, and were destroyed in Anatolia. The armies of the princes followed, fought their way across Asia Minor, and took Antioch in 1098 after a siege of eight months that nearly finished them. The Muslim powers were divided between Sunni Seljuks and Shia Fatimids and between rival Seljuk emirs, and none treated the Franks as the main enemy. The Fatimids had actually retaken Jerusalem from the Turks in August 1098 and tried to negotiate with the crusaders as possible allies.

How each side saw it

The Latin chroniclers

Three eyewitnesses left accounts: the author of the Gesta Francorum, Raymond of Aguilers and Fulcher of Chartres, who arrived shortly after. None conceals the killing. Raymond writes that in the Temple men rode in blood up to their knees and bridle reins, a phrase borrowed from the Book of Revelation, and calls it a just and splendid judgment of God that the place should be filled with the blood of those who had profaned it. To them the city had been polluted and was being cleansed, and the victory against such odds proved that God had willed the journey.

Muslim writers

The earliest Muslim notices are brief. Ibn al-Qalanisi of Damascus, writing within living memory, records that many were killed and that the Jews were burned in their synagogue. Ibn al-Arabi, a scholar in the region at the time, gives 3,000 dead in the Aqsa mosque. The figure of 70,000, with imams, scholars and ascetics among them, comes from Ibn al-Athir more than a century later. Refugees reached Baghdad in Ramadan and wept in the caliph’s mosque, and a poet reproached the princes of Islam for sleeping. No army came. The call to a counter-crusade, first made by al-Sulami in Damascus in 1105, took decades to be heard.

The Jews of Jerusalem

Jews had fought on the walls of their quarter in the north-east, where Godfrey’s men broke in. Letters preserved in the Cairo Geniza, written within months by community leaders in Egypt and studied by S. D. Goitein, add what the chronicles lack. They speak of those killed, but also of many captives, men and women, taken to be sold, and of a great effort by the Jews of Ascalon and Cairo to raise money to ransom them and to buy back hundreds of looted books and Torah scrolls. One letter notes that the Franks, unlike other conquerors, did not rape the women.

Eastern Christians

The Greek, Syrian, Armenian and Georgian Christians of Jerusalem had been expelled before the siege and so survived it, but the victory was not theirs. The Greek patriarch had died in exile, and the crusaders installed a Latin one, Arnulf of Chocques, who removed the eastern clergy from the Holy Sepulchre and, by the Latin sources’ own account, had Orthodox priests tortured until they revealed where a fragment of the True Cross was hidden. Byzantine writers such as Anna Komnene regarded the Franks as oath-breakers who had promised to restore imperial lands and kept them.

What is disputed

The scale of the massacre is the main dispute. Medieval figures run from 3,000 to 70,000, and the city’s population after the expulsions and flight may have been only 20,000 to 30,000. Some historians have argued the Latin accounts exaggerate for effect, using biblical language; Benjamin Kedar’s review of the evidence concludes that the killing was real, extensive and continued for three days. The Geniza letters show that survivors were more numerous than the chronicles imply. The book’s remark that the day was the anniversary of the Hijra is mistaken: by the Muslim lunar calendar it fell in the month of Shaban 492. Godfrey’s exact title is also uncertain.

What followed

A week later the princes chose Godfrey as ruler; he is said to have refused to be called king in the city where Christ wore thorns. On 12 August he routed a Fatimid relief army at Ascalon. Pope Urban died in Rome on 29 July without hearing the news. The Latin kingdom held Jerusalem for eighty-eight years, until Saladin took it in October 1187 and, pointedly, let its people ransom themselves. In the Muslim world the events of 1099 were recalled far more in the twentieth century than in the centuries before, and they remain a reference point in the politics of the region.

