Parallax

20 July, 1944

The briefcase under Hitler’s table

A colonel with one hand and one eye planted a bomb a few feet from Adolf Hitler, flew to Berlin believing him dead, and was shot in a courtyard before the day was out.

The Wolf’s Lair, near Rastenburg, East Prussia

Claus Schenk Graf von Stauffenberg landed at Rastenburg airfield a little after ten in the morning with his adjutant, Werner von Haeften, and two packets of plastic explosive. As chief of staff to the commander of the Reserve Army he had been summoned to report at Hitler’s daily conference. On arrival he learned that the meeting had been brought forward to half past twelve because Mussolini was expected that afternoon.

That cost him time he needed. He asked for a room in which to change his shirt, and there, with a pair of pliers adapted for a man who had lost his right hand, two fingers of his left and his left eye in Tunisia the year before, he crushed the acid fuse on the first charge. A sergeant knocked to hurry him. The second charge went back into Haeften’s bag unarmed. Experts have judged that both together would have killed everyone in the room.

The conference was held in a wooden hut with its windows open against the heat. Stauffenberg put his briefcase under the heavy oak map table, to Hitler’s right, murmured that he had a telephone call to make, and left. An officer who found the case in his way, Colonel Heinz Brandt, pushed it to the far side of one of the table’s solid supports. At 12.42 it exploded. Four of the twenty-four men present died, Brandt among them. Hitler, shielded by the table support, came out with burst eardrums, burns and his trousers in ribbons.

Stauffenberg saw the blast, talked his way through two checkpoints and flew to Berlin certain that Hitler was dead. There the plan was to issue the orders code-named Valkyrie, written for use against internal unrest, and have the Reserve Army arrest the SS and Party leadership. But his fellow conspirators at army headquarters in the Bendlerstrasse had heard conflicting reports and waited more than three hours. In Paris the plotters did arrest over a thousand SS and security men. In Berlin a guard battalion commander, Major Otto Remer, sent to seize Goebbels, was instead handed a telephone and heard Hitler’s voice.

By evening officers loyal to the regime had retaken the building. General Friedrich Fromm, who had known of the plot and now needed witnesses silenced, held a court martial on the spot. Shortly after midnight Stauffenberg, Haeften, General Friedrich Olbricht and Colonel Albrecht Mertz von Quirnheim were shot by the light of a lorry’s headlamps. Fromm was himself executed the following March.

How it came to this

There had been plans to remove Hitler since 1938, when a group of generals and diplomats prepared a coup to forestall war over Czechoslovakia and abandoned it after the Munich agreement. Victory in 1940 silenced most military doubters. Opposition revived on the eastern front, where Colonel Henning von Tresckow gathered officers at Army Group Centre who made several attempts in 1943, including a bomb disguised as bottles of brandy that failed to go off in Hitler’s aircraft. Around them were civilians of very different politics: the conservative former mayor Carl Goerdeler, Social Democrats such as Julius Leber, and the Kreisau Circle of Helmuth James von Moltke, which planned for a Germany after Hitler but mostly rejected assassination.

By July 1944 the war was plainly lost. The Allies were ashore in Normandy and the Red Army had just destroyed Army Group Centre. The Gestapo was closing in: Moltke had been arrested in January and Leber on 5 July. Stauffenberg, a Catholic aristocrat from Swabia who had at first welcomed the regime’s early successes, was the only conspirator with regular access to Hitler, and he was also the man needed in Berlin to run the coup.

How each side saw it

The conspirators

They knew the odds. Tresckow’s message to Stauffenberg, recorded by his aide Fabian von Schlabrendorff, was that the attempt must be made at any cost, because what mattered was no longer the practical result but that the German resistance should have dared the decisive act before the world and before history. Tresckow killed himself at the front the next day. In the People’s Court, before the shouting judge Roland Freisler, several defendants said plainly that they had acted because of the murders committed in Germany’s name. Stauffenberg’s last words are reported as a cry to holy Germany, or in another hearing, secret Germany.

Germans at the time, and after

Security service reports on public opinion in the days after the bomb recorded shock and relief that the Fuhrer had survived, and anger at a clique of officers; how freely anyone spoke is another matter. After 1945 many West Germans still regarded the plotters as oath-breakers. Remer, by then a neo-Nazi politician, called them traitors and was convicted of defamation in 1952 in a case brought by the prosecutor Fritz Bauer, a turning point in their rehabilitation. East Germany honoured Communist resistance instead and treated the officers as reactionaries until the 1980s. The Bendlerblock courtyard is now the national memorial.

The Allies

London and Washington had refused contact with the German opposition and held to the demand for unconditional surrender announced in 1943. Churchill told the Commons in August 1944 that the highest personalities in the Reich were murdering one another. The Allies feared a repeat of 1918, with a German army claiming it had never been beaten, and distrusted men who hoped to make peace in the west while holding the line in the east. After the war Churchill was widely credited with a tribute to the resistance, but no record of his making it has been found.

Critical historians

Hans Mommsen and others have pointed out that most of the conspirators were not democrats. Goerdeler’s drafts envisaged an authoritarian state and kept Austria, the Sudetenland and the 1914 frontier with Poland. Christian Gerlach has documented the involvement of some Army Group Centre officers in the killing of Jews and civilians in occupied Belarus before they turned against Hitler. Defenders, among them Peter Hoffmann, answer that the persecution of the Jews is named as a motive in the plotters’ own papers and testimony, and that men inside a criminal system were the only ones in a position to strike at it.

