Parallax

23 July, 1885

Grant finishes his book and dies

Swindled out of everything he owned and told he had cancer of the throat, the general who won the American Civil War spent his last year writing to keep his widow from poverty. He finished with days to spare.

Mount McGregor, New York, United States

In May 1884 Ulysses S. Grant, twice president of the United States, discovered that he was ruined. He had put his name and his savings into a Wall Street firm, Grant and Ward, run by his son and a plausible young financier named Ferdinand Ward. Ward had been paying old investors with new investors’ money. When it collapsed Grant had about eighty dollars in his pocket and owed William Vanderbilt a hundred and fifty thousand, borrowed two days earlier at Ward’s request. He insisted on handing Vanderbilt his swords, medals and the gifts of foreign governments as security.

That summer he bit into a peach and felt a stab of pain in his throat. He did not see a specialist until October. The diagnosis was cancer at the base of the tongue, the result, his doctors thought, of twenty cigars a day. It was inoperable. To earn money he had already agreed to write articles on his battles for the Century magazine, and found, to his surprise, that he could do it. The magazine offered a contract for a full memoir on its standard terms.

Mark Twain, who had recently set up his own publishing firm, heard about the offer and came to the house. He told Grant the terms were an insult and offered seventy per cent of the profits, with the book to be sold door to door by subscription, much of it by veterans in their old uniforms. Grant signed in February 1885. He wrote in an armchair, wrapped in a shawl, at first dictating and, when his voice went, in pencil. Cocaine solution and morphine dulled the pain; he could swallow little but liquids and slept sitting up for fear of choking. Reporters kept watch from across the street.

In June, to escape the city heat, he was moved to a borrowed cottage on Mount McGregor, in the hills above Saratoga. He worked on the porch in a top hat, a scarf round his neck, communicating with his doctors on slips of paper. On one he wrote that he was a verb rather than a personal pronoun: a verb signifies to be, to do, or to suffer, and he signified all three. He was still revising in mid-July.

He died on the morning of 23 July at eight minutes past eight, aged sixty-three, with his wife Julia and their children in the room. His son stopped the mantel clock. The two volumes sold more than three hundred thousand sets, and Julia Grant received about $450,000.

How it came to this

Grant’s rise is one of the least likely in American history. A tanner’s son from Ohio, he passed through West Point without distinction, fought well in the Mexican War, which he thought unjust, and resigned from the army in 1854 amid stories about his drinking. In 1861 he was a clerk in his father’s leather shop. Within three years he had taken Forts Henry and Donelson, Vicksburg and Chattanooga and been given command of all the Union armies. In April 1865 he accepted Robert E. Lee’s surrender at Appomattox on terms that sent the Confederates home with their horses.

He was elected president in 1868 at forty-six. His two terms covered the hardest years of Reconstruction: he backed the Fifteenth Amendment, created the Department of Justice and used federal troops and courts to break the first Ku Klux Klan. They were also marked by a financial panic in 1873 and by a run of corruption cases reaching his cabinet and his private secretary, though never Grant himself. By the time he left office in 1877, northern voters had tired of enforcing Black citizenship in the South.

How each side saw it

The white South and the Lost Cause

In defeat, former Confederates such as Jubal Early built an account of the war in which Lee was the greater soldier and Grant a butcher who won only by spending lives the North could afford. Grant’s presidency, in the same tradition, was the corrupt rule of bayonets over a prostrate South. Early twentieth-century historians of the Dunning school gave this version academic standing, and it shaped textbooks for two generations. Yet at his funeral two Confederate generals, Joseph Johnston and Simon Buckner, served as pallbearers beside Sherman and Sheridan, and Southern newspapers recalled the terms he gave at Appomattox.

Black Americans

Frederick Douglass, who had campaigned for him, eulogised Grant as the protector of the freedman and said that in him the Negro found a protector and the Indian a friend. Black voters supported him overwhelmingly, and his suppression of the Klan in South Carolina in 1871 was the most forceful federal defence of their rights until the 1950s. But the same communities watched his administration decline to send troops to Mississippi during the violent elections of 1875, a decision Grant later said he regretted. For them the tragedy of his presidency was not that he intervened in the South but that the country stopped him.

Native nations

Grant announced a Peace Policy, appointed Ely Parker, a Seneca and his wartime secretary, as the first Native commissioner of Indian affairs, and handed the reservations to church missions in place of political appointees. Its aim was the end of Native societies by assimilation rather than by killing. When gold was found in the Black Hills, guaranteed to the Lakota by the treaty of 1868, his administration decided in 1875 to stop keeping miners out and ordered the Lakota on to their agencies. The war that followed included the Little Bighorn. Lakota tradition and the United States Supreme Court, in 1980, agree that the Black Hills were taken unlawfully.

American Jews

In December 1862 Grant issued General Orders No. 11, expelling Jews as a class from his military district in an attempt to stop cotton smuggling. Jewish families in Paducah, Kentucky, were given twenty-four hours to leave. Lincoln revoked the order within weeks after a protest carried to the White House. It was used against Grant in the 1868 campaign. As president he appointed more Jews to office than any predecessor and attended the dedication of a Washington synagogue, and the historian Jonathan Sarna concludes that he spent his later life making amends. His wife called it that obnoxious order.

