Parallax

22 July, 1209

The sack of Beziers

A crusading army reached a prosperous southern city expecting a long siege. It was inside the walls within hours, and the papal legate reported to Rome that nearly twenty thousand people had been put to the sword.

Beziers, Languedoc

The army that came down the Rhone valley in July 1209 was the largest anyone in the south had seen: northern French barons, bishops, knights serving the forty days that earned a crusader’s indulgence, and a long tail of servants, mercenaries and camp followers. At its head was Arnaud Amalric, abbot of Citeaux and legate of Pope Innocent III. Its first target was the land of the young viscount Raymond-Roger Trencavel, who had tried to submit and been refused.

Trencavel rode to Beziers, told the citizens to defend themselves, and left for his stronger fortress at Carcassonne, taking the city’s Jews with him. On 21 July the crusaders arrived on the far bank of the Orb. The bishop of Beziers, Renaud de Montpeyroux, who had been with the army, crossed the bridge with a list of some two hundred and twenty names of heretics and their protectors and an offer: hand these over, or leave the city yourselves, and you will be spared. According to the poet William of Tudela, the townspeople answered that they would rather be drowned in the salt sea. The bishop left with a few Catholics. Most stayed, priests included.

The walls were strong and the city well stocked. The leaders of the crusade were still discussing how to conduct the siege next morning, the feast of St Mary Magdalene, when a party of townsmen made a sortie over the bridge, waving banners and shouting insults, and killed a crusader and threw him in the river. The camp servants, the men the sources call ribauds, went for them with clubs and poles, barefoot and in their shirts, without waiting for orders. They chased them back to the gate and got in.

Once the knights saw what was happening they armed and followed. Resistance collapsed in two or three hours. People crowded into the churches, the cathedral of Saint-Nazaire and the church of the Madeleine, and were killed there; clergy were cut down in their vestments. The knights then drove the servants out of the houses to take the plunder for themselves, and the servants, in a rage, set the city alight. The cathedral roof came down in the fire.

Arnaud Amalric wrote to the pope within weeks. While the barons were still deliberating, he explained, the common soldiers had attacked without consulting them, and our men, sparing neither rank nor sex nor age, put to the sword almost twenty thousand people. He called it a marvel of divine vengeance.

How it came to this

In the towns and castles between the Rhone and the Garonne, a dissident Christianity had taken root in the twelfth century. Its ministers, known to their followers simply as good men and good women, lived in poverty and chastity, refused meat and oaths, and taught that the material world was the work of an evil power and the Roman Church no church at all. Catholics called them heretics, Albigensians, later Cathars. The southern nobility tolerated them and often had them in the family. Preaching missions, including one by the Spaniard Dominic Guzman, had made little headway.

In January 1208 the papal legate Peter of Castelnau was murdered on the bank of the Rhone, a day after a furious meeting with Count Raymond VI of Toulouse. Innocent III blamed the count and proclaimed a crusade, offering those who fought in the south the same spiritual rewards as those who went to Jerusalem, and the lands of heretics to whoever could take them. Raymond did public penance in June 1209 and joined the army himself, which turned it against his nephew Trencavel instead.

How each side saw it

The crusade’s own chroniclers

Peter of les Vaux-de-Cernay, a young Cistercian who joined the army later and wrote its official history, saw providence in the date. The people of Beziers, he recalled, had murdered their own viscount in the church of the Madeleine forty-two years before, and it was fitting that they should be destroyed on the Magdalene’s feast, some of them in that same church. He describes the citizens as robbers and heretics to a man. William of Tudela, a cleric from Navarre who favoured the crusade, is franker about method: the leaders had agreed that any place that resisted would be put to the sword, so that terror would open the gates of the rest.

The south

The second half of the Occitan Song of the Crusade was written by an anonymous poet on the other side, for whom the northerners are simply invaders, and the virtues at stake, which he calls paratge, are honour, right and the southerners’ own way of life. He does not write as a heretic; nor did most of those who died at Beziers, a largely Catholic town whose people would not give up their neighbours. Since the nineteenth century Occitan regionalists have made the massacre the founding wound of a suppressed nation, and the name Cathar country is now used to sell the region to tourists.

The Catholic Church

Innocent III had called for the heretics’ lords to be dispossessed, not for a massacre, and his later letters show unease at how the war was conducted and at the greed of its leaders; he did not, however, rebuke his legate for Beziers. Medieval canon lawyers held that heresy was treason against God and that a Christian prince who protected it forfeited his lands. In March 2000, in the Day of Pardon liturgy at St Peter’s, John Paul II asked forgiveness for the use of violence in the service of truth, without naming particular events.

What is disputed

The best-known line about Beziers is the weakest attested. The words kill them all, the Lord will know his own are put in the legate’s mouth only by Caesarius of Heisterbach, a German monk writing a collection of edifying stories some ten years later, and even he says only that Arnaud is reported to have said it. The legate’s figure of twenty thousand probably exceeds the whole population, which historians put at around ten thousand, swollen by refugees. More fundamentally, Mark Pegg and R. I. Moore argue that no organised Cathar church existed and that inquisitors largely constructed it; Peter Biller and others maintain the evidence for one is sound.

