Parallax

28 July, 1794

Robespierre goes to the guillotine

Outlawed by the Convention he had dominated, his jaw smashed by a pistol ball, Maximilien Robespierre was executed without trial on 10 Thermidor. The men who killed him had as much blood on their hands as he did, and wrote the history.

Paris, France

On 26 July 1794, 8 Thermidor of Year II in the revolutionary calendar, Robespierre came back to the National Convention after weeks of absence and spoke for two hours. He said that a conspiracy against liberty reached into the Convention and its governing committees, and that it must be purged. He would not say whom he meant. Every deputy with a bad conscience, and after a year of Terror there were many, concluded that it might be him.

The next day his young ally Saint-Just rose to speak and was cut off within minutes. Tallien and Billaud-Varenne took the rostrum; the chairman rang his bell whenever Robespierre tried to answer, and deputies shouted ‘Down with the tyrant’. The Convention voted the arrest of Robespierre, Saint-Just and the paralysed Georges Couthon. Robespierre’s brother Augustin and Philippe Le Bas asked to share their fate and were taken too.

It nearly failed. The Paris Commune, loyal to Robespierre, called the city to arms, the gaolers refused to lock up the prisoners, and by evening all five were free at the Hotel de Ville with guns and guardsmen in the square outside. But they hesitated to lead an insurrection against the elected assembly, most of the city’s forty-eight sections sent no men, and after midnight the square emptied. The Convention declared them outlaws, which meant they could be executed on proof of identity alone.

At about two in the morning of 28 July the Convention’s forces walked in almost unopposed. Le Bas shot himself dead. Augustin Robespierre jumped from a window and broke his leg. Couthon was found at the foot of a staircase. Maximilien was found with his lower jaw shattered by a pistol ball. He was carried on a plank to the Committee of Public Safety’s rooms and lay for hours on a table, dabbing at the blood, while people came to stare.

That afternoon the Revolutionary Tribunal took a few minutes to confirm who the prisoners were. Three carts carried twenty-two men to the Place de la Revolution, now the Place de la Concorde, through crowds that jeered. Robespierre, aged 36, was the last but one to climb the scaffold. The executioner tore away the bandage holding his jaw together, and witnesses remembered the scream. Over the next two days 83 members of the Commune followed him.

How it came to this

Robespierre was a provincial lawyer from Arras who came to Versailles in 1789 as a deputy and made his name as the most consistent democrat in the assembly. He argued for votes for all men, for civil rights for Jews and actors, against slavery and, in 1791, against the death penalty. He opposed the war of 1792. His followers called him the Incorruptible. In July 1793 he joined the Committee of Public Safety, twelve men who governed a republic invaded on every frontier and in civil war in the west. He was its best-known voice, never its chairman or master.

Under that government revolutionary courts passed about 16,600 death sentences, and many more people died in prison or were killed without trial, above all in the Vendee. Robespierre defended terror as justice made swift, had the factions to his left and right executed in spring 1794, among them his old colleague Danton, and backed the law of 22 Prairial, which stripped defendants of counsel. In the seven weeks after it more than 1,300 people were guillotined in Paris. By then French armies were winning, and the emergency that had justified it all was passing.

How each side saw it

The Thermidorians

The men who brought him down said they had saved the Republic from a dictator. Their official report, compiled by the deputy Courtois from papers seized in Robespierre’s lodgings, portrayed a would-be tyrant, and stories were put about that he had planned to marry Louis XVI’s daughter and make himself king. Several of the plotters, including Fouche, Tallien, Barras and Collot d’Herbois, had directed mass executions in Lyon, Bordeaux and the south, and had reason to fear Robespierre would call them to account. Loading the Terror on to one dead man suited them, and their version shaped opinion for a century.

Working Paris

The sans-culottes who had carried the Revolution in 1792 and 1793 mostly stayed at home on the night of 9 Thermidor. The government had executed their own spokesmen that spring and shut down the section clubs, and only days earlier the Commune had published a scale of maximum wages that cut many workers’ pay. Police reports say labourers shouted curses on the ‘maximum’ as the carts went by. They gained nothing by it: price controls were abolished within months, the winter of 1794-95 brought hunger, and the last popular risings were put down by the army in the spring.

The families of the condemned

For the tens of thousands who had lost relatives to the tribunals, and for royalist and Catholic France, the scene on the scaffold was justice, and accounts describe women in the crowd calling down their children’s deaths upon him. Prisons began to empty within days. In the west, where republican columns had killed civilians in very large numbers, Robespierre’s name stood for the whole Republic, although the worst of that repression had been carried out by generals and deputies on mission. Revenge followed: in 1795 gangs in Lyon and the Rhone valley murdered former Jacobins in what became known as the White Terror.

Historians who defend him

From the early twentieth century Albert Mathiez and the society for Robespierrist studies he founded argued that Robespierre was a sincere democrat who tried to restrain the worst terrorists and was killed by corrupt men for it. They point out that he had stayed away from the committee during the bloodiest weeks. Francois Furet and others replied that his language of virtue and conspiracy was the Terror’s own logic. More recently Jean-Clement Martin has argued that ‘the Terror’ as a single system was itself a label invented after Thermidor, and biographers such as Peter McPhee describe an exhausted, sick man rather than a monster.

