The army that came down the Rhone valley in July 1209 was the largest anyone in the south had seen: northern French barons, bishops, knights serving the forty days that earned a crusader’s indulgence, and a long tail of servants, mercenaries and camp followers. At its head was Arnaud Amalric, abbot of Citeaux and legate of Pope Innocent III. Its first target was the land of the young viscount Raymond-Roger Trencavel, who had tried to submit and been refused.
Trencavel rode to Beziers, told the citizens to defend themselves, and left for his stronger fortress at Carcassonne, taking the city’s Jews with him. On 21 July the crusaders arrived on the far bank of the Orb. The bishop of Beziers, Renaud de Montpeyroux, who had been with the army, crossed the bridge with a list of some two hundred and twenty names of heretics and their protectors and an offer: hand these over, or leave the city yourselves, and you will be spared. According to the poet William of Tudela, the townspeople answered that they would rather be drowned in the salt sea. The bishop left with a few Catholics. Most stayed, priests included.
The walls were strong and the city well stocked. The leaders of the crusade were still discussing how to conduct the siege next morning, the feast of St Mary Magdalene, when a party of townsmen made a sortie over the bridge, waving banners and shouting insults, and killed a crusader and threw him in the river. The camp servants, the men the sources call ribauds, went for them with clubs and poles, barefoot and in their shirts, without waiting for orders. They chased them back to the gate and got in.
Once the knights saw what was happening they armed and followed. Resistance collapsed in two or three hours. People crowded into the churches, the cathedral of Saint-Nazaire and the church of the Madeleine, and were killed there; clergy were cut down in their vestments. The knights then drove the servants out of the houses to take the plunder for themselves, and the servants, in a rage, set the city alight. The cathedral roof came down in the fire.
Arnaud Amalric wrote to the pope within weeks. While the barons were still deliberating, he explained, the common soldiers had attacked without consulting them, and our men, sparing neither rank nor sex nor age, put to the sword almost twenty thousand people. He called it a marvel of divine vengeance.
How it came to this
In the towns and castles between the Rhone and the Garonne, a dissident Christianity had taken root in the twelfth century. Its ministers, known to their followers simply as good men and good women, lived in poverty and chastity, refused meat and oaths, and taught that the material world was the work of an evil power and the Roman Church no church at all. Catholics called them heretics, Albigensians, later Cathars. The southern nobility tolerated them and often had them in the family. Preaching missions, including one by the Spaniard Dominic Guzman, had made little headway.
In January 1208 the papal legate Peter of Castelnau was murdered on the bank of the Rhone, a day after a furious meeting with Count Raymond VI of Toulouse. Innocent III blamed the count and proclaimed a crusade, offering those who fought in the south the same spiritual rewards as those who went to Jerusalem, and the lands of heretics to whoever could take them. Raymond did public penance in June 1209 and joined the army himself, which turned it against his nephew Trencavel instead.