What is disputed

Rumour in 1885, started by a former aide, held that Grant had not written the memoirs himself; later versions credited Twain. The surviving manuscript, in Grant’s hand and his stenographer’s, settles the matter: Twain edited proofs. The larger argument is over the presidency. For most of the twentieth century scholars ranked it near the bottom. Biographers since the 1990s, among them Brooks Simpson, Joan Waugh, Ronald White and Ron Chernow, have rated it far higher on the strength of his civil rights record, while William McFeely’s earlier biography remains the sternest modern portrait. How much Grant drank is still debated.

What followed

A million and a half people watched the funeral procession in New York on 8 August, which took five hours to pass. His tomb on Riverside Drive, completed in 1897, is the largest mausoleum in North America. The Personal Memoirs, which end in 1865 and say nothing of the presidency, have never been out of print and are regularly called the finest military memoir in English. Ferdinand Ward served six years in Sing Sing. Twain’s publishing house went bankrupt in 1894. Grant’s reputation, which sank as the country abandoned Reconstruction, has risen as historians have returned to it.

Read further

  • Ulysses S. Grant, Personal Memoirs of U. S. Grant (1885-86)
  • Ron Chernow, Grant (2017)
  • Joan Waugh, U. S. Grant: American Hero, American Myth (2009)
  • William S. McFeely, Grant: A Biography (1981)
  • Jonathan D. Sarna, When General Grant Expelled the Jews (2012)

Same day, other years

1914

Austria-Hungary hands Serbia a forty-eight-hour ultimatum

Belgrade, SerbiaEurope

At six in the evening the Austrian envoy, Baron Giesl, delivered a note to the Serbian finance minister, the prime minister being away on an election tour. It held Serbia morally responsible for the murder of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo twenty-five days earlier and made ten demands, among them the suppression of anti-Austrian publications and societies, the dismissal of named officers, and the participation of Austrian officials in the inquiry on Serbian soil. Delivery had been timed for the hour the French president sailed from St Petersburg. The British foreign secretary called it the most formidable document he had seen addressed by one state to another. Serbia’s reply accepted most points. Austria declared war on 28 July.

Seen from elsewhere. Vienna held, correctly, that officers of Serbian military intelligence had armed the assassins, though it could not prove it then. Belgrade saw terms no sovereign state could accept. Fritz Fischer’s school stresses Germany’s prior promise of support; Christopher Clark spreads responsibility across all the powers.

1921

The Chinese Communist Party holds its first congress

Shanghai, ChinaAsia

Thirteen men met on the evening of 23 July in a house in the French Concession belonging to the brother of one of them. They represented some fifty members nationwide. Two agents of the Communist International were present. The party’s two senior figures, Chen Duxiu and Li Dazhao, were not, and a twenty-seven-year-old delegate from Hunan named Mao Zedong took the minutes. After a stranger wandered in on 30 July and police searched the house, the delegates moved to a hired boat on a lake at Jiaxing to finish. They elected Chen secretary in his absence. Within twenty-eight years the party governed China.

Seen from elsewhere. The party celebrates its birthday on 1 July, a date Mao chose years later when no one could remember the real one; scholars fixed 23 July from Comintern records around 1980. Of the thirteen, several left or were expelled and two served Japan’s wartime client government. Official history plays down the Comintern’s role.

1952

The Free Officers seize Cairo

Cairo, EgyptAfrica

During the night of 22-23 July a group of middle-ranking army officers arrested their own generals and occupied army headquarters, the radio station and the airport. At half past seven in the morning one of them, Anwar Sadat, read a statement on air announcing that the army had purged itself of traitors and bribe-takers. The public face of the movement was a respected general, Muhammad Naguib; its organiser was a thirty-four-year-old colonel, Gamal Abdel Nasser. Three days later King Farouk abdicated and sailed for Italy on the royal yacht, saluted by twenty-one guns. A republic followed in 1953. Egypt was ruled by Egyptians, without a foreign garrison or a foreign dynasty, for the first time in many centuries.

Seen from elsewhere. Land reform and the departure of the British made the officers popular. But within weeks two leaders of a textile strike were hanged, parties were dissolved in 1953, and the Muslim Brotherhood, at first an ally, was crushed in 1954. Egyptians still argue over whether 23 July was a revolution or a coup.

1983

An ambush in Jaffna sets off Black July

Jaffna and Colombo, Sri LankaAsia

Late on 23 July fighters of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam detonated a mine under an army patrol at Thirunelveli, near Jaffna, and shot the survivors. Thirteen Sinhalese soldiers died. The next evening, after a tense mass funeral in Colombo, crowds began attacking Tamils. Over the following week gangs, some carrying electoral lists that identified Tamil households, burned homes and businesses and killed people in the street across the capital and the south. Fifty-three Tamil prisoners were murdered inside Welikada jail. The government’s death toll was about 400; Tamil organisations and many researchers say 2,000 to 3,000. Some 150,000 people were left homeless. A civil war followed that lasted until 2009.

Seen from elsewhere. President Jayewardene’s government blamed left-wing parties and banned three of them. Survivors and later inquiries pointed to organisers within the ruling party and to police who stood by. Many Sinhalese and Muslim families hid Tamil neighbours. In 2004 President Chandrika Kumaratunga apologised on behalf of the state.

Also on 23 July