What is disputed

Could the coup have succeeded had Hitler died? Many historians doubt it, given the loyalty of the SS and of most generals, and the conspirators’ failure to seize the radio and telephone exchanges. The number of victims of the reprisals is often given as nearly 5,000 executed out of 7,000 arrested; that figure comes from a wartime British source and sweeps in unrelated cases, and research since puts executions directly tied to the plot at about 200. How much Field Marshal Rommel knew, before he was forced to take poison in October, remains unsettled.

What followed

The trials ran until the last weeks of the war. Defendants were hanged at Plotzensee prison from meat hooks, and the executions were filmed. Under the practice of kin liability, wives were imprisoned and children taken to a home under new names. By the reckoning of the historian Rudiger Overmans, about as many German soldiers died in the ten months after 20 July as in the previous five years of war, and the death camps and death marches continued to the end. The plot gave post-war Germany an answer, however partial, to the question of whether anyone had tried.

Read further

  • Peter Hoffmann, The History of the German Resistance, 1933-1945 (1977)
  • Joachim Fest, Plotting Hitler’s Death: The German Resistance to Hitler, 1933-1945 (1996)
  • Ian Kershaw, Hitler, 1936-1945: Nemesis (2000)
  • Hans Mommsen, Alternatives to Hitler: German Resistance under the Third Reich (2003)
  • Fabian von Schlabrendorff, The Secret War Against Hitler (1965)

Same day, other years

1402

Timur captures the Ottoman sultan at Ankara

Ankara, AnatoliaMiddle East

Bayezid I, called the Thunderbolt, had spent a decade swallowing the Turkish principalities of Anatolia and besieging Constantinople. Timur, the Central Asian conqueror who had already sacked Delhi, Aleppo, Damascus and Baghdad, took the dispossessed princes under his protection and marched west. On the plain north of Ankara the Anatolian cavalry in Bayezid’s army saw their former lords under Timur’s banners and went over to them. The sultan’s Serbian vassals and his janissaries fought on until evening. Bayezid was run down and captured, and died in captivity eight months later. His sons fought each other for eleven years, and Constantinople, which had been close to surrender, survived for another half century.

Seen from elsewhere. Timurid court histories say the sultan was treated with honour. The tale that he was carried about in an iron cage, made famous by Marlowe, comes from hostile and later writers and may rest on a word for a barred litter. Some sources date the battle to 28 July.

1810

A quarrel over a flower vase starts a revolution in Bogota

Bogota, New GranadaThe Americas

It was market day. A group of American-born notables sent to borrow an ornamental vase from a Spanish shopkeeper, Jose Gonzalez Llorente, for a dinner in honour of a visiting royal commissioner, expecting a refusal they could use. They got one, with an insult by their account, and the argument spilled into the main square. By evening a crowd had forced the viceroy to permit an open meeting of the town council, which sat through the night and set up a governing junta. With Spain occupied by Napoleon and its king a prisoner, similar juntas were forming across the continent. Colombia keeps 20 July as its independence day.

Seen from elsewhere. The act signed that night swore loyalty to Ferdinand VII and named the viceroy as the junta’s president; a full break with Spain came later and province by province. Much of the population, including Indigenous communities around Pasto, fought for the king for another decade.

1951

King Abdullah is shot at the door of al-Aqsa

JerusalemMiddle East

Abdullah I of Jordan had come up to Jerusalem for Friday prayers with his fifteen-year-old grandson Hussein. As he stepped through the entrance of the al-Aqsa mosque a young tailor’s apprentice, Mustafa Ashu, came from behind the door and shot him in the head at close range. The guards killed the gunman on the spot. A second bullet struck the boy and, by his own account, glanced off a medal his grandfather had insisted he wear. Abdullah had annexed the West Bank the year before and was known to have been in secret talks with Israel. Six men were condemned, among them a relative of the exiled former mufti of Jerusalem. Hussein became king in 1952.

Seen from elsewhere. To many Palestinians Abdullah had traded their country for an enlarged kingdom of his own; Avi Shlaim’s study of his dealings with the Zionist leadership is titled Collusion Across the Jordan. Jordanian accounts present him as a realist who saved the Old City and the West Bank from the wreck of 1948.

1974

Turkish troops land on Cyprus

Kyrenia, CyprusEurope

Five days earlier the military junta in Athens had used the Cypriot National Guard to overthrow President Makarios and install a gunman who favoured union with Greece. Turkey, citing its right as a guarantor of the 1960 independence settlement, landed troops on the north coast at dawn on 20 July and dropped paratroops near Nicosia. The junta in Athens collapsed within days. After talks failed, a second Turkish offensive in mid-August took about 36 per cent of the island. Some 160,000 Greek Cypriots fled or were driven south and tens of thousands of Turkish Cypriots moved north. About 2,000 people from both communities were listed as missing. The dividing line still runs through Nicosia.

Seen from elsewhere. Turkey calls it a peace operation that saved Turkish Cypriots, who had been attacked and confined to enclaves since 1963, from annexation by Greece. Greek Cypriots and repeated UN resolutions call it an invasion and an occupation. The state declared in the north in 1983 is recognised only by Turkey.

Also on 20 July