Read further

  • Gesta Francorum et aliorum Hierosolimitanorum, edited and translated by Rosalind Hill (1962)
  • Francesco Gabrieli, Arab Historians of the Crusades (1969)
  • Carole Hillenbrand, The Crusades: Islamic Perspectives (1999)
  • Thomas Asbridge, The First Crusade: A New History (2004)
  • Jonathan Riley-Smith, The First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading (1986)

Same day, other years

1410

Poland and Lithuania break the Teutonic Knights at Grunwald

Grunwald, Prussia (now Poland)Europe

The Teutonic Order, a crusading brotherhood of German knights, ruled Prussia and the Baltic coast and had fought pagan Lithuania for more than a century. Lithuania’s conversion and its union with Poland in 1386 removed the Order’s reason for existing without ending its wars. On 15 July 1410 the combined army of King Wladyslaw Jagiello and his cousin Grand Duke Vytautas, with Ruthenian, Tatar, Bohemian and Moldavian contingents, met the Order’s forces between the villages of Grunwald and Tannenberg. After hours of fighting the Grand Master, Ulrich von Jungingen, and most of his senior officers lay dead. The Order’s castle at Marienburg held out, and the peace of 1411 cost it little land, but its power never recovered.

Seen from elsewhere. Three nations use three names: Grunwald, Tannenberg and Zalgiris. The Polish chronicler Dlugosz says the Lithuanians fled; Lithuanian historians, citing a letter published by Sven Ekdahl, call it a feigned retreat. Germans named their 1914 victory nearby Tannenberg to cancel the memory. Belarusians and Russians also claim the banners that held the line.

1799

French soldiers find the Rosetta Stone

Rashid (Rosetta), EgyptAfrica

Napoleon’s army had occupied Egypt for a year when soldiers strengthening an old fort near the town of Rashid, on the western mouth of the Nile, pulled a broken slab of dark granodiorite out of a wall. The officer in charge, Pierre-Francois Bouchard, saw that it carried three bands of writing and sent it to the scholars in Cairo. The text is a priestly decree of 196 BC honouring the boy king Ptolemy V, given in hieroglyphs, in the everyday Egyptian script called demotic, and in Greek. When the French surrendered in 1801 the British claimed it, and it has been in the British Museum since 1802. Jean-Francois Champollion announced his decipherment of hieroglyphs in 1822.

Seen from elsewhere. The exact day was not recorded; mid-July is certain and 15 July is the date usually given. Egyptian archaeologists have repeatedly asked for the stone’s return as a spoil of war. The museum replies that it was ceded under a treaty, which an Ottoman officer signed and no Egyptian did. British writers long pressed Thomas Young’s prior claim against Champollion.

1974

A coup in Cyprus opens the way to partition

Nicosia, CyprusEurope

On the morning of 15 July 1974 the Cypriot National Guard, led by officers from mainland Greece and acting for the military junta in Athens, attacked the presidential palace in Nicosia with tanks. The president, Archbishop Makarios, escaped through a back gate and was flown out by the British. The plotters installed Nikos Sampson, a gunman known for attacks on Turkish Cypriots, with the aim of union with Greece. Five days later Turkey landed troops on the north coast, citing its rights as a guarantor of the island’s 1960 constitution. A second offensive in August left it holding more than a third of Cyprus. Some 160,000 Greek Cypriots fled south and about 45,000 Turkish Cypriots later moved north.

Seen from elsewhere. Greek Cypriots speak of invasion and occupation, Turkish Cypriots of a peace operation that ended a decade in which they had been attacked and confined to enclaves. The junta fell within days. The state declared in the north in 1983 is recognised only by Turkey, and roughly two thousand people from both communities were listed as missing.

2016

Part of the Turkish army attempts a coup

Istanbul and Ankara, TurkeyMiddle East

On the evening of Friday 15 July 2016 soldiers blocked the bridges over the Bosphorus, tanks appeared at Istanbul’s airport, and jets flew low over Ankara. A statement read on state television announced that a ‘peace council’ had taken power. President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, on holiday on the coast, reached a television presenter by video call on a mobile phone and told people to go into the streets. Tens of thousands did, and mosques broadcast the call through the night. Rebel aircraft bombed the parliament building, and soldiers fired on crowds. By morning the attempt had failed. About 250 people opposing it were killed, along with dozens of soldiers on the other side.

Seen from elsewhere. The government blamed followers of the preacher Fethullah Gulen, a former ally living in the United States, who denied any part; Washington declined to extradite him. Under two years of emergency rule more than 100,000 public employees were dismissed and tens of thousands jailed, among them Kurdish politicians, journalists and academics. Critics called it a purge of all opposition.

Also on 15 July