Parallax

25 July, 1593

Henri IV kneels at Saint-Denis

After four years of failing to conquer his own kingdom by force, the Protestant king of France walked to an abbey door in white satin and asked to be let into the Catholic Church. Whether he meant it has been argued over ever since.

Saint-Denis, near Paris, France

On Friday 23 July 1593 Henri of Navarre, king of France in law since 1589 and in practice of perhaps half of it, sat down at Saint-Denis with a group of bishops and theologians for a morning of instruction that ran to about five hours. He had been a Calvinist, then a Catholic under threat of death after the St Bartholomew massacre of 1572, then a Calvinist again. That day he wrote to his mistress, Gabrielle d’Estrees, that on Sunday he would take ‘the perilous leap’. The phrase is his own and survives in the letter.

On the Sunday morning, 25 July, he dressed in white satin with a black cloak and hat and walked through decorated streets to the abbey church where the kings of France were buried. Renaud de Beaune, archbishop of Bourges, sat waiting in a chair at the great door with other prelates around him. The exchange that followed was scripted. Who are you? The king. What do you ask? To be received into the bosom of the Catholic, Apostolic and Roman Church. Do you wish it? Yes, I wish it and desire it.

Henri knelt, swore to live and die in the Roman faith and to renounce all heresies contrary to it, handed over a signed profession, and kissed the archbishop’s ring. He was absolved and led inside to the altar, where he repeated the oath, made his confession behind a curtain and heard High Mass. The crowd shouted for the king.

A good part of that crowd had come out from Paris, which was still held against him by the Catholic League and a Spanish garrison. The papal legate, Cardinal Filippo Sega, had forbidden Parisians to attend on pain of excommunication and declared in advance that the ceremony was void, since only the pope could absolve a relapsed heretic. They walked the few miles north anyway. It was the clearest sign Henri had yet been given that the capital was tired of the war.

The leap did not win the kingdom at once. Reims, where kings were crowned, was in League hands, so Henri was anointed at Chartres in February 1594, with oil from a different holy phial. In March the governor of Paris opened the gates at dawn and the king rode in almost without a shot, then stood at a window to watch the Spanish troops march out. Pope Clement VIII did not grant his own absolution until September 1595, and the last League magnates and Spain did not make peace until 1598.

How it came to this

France had been fighting over religion since 1562. By the 1580s the wars had become a three-cornered struggle between the Valois crown, the Huguenot party led by Henri of Navarre, and the Catholic League of the Guise family, which Philip II of Spain subsidised. In 1584 the death of the king’s last brother made Navarre heir to the throne under the Salic law. The League refused to accept a heretic. In 1588 Henri III had the Guise brothers murdered at Blois, and on 1 August 1589 he was himself stabbed by a Dominican friar, Jacques Clement. Dying, he recognised Navarre and urged him to convert.

Henri IV beat the League in the field at Arques and Ivry, but he could not take Paris. His siege of 1590 starved the city, killing people in numbers contemporaries put in the tens of thousands, before a Spanish army from the Netherlands relieved it. In 1593 the League called an Estates General in Paris to elect a Catholic king, and Spain put forward Philip’s daughter, the Infanta Isabella. That overreach offended French opinion, the Parlement of Paris upheld the Salic law in June, and royalist Catholics negotiating at Suresnes told Henri the moment had come.

How each side saw it

The Huguenots who had fought for him

For the Protestant minority this was the loss of their protector, and some called it betrayal. Philippe Duplessis-Mornay, his closest Calvinist adviser, was kept away from the instruction and wrote to him in reproach. The soldier-poet Agrippa d’Aubigne, in his Histoire universelle, treated the abjuration as a fall for which the king would be punished. Elizabeth I of England, who had sent him money and men, wrote a famous letter of dismay asking what griefs and regrets she felt at the news. Huguenot assemblies spent the next five years pressing for written guarantees, which is how the Edict of Nantes came about.

The Catholic League and Rome

To committed Leaguers the ceremony was theatre. Henri had abjured once before and gone back, the bishops at Saint-Denis had no authority to lift a papal excommunication, and a convenient conversion on the eve of a rival’s election proved nothing. The Paris preacher Jean Boucher delivered and then printed a series of sermons on the ‘simulated conversion’. Rome held the same line for two years: Clement VIII refused to receive the king’s envoy in 1593. The League’s own records and pamphlets survive in quantity, and they show that this was a mass urban movement with real religious conviction, not merely a Spanish instrument.

The royalist Catholics, or ‘politiques’

Catholics who had backed Henri since 1589 saw the conversion as the only exit from a war that was destroying the country and inviting a Spanish succession. Their case was that the state could survive two religions but not the loss of its lawful king. The Paris diarist Pierre de L’Estoile, a royalist lawyer living under League rule, recorded the hunger, the processions and the relief. The Satyre Menippee, a satire written by a group of Paris royalists and printed in 1594, mocked the League’s Estates General and did much to fix the image of Henri as the reasonable man among fanatics.