What followed

Narbonne submitted at once and Carcassonne within three weeks; Trencavel died in his own dungeon that November. The crusade then chose a commander, Simon de Montfort, who had not led at Beziers but would wage the war for nine years until a stone from a catapult killed him outside Toulouse. Fighting went on until 1229 and ended with the south passing to the French crown. To finish what the armies had not, the papacy created the Inquisition in the 1230s. The last known Cathar good man was burned in 1321.

Read further

  • William of Tudela and an anonymous successor, The Song of the Cathar Wars, translated by Janet Shirley (1996)
  • Peter of les Vaux-de-Cernay, The History of the Albigensian Crusade, translated by W. A. Sibly and M. D. Sibly (1998)
  • Jonathan Sumption, The Albigensian Crusade (1978)
  • Mark Gregory Pegg, A Most Holy War: The Albigensian Crusade and the Battle for Christendom (2008)
  • Laurence W. Marvin, The Occitan War: A Military and Political History of the Albigensian Crusade, 1209-1218 (2008)

Same day, other years

1793

Alexander Mackenzie reaches the Pacific overland

Dean Channel, British Columbia, CanadaThe Americas

A Scottish fur trader of the North West Company, with one clerk, six voyageurs, two Indigenous hunters and a dog, had left a post on the Peace River in May to find a route to the western sea. They forced a canoe through the Rockies and on to the upper Fraser, where Dakelh people warned them the river below was impassable and showed them a trail west. They walked it for two weeks, were feasted on salmon by the Nuxalk in the Bella Coola valley, and were lent canoes to reach salt water. On a rock in Dean Channel Mackenzie wrote in vermilion and grease: Alex Mackenzie, from Canada, by land, 22d July 1793.

Seen from elsewhere. The path he followed was an old trade road along which coastal peoples carried fish oil to the interior; it is now called the Nuxalk-Carrier Grease Trail. He was first only among Europeans north of Mexico. Heiltsuk men he met on the water were hostile, saying a ship’s crew, probably George Vancouver’s, had recently fired on them.

1942

The deportations from the Warsaw ghetto begin

Warsaw, German-occupied PolandEurope

On the morning of 22 July SS officers led by Hermann Hofle came to the office of Adam Czerniakow, chairman of the Jewish Council, and dictated an order: all Jews, with listed exceptions, were to be resettled in the East, six thousand a day, starting that afternoon. The Jewish police were to deliver them to the loading yard at the northern edge of the ghetto. The trains went to Treblinka, some fifty miles away, where people were gassed on arrival. Czerniakow swallowed cyanide the next day after being told to include children. By 21 September at least a quarter of a million people had been taken. A fighting organisation formed in the ghetto within a week of the first transport.

Seen from elsewhere. The Germans kept up the fiction of labour in the East, and many in the ghetto could not believe otherwise until escapees returned. The ghetto’s archivist Emanuel Ringelblum judged Czerniakow harshly for dying without warning his people; others have seen the suicide as the only protest open to him.

1946

The Irgun bombs the King David Hotel

Jerusalem, British Mandate of PalestineMiddle East

The hotel’s south wing housed the secretariat of the British administration and its military headquarters. Shortly after noon men of the Irgun, the underground group led by Menachem Begin, dressed as Arab workers, carried milk churns filled with explosives into the basement kitchen beneath it. The charges went off at 12.37 and the wing’s six floors collapsed. Ninety-one people were killed: British officials and soldiers, and Arab and Jewish clerks, typists and hotel staff, with Arabs the largest group among the dead. The attack followed a British operation three weeks earlier in which thousands of Jews were detained and Jewish Agency papers seized, some of them taken to the hotel.

Seen from elsewhere. The Irgun has always said it telephoned warnings to the hotel and others, and that the British refused to evacuate; British officials denied that any warning reached anyone able to act. The Jewish Agency condemned the bombing, though the Haganah had earlier approved the plan. A plaque unveiled in 2006 repeating the Irgun account drew a British protest.

1994

A lieutenant takes power in the Gambia

Banjul, The GambiaAfrica

Sir Dawda Jawara had led the Gambia since independence in 1965, presiding over one of the few African states to hold regular multi-party elections throughout those decades. On 22 July a group of junior army officers, angry over pay and conditions and accusing the government of corruption, seized the airport and radio station and marched on the State House. Jawara escaped aboard a visiting American warship. The soldiers’ leader, Yahya Jammeh, was twenty-nine. He promised a brief transition and ruled for twenty-two years, winning four elections, before losing a fifth in 2016 and leaving for exile only when West African troops crossed the border. No one was killed on the day of the coup.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Gambians welcomed the soldiers in 1994, and 22 July was celebrated for two decades as the anniversary of a revolution that built roads, schools and a university. A truth commission that reported in 2021 held Jammeh responsible for the deaths of at least 240 people, and for torture and rape.

Also on 22 July