What is disputed

How Robespierre’s jaw was broken is unsettled. A young gendarme named Merda claimed to have shot him and was rewarded for it; many historians think Robespierre tried to kill himself and misjudged the shot. A half-signed appeal to his own section, bearing the letters ‘Ro’ and dark stains, has been read as evidence either way. He was never tried: the tribunal only identified him. He did not head the Committee of Public Safety, and the popular image of a personal dictatorship is rejected by most specialists. Total deaths in the Terror are estimates, usually put between 30,000 and 40,000 excluding the war in the Vendee, where figures are far higher and bitterly contested.

What followed

The Convention dismantled the machinery of the Terror over the following months, closed the Jacobin Club in November and put some of the worst offenders, such as Carrier of the Nantes drownings, on trial. A new constitution in 1795 restricted the vote to property owners and created the Directory, which a general named Bonaparte overthrew four years later. ‘Thermidor’ entered the political vocabulary for the moment a revolution turns on its radicals; Trotsky applied it to Stalin. France has never agreed about Robespierre. Paris has a Metro station named after him in a suburb, and no street.

Read further

  • Colin Jones, The Fall of Robespierre: 24 Hours in Revolutionary Paris (2021)
  • Peter McPhee, Robespierre: A Revolutionary Life (2012)
  • R. R. Palmer, Twelve Who Ruled: The Year of the Terror in the French Revolution (1941)
  • Donald Greer, The Incidence of the Terror during the French Revolution (1935)
  • Ruth Scurr, Fatal Purity: Robespierre and the French Revolution (2006)

Same day, other years

1402

Timur captures the Ottoman sultan at Ankara

Cubuk plain, near Ankara, AnatoliaMiddle East

Bayezid I, called the Thunderbolt, had spent a decade swallowing the Turkish principalities of Anatolia and had Constantinople under blockade. The dispossessed princes fled to Timur, the conqueror of Persia, Delhi and Damascus, who marched west. The armies met north of Ankara in the heat of late July 1402. Timur had cut the Ottomans off from water. During the battle the Anatolian cavalry, seeing their former lords on the other side, went over to them, and the Tatar auxiliaries followed. Bayezid’s Serbian vassals and his janissaries fought on until evening. The sultan was caught trying to ride away and died in captivity the following March.

Seen from elsewhere. The date is usually given as 28 July, though some sources say 20 July. The tale that Timur kept Bayezid in an iron cage comes from later writers and may have grown from a barred litter. Byzantium saw a miracle: the siege was lifted and the city survived another fifty years.

1540

Thomas Cromwell is beheaded; the king marries the same day

Tower Hill, LondonEurope

For eight years Thomas Cromwell, a Putney tradesman’s son, had run Henry VIII’s government. He steered the break with Rome through Parliament, dissolved the monasteries and brought down Anne Boleyn. Then he arranged the king’s marriage to Anne of Cleves, which Henry disliked from the first meeting. On 10 June 1540 he was arrested at the council table. He was condemned for treason and heresy by act of attainder, without a trial, and kept alive long enough to give evidence for the annulment. His letter from the Tower ends with a plea for ‘mercy, mercy, mercy’. He was beheaded on 28 July. That day at Oatlands Henry married Catherine Howard, niece of Cromwell’s chief enemy.

Seen from elsewhere. The northern rebels of 1536 had demanded his head as a heretic and despoiler of the church, and conservative nobles thought him a base-born upstart. Henry was complaining within months, according to the French ambassador, that he had been tricked into killing his most faithful servant. Historians still divide between Cromwell the state-builder and Cromwell the enforcer.

1821

San Martin proclaims the independence of Peru

Lima, PeruThe Americas

Jose de San Martin, the Argentine general who had crossed the Andes to free Chile, landed in Peru in 1820 with a small army carried by a Chilean fleet under the British admiral Cochrane. He preferred to wait and negotiate. In July 1821 the Spanish viceroy abandoned Lima for the highlands, and the city’s notables signed an act of independence. On 28 July, in the main square, San Martin unfurled a new flag and declared Peru ‘free and independent by the general will of the people and by the justice of its cause, which God defends’. He took the title of Protector. The royalist army was still intact; the war was won only at Ayacucho in December 1824.

Seen from elsewhere. Lima was the most loyal capital in Spanish America, and many of its elite signed out of fear of disorder once the viceroy had gone. Some Peruvian historians have called it an independence brought from outside. Indigenous communities fought on both sides, and the tribute they paid was soon reimposed by the republic.

1976

An earthquake flattens Tangshan

Tangshan, Hebei, ChinaAsia

At 3.42 in the morning of 28 July 1976 a fault ruptured directly beneath Tangshan, a coal and steel city of about a million people east of Beijing. Almost every building was unreinforced brick. Within seconds most of the city had collapsed on its sleeping inhabitants, and a strong aftershock that afternoon brought down much of what was left. Miners coming off shift and soldiers dug survivors out by hand. The government announced that China would rely on its own efforts and declined foreign help. The official death toll, not released until 1979, was about 242,000, which makes it one of the deadliest earthquakes ever recorded.

Seen from elsewhere. An early provincial estimate of 655,000 dead leaked abroad, and some researchers believe the official figure is too low. Seismologists had warned of a possible large quake in the region; one county, Qinglong, acted on the warning and evacuated its buildings in time. Mao died six weeks later, and many Chinese read the disaster as an omen.

Also on 28 July