What is disputed

The line ‘Paris is well worth a Mass’ is almost certainly not Henri’s. It is not in any contemporary account of the conversion; a version first appears in print in 1622, in an anonymous satire, put into the mouth of his minister Sully. Sincerity is the real argument. An older tradition, shared by admirers and enemies, makes him a sceptic who changed churches as policy required. Michael Wolfe has shown how seriously contemporaries debated the question, and Ronald Love argues that Henri held real religious convictions and resisted conversion for four years at great cost precisely because it troubled his conscience. The abbey of Saint-Denis, often called a cathedral in accounts of the day, became one only in 1966.

What followed

In April 1598 Henri signed the Edict of Nantes, giving Huguenots liberty of conscience, worship in specified places, access to offices and fortified towns of their own. It was a truce between two confessions rather than a statement of toleration, and Catholic parlements registered it under protest. Henri was stabbed to death in his coach in Paris on 14 May 1610 by Francois Ravaillac, a Catholic who believed the king was about to make war on the pope. His grandson Louis XIV revoked the edict in 1685. French memory later made ‘good King Henri’ the most popular of its monarchs.

Read further

  • Michael Wolfe, The Conversion of Henri IV: Politics, Power, and Religious Belief in Early Modern France (1993)
  • Ronald S. Love, Blood and Religion: The Conscience of Henri IV, 1553-1593 (2001)
  • Mack P. Holt, The French Wars of Religion, 1562-1629 (1995)
  • David Buisseret, Henry IV (1984)
  • Pierre de L’Estoile, Memoires-Journaux

Same day, other years

1261

Constantinople falls back into Greek hands

ConstantinopleEurope

Since the Fourth Crusade sacked it in 1204, Constantinople had been the capital of a shrinking Latin empire propped up by Venice. In July 1261 Alexios Strategopoulos, a general of the Greek successor state at Nicaea, was passing through Thrace with about 800 men, many of them Cuman horsemen, on a reconnaissance. Local farmers told him the Latin garrison and the Venetian fleet were away attacking an island in the Black Sea. In the night of 24 to 25 July his men slipped in through a passage by a gate, opened it from inside and took the city by morning. The Latin emperor Baldwin II fled by ship. Michael VIII Palaiologos entered on 15 August.

Seen from elsewhere. Western accounts treated it as a theft to be reversed, and popes and Angevin kings planned reconquest for decades. The restoration was also founded on a crime: within months Michael had the eleven-year-old legitimate emperor, John IV Laskaris, blinded. The Greek historian George Pachymeres records the bitterness this left in Asia Minor.

1894

Japan opens a war by sinking a British steamer

Off Pungdo, west coast of KoreaAsia

Japan and Qing China had both sent troops into Korea during the Donghak peasant rising, and on 23 July Japanese soldiers seized the royal palace in Seoul. Two days later three Japanese cruisers met two Chinese warships off the island of Pungdo and drove them off. Then the cruiser Naniwa, under Captain Togo Heihachiro, stopped the Kowshing, a British-owned steamer chartered to carry about 1,100 Chinese soldiers. The troops refused to let the British officers surrender the ship. After hours of signalling Togo sank her. The European officers were picked up; most of the Chinese, more than 800 men, drowned or were shot in the water. War was declared a week later, on 1 August.

Seen from elsewhere. China called it an attack without a declaration of war on a neutral-flagged ship. Japan said the Chinese had fired first that morning, and British jurists writing to The Times concluded that Togo had acted within the law of war. For Koreans the war was fought on their soil over who would control them.

1898

United States troops land in Puerto Rico

Guanica, Puerto RicoThe Americas

With Spain already beaten in Cuba, General Nelson Miles put an American force ashore at the small southern harbour of Guanica on 25 July 1898, after the gunboat Gloucester had cleared the beach. Resistance was light and in many towns the troops were cheered. Three days later, at Ponce, Miles issued a proclamation promising the islanders ‘the blessings of the liberal institutions of our government’. The campaign lasted nineteen days before the armistice. Spain ceded the island in the Treaty of Paris that December. Congress set up a civil government under an appointed governor in 1900 and extended United States citizenship in 1917.

Seen from elsewhere. Puerto Rico had won an autonomous government from Spain in 1897, and its elected parliament had met for the first time eight days before the landing. Independence supporters date the loss of self-rule from Guanica. The commonwealth constitution was deliberately proclaimed on 25 July 1952, and the island’s status is still contested.

1978

The first baby conceived outside the body is born

Oldham, EnglandEurope

Louise Joy Brown was delivered by caesarean section at Oldham General Hospital shortly before midnight on 25 July 1978, weighing 5 pounds 12 ounces. Her mother, Lesley Brown of Bristol, had blocked fallopian tubes. The gynaecologist Patrick Steptoe had collected a single egg by laparoscopy; the physiologist Robert Edwards and the embryologist Jean Purdy fertilised it in a dish and Steptoe returned the embryo two and a half days later. The team had worked for a decade without public funding, after the Medical Research Council turned them down in 1971, and had seen scores of failed transfers. Edwards received the Nobel Prize in 2010. Many millions of children have since been born by the method.

Seen from elsewhere. The Catholic Church objected that conception had been separated from the marital act and that embryos were created and discarded; its 1987 instruction Donum Vitae condemned the technique. Some scientists at the time thought the risk of abnormality made the attempt irresponsible. Jean Purdy’s part went largely unacknowledged for decades.

Also on 25 July