Parallax

19 July, 1848

Seneca Falls: a declaration with one word changed

Five women called a meeting at ten days’ notice in a small mill town in upstate New York. They rewrote the Declaration of Independence, and the only resolution that nearly failed was the one asking for the vote.

Seneca Falls, New York, United States

The meeting was planned over tea. On 9 July 1848 Elizabeth Cady Stanton, a thirty-two-year-old mother of three who had recently moved to Seneca Falls and disliked it, was invited to the house of Jane Hunt in nearby Waterloo. The other guests were Quakers: Lucretia Mott, a well-known minister and abolitionist visiting from Philadelphia, her sister Martha Wright, and Mary Ann M’Clintock. Stanton, by her own later account, poured out her discontent with a woman’s lot so forcefully that the party decided to do something. They wrote a notice for the Seneca County Courier calling a convention to discuss the social, civil and religious condition and rights of woman, to meet in ten days.

A week later, around a mahogany table in the M’Clintock parlour, they looked for a form for their grievances and found it in the Declaration of Independence. Stanton did most of the drafting. Where Jefferson had written that all men are created equal, the new text said all men and women. Where he listed the wrongs done by George III, it listed those done by man to woman: no vote, no voice in the laws, no right for a wife to her wages or property, no custody of her children after divorce, exclusion from colleges and the professions.

On Wednesday 19 July the Wesleyan Methodist chapel was locked, and a boy was lifted through a window to open it. About three hundred people came over the two days. The first had been intended for women only, though men who turned up were allowed to stay and listen. None of the organisers felt able to preside over a mixed public meeting, so on the second day Lucretia Mott’s husband James took the chair.

The Declaration of Sentiments was adopted with little argument. So were all the resolutions but one. The ninth declared it the duty of the women of the country to secure to themselves their sacred right to the elective franchise. Lucretia Mott had warned Stanton it would make them look ridiculous, and Stanton’s husband Henry, an abolitionist politician, left town rather than be associated with it. On the floor it was saved by Stanton and by Frederick Douglass, the formerly enslaved editor of the North Star in Rochester, who argued that the ballot was the right by which all others were secured. It passed by a small majority.

One hundred people signed the Declaration, sixty-eight women and thirty-two men. Only one of the women, a young glovemaker named Charlotte Woodward, was still alive when American women voted in a presidential election in 1920.

How it came to this

The women at Seneca Falls had learned their politics in the anti-slavery movement. Upstate New York in the 1840s was thick with reform: temperance, abolition, religious revival and utopian communities. Women collected petitions, raised funds and, in the case of the Grimke sisters in the 1830s, lectured to mixed audiences, for which they were denounced by the clergy of Massachusetts. In 1840 Mott and Stanton met in London at the World Anti-Slavery Convention, where the female delegates were refused seats and made to sit behind a curtain. The two agreed then to hold a women’s meeting at home; it took them eight years.

The law they objected to was the English common law of coverture, under which a married woman had no separate legal existence: she could not own property, sign a contract or sue in her own name. New York had passed a Married Women’s Property Act in April 1848, partly at the urging of wealthy fathers. In Europe that spring governments were falling to revolution. Seneca Falls itself was a canal and factory town with a free-thinking Quaker congregation a few miles away.

How each side saw it

The newspapers

Most of the press treated the convention as a joke or a threat. Editors mocked the signers as unsexed women and henpecked husbands and asked who would cook dinner. One Philadelphia paper wrote that a woman is nobody and a wife is everything. Under the ridicule some signers asked for their names to be removed. Stanton later said the mockery did the movement a service by spreading its demands to readers who would never otherwise have heard them. Douglass’s North Star was among the few papers to defend the meeting, in an editorial on the rights of women; the paper’s masthead declared that right is of no sex.

Black women

No Black woman is known to have attended, and the Declaration’s complaint that man had withheld from woman rights given to the most ignorant and degraded men had an edge that sharpened over time. After the Civil War Stanton and Susan B. Anthony opposed the Fifteenth Amendment because it enfranchised Black men and not women, sometimes in openly racist terms. Black suffragists such as Frances Harper, Mary Church Terrell and Ida B. Wells built their own organisations and were asked to march at the back of white-led parades. Rosalyn Terborg-Penn and others have documented a struggle for the vote that for many Black women ended only in 1965.

Haudenosaunee women

Seneca Falls stands on the homeland of the Haudenosaunee, or Iroquois, whose Seneca and Cayuga nations still had communities nearby in 1848. In those nations clan mothers nominated and could remove chiefs, descent and property passed through the female line, and a wife kept what was hers. Mott had visited the Seneca at Cattaraugus weeks before the convention. The historian Sally Roesch Wagner argues that reformers such as Stanton and Matilda Joslyn Gage, who both wrote about Iroquois women, drew their sense of the possible from these neighbours. Other historians think the influence real but hard to measure. Haudenosaunee women themselves were not invited.

What is disputed

Whether Seneca Falls was the beginning of anything is the main argument. Lisa Tetrault has shown that the idea of 1848 as the movement’s birthplace was built up in the 1870s and 1880s by Stanton and Anthony, partly to assert their leadership over rivals; it sidelines earlier events such as the 1837 women’s anti-slavery convention and an 1846 suffrage petition by six women in Jefferson County, New York. Stanton’s vivid recollections, written decades later, are the source for much of the detail, including Mott’s remark about looking ridiculous. The attendance figure of three hundred is an estimate.

What followed

A second convention met in Rochester two weeks later with a woman in the chair, and national conventions followed from 1850. Stanton met Susan B. Anthony in 1851 and the two worked together for half a century. Wyoming Territory gave women the vote in 1869, New Zealand in 1893. The Nineteenth Amendment was ratified in 1920, seventy-two years after the ninth resolution, though Native American, Asian American and most southern Black women remained shut out for decades more. The chapel, used in between as a garage and a laundrette, is now a national historical park.

Read further

  • Judith Wellman, The Road to Seneca Falls: Elizabeth Cady Stanton and the First Woman’s Rights Convention (2004)
  • Lisa Tetrault, The Myth of Seneca Falls: Memory and the Women’s Suffrage Movement, 1848-1898 (2014)
  • Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Eighty Years and More: Reminiscences 1815-1897 (1898)
  • Rosalyn Terborg-Penn, African American Women in the Struggle for the Vote, 1850-1920 (1998)
  • Sally Roesch Wagner, Sisters in Spirit: Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Influence on Early American Feminists (2001)

Same day, other years

1553

London turns against Queen Jane

London, EnglandEurope

Edward VI had died on 6 July, aged fifteen, leaving a document that cut his half-sisters out of the succession in favour of his Protestant cousin Lady Jane Grey, daughter-in-law of his chief minister, the Duke of Northumberland. Jane, about sixteen, was proclaimed on 10 July. Mary Tudor fled to East Anglia and raised her standard at Framlingham; gentry, townsmen and the crews of the royal ships came over to her. On 19 July the Privy Council, with Northumberland away in the field, changed sides and had Mary proclaimed at Cheapside to bonfires and bells. Jane’s father tore down the canopy of state over her chair in the Tower. She was beheaded the following February.

Seen from elsewhere. Tradition makes Jane a usurper’s puppet. The historian Eric Ives argued instead that she was queen by the dying king’s own will and that Mary’s was the successful rebellion. Protestants soon had reason to regret their loyalty to the legitimate line: Mary’s government burned some 280 of them.

1864

The Heavenly Capital falls

Nanjing, ChinaAsia

After a siege of more than two years the Hunan Army of Zeng Guoquan exploded a mine under the eastern wall of Nanjing and poured through the breach. The city had been the capital of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom since 1853. Its founder, Hong Xiuquan, a failed examination candidate who believed himself the younger brother of Jesus, had died seven weeks earlier. The sack lasted days: the victors killed soldiers and civilians alike and burned much of the city. The commander’s brother, Zeng Guofan, reported 100,000 enemy dead to the throne, a figure historians think inflated. The civil war as a whole is commonly estimated to have cost at least twenty million lives.

Seen from elsewhere. The Taiping saw the Manchu Qing as foreign demons and themselves as founders of a godly kingdom of shared land and equality of the sexes, ideals their own court ignored. Sun Yat-sen and later the Communists claimed them as revolutionary forerunners. More recent Chinese scholarship stresses the destruction.

1947

Aung San is shot at the cabinet table

Rangoon, BurmaAsia

At about half past ten in the morning, men in army uniform ran up the stairs of the Secretariat building and opened fire with submachine guns on a meeting of the Executive Council. Aung San, the thirty-two-year-old head of the interim government who had negotiated Britain’s promise of independence six months earlier, died with six of his ministers, a senior official and a bodyguard. The gunmen were traced to U Saw, a pre-war prime minister who hoped to be asked to form a government. He was hanged in 1948. Burma became independent on 4 January that year without the one leader who had the trust of the army and of several minority peoples. The day is kept as Martyrs’ Day.

Seen from elsewhere. Two British officers were convicted of supplying U Saw with weapons from army stores, and many Burmese have long suspected a wider British hand, which no evidence has established. Minority leaders note that the autonomy Aung San promised at Panglong in February 1947 died with him.

1992

A car bomb kills the judge Paolo Borsellino

Palermo, Sicily, ItalyEurope

Fifty-seven days after his friend and colleague Giovanni Falcone was blown up on the motorway from the airport, Borsellino went to visit his mother in Via D’Amelio on a Sunday afternoon. A parked car full of explosives was detonated as he rang the bell. He and five police bodyguards died, among them Emanuela Loi, the first woman of the Italian state police killed on duty. The two magistrates had built the case that convicted hundreds of mafiosi in the Palermo maxi-trial. Public fury in Sicily was directed at politicians as much as at Cosa Nostra, and the state sent the army to the island. The boss Salvatore Riina was arrested six months later.

Seen from elsewhere. The first investigation rested on a false witness, and several convictions were quashed years later. The red diary Borsellino carried was never found. His family maintains that state officials were negotiating with the mafia and that he was killed for opposing it. Courts convicted officials on that charge in 2018 and acquitted them on appeal.

Also